7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
My quotation excludes a paragraph in which he says that under certain tragic circumstances, suicide is justified. I was only concerned with the status of the primary choice, so I excluded that side note.
Yes, I understand, and your exclusion was unobjectionable. I was only noting the fact because it is the very question of the morality of suicide (and more specifically, forum members arguing that “suicide is always immoral”) that sent us down this multi-thread-spanning rabbit-hole of an argument to begin with. So whatever else we decide, I am interested/invested in its implication for the question of suicide, and I mean to retain that initial context.
As for the rest, given my initial read-through, I must report that I suspect we’re coming perilously close to fundamental agreement. Hopefully I can trigger some fresh controversy anon and perhaps inspire you to a proper condemnation.
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
No. The choice is to follow the desire, instead of denying it. Adult humans have volition in this regard, animals and babies do not. This is why babies are entirely exluded from the field of ethics (not sure why we’re bringing them up).
LOL, well… erm, this is awkward, but I’d thought you yourself raised the topic of babies in your first post in this thread (hard upon Eiuol, who also brought that very topic up). It seemed fashionable to discuss babies, at the time, and I suppose that I am a slave to fashion.
But never mind that now (so long as we can). We can agree that adult humans have volition and choice in a way that neither animals nor babies (and especially newborns, and especially especially the prenatal) do – yes?
So saying that “babies make a choice,” whether it be a choice to live, or to die, or to eat Big Macs, is a mistake.
And I know that you have sometimes argued for a “choice” which does not take place in time or space, and which is “made for you,” and which you cannot choose not to make, and so forth – and maybe you think babies capable of that kind of “choice” – but I hope you’ll understand that, to me, it’s a bit like the dragon in Carl Sagan’s garage. I don’t think that “choice” is a choice at all.
If it’s reduced to a “desire to live,” I still can’t agree that babies have such a “desire” in any sensible fashion. (Again: they do not know that they are alive; they do not know what “living” is, or what the alternative is, or anything, really.) But that’s okay. A “desire to live” is still closer to what I believe to be true about babies than a “choice to live,” which is utterly insensible, and we should always strive to get as close as we can to truth, and to reality.
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
The point is that desire is intricately linked to choice, but not in a deterministic or behaviouristic fashion (and this can be said only about adult humans).
If we’re talking about adult humans, I agree that adult humans can choose to live – or die. Biddle in the video in my OP speaks to this, specifically, and he says that people who have a context (as, in my experience, people often do) can both ask and answer the question of “why should I choose to live”? I agreed with him.
He also argued that it would be better for some people in some circumstances to commit suicide. I agreed with him there, too.
If you think that’s “not morality,” I don’t even really care at this point, lol.
It still stands rather starkly against those who would claim that suicide in such cases is immoral, and it stands against those who would argue that suicide in such cases is either “subjective” or “arbitrary” (because I think that Biddle is right in his identification, and that desiring that which is better for the self is neither “subjective” nor “arbitrary”). I think it’s probably easier to call it “moral” rather than trying to create some ad hoc realm for the “justified-but-not-moral,” and moreover correct to call it moral, and still-moreover meaningful with respect to other ethical “controversies” to call it moral, but it otherwise seems almost like a semantic pursuit at this point.
If you would tell such a person, in the sorts of circumstances Biddle imagines, “your proposed suicide isn’t moral, per se… but it’s ‘justified’,” well, that’s at least a damn sight better than telling them that their suicide is immoral – that they should instead strive to live as long as possible, regardless of circumstances, because “happiness is always possible” (and there are people on this board who would say just this thing).
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
There is no such thing as an ‘unconscious choice’, excluding sleepwalkers or people on LSD. The source of the whim may well be automatic - the emotional mechanism merely reacts to your stored conscious or subconscious premises - but people have the faculty of volition, i.e. of choosing whether to follow their whims or not. “Should I think about it, or should I just act on my impulse?” This is why we can hold criminals accountable for their actions.
Agreed to all of this. (Minor caveat: not sure what I believe with respect to sleepwalkers or LSD; never really considered them.)
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
I’d be wary of conflating ‘choosing to live’ with ‘choosing to survive’. Ethics is geared toward a flourishing life, not (just) keeping the agent alive. Ayn Rand, as her novels prove abundantly, equated living with the broader meaning, i.e. functioning properly, being a happy individual.
You well know that I argue against ethics as “survival” alone, and much more for “flourishing” (though I am critical of many of the arguments made under the “flourishing” banner; I have a somewhat specific notion of what it means to “flourish,” though my thoughts on that matter are not yet settled or fully developed).
It is because I do not conflate “life” with “survival” that I believe that suicide may be moral in some cases. I believe that when the proper ends of ethics are understood, “keeping the agent alive” may not only lose its value but may become a disvalue.
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
All choices presupose that you want the object for some end, i.e. enjoyment, well-being, pleasure, happiness, safety. Metaphysicaly, enjoyment is an indicator of proper self-preservation, but psychologicaly you don’t give a damn about that. Your concern is the enjoyment, the pleasure. Pursuing well-being is pursuing life, and this is how it works for all higher animals. The major difference is that we don’t have automatic knowledge of good or bad.
I agree that we do not have “automatic knowledge of good or bad.” This is why we need ethics.
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
If we don’t choose our pleasures properly we end up obese, or addicted to heroin, or struggling with an STD. So it’s both, life and milk.
Doubleplus agreed.
More than “life and milk,” it is a life full of milk that we truly want. Milk is the stuff (of its nature) such that life is worth living. But yes, we must choose our pleasures properly to achieve this “life full of milk.”
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
If you want to die for no reason (like the creature in the example of the philosophy professors), or if something tragic happens that makes living unbearable to you, what do you need ethics for? To hang it on the wall?
If you want to die for no reason then you are a mythological creature, and as such I recommend immediate travel to Asgard to capture mighty Thor’s hammer, Mjölnir. For if you’re going to live the life (howsoever temporarily) of a mythological creature that cannot exist in reality, it might be fun to wield lightning for a while.
(And when you’re done, yes, you can hang Mjölnir on the wall, which I think would be quite attractive.)
If something tragic happens that makes living unbearable to you in some actual context, in reality, you might yet need ethics to manage your exit as best as possible, for even then some exits will be preferable to others, in reason. Some of these scenarios have been discussed at length in other recent threads about suicide, here and here. (If they need to be revisited, it might make more sense to pick up the conversation there. If absolute need be, we can pick them up here, or even start fresh.)
7 minutes ago, KyaryPamyu said:
What about people who choose live, but only so that they can continue whipping themselves, drinking laundry water and starving themselves on purpose? That would be an example of pure immorality.
I agree.
Also immoral: those who would suffer and suffer and suffer (through a life of inescapable torture) because they believe that there is some value in “survival” for its own sake, or counsel others to do likewise, or condemn those who commit suicide to escape such torture.