Marsha Enright’s representation of Harry Binswanger’s situation of teleological concepts within modern biology and modern physical science more generally is erroneous, as I said above. I’ll be writing more about his book shortly, and post it in a pre-existing thread: https://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?/topic/3614-biological-basis-of-teleological-concepts/#comment-83343. (Beginning is here: https://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?/topic/38490-theory-of-mind/&page=3#comment-393337).
There is another important error, which is in her treatment of Aristotle’s four causes (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-causality/#FourCaus). The error is in her conception of formal causality. She treats it as “shape or configuration (such as a helix or a feedback system," and on that error, she concludes that modern science recognizes Aristotelian formal causation as at work in nature outside the operations of consciousness. That picture is incorrect. Aristotle’s formal causality is intimately related to final causality. Neither is put to work in the course of contemporary physics, chemistry, geology, or other sciences outside of biology and psychology.
“Substance is on the one hand, matter, on the other hand, form, that is, activity” (Metaph. 1043a27–28, A. Kosman translator) Shape, such as shape of a bronze statue, is not all Aristotle means here by form. For Aristotle explanation of substance (which is most fundamental thing among beings) requires both matter and form in his sense, not in common sense or in scientific knowledge. Like most all moderns, and certainly all modern science, Rand and Peikoff reject Aristotle’s fundamental form/matter division of all beings. (See chapter 5 “Aristotle’s Theory of Form” in D. Bostock’s Space, Time, Matter, and Form – Essays on Aristotle’s Physics; chapter 3 “Form” in K Koslicki’s Form, Matter, Substance; Michael Frerejohn’s Formal Causes: Definition, Explanation, and Primacy in Socratic and Aristotelian Thought; J.G. Lennox’s “Form as Cause and the Formal Cause – Aristotle’s Answer” in Neo-Arisrtotelian Perspectives on Formal Causation.)