It came out today/yesterday I heard, my friend was playing it when I called him and I looked it up on Wikipedia and saw what it said about it being inspired by Atlas. I was about to make a thread about it but I saw this one. I might be getting a 360 soon so I will get the game and check it out.
Oh, they are two threads about this game. I suggest merging them.
But yeah, a friend told me he really liked it and I looked it up on Wiki and found it was inspired by Atlas. BUT as far as I can tell, it never said anything about being an Objectivist game or city or whatever. So don’t say things like that.
You never know, it might have been messed up because the people in it were like the Brandens… ![]()
Oh, they are two threads about this game. I suggest merging them.
But yeah, a friend told me he really liked it and I looked it up on Wiki and found it was inspired by Atlas. BUT as far as I can tell, it never said anything about being an Objectivist game or city or whatever. So don’t say things like that.
You never know, it might have been messed up because the people in it were like the Brandens… :lol:
It’s not really an “Objectivist” city per se. It is just that the city is similar in many ways to Galt’s Gulch in that it was hidden from the major population and inhabited by productive geniuses and had some form of highly capitalist economy.
It’s not really an “Objectivist” city per se. It is just that the city is similar in many ways to Galt’s Gulch in that it was hidden from the major population and inhabited by productive geniuses and had some form of highly capitalist economy.
That’s what I meant. It might have some similarities, but that doesn’t mean it’s the same thing. If anything, it looks pretty cool, I went to Best Buy and Wal-Mart today and saw it everywhere and it looks pretty cool! I’ll have to get it and play through it to come up with a good review.
Hi, I am new to the forums and look forward with discussing various topics with you guys/gals.
I think Bioshock has amazing graphics, creative and unique gameplay, and an entertaining story line. But I guess what it really comes down to is this Andrew Ryan guy is suppose to be some what based on Ayn Rand, and from as far as I can tell, Andrew Ryan is a crazy sociopath. So I think from a philosophical standpoint, that would be a knock on objectivism. Furthermore I don’t think a Utopia of objectivist intellectuals would be turn asunder by some stem cells. Regardless the game is entertaining and I am eager to see if my theory that this is actually quite anti objectivist is correct.
Happy gaming,
Pat
I’m about 10-15 hours in and so far I view it as anti-objectivist… I’m desperately hoping it will recover. It’s still completely possible. Andrew Ryan is being painted as a hypocritical murderer but until I understand his reasoning and the full story I cannot tell if it was justified or not.
If the director is trying to knock objectivism it’s because he failed to understand it, Andrew Ryan would not be a true objectivist.
If the director is trying to knock objectivism it’s because he failed to understand it, Andrew Ryan would not be a true objectivist.
Spoiler alert!
I know for a fact that he knows Andrew Ryan is not a true Objectivist. He said as much in the interview but requested I didn’t publish a spoiler. I haven’t played yet, but now that the game is out, I think it is safe to say that. In his words, “He’s no John Galt.”
And by “the interview,” I mean this.
Again, I haven’t played it yet but this may not be crack on Objectivism so much as trying to make an interesting storyline. You’ve got to admit, crazy ass-mutants are more interesting to fight against then cowardly tax collectors.
Plus, look at some of the stories about Super-Man in the alternate universes. Sometimes Super-Man goes crazy and turns evil, that doesn’t mean that Super-Man is bad or what he stands for is bad… just that version of Super-Man.
It might be something similiar?
I don’t think so. I really hope your right Mammon, but at the part I am at Andrew Ryan talks about how he once owned a forest and the government tried to sieze it from him so he burnt it to the ground. He then uses this rational at his explanation for attempting to kill everyone on Rapture. Also I would find a certain grim satisfaction in fighting a bunch of tax collecters, as long as they initiated the violence of course.
I don’t think so. I really hope your right Mammon, but at the part I am at Andrew Ryan talks about how he once owned a forest and the government tried to sieze it from him so he burnt it to the ground. He then uses this rational at his explanation for attempting to kill everyone on Rapture. Also I would find a certain grim satisfaction in fighting a bunch of tax collecters, as long as they initiated the violence of course.
The forest thing sounds pretty parallel to the way Francisco treated D’Anconia Copper in Atlas Shrugged – the People’s State of Argentina tried to nationalize his company, and he destroyed it. Francisco, as I recall, arranged the destruction in a way that did not kill innocent workers. You’d need a lot more justification than “they tried to take my stuff” to justify mass killing.
Also I would find a certain grim satisfaction in fighting a bunch of tax collecters, as long as they initiated the violence of course.
By definition of their job title, wouldn’t they have to have initiated it? ![]()
The forest thing sounds pretty parallel to the way Francisco treated D’Anconia Copper in Atlas Shrugged
I was thinking more of Ellis Wyatt and the “torch.” What Levine is doing with the game could be said to be more akin to American McGee’s Alice for Objectivism meets System Shock. That much I’m sure of. The question is whether he did it clearly enough for it to be recognizable as a distortion, or whether it is muddled and becomes another libertarian smear-job-by-association.
Right now, my video card doesn’t have shader model 3.0 so I’m stuck in the dark for the time being. (the game won’t run without it)
I was actually thinking of Roarke and his detonation of the his buildings but I think all those examples apply equally. Im done with this game, its getting more and more disgusting as you go on, I can’t keep playing it without feeling dirty, on a sidenote anyone know of any good first person shooters for the 360?
Thanks
I was actually thinking of Roarke and his detonation of the his buildings but I think all those examples apply equally. Im done with this game, its getting more and more disgusting as you go on, I can’t keep playing it without feeling dirty, on a sidenote anyone know of any good first person shooters for the 360?
Thanks
Disgusting how? Do you mean violent? If you’re disgusted because you think the game is anti-reason or objectivism I can say the good news is that after playing for a while and getting to a big reveal I can strongly say this game is definitely not anti-objectivism. I don’t want to say anymore because it will be a spoiler, even saying this is a bit of a spoiler if you try to connect the dots.
I had my doubts at first but I was confident a real life Elsworth Toohey could never create & direct a game as brilliant and masterful as this. Just like in the books, strong minds, and objective reasoning is required to create good art people can admire. Elsworth would never have the confidence to create something great or the desire.
As for other FPS games on the 360 my top 3 suggestions in this order would be: Gears of War (not quite first person), Oblivion (FPS/RPG), & Rainbow 6 Vegas. Aside from FPS games I would strongly suggest Dead Rising.
In my opinion none of these games compare to Bioshock on level of importance, interest, & quality.
Well I’ll be darned, I about lost hope for this game but I guess I’ll keep playing to see if it gets any better.
Spoiler Alert
I just completed the part where the artist has you hunt down and kill 4 people, take pictures of their corpses and then add them to his “masterpiece.” I am hoping this is the all type low point of the game because i didn’t exactly feel uplifted helping this crazy make his macabre art.
Thank you for your game sugguestions, I agree with your first 3 choices, those were the first 3 games I got for the 360. I havent tried Dead Rising yet, I’ll have to give it a shot.
Thanks
Bioshock is a first person shooter with Objectivist overtones. http://www.gamerswithjobs.com/node/32465
The protagonist is Andrew Ryan and there is a mysterious man called Atlas who is supposedly the antagonist.
The initial plot of BioShock – the founding of this utopia – mirrors the plot (albeit through a glass darkly) of Rand’s 1960’s epic book “Atlas Shrugged.” In “Atlas Shrugged” the worlds elite – the “atlases” – stage a minor rebellion and remove themselves to a better place: a valley where they can be free of the eye and hand of the world’s governments and those who would leech off their talents. While the rhetoric of Rapture’s founder, Andrew Ryan (an anagram of Ayn Rand with an extra “rew” thrown in for obfuscation) sounds like a Randian polemic, his nemesis is ambiguously named “Atlas.” To figure out which one is really the good guy or the bad guy, we’ll all have to play the game.
Here is the wiki link.
I just completed the part where the artist has you hunt down and kill 4 people, take pictures of their corpses and then add them to his “masterpiece.” I am hoping this is the all type low point of the game because i didn’t exactly feel uplifted helping this crazy make his macabre art.
I agree. The reveal made me feel better about that too.
I want to say more but I don’t know how to highlight text in black to hide a spoiler.
Cool thats all I needed to know, I’ll keep playing it then, thanks for the info
There are at least two other threads on this.
I want to say more but I don’t know how to highlight text in black to hide a spoiler.
It’s under “insert special item,” to the left of “fonts.” The mods should edit Pat’s post to use it, too.