-
Posts
687 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
39
Reidy last won the day on July 20 2023
Reidy had the most liked content!
Profile Information
-
Interests
Architecture, cooking, music
-
Location
Fremont CA
-
Gender
Male
Previous Fields
-
Sexual orientation
Gay / Lesbian
-
Relationship status
Single
-
State (US/Canadian)
California
-
Country
United States
-
Biography/Intro
Aesthete: Bach, Sibelius, Wright, Garbo, Dietrich, Piaf, Coward (as well as the obvious) foremost. Francophile malgré tout.
-
Experience with Objectivism
Since high school (1961)
-
Copyright
Copyrighted
-
Real Name
Peter Reidy
-
School or University
Philosophy and classics, UCLA
-
Occupation
Software test
Recent Profile Visitors
Reidy's Achievements
Advanced Member (5/7)
148
Reputation
-
Is there a recording of the Albert Ellis/NB debate?
Reidy replied to Skylark1's topic in Questions about Objectivism
Branden said, far more credibly, that the word he used was "absolutist" and that Ellis misheard him. He cited the misunderstanding as evidence that Ellis was philosophically illiterate, since anyone with an elementary knowledge of philosophy would know that Branden would never say that. -
Boydstun reacted to a post in a topic: Is there a recording of the Albert Ellis/NB debate?
-
Is there a recording of the Albert Ellis/NB debate?
Reidy replied to Skylark1's topic in Questions about Objectivism
Lots of material about the debate or, more broadly, about the issues between them: albert ellis nathaniel branden debate - Search (bing.com) albert ellis nathaniel branden debate - Google Search -
Is there a recording of the Albert Ellis/NB debate?
Reidy replied to Skylark1's topic in Questions about Objectivism
Probably not. They had a contract whereby either one could veto written or recorded dissemination of the contents, and Branden chose to invoke his veto, explaining his reasons in The Objectivist. Branden also said that Is Objectivism a Religion was the material Ellis prepared for the debate, so it should give a good idea of his thinking on the topic. -
necrovore reacted to a post in a topic: Reblogged:'Machiavellian' Triumphs and Traps
-
What's the truth about realtors and commissions?
Reidy replied to Doug Morris's topic in Economic News
This is easy to test. See if rates in the US are lower a year from now. -
What's the truth about realtors and commissions?
Reidy replied to Doug Morris's topic in Economic News
Yaron Brook took this up on his show, expanding on Necrovore's point that real estate agents are a cartel, held in place by licensing laws. Market failure had nothing to do with it. He predicts that commissions will go way down in the short run, because there are too many agents, then go up to 4% or 5%. -
You might be able to find The Objectivist in a library, perhaps through interlibrary loan. The link at online in my previous post leads to some other sources for the article. CORRECTION: Turns out you can buy it: The Objectivist (1966-1971) (Hardcover) – The Ayn Rand Institute eStore
-
The Objectivist ran a 4-part article "Biology Without Consciousness - and its Consequences" by Robert Efron, a physician / neuroscientist, in 1968. (He's apparently still in practice.) It's available, paywalled, online, presumably the text that ran in The Objectivist. I gather that an Objectivist would say consciousness is an activity of a person and that a functioning nervous system is a necessary condition of this activity.
-
What are some counter-cultural rules you live by?
Reidy replied to stansfield123's topic in Miscellaneous Topics
Shirts on the left, sorted left to right from least to most recently washed. Pants on the right, sorted in the same sequence. Continuing to the right, around the corner: washed but not ironed, then worn but not yet ready for the laundry, neither in any special order. -
The recent moves by big donors away from donating to universities (e.g.) is interesting, for one reason, because it's just what Rand was advising decades ago. She said it as far back as the 60s. Here's an example from 1982.
-
A few years back on Quora somebody wanted to know what Aristotle meant when he said that the mark of the educated man is the ability to hold two contradictory ideas at once. Several people chimed in with what they thought were Aristotelian explanations, but the quote turned out to be from F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Crack-Up. (They say that if you read the whole thing, Fitzgerald says that eventually you have to resolve the inconsistency.)
-
The Laws of Biology reacted to a post in a topic: "The pursuit of truth is not important." What is the context and meaning of that Ayn Rand quote?
-
Are you sure this is an accurate quote? It looks hinky to me. The Romantic Manifesto is a book-length anthology. Do you know which of the collected pieces is supposed to contain it? The Objectivist was a monthly. Do you know which month in 1969? I have all the 1969 issues except July. Tell me which month and I'll check it out.