Jump to content
Objectivism Online Forum

Reblogged:George Takei’s Breathtaking Stupidity

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

George Takei played Sulu on the original Star Trek series. He’s also an outspoken and openly gay man.

You would think a gay man would not stand up for an ideology, religion or political movement whose most fervent and consistent advocates think that homosexuality is grotesquely immoral at best, and punishable by death, at worst. And yet like his fellow progressive Democrats, he does.

He would never support a socially conservative Christian who opposed gay marriage. Yet when it comes to Islam, the most fervent opponent of homosexuality in the history of all humankind, he’s asking people to sign a petition in special defense of Islam and Muslims. Under the philosophy of individual rights and the U.S. Constitution, of course the government has no right to arbitrarily seize personal property or individual persons, without due process under a rational system of laws. But why the extra and special protection for Muslims? Why does his heart bleed for a people whose ideology has no use whatsoever for him, some of whom would behead or throw him off a building in a minute under the Sharia Law advocated by Islam?

Let’s be real. Islam is not merely a religion. It’s a political ideology. In my own home town of Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, there’s an active gay and lesbian community. Just 45 minutes north, there’s reportedly a growing Muslim population whose mosques are already under development. (Source: Susan Monday Show, Delaware 105.9 on 1/12/17). Some people — whether gays and lesbians or their loved ones — are more than a little concerned about the impact on the safety and individual property rights of the gay and lesbians who live nearby. It’s politically incorrect to admit it (Rehoboth Beach is a hardcore left-wing enclave), but I hear private expressions of concern on a regular basis. Such concern is entirely rational. Given what happened at the Pulse nightclub last year in Orlando, Florida, it seems reasonable to assume that individual gay and lesbian lives could be in danger, particularly at bars or in other public places, as Islamic houses of worship proliferate. The mayor of Dover and other politicians insist that existing law enforcement can handle the risks just fine, and we see how well that has worked out over the past few years of brutal Islamic attacks.

It doesn’t matter if most Muslims are not active terrorists. The fact remains that virtually all terrorism arises from Muslims who were radicalized at their local mosque. We all know that such petitions and appeals to “diversity and justice” like Takei’s ridiculous petition don’t have anything to do with equal protection of all persons under the Constitution. What they do seek to do is impose a sense of unearned guilt on the actual or potential victimization of innocent people at the hands of advocates of an evil, irrational political-social movement of which the gay and lesbian community represents a bull’s eye target. Not smart, not right and not rational!

If you read Takei’s petition, you’ll find an unwholesome and untenable false alternative. Either you pretend Islam and Muslims are about as dangerous as the Pennsylvania Dutch or Hasidic Jews, as the petition does, or else you support concentration camps for Muslims. It’s an absurd choice. The purpose of such package deals is to instill unearned guilt. “Oh, my, if I don’t think in politically correct ways about Islam like that wonderful gay progressive George Takei does, then I must be some kind of Nazi.” Sign the petition, and make sure your progressive friends know you’ve done the same. It’s the kind of evasiveness and bone-headed thinking that causes people to look back on the years leading up to Nazi Germany and asking themselves, “How could otherwise reasonable and educated people let this happen?”

Hypocrisy is too kind a term to describe the level of willful blanking out of rational thought such petitions require. If a white supremacist movement launched a series of internationally driven bombings and beheadings against anyone who disagreed with them, it would be reasonable and necessary for the governments of free societies to keep an eye on them in order to avoid more killings. Immigration policies would have to be reevaluated as well, to ensure that white supremacists are not entering the country. In that case, Takei would demand the strongest government response possible. Yet if you so much as suggest that Islam isn’t rational or decent, in Takei’s universe you’re worthy of being charged with hate speech and possibly a crime, as Obama’s Attorney General and undoubtedly a President Hillary Clinton were prepared to take us.

One can only assume that when someone who’s actually gay, and publicly so as George Takei is, makes such a move, that he’s simply trying to prove a point. My own theory is that he’s trying to gain approval from fellow progressives and leftists who seek to show what they view as their own moral superiority over others. They seem to feel that their willingness to risk and sacrifice their own interests and perhaps their very lives for the sake of public displays of political correctness makes them above everybody else. I wonder if anyone who died in the Pulse nightclub made that mistake. And why should anyone else dies just so that Takei and progressives like him get to prop up their inner sense of inferiority masquerading as sophistication?

Rational, thinking people understand that we don’t have to pretend that Islam is a movement dedicated to peace, love and tolerance any more than the Nazi movement was in its own time. Takei’s attempt to instill a sneering, fawning sense of unearned guilt in our souls does not work with me. And if you value your life, it shouldn’t work with you, either.

Political correctness is deadly. You excuse or forgive your own would-be destroyers at the cost of your self-esteem, your pride, your integrity and, in the end, quite possibly with your life. Don’t let it happen for the sake of moral and intellectual lightweights like George Takei.

Follow Dr. Hurd on Facebook. Search under “Michael  Hurd” (Rehoboth Beach DE). Get up-to-the-minute postings, recommended articles and links, and engage in back-and-forth discussion with Dr. Hurd on topics of interest. Also follow Dr. Hurd on Twitter at @MichaelJHurd1

Dr. Hurd’s writings read on the air by Rush Limbaugh! Read more HERE.

The post George Takei’s Breathtaking Stupidity appeared first on Michael J. Hurd, Ph.D. | Living Resources Center.

View the full article @ www.DrHurd.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He would never support a socially conservative Christian who opposed gay marriage.

-------------------------------------

Escape to the future fallacy. How do you know that if a president elect threatened to target all conservative Christians (because, for instance, all attacks against abortion clinics have been committed by conservative Christians), George Takei wouldn't stand up for their rights?

 

Rational, thinking people understand that we don’t have to pretend that Islam is a movement dedicated to peace, love and tolerance any more than the Nazi movement was in its own time.

-------------------------------------

What do you mean "was"? The Nazi movement still exists. And they're huge supporters of Trump. In the US, they are free to gather and share their beliefs, same as Muslims, conservative Christians, and everyone else:

http://www.americannaziparty.com/

The reason why no one is standing up for their rights is because the president elect isn't threatening their rights. He's only threatening the rights of Muslims.

Edited by Nicky
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...