A Philosophy Degree - Who needs it?

May I inquire what you find interesting about Linguistics? From what I understand, it seems that its exploring the entire idea of universals and concept formation across the entire human race, which I believe to be a very exciting proposition. Are there a lot of nuances and intricacises to it? I ask because I love systems with which there is still a lot to be solved.

What was originally attractive to me was my discover of Indo-European languages and the notion of remote language relatedness and reconstruction. These days, I’m more into the hunt for universals, from a field-work perspective (i.e. describing languages which haven’t been worked on before).

It was exactly that fact that studying properties of language can lead to insights into the nature of the human mind that appealed to me, and has sustained by interest for 35 years now. Every day, I find some new puzzle that needs solving and every week or so, I see how this puzzle relates to that puzzle. That’s why I went into linguistics rather than law or medicine (though now I finally see how to make law be equally stimulating as an intellectual enterprise).

If any of the students had expressed a real reason, how would that have affected your recommendation in terms of admittance (assuming that’s why you were interviewing)? Do you think that idea is common among college interviewers?

Totally, utterly. I don’t know how common it is – as I recall, all of the interviewers were faculty (or visiting, in my case) in the department, so we shared interests though different understandings of the cold, hard realities. We all got how vitally important it is to have students be interested in the material, and not just be bodies in a body-count game. (Mr. Tenure may know from the newspapers why this is a difficult subject to discuss in public – I was there in the first 6 months of 2003). I don’t know about interviewing in the US, but from what I can tell, it’s conducted by functionaries, not faculty.

What sort of puzzles are there contained within linguistics? It’s obviously more I’m taking more than passing interest in this now that you mention it. Perhaps this might be better answered in a PM, I don’t mind.

To answer JASKN’s question: I love acting and I adore the theatre. I get utterly lost when I pick up a script, lost in my imagination as I imagine all the possibilities of how it could be staged, and how a piece could be performed. I love that description where Rand describes how Roark can just see a building emerge from the ground in his head, because that’s just what it’s like for me with the stage.

A great playwright or scriptwriter can create the mood of the piece and all the physicality required just through his choice of words, instead of having to write - <Angelo looks lustfully at Isabella><Isabella feels vulnerable>.

I love to act, but I also wish I could write plays like these men and women have before me. Philosophy, in that sense, would be a great path into understanding humanity as it is (morally subjective and all that) rather than just as it ought to be (upright and strong). That’s why I ask Odden about linguistics, because in fact, it seems an understanding of the “Why” behind language may be undeniably valuable in my goals.

Hey, didn’t Ayn Rand (if I remember correctly) write a few lines about studying philosophy in her essay “Philosophy: Who Needs It”? I gave my book away, thinking that it was on my CD-Rom…of which I think I was mistaken, since I can’t find it there. Damn.

Indeed I was correct. I just got back from buying a first edition of “Philosophy: Who Needs It”. She has this to say in that same titled essay:

Now you may ask: If philosophy can be that evil, why should one study it? Particularly, why should one study the philosophical theories which are blatantly false, make no sense, and bear no relation to real life?

My answer is: In self-protection–and in defense of truth, justice, freedom, and any value you ever held or may ever hold.

She goes on:

The battle of philosophers is a battle for man’s mind. If you do not understand their theories, you are vulnerable to the worst among them.

I’d like to add now, that after thinking this problem over and over, I am going to stick with my original decision to go to University. I shall continue with my plan to study philosophy, but my goals are different now. They are, in no particular order:

To study the areas that Objectivism does not yet cover

To integrate myself with the prototypical philosophers to Objectivism

To understand the threats to humanity that are presented to us from other philosophies, and to guard myself against them.

Also, I am seriously considering doing a Joint Honours, where I study 2/3 Philosophy and 1/3 Linguistics, so I may integrate the theories of language formation into the theories of concept formation, and just in general, to better understand how the mind works and formulates ideas through language. I still need to consider how much I really want to study Linguistics however, so more study into the subject must be done first.

Thanks for all the input guys. I think this has been a really productive thread, and helpful for myself at least. My long term goal is still to enter the world of theatre - I’m just taking a different route than most. In fact, I’ve spoken to several students at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Arts in London (RADA), and they’d gone to Uni to study an academic subject they were passionate about, and they felt that it was actually a lot more worthwhile to do that.

Only trouble now is money… student loans for Uni will be fine, but the £30,000 for RADA… hmm… maybe I can figure something out like Marcus Orlovsky did. Seriously, that guy is a living legend, read his profile there and you’ll understand.

So, this October, I’m off to the University of York. For those that wonder about why I keep that quote in my signature, it’s like a challenge to myself. It makes me laugh, because I simply imagine the word, ‘…yet’ at the end, as if that guy is just begging me to try and change things.

In my second year, I get the opportunity to study abroad. I was wondering, besides Hong Kong and Singapore, if you guys know any of these Universities and can comment on which one would be best:

http://www.york.ac.uk/admin/intnat/studyab…de/partners.htm

Sadly, Austin isn’t on there, but there’s University of California, York (Canada), Columbia New York and Illinois.

Do any of you guys know anything about these places?

there’s University of California, York (Canada), Columbia New York and Illinois.

Do any of you guys know anything about these places?

Columbia University and the University of Pennsylvania are definitely some of the highest ranked institutions in the United States. Although these rankings are largely based on research and grants, you will still be surrounded by a large population of intelligent and ambitious undergraduates if you choose to study at either place.

Objectivist intellectual John Ridpath is a retired professor of intellectual history at York University in Canada. It is too bad that you probably would not be able to interact with him if you went there.

The University of California at Berkeley and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champlain are also highly regarded universities. As you probably know, the University of California at Irvine is very close to the Ayn Rand Institute. If you are at all interested, I recommend getting in touch with ARI to see if there are any possibilities that you could be involved with them during your study abroad.

I’m considering philosophy major in combination with my degree, just to improve my expression and the opportunity to discuss abstractions with other people interested in the same but having recently looked into OAC, I think it may be the better option.

I minored in Philosophy in addition to my Biology degree. That worked out pretty well.

So, let’s just jump right in here. If one is a student of Objectivism, what reason is there to study Philosophy at university? I mean, surely, if you have the great fortune of finding an Objectivist tutor or professor, then he can challenge you and teach you in great depth about Objectivism. But, the fact is, that subjectivism and the kind of philosophy taught these days appears to be rife with, “Well, geez, we may never know the answers! Well, hand in your tests”.

I mean, it’s a mixed bag really. I guess I can just stick to studying Philosophy of Mind and aesthetics, maybe Philosophy and Science too. I’ll steer clear of ethics though, and leave that to the autodidact in me. But then, that’s just the thing:

Why study philosophy, if you’re an Objectivist? Surely after comprehensive induction and reading of Objectivist philosophy, you’re ready to face the big, wide world. I mean, once you fully comprehend the meaning of the axioms, then everything starts to flow from that, no?

The pursuit of knowledge is an end in itself. If you are curious and want to, there is no reason not to.

The pursuit of knowledge is an end in itself. If you are curious and want to, there is no reason not to.

Wrong. To persue knowledge with no intend on using it ever for some productive use is pointless.

The pursuit of knowledge is an end in itself. If you are curious and want to, there is no reason not to.

As EC said, this is incorrect. Going about it this way will sooner or later drain one’s motivation completely. In fact, this is one of leading problems with education: Teachers don’t provide the answer to the “Why?” of learning, which is “Why should we learn this?” To worsen things, I’ve heard some teachers answer “I have no idea just do it.”

As EC said, this is incorrect. Going about it this way will sooner or later drain one’s motivation completely. In fact, this is one of leading problems with education: Teachers don’t provide the answer to the “Why?” of learning, which is “Why should we learn this?” To worsen things, I’ve heard some teachers answer “I have no idea just do it.”

Good philosophy teacher put the information before you and help you to interpret it. Bad philo teachers just leave you with riddles. Good teachers know what they are doing and why. Bad teachers know neither.

Education is and end in itself as it teaches you how to live life. As Rand said…

The only purpose of education is to teach a student how to live his life—by developing his mind and equipping him to deal with reality. The training he needs is theoretical, i.e., conceptual. He has to be taught to think, to understand, to integrate, to prove. He has to be taught the essentials of the knowledge discovered in the past—and he has to be equipped to acquire further knowledge by his own effort.

With someone there to mentor and help you find knowledge it’s much easier than going it alone.

OP: Honestly look into an education, if you don’t like what you see, or don’t think it’s useful for you, then don’t do it. Despite the party line, any higher degree will help improve your life in the long run over only having a high school education.

Despite the party line, any higher degree will help improve your life in the long run over only having a high school education.

What are you talking about? Do you have any objective evidence of this? Perhaps you meant to say: “Despite the party line, I have found that a higher degree improved my life in the long run over only having a high school education.”

Education is and end in itself as it teaches you how to live life. As Rand said…

The former sentence has an inter-contradiction in it, and the quote you posted in the latter disagrees with your point rather than strengthening it. For an education to be “an end in itself” you would just have to learn for the sake of learning, and not use the knowledge gained. It’s like going to a garage sale to buy expensive furniture you’ll never sit on. Using your education to help you live would mean that an education would not be an end in itself, but rather an application to one’s life.

Despite the party line, any higher degree will help improve your life in the long run over only having a high school education.

What are you talking about? Do you have any objective evidence of this? Perhaps you meant to say: “Despite the party line, I have found that a higher degree improved my life in the long run over only having a high school education.”

adrock is right, Breschau. Consider a man who loves to work on cars, and is better at it than anything else. Should he pursue a college degree? There are thousands of careers like that. Or perhaps you were referring only to a philosophy degree?

However, I disagree here:

To persue knowledge with no intend on using it ever for some productive use is pointless.

If a man is already pursuing a career in a field of his dreams, an education can certainly be an end in itself. Perhaps the man simply likes knowing about things because it gives him pleasure, or it makes what he already knows and is interested in so much more interesting. An education can be applied to one’s career (productive life), or it can have other purposes. Maybe I am learning about jets because my brother is joining the Airforce. Maybe I need to learn a particular recipe to impress a particular date this weekend. Or, maybe I am just curious about the history of China. An education need not be confined to the purpose of productive work.

adrock is right, Breschau. Consider a man who loves to work on cars, and is better at it than anything else. Should he pursue a college degree? There are thousands of careers like that. Or perhaps you were referring only to a philosophy degree?

I think this contradicts the later part of your post - you seem to be saying here that a college degree is only useful if it helps with a career, while the later part of your post denies that. I dont think your man should necessarily pursue a college degree, but I do think his life would probably be enriched by a study of the liberal arts in general.

University study isnt really directly about a ‘career’ anyway - that wasnt the aim historically, and even today most people wont get a job related to their undergrad discipline (unless they stay on for post-graduate study). A man may not need any academic study to work on cars, but his entire being isnt defined by his being a mechanic and theres going to be a lot of hours in the day where he isnt working on cars. The historical aim of university study was to create well-rounded integrated people, not as some kind of vocational qualification to help them get a job. This has been somewhat corrupted over the last 100 years though, which I think is a shame.

I think this contradicts the later part of your post - you seem to be saying here that a college degree is only useful if it helps with a career, while the later part of your post denies that.

That wasn’t my intent, so I’ll try to clarify.

I was first talking about a college degree in relation to one’s career, which is one purpose for pursuing an education (used broadly to include individual study or college instruction). Then, I was talking about an education (which could include college) not related to one’s career (that is, productive work), and several reasons one might choose to do that.

It is a widespread mistake that is totally unfounded to equate ‘education’ with ‘college degree’. Only after seperating the two concepts into what they are, as JASKN did, is a discussion possible.

However, I disagree here:

If a man is already pursuing a career in a field of his dreams, an education can certainly be an end in itself. Perhaps the man simply likes knowing about things because it gives him pleasure, or it makes what he already knows and is interested in so much more interesting. An education can be applied to one’s career (productive life), or it can have other purposes. Maybe I am learning about jets because my brother is joining the Airforce. Maybe I need to learn a particular recipe to impress a particular date this weekend. Or, maybe I am just curious about the history of China. An education need not be confined to the purpose of productive work.

Yeah, I was wrong here. I study all kinds of subjects all the time just because I want to know as much as I can about–everthing. This guy just had me on tilt a bit yesterday, and I think I responded without fully considering what I was saying. However I still thing knowledge should be put to use whenever possible, while it’s cool to know the answers to most things, putting that knowledge to practical use is the ultimate goal when feasable.

So, I’ve kind of started University now. Lots of people, some interesting, many not, but, you know, I’m just digging around to find interesting people and just trying to be sociable. I’ve had a few introductory things to the actual course itself and it seems pretty good so far. The lecturer was talking about how the Philosophy department believes it is most important that you develop your skills at thinking properly and critically about the material you’re dealing with, rather than remembering it by rote - which is always nice.

No sign of great intellectual corruption just yet or anything like that just yet, but a lot of people who don’t really know why they are doing their course and don’t seem that interested in being here to study.