Draft

Okay, I don’t really think we should move to a deserted island. I was being entirely hypothetical. I, too, believe that this country is not yet beyond all hope, but I disagree when you say that Objectivism is winning. Yes, many more people are exposed to it than there used to be. Well, any person with a basic knowledge of statistics can tell you that part of that is because the population has grown. Even so, many people who become somewhat familiar with it just let it slide off their backs, or even become adamantly opposed to it.

“Men occasionally stumble on the truth, but most of them pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing had happened.”

-Winston Churchill

If you need an example of this, go to hobbes.resnet.tamu.edu/forums, run a forum search on “Ayn Rand” or “Objectivism” and read the discussions. Particularly look for the posts by the members named Whiteflea, Zathras, and Anatole.

Seems to me that to start a perfect society, we’d need to invite people who share many Objectivist principles but aren’t actually Objectivists.  The cold, hard truth is that the people who are the “motor of the world,” such as Bill Gates and people in similar positions, are not Objectivists.

Yet they are major producers.

Hank Rearden and Dagny Taggert weren’t Objectivists, either. :smiley: Being able to invite producers frustrated of trying to get along in a major “mixed economy” into a Galt’s Gulch is a very appealing idea. :wink:

They were certainly Objectivists by the end of the book. That’s why they Dagny was only allowed to stay in the Gulch for a certain period of time.

They were certainly Objectivists by the end of the book. That’s why they Dagny was only allowed to stay in the Gulch for a certain period of time.

EDIT: I have no idea why this posted twice. Anyone who has the power to delete it, please do so.

They were certainly Objectivists by the end of the book.  That’s why they Dagny was only allowed to stay in the Gulch for a certain period of time.

EDIT: I have no idea why this posted twice.  Anyone who has the power to delete it, please do so.

I think Yes has made a point that is both amusing and interesting. In the fictional world of Atlas Shrugged, there is no philosopher-novelist named Ayn Rand and thus no system of ideas named “Objectivism.” It is true that “This is John Galt Speaking” is as accurate a prospectus of Objectivism as you could ask for. But Yes is correct. Strictly speaking, there are no Objectivists in Atlas.

Eric Mathis writes: “…of the millions who devour Atlas Shrugged only a tiny percentage become full fledged Objectivists.”

This is true. But unanimous, monolithic philosophic agreement isn’t necessary for a cultural renaissance. Of the many who read John Locke, for example, only one grew up to be the third president of the United States. The majority of the population will always be ballast, for good or bad, regarding philosphic principles.

EM continues: “…as someone who spends hundreds of hours each year reading scholarly journals in philosophy, political science and economics, I see no evidence whatever of an Objectivist renaissance among academics.”

Well maybe you’re reading the wrong things. Maybe the influence hasn’t reached your particular experience yet. Most journals cling to an editorial status quo; the more specialized, the more this effect applies. But the trend is there: Alan Gotthelf at University of Pittsburgh, Tara Smith’s upcoming publication for [i forget the publishing company – a prestigious academically-oriented book publisher. If somebody remembers please feel free to post it]. University chairs and departments endowed by Objectivists, the Anthem Fellowship Program and the Ayn Rand Business Library at Auburn [again, going by memeory here; feel free to correct if necessary]. The number of Objectivist students entering acedemia growing exponentially. This list could go on for quite a while…

EM: “But let us go ahead and suppose that Ayn Rand’s philosophy will grow three times as fast in its second 50 years as in its first – where does that leave us?”

Assuming we could quantify such a thing, it would leave us 300% better off than in 1956. But why the supposition? What rationale justifies 3x as a measure?

Let’s consider another example: let’s suppose that computer memory available for home computer users increases 3 times faster in the 50-year period after 1980, as it did in the 50 years before 1980. At that rate people will be able to play Pac Man on their home computer well before the 22nd century!

Fact is, intellectual movements tend to simmer and ferment, and then progress in exponential bursts. The Renaissance did not produce great art and culture at a rate 3 times the progress of the dark ages, it exploded a hundred times that fast.

The industrial revolution didn’t continue the rate of progress and wealth of previous ages, it surpassed previous ages’ wealth in terms beyond description. Objectivism further improves on these movements, in its noncontradicotry alliance with reality. If you’d be interested in making a long-term bet, a la Simon and Ehrlich, about the future state of Objectivism, I’d be more than happy to take your money. :slight_smile:

EM: “That would be like counseling Midas Mulligan to forget about Galt’s Gulch and spend his money giving away copies of Bastiat’s The Law…”

It would be like that, except for one thing: Midas Mulligan was a fictional character. His real-world creator, Ayn Rand, regarded Utopian fantasies as naive.

EM: “Call me selfish, but my philosophy is to free myself first.”

You are free, Eric Mathis. Note the computer under your fingers and the uncensored message in front of your eyes.

Moose notes: “many more people are exposed to [Objectivsm] than there used to be. Well, any person with a basic knowledge of statistics can tell you that part of that is because the population has grown.”

If the rate of population growth equalled the rate at which Ayn Rand’s name is increasingly mentioned in the media, you wouldn’t have had the elbow room to type that sentence.

From Moose: “Even so, many people who become somewhat familiar with it just let it slide off their backs, or even become adamantly opposed to it.”

That’s their problem, not mine. Historically, that same has been true of every new idea from anaesthesia to heavier-than-air flight. The existence of ballast doesn’t tell me much about the direction of the ship.

From Moose: "If you need an example of this, go to [a sp. forum] and read the discussions [of “Objectivsm” and “Ayn Rand”].

Now why would I do that? I know idiots exist; I don’t need to immerse myself in their culture.

Oh, that’s just silly semantics. They agree with the principles of Objectivism, so they might just as well be called Objectivists.

This is true. But unanimous, monolithic philosophic agreement isn’t necessary for a cultural renaissance. Of the many who read John Locke, for example, only one grew up to be the third president of the United States. The majority of the population will always be ballast, for good or bad, regarding philosphic principles.

I read the above response by Eric Mathis, but could not read/understand a good bit of it. If you’d like to edit and repost, I’d be happy to respond when I get a chance.

I read the above response by Eric Mathis, but could not read/understand a good bit of it. If you’d like to edit and repost, I’d be happy to respond when I get a chance.

This is true. But unanimous, monolithic philosophic agreement isn’t necessary for a cultural renaissance. Of the many who read John Locke, for example, only one grew up to be the third president of the United States. The majority of the population will always be ballast, for good or bad, regarding philosphic principles.

The writings of John Locke and the English libertarian “Cato,” were well known and highly regarded among the men of wealth and influence in the American colonies. Please offer some evidence that anything like this is taking shape with regard to Ayn Rand and those who have influence over modern American society.

Well maybe you’re reading the wrong things. Maybe the influence hasn’t reached your particular experience yet. Most journals cling to an editorial status quo; the more specialized, the more this effect applies. But the trend is there: Alan Gotthelf at University of Pittsburgh, Tara Smith’s upcoming publication for [i forget the publishing company – a prestigious academically-oriented book publisher. If somebody remembers please feel free to post it]. University chairs and departments endowed by Objectivists, the Anthem Fellowship Program and the Ayn Rand Business Library at Auburn [again, going by memeory here; feel free to correct if necessary]. The number of Objectivist students entering acedemia growing exponentially. This list could go on for quite a while…

Great! The growth of Objectivists entering academic positions and publishing in academic journals is both exciting and commendable. But it hardly suggests that there is a “renaissance” in Objectivism at the university level. I no longer have Lexus/Nexus access, but any real demonstration of the rise of Objectivism in academia would have to pass a comparison test of Lexis/Nexus five years ago with it today.

Assuming we could quantify such a thing, it would leave us 300% better off than in 1956. But why the supposition? What rationale justifies 3x as a measure?

My guess is that we will not be politically better off even if we have three times the number of Objectivists as we have today – and if we are it will only be a matter of coincidence. Three times the number is still a very tiny percentage of the electorate and only a tiny percentage of those who exert influence over politics and popular culture.

Let’s consider another example: let’s suppose that computer memory available for home computer users increases 3 times faster in the 50-year period after 1980, as it did in the 50 years before 1980. At that rate people will be able to play Pac Man on their home computer well before the 22nd century!

Non sequitur. Just because there was a home computer revolution, it doesn’t follow that Objectivism will enjoy the same success. You still have not presented any compelling evidence that Objectivism is going to become the dominant philosophical model 30, 40 or even 50 years hence.

Fact is, intellectual movements tend to simmer and ferment, and then progress in exponential bursts. The Renaissance did not produce great art and culture at a rate 3 times the progress of the dark ages, it exploded a hundred times that fast.

The industrial revolution didn’t continue the rate of progress and wealth of previous ages, it surpassed previous ages’ wealth in terms beyond description. Objectivism further improves on these movements, in its noncontradicotry alliance with reality. If you’d be interested in making a long-term bet, a la Simon and Ehrlich, about the future state of Objectivism, I’d be more than happy to take your money.

The superiority of an idea is no guarantee of its success in popular culture. For example, the intellectual validity of theism was thoroughly refuted by the middle of the 18th century. But it’s still very much a part of our culture and shows no sign of going away.

It would be like that, except for one thing: Midas Mulligan was a fictional character. His real-world creator, Ayn Rand, regarded Utopian fantasies as naive.

I’m disappointed to hear that Rand thought that the heroes of her great novel were naïve.

You are free, Eric Mathis. Note the computer under your fingers and the uncensored message in front of your eyes.

If I’m free what happened to all that money I sent the IRS last month?

I hate to go back to the stated topic…but…

The Army has missed its recruitment goals for the last three months straight. It missed April by 42%. My recollection is that it was actually missing the goals several months prior to that but revising the stated goals downward after the fact so that it could “meet” them (so the amount they missed by must have been smaller).

In some period of time if this trend continues the military is not going to have the manpower to continue to pursue all of its obligations.

It seems to me very clear that this is something of a referendum on the desire of the American people to pursue the Iraq War.

If the people do not support the war by being willing to fight in it, then the government is immoral to continue to fight it, and should begin pulling out.

Since when is morality defined by what the American people want? Pulling out of Iraq would be admitting defeat and would be seen as a victory for Islamofascism over the West. What’s immoral isn’t the fact that we’re still fighting the war. What’s immoral is the fact that we haven’t blown the Middle East off the face of the earth.

Well…

  1. It is immoral to force people to fight in war (i.e. a draft is immoral)

  2. It is immoral to keep an army in the field if it is undermanned and unable to function properly as a result

  3. I think it is immoral at a certain point to maintain people in the military beyond their contractual obligations without a national emergeny. Even if you disagree with that you will agree that this is going to drive morale down and they are going to have to be let go eventually.

I guess 2 currently isn’t the case but without some way to get people to fight we just have to wait for attrition to make 2 be the case.

I would think the moral thing to do would be to pull out before it was painfully obvious that 2 was the case.

Where do you plan to get the manpower from without a draft given that enlistments are down?

If we would fight a proper war, we wouldn’t need anymore manpower. If Bush had decided to unleash the dogs of war instead of pussyfooting around like we have been, we could have easily destroyed the insurgence in less than a year. It’s never too late to make the right decision.

Yeah… Nuclear weapons! :slight_smile:

Yeah… Nuclear weapons! :slight_smile:

If nuclear weapons are the answer, why not reduce the entire U.S. armed forces to just a few missile launch crews?

EM wrote: “The writings of John Locke and the English libertarian “Cato,” were well known and highly regarded among the men of wealth and influence in the American colonies. Please offer some evidence that anything like this is taking shape with regard to Ayn Rand and those who have influence over modern American society.”

What evidence do you wish? It’s a rather large order, if you want a thorough list. You want multi-millionaires? Monroe Trout. John McCaskey. You want top-500 NYSE and Nasdaq coporate heads? John Allison, BBT Bank. T.J. Rodgers, Cypress Semidonductor. You want eveidence of recent influence among businessmen in the tech sector? Just google “silicon valley” and “Ayn Rand”, and get back to me after you’ve read the first thousand entries. Rand’s influence among doctors? Small business owners? Within the culture at large? Just link to Ayn Rand News via Google, the link of which is provided on this site’s homepage. Who else has influence in modern American society? University intellectuals? I’ve already pointed to O-ism’s inroads into academia in previous posts. What is it you’d regard as “evidence”, if not pages an pages of evidence?

EM continues: “…The growth of Objectivists entering academic positions and publishing in academic journals is both exciting and commendable. But it hardly suggests that there is a “renaissance” in Objectivism at the university level.”

It hardly suggests this? Orders-of-magnitude greater numbers and quality of Objectivists teaching and publishing seems to suggest exactly that.

EM: “…I no longer have Lexus/Nexus access, but any real demonstration of the rise of Objectivism in academia would have to pass a comparison test of Lexis/Nexus five years ago with it today.”

Well, then, I’ll make this line of discussion easier: Access the LN database through whichever method you wish. When you show me that there has been no increase in academic tratment of Objectivism/Ayn Rand since Q2 2000, I will pay for your LN subscription.

EM: “…My guess is that we will not be politically better off even if we have three times the number of Objectivists as we have today – and if we are it will only be a matter of coincidence.”

Can you offer any reason why I should regard your “guess” as relevant here?

“Three times the number is still a very tiny percentage of the electorate and only a tiny percentage of those who exert influence over politics and popular culture.”

The electorate do not have to be philosophers. Their teachers’ teachers do. When there are three times more Objectivist professors in universities – which looks to be inevitable within about 10 years – we’ll find out whether their influence is 3 times as much, or much more than that.

EM [referring to my example of the growth of home computer influence]: “Non sequitur. Just because there was a home computer revolution, it doesn’t follow that Objectivism will enjoy the same success.”

Of course it was a non sequitur. That was its point. You had given an example wherein O-ist influence had prgressed at a certain rate for a certain time period, with the implication that it would then likely continue at that rate. My coutner-example illustrated that such are dangerous assumptions.

EM: “You still have not presented any compelling evidence that Objectivism is going to become the dominant philosophical model 30, 40 or even 50 years hence.”

Of course I haven’t. One does not “present compelling evidence” of the state of intellectual movements 50 years into the future. People have free will. Nothing man-made can be guaranteed for the future. I have, however, offered plenty of evidence that the Objectivist movement is growing. Financially, professionally, culturally.

EM: “I’m disappointed to hear that Rand thought that the heroes of her great novel were naïve.”

You can attempt to attribute to me things I didn’t say, all you want. Rand was clear: she regarded the culture as flawed but capable of correction. She regarded utopians as naive.

EM: “If I’m free what happened to all that money I sent the IRS last month?”

This topic – whether or not we are free in our current culture – has been done ad nauseum on this, and other, fora. I’ve said my piece on it elsewhere, and have nothing more to contribute here.

Let’s close this digreesion – for which I apologize to other forum mebers (I’m not that swift navigating the forum site, and realize I should have started another thread, but didnt’ want to lose all the posting in a cyber-limbo mistake) – with a challenge:

EM, you come up with some objective, exact, discrete measurements, by which you’d concede an either growing or waning influence of Objectivism in the culture. Present these terms here, including the time frame, and we’ll bet $1.00, just like Julian Simon and Paul Ehrlich did. At the designated date in the future, you present the evidence exactly as you agreed in the terms, and the winner walks away one dollar and considerable I-told-you-so rights richer.

Sound fair?

I don’t think the draft is going to happen. But if it does, and they decide to draft the ladies as well, I got a plan to get out of it. My friend and I have agreed to go put on a nice make-out show for the army recruiters so we get the boot for being icky lesbians. I know it sucks to fake reality, but if they’re going to be stupid enough to continue to exclude people based on their sex lives I’m taking advantage of their stupidity. They don’t have to know me and my buddy both dig the fellas…

On a more disturbing note, the draft may not be popular, but this idea of “national service” is. You know, the notion of taking young people out of high school or college and forcing them to “serve their country” in a non-military way, doing other pet projects for the government. A lot of people are in favor of this, even my own damn mom! I tried to explain to her that I own my life and that it’s immoral for the government to make (yet another) claim on it, but she’s of the mind that “we owe it to the nation to give back to the community”, whatever that means. I think we should be focusing our energy on stopping the much more real possibility of this national service crap.

If nuclear weapons are the answer, why not reduce the entire U.S. armed forces to just a few missile launch crews?

Simply because we need more nukes then that to use as a deterrent to Chinese and Russian aggression. We need a regular force, because sometimes it is in our interest to convert nations to Capitalist Republics instead of killing them all and irradiating their natural resources.

We need a regular force because it is always within our interests to defend ourselves against known, and ever-present, enemies of freedom, such as rogue Middle East states who sponsor terrorism.

I view our attacking such a rogue state and imposing a constitutional republic on them as being a consequence of our right to defend our self-interests.

That can be done with a sound strategy based upon principle, and with an all-enlisted armed force.

To impose a draft to achieve an end of “adequate recruitment” is akin to imposing slavery upon those drafted.