Are there any good arguments against Rand?

I looked at several articles that were presented by both Mr. Speicher and y_feldblum and I found that the articles y_feldblum had given me were actually written by a professor of philosophy at UNF, here in Jacksonville. I sent him a brief email explaining that I’d love to hear in person why he has written so much against Objectivism. It suprised me to see someone go to great lengths to denounce the philosophy. I recieved an email promptly and we have arranged a time to sit and meet.

I plan on sitting down with him and discussing the errors (in his eyes) of Objectivism, but instead of going into long winded discussions about why this philosophy is bad and discuss the deep issues of it, I’m going to cut it to a couple very simple questions after I present him with my particular situation. I’m going to take a pretty superficial approach to the philosophy and to my changes.

First, I’m going to tell him that I have completely turned a 180 in my life…I’ll explain that I now know and understand ethics, morallity, work ethics and I now know what it takes to succeed and be happy in the world. I hate to go a superficial direction with this ‘esteemed’ professor of philosophy but I feel that that is all I need to hear from such a opponent of the philosophy. I then will ask him why he thinks it’s such a bad thing that this philosophy exists and ask him how it could be a bad thing if it’s made such positive changes in my life.

Hopefully he’ll be able to make a good case because I’m up for a good conversation with someone who’s well educated and who opposes Objectivism. Most people I’ve run into who oppose the philosophy just say “She’s selfish and stupid” or something ridiculous like that…I don’t tolerate such ignorance.

Any opinions?

~Michael

Hopefully he’ll be able to make a good case because I’m up for a good conversation with someone who’s well educated and who opposes Objectivism.  Most people I’ve run into who oppose the philosophy just say “She’s selfish and stupid” or something ridiculous like that…I don’t tolerate such ignorance.

Any opinions?

~Michael

Michael,

My suggestion is to treat this as a learning experience. If I were in your place, I would not expect to “win” an “argument.” I would try to learn as much as possible about this professor’s disagreements with Objectivism, so I could later subject them to my own critical analysis.

Because this person is well-educated, he may be able to come up with a lot of arguments that appear good at first glance. Take your time and don’t expect that you have to answer every one of his arguments on the spot.

Any opinions?

~Michael

I think I agree with you’re general goal here to find some persuasive and difficult-to-rebut arguments against Objectivism. I do that to some extent by listening to archives of collectivist radio talk shows (like Thom Hartman). It helps to clarify your ideas to have to defend them.

On this note, I think you’ll get more out of a face-to-face with an anti-Objectivist philosophy professor than you would from anything you’ll read.

Your superficial approach, while it will make a good “ice breaker”, sounds a lot like the arguments I hear in favor of religion, and religion almost always has a lot of really bad philosophy associated with it, so I wouldn’t expect it to hold much sway with this professor. I generally second Chumley’s advice. Try to listen more and avoid arguing on the spot - ask for clarification if something unclear, but don’t waste your time trying to “win” an argument with him or change his mind. Of course, by trying to get clear ideas out of him, you might end up changing his mind anyway.

Yeah, I’m not planning on arguing really…I know that this man is very educated and I’m looking to just keep it one sided to a degree. If anything I’d like to create a good relationship with this person for he is someone who has a lot of knowledge on subjects that interest me. As someone who isn’t in college it is VERY few and far between I find someone who is willing to discuss subjects of this caliber, let alone find someone willing and able too. So I’m approaching this with honest intentions to learn more about the philosophy that has changed my life for the good. I’m hoping that he won’t dismiss me on the grounds of my ‘stubborness’ but I’m sure he wont just by the tone of the email I recieved.

I actually feel pretty fortunate to have stumbled accross such an opponent of Objectivism so near me. It’s going to a fun next couple of weeks, thats for sure.

~Michael

Your superficial approach, while it will make a good “ice breaker”, sounds a lot like the arguments I hear in favor of religion, and religion almost always has a lot of really bad philosophy associated with it, so I wouldn’t expect it to hold much sway with this professor. I generally second Chumley’s advice. Try to listen more and avoid arguing on the spot - ask for clarification if something unclear, but don’t waste your time trying to “win” an argument with him or change his mind. Of course, by trying to get clear ideas out of him, you might end up changing his mind anyway.

I appreciate your honesty on the subject, it may come off as a similiar argument religion uses, and thats not what I want to do. I’m sure I’ll be able to speak to him and convey my intentions properly and still hold an intellectual conversation with him. And like I said in the post above this, I don’t think there will be any arguing with someone who is so accomplished and has pretty extensive knowledge under his belt…i’m not stupid. :lol:

I don’t think there will be any arguing with someone who is so accomplished and has pretty extensive knowledge under his belt

Who exactly is this professor, and which of the essays did he write?

Who exactly is this professor, and which of the essays did he write?

Robert Bass

Department of Philosophy

University of North Florida

http://www.noblesoul.com/orc/critics/index.html

Click that and look at the articles on Ethics, he has several others on other topics as well.

This is the straight Objectivism stuff he’s written

http://personal.bgsu.edu/~roberth/oism.html

He doesn’t have a very nice webpage though…it’s rather lame, but he’s a Philosophy Professor and has much more college under his belt than most laypeople I meet.

~Michael

Robert Bass

Department of Philosophy

University of North Florida

http://www.noblesoul.com/orc/critics/index.html

Click that and look at the articles on Ethics, he has several others on other topics as well.

I’m a little confused. If your original goal was to find some serious critique of Objectivism, why are you going to talk with him rather than reading and rebutting his essays?

I’m a little confused. If your original goal was to find some serious critique of Objectivism, why are you going to talk with him rather than reading and rebutting his essays?

No need to be confused. I still am reading them and rebutting them, but I want to speak to the man who wrote them, he’s less than 20 minutes away. It’s the only logical step in the situation IMO…if I have a chance to speak to someone on the subject that I was looking to read about, it would just be that much better for me.

Don’t worry about anything though, if there is a concern that this person may sway my views I can assure you that that isn’t the case. I’m going to use his arguments to reinforce my views if anything.

Consider it a self satisfaction mission… :stuck_out_tongue:

~Michael

No need to be confused.  I still am reading them and rebutting them, but I want to speak to the man who wrote them, he’s less than 20 minutes away.

Okay. Have fun.

Don’t worry about anything though, if there is a concern that this person may sway my views I can assure you that that isn’t the case. I’m going to use his arguments to reinforce my views if anything.

Why does it matter that he may sway your views? Let him try. As long as you don’t renounce all consideration of objectivism, let the most righteous idea win.

The whole point of advocating a philosophy is that it is correct.

Why does it matter that he may sway your views? Let him try.  As long as you don’t renounce all consideration of objectivism, let the most righteous idea win.

The whole point of advocating a philosophy is that it is correct.

The reason why I said that I’m sure it won’t sway my view of Objectivism is because I know it to be correct. If he presents a good argument and not a frivolous one based on lots of hypotheticals and mystics then I may pursue the knowledge necessary to understand his views…but all in all, it’ll be a great learning experience.

I sometimes wish I had the time and resources available to get to fulltime college.

~Michael

Release please IM me on AIM at Energitia or email me at [email protected]

Thank you

Release please IM me on AIM at Energitia or email me at [email protected]

Thank you

Done and done.

From what I can tell on the Robert Bass article “Egoism, Rights and the Equal-Interests Argument” he uses the argument that for one individual to gain other individuals must suffer. In other words that wealth is static and that when one trades there is always a losing party or parties. Since this a false assumption everything based on that assumption must also be false.

From what I can tell on the Robert Bass article “Egoism, Rights and the Equal-Interests Argument” he uses the argument that for one individual to gain other individuals must suffer. In other words that wealth is static and that when one trades there is always a losing party or parties. Since this a false assumption everything based on that assumption must also be false.

I’ve already found many errors and misunderstandings in his essays, and I think I will bring them up to him…I’m going to be very prepared for our encounter.

~Michael

What’s the point? Are you looking to raise doubts in your mind? For what end?

Doubts are a normal part of learning and integrating a philosophy into your life. Even after years of study, there will at least be points that stand unclear in your mind. This is true of any philosophy. But questions should properly come from your first-handed grasp of the facts and the application of the facts using your own mind not from what someone else said in a book or a journal.

I did read some “third-party” material when I was first learning Objectivism. But really, it didn’t add to my understanding at all. I would recommend focusing on the positive aspects of Objectivism before researching its opponents. This will do a greater benefit to your understanding in the long run.

Isn’t one of the purposes of philosophy to discuss and understand someone else’s views along with your own? I think to better understand philosophy is is necessary to understand both sides in order to come up with your own. I don’t know, maybe I misunderstood your reply.

 Good Arguments Against Rand?

My take:

There are two philosophical “schools” which argue against Objectivism:

  1. A priori, as held by Plato and Augustine, among others, and

  2. Emmanuel Kant & Co., who I label “nihilism.”

As an architect, and a proponent of Objectivism and Capitalism, I strongly favor the Aristotelian approach, which has evolved into modern Objectivism, without modification.

My take:

There are two philosophical “schools” which argue against Objectivism:

1.  A priori, as held by Plato and Augustine, among others, and

2.  Emmanuel Kant & Co., who I label “nihilism.”

As an architect, and a proponent of Objectivism and Capitalism, I strongly favor the Aristotelian approach, which has evolved into modern Objectivism, without modification.

Objectivism rests on three axioms.

Axiom One: Existence exists.

Axiom Two: I am conscious.

Axiom Three: A is A.

The best way to prove Objectivism is to begin by refuting one or more of these. All of Objectivism amounts to a logical body of knowledge based on these, including the Scientific Method. If I were to try to disprove Objectivism as a philosophy, I would try to establish a philosophy based on these axioms. Every time I have seen this attempted, one of three outcomes resulted. Either the philosophy incorporated a contradiction at some point, or the philosophy violated one of these axioms, or the philosophy was Objectivism given another name.

There are no - and never have been any - good arguments against Ayn Rand.

Are there, or have there ever been any “good” arguments against 2+2=4???

It is exactly the same issue.