Sexual attraction is a response to value?
I agree.
Is there rational value in youth? A slender build? Facial symmetry?
Absolutely. These suggest fertility and energy, a life-affirming approach to eating habits and exercise, and freedom from disease and genetic mishap, respectively. (Just as being “plump” once signified having money enough to eat well.)
So, is it “reasonable” for a man to be sexually attracted to a young, slender, pretty woman? (I use man and woman for convenience; I’d prefer to keep homosexuality as a separate discussion.) It is, insofar as a person values energy, exercise, health, etc., which all appear to be sensible values.
Scenario: a man meets a woman who is young, slender, and pretty, and consequently finds her sexually attractive. His initial attraction may suggest that there are values to be gained from an association with this woman, the physical act of sex being just one. After all, if her slenderness is as a result of a specific nutritional and exercise regimen, then it may be possible to infer a certain level of commitment to reason, and an integrity to act upon what she holds to be true, etc. Her hygiene does not exist in a vacuum; it is only made possible by her taking action, and those actions speak of her character. And beyond broad categories of dress, build, age, etc., there are a myriad of more-subtle physical details that may communicate themselves on a subconscious level: how a person’s eyes move when they speak; how their body posture indicates attentiveness when they listen; whether their smile “reaches the eyes,” and is genuine; so on, and so on, and so on. All of these data say something about a person, and all of it, in sum, may result in a greater or lesser attraction.
However. We also know that “appearances can be deceiving,” which here means that our attempts to infer character from appearance, both consciously and subconsciously, are fraught with difficulty and the potential for misstep. As a basic example, a slender woman’s build may indicate her commitment to nutrition and exercise… or… it may be a quirk of her metabolic nature. Or, she might be engaged in a particular diet based on some strange mystical belief. In short, we know that her body type says something about her, but what…? Typically, we can only draw so many conclusions, and those only so strongly, based on physical appearance (though with practice and thought a person may increase in his skill), and to “truly” know a person, we must get to know him/her better through conversation – not just once, but often over time.
We recognize that our attraction signifies “things of value” that may be available for trade with a person. Is orgasm, itself, of value? I’d say that it is, in context. Masturbating in a burning building is a bad idea. But masturbation after a day’s work, taking joy in one’s own ability to relax, experience pleasure, etc.? Is a pleasant thing to do from time to time. Sex with another is much like masturbation – or can be, at any rate – but it is also intrinsically different. Apart from awareness of the other persons’ experience of the activity, and the pleasures that one may take in providing pleasure to another, it is simply different to provide oneself pleasure versus having it provided by another. As one small example of this difference, another person is capable of surprising you – touching you where you did not expect to be touched – which results in a different, more intense, and often more pleasurable physical sensation. These differences together can amount to a significant difference overall in the pleasure taken between sex and masturbation, so that to crave sex with another is not necessarily the same as craving masturbation (which can be, itself, more than craving the simple release/pleasure of orgasm).
As always, context is crucial. Sex in a burning building is as bad of an idea as masturbation, or worse in that two would die.
Casual sex.
So we have our man attracted to our young, slender, pretty woman. He recognizes that an association with her may result in all sorts of trades for things he values; his attraction, itself, signifies that there’s good reason for optimism on this score. What kinds of things may be traded? Conversation, for instance? Sure – her appearance is a good initial indication that she may be intelligent, and have worthwhile things to say, and provoke deeper and more exacting thought; this is one among the greatest things that men can trade with one another.
What of sex? Yes. That’s another value that can possibly be traded for: she is a potential source of great physical pleasure, which, so long as one’s smoke detector is working, is a good thing to experience.
If this man’s attraction leads to conversation – and coming to understand that this woman is as her appearance would suggest her to be; that is, she is attractive through-and-through – it might lead to all sorts of possibilities in terms of relationships, including friendship or even a lifelong partnership. At what point in that journey is sex “permissible”? When would they be justified in trading physical pleasures to one another? I’d say, as soon as each is satisfied that the trade is worthwhile. This might be on the wedding night. It might be shortly after meeting. Depending on their ability to assess the other’s character, depending on their satisfaction that certain risks of having sex (e.g. pregnancy, disease) have been minimized, depending on their personal convictions that there is nothing inherently wrong with taking pleasure, etc. At some point, there is no longer a reason to deny this exchange of pleasure.
What might make the sex “casual”? As one example, they might be on different career paths. Perhaps there is value for them in sharing physical pleasure, and other beneficial aspects of companionship, together for a night (or a month, or what-have-you), but to commit to a permanent partnership would be to sacrifice a greater value. Perhaps even spending the time to get to know the other to the point whether one could say they’d be “marriage material” is too expensive, in a given context. Is there any reason here to withhold the trade of physical pleasure which both sides deem is for their individual benefit? There is not. “Casual” sex is not valueless sex, just as sex between evil people in a 20 years marriage is not a beautiful thing.
As to “promiscuity,” how many times may such a scenario occur? How many times may a person “reasonably” have sex with a truly (inside as well as out) attractive partner, despite a longer engagement being undesirable? More to the point, outside the particulars of an individual’s life-as-it’s-actually-lived, would there be any sense in trying to assign a number to such a thing?
To summarize: Sex that is indiscriminate (without regard to the nature of the other participant), or sex predicated on evil values, is not a rationally desirable thing, just as sex in a burning building is a bad idea. But sex as a response to rational values is a good thing. There is nothing inherent to “casual” sex that necessitates it being anything other than that.