Brook on O'Reilly 12/13

How does Hannity do with ARI-affiliated speakers?

Tom Bowden was the only one interviewed that I can recall, and I do not remember if Hannity himself interviewed him, but nothing on Hannity’s show could compare to the abuse that O’Reilly heaped on Peikoff on at least one occasion.

I think Brit Hume is a good interviewer, for the most part.

I rarely watch these shows, but my wife Betsy does and I know she thinks highly of Brit Hume.

I like Ed Locke’s columns.

Yes, he is terrific in a multitude of ways.

Note that Fox has been open to ARI-affiliated speakers. In addition to those on the O’Reilly show, Ed Locke was on Brit Hume’s show a couple of times, and Tom Bowden was on Hannity and Colmes.

I missed Locke and Bowden! That would have been great to watch. I rarely watch tv anymore. :slight_smile:

Harry Binswanger was very impressive on Geraldo Rivera’s show a year or so ago. Binswanger is very careful and measured in his responses, and usually hits the target well.

Harry Binswanger was very impressive on Geraldo Rivera’s show a year or so ago.  Binswanger is very careful and measured in his responses, and usually hits the target well.

Yes, I thought he did very well. As did Peter Schwartz and Yaron Brook when they too were on Geraldo. (ARI is surely doing something right in promoting Objectivism in this medium.)

There is also Jonathan Hoenig from Capitalist Pig who is on one the show “Cashin’ In”. Most of the time he is recomending stocks, but every once in awhile throws in a mention of Ayn Rand. I don’t know how much of an Objectivist he is in reality however (he does link to ARI, and not TOC when he refers to Objectivisim).

I thought Yaron Brook was terrific on the show. In the short time he had, he got in a large number of points, and stood up to O’Reilly real well. Brook got across what you otherwise never hear on TV, Fox or elsewhere, about how we need to do whatever it takes to win this war, and how we need to stop sacrificing our soldiers out of concern for the civilians. Brook also hammered home that it is appeasement which emboldens the enemy, and a strong, uncompromising stance is what is needed to bring the enemy to its knees. Great stuff!

I thought Yaron Brook was terrific on the show. In the short time he had, he got in a large number of points, and stood up to O’Reilly real well. Brook got across what you otherwise never hear on TV, Fox or elsewhere, about how we need to do whatever it takes to win this war, and how we need to stop sacrificing our soldiers out of concern for the civilians. Brook also hammered home that it is appeasement which emboldens the enemy, and a strong, uncompromising stance is what is needed to bring the enemy to its knees. Great stuff!

This is the first time I’ve seen an ARI guy on any major media, and I’m excited with Brook’s performance, for all the reasons you’ve given. Every time O’Reilly said that we’d “alienate the world” or that “the rest of the world doesn’t see it that way,” I wanted to shout Who cares?!

If anybody gets around to watching it again, look for all of Bill’s responses when Brook brings up Hiroshima. First he responded that “the rest of the world didn’t have nukes then,” then he said that “we asked those nations to surrender,” and his final attempt to distinguish Fallujah from Hiroshima was to say “Iraq didn’t attack us! That’s a very important difference.”

I just turned on the tube, and quote randomly happened to catch the last 10 seconds of the interview :frowning:

But isn’t it great that you can randomly come across Objectivist speakers in the media : :smiley:

Does anyone else think that Dr Brook and Dr Binswanger are responsible for much of this success?

I was surprised O’Reilly actually let Brook complete some of his thoughts. And they were good ones!

“I’d like to see Fallujah turned to dust.” Ditto.

He perfectly essentialized the flaw of the current war when he pointed out that the moral emphasis in past wars that we won was on preserving the lives of our soldiers, while in this one the emphasis is on preserving the lives of Iraqi civilians. O’Reilly concluded by saying, “I’d like to see us get more aggressive, but you can’t kill civilians.” Then how exactly do we fight this war when the enemy is hiding among them? Blank-out. All he can come up with to say is, "We have to fight it ‘smarter’ ". Gee, that’s real helpful there, Bill.

Did anyone watch Michael Newdow on the Hannity and Colmes program? He ate Hannity’s lunch. Whatever Newdow’s faults may be, he is an effective and persuasive speaker, at least on this seperation of church and state issue. He knows his stuff. Then I switched stations and saw Christopher Hitchens likewise making mincemeat of Pat Buchanan on Scarborough Country. I like Hitchens more and more the more I see and read of him, though I don’t know much about the guy.

O’Reilly really revealed himself last night, he actually said, “Perception is reality”.

Yeah he said “we have to fight it smarter” - that’s a mean underhand insult, i.e. your solution is dumb, my solution is smart, but I don’t actually know what my solution is; all I know is that it’s smarter than yours. That’s almost like saying any solution is smarter than yours, by definition.

O’Reilly really revealed himself last night, he actually said, “Perception is reality”.

I was surprised by that too. It was after Bill said that killing civilians would make us Nazis. When Brook responded that we are the good guys defending America, Bill said “Well the Nazis thought they were right too.” Brook then said “It doesn’t matter what you think you are, what matters is what you truly are.” Then came Bill’s awful plunge into subjectivism: “Perception is reality.”

The whole exchange reminded me why I never watch O’Reilly’s show. Brook needed, say, 3-5 sentences to get a significant point across, but the host would cut him off after one or two. And he would cut him off not with some intelligent question or counterargument, but with the most trite or ridiculous sort of statement.

For example, when Brook correctly argued that we need to place higher moral value on the lives of our soldiers than on those of Iraqi civilians, O’Reilly countered with the claim that that would make us Nazis.

This guy loves to act like a know-it-all, and won’t even go to the trouble of listening to what his guests say. His guests often come on to have a serious discussion, and he wants to throw spitballs at them.

I’m glad Brook at the chance to make the points he did, but it’ll be a long time before I revisit “The No-Spin Zone.”

(Incidentally, I think the nickname of his show is apt: he is a man devoid of spin – that is, ideology. He is an utter pragmatist, accepting the most banal and trite platitudes of the day, regardless of their mutual inconsistencies.)

…The whole exchange reminded me why I never watch O’Reilly’s show… 

I agree!! He’s disgusting. (Imagine a vomiting smiley here.)

Dr. Brook made some excellent points, but I was disappointed that he even mentioned bringing democracy to Iraq by bringing it’s culture to it’s knees, like we did with Japan after WW II. It would be too easy for a listener to assume that we need this as a reason to reduce them (and Iran) to dust. Being consistent with the concept of fighting in defense of the United States by removing a threat to it doesn’t necessarily require the emergence of democracy in Iraq after the war, just the removal of the threat. Bringing the “democarcy after the war” notion into the discussion smacks too much of the old “white man’s burden” argument used to justify the British colonies and of Bush’s altruistic attempt to turn Iraq into Missouri.

I was surprised by that too. It was after Bill said that killing civilians would make us Nazis. When Brook responded that we are the good guys defending America, Bill said “Well the Nazis thought they were right too.” Brook then said “It doesn’t matter what you think you are, what matters is what you truly are.” Then came Bill’s awful plunge into subjectivism: “Perception is reality.”

“The Nazis thought they were right too”

“Perception is reality”

Okay, Bill. So you’re saying that the Nazis WERE right, then? :smiley:

Is the Brook vs. O’Reilly interview available on the net at all?

Is the Brook vs. O’Reilly interview available on the net at all?

Now it’s on ARI in either “news” or “media.” You need RealPlayer.

Thank you.