Jump to content
Objectivism Online Forum

Recreation

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

I have some questions in regards to recreation.

What defines a recreational activity? What purpose do they serve? When is it moral to engage in one? Should it have to enhance your productive life in some way in order to be moral?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have some questions in regards to recreation.

1) What defines a recreational activity? 2) What purpose do they serve? 3) When is it moral to engage in one? 4) Should it have to enhance your productive life in some way in order to be moral?

1) Any non-work-related activity that gives one pleasure.

2) To stimulate one's mind or body.

3) Whenever it is not destructive of oneself or others.

4) No.

Edited by Eric Mathis
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm also wondering if the idea of "recreating" has anything to do with recreation.

1) Any non-work-related activity that gives one pleasure.

2) To stimulate one's mind or body.

3) Whenever it is not destructive of oneself or others.

4) No.

1. Pleasure is a sensory faculty, and recreation as far as I am aware has nothing to do with being pleasing to the senses.

2. What do you mean by this?

4. If it does not enhance your productive life in any way, of what good is it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm also wondering if the idea of "recreating" has anything to do with recreation.

1. Pleasure is a sensory faculty, and recreation as far as I am aware has nothing to do with being pleasing to the senses.

The next time I jump into a swimming pool on a hot day, I'll try to remind myself of that.

2. What do you mean by this?

"Stimulate" means "to excite or invigorate." For me, reading Raymond Chandler, watching Marx Brothers comedies, chatting on the Internet, and playing fetch with my dog are stimulating activities. "Recreate" literally means "to impart fresh life to."

4. If it does not enhance your productive life in any way, of what good is it?

Recreation is valuable in and of itself. I have a friend who retired at 45 to pursue his passion for travel. His daily activities do not add to his wealth, but they are no less valuable for that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The next time I jump into a swimming pool on a hot day, I'll try to remind myself of that.

The point is, you exclude any other aspect, e.g. happiness, from the equation, because you specified pleasure as the sole defining characteristic. And by the definition you offered, engaging in recreational activities is hedonistic.

Recreation is valuable in and of itself.

That is intrinsicism, which is contrary to Objectivism. I am only interested in what Objectivists think.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Humans need physical rest -- as in sleep.

I'd hazard a preliminary hypothesis that non-physical rest is a human need somewhat in the same sense as art is a human need.

Non-physical rest consists of "doing some else for a change". It can even be something that is physically strenuous. For instance, someone who's career involves little physical exercise may "rest" by running.

Like art, well-chosen recreation is enjoyable and adds to one's sense of well being.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The point is, you exclude any other aspect, e.g. happiness, from the equation, because you specified pleasure as the sole defining characteristic. And by the definition you offered, engaging in recreational activities is hedonistic.

I never said happiness should be excluded from the equation. In fact, I urge all those whose pleasures diminish their happiness to cease and desist from such pleasures this instant.

That is intrinsicism, which is contrary to Objectivism. I am only interested in what Objectivists think.

All right. My point was not that one should pursue recreation purely for recreation's sake. Obviously, recreation is pointless if it makes one less happy. I only wished to express the idea that certain activities can be worthwhile, even if they are not at all related to one's productivity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Humans need physical rest -- as in sleep.

I'd hazard a preliminary hypothesis that non-physical rest is a human need somewhat in the same sense as art is a human need.

Non-physical rest consists of "doing some else for a change". It can even be something that is physically strenuous. For instance, someone who's career involves little physical exercise may "rest" by running.

Like art, well-chosen recreation is enjoyable and adds to one's sense of well being.

I like this explanation a lot. Exercise would be a bit like resting for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What defines a recreational activity? What purpose do they serve? When is it moral to engage in one? Should it have to enhance your productive life in some way in order to be moral?

Recreation is "re-creating" something. Since entropy breaks down that which

is "created", if a creation is deemed valuable it is a good thing to "re-create" it.

The purpose of recreation is stated above. It is to "re-create" that which entropic

forces have and are breaking down.

Increasing what one values is a moral activity. "Re-creating"

(restoring/increasing) what one values is therefore a moral good, and an ethical

imperative.

Any act that enhances what you value is "productive", and therefore is part of

your "productive life".

Increasing what you value IS "production".

Your definition of "recreational activity", as you're using it above, contains the

assumption that it's possible to be "recreational" while NOT being productive.

Any activity that is not "productive" (increasing a value of yours) is not a "re-

creation" of your values,.. It is a merely a waste of time.

(( You might try defining what you mean by particular words, like "recreation", to

yourself, and then in your questioning to others, as that usually makes

the "answer" either obvious or at least easier for others to deal with [answer]. The

goal is to find a way to question YOURSELF, with the last resort being the

questioning of others, about things that you don't understand. ))

-Iakeo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4. If it does not enhance your productive life in any way, of what good is it?

What are your highest personal values? I have three: work, friends, and leisure (recreation). My main leisure activities take a particular form: "roving" -- either physically by walking or bicycling, or mentally by reading certain types of fiction.

My recreation enhances my friendships, directly and indirectly, and my productivity as well. How? By being re-creational. That is, recreation helps me restore myself psychologically after I have become frazzled with stressful situations, in work or another area of life.

All three of my highest personal values support my ultimate value, happiness.

What about you? What is your ultimate purpose and what are the highest personal values that support it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...