I think we’re getting a bit away from the original thrust of the TED talk, but that’s okay. The discussion continues regardless. However, if we want to address the idea of “Atheism 2.0” I think we need to take a step back for a second and reexamine some things.
First of all, the speaker at the conference is not an Objectivist, so some of his ideas don’t mesh with Objectivism. For example, he advocated didactic learning (or learning by rote; memorization out of context), which is clearly at odds with the O’ist position that one must understand why a thing is true – why reason is the best way for man to live, why anarcho-capitalism is not a viable political idea, why altruism is not a moral system by which to live one’s life. Also, religion is not what he is advocating. He is advocating some of the methods of religion, such as intellectuals giving sermons rather than lectures. In this case, he defines sermons as imparting information on how to live one’s life (morality), whereas lectures put forth some piece of information or topic of study. Again, he is advocating didactic learning, but if instead of imparting morality through rote you explain why a thing is moral, sermons (as defined) could be an effective method for spreading and concretizing ideas.
Also, the word faith is being bandied about, by some, as if it did not have a concrete definition. Faith is defined as, “confidence or trust in a person or thing,” specifically, “belief that is not based on proof.” As such, it is at odds with any philosophy of reason, which requires proof for concepts in the framework that reality exists and we are capable of perceiving it. In our every day lives we hear a lot of things that we take with at least some measure of faith, for convenience’s sake (we hear that scientists have discovered ice on Mars, we say, “Oh, that’s interesting,” and move on without verifying this irrefutably, unless we’re really interested or in the same field of study), but we can allow ourselves to do this because, in theory, the scientists are working with reason and within the scientific method, which has been objectively shown to be our most reliable method for obtaining information about reality. This isn’t always a good practice, because, more often that one would think, scientists don’t properly follow the scientific method and report faulty results, but for things that don’t directly impact our lives it’s more efficient to take the scientists’ word for it than to spend hours verifying the efficacy of their testing procedure by taking a fine-toothed comb to their journal publications. This is not to say that reason is somehow flawed or that faith is the better of the two, just that if we attempted to verify for ourselves, independent of outside help, every piece of the accumulated knowledge of the ages as well as all new science, we would spend our lives cloistered in a laboratory, repeating experiments that have already been done ad nauseam.(I think I made that clear, but I’d be happy to clarify if someone’s not following.)
And I believe that’s all I have to say for now. If I forgot something I’ll add it in later.