drugs

You can get high even though that might infringe on my personal rights as long as my property rights are protected? You’re suggesting that we can control the behavior of drugged individuals or that they can control their own behavior.

What is being suggested is that I can control my behaviour at all time. If that proves not to be true, and I violate your rights, then you can put me in jail.

If you are suggesting that my using drugs constitutes a violation of your rights, I suggest you prove that first, and only then start talking about restricting what I may or may not use.

Until then you are the one violating my rights by using the weapons of the government to dictate what substances I may ingest, buy or sell, thus initiating force against me. By doing this to me, you are acting like every thug, and you lose the right to be treated with the respect I generally extend to my fellow human beings.

So Marijuana doesn’t inhibit your rationality?

It does inhibit my thinking, so does alcohol. There’s no way I can solve a problem after three beers with the same ease that I can solve it sober.

However, whether I smoked a joint or had a few beers, it is my experience that I would still know how to go about solvintg the problem, it’s just that it wouldn’t go as fast. Of course it doesn’t matter, since I only drink or smoke once all my work is done.

So, the answer is that the ammount I smoked never caused me to stop thinking rationally, but it does obviously slow me down, just like alcohol. (in fact I would say alcohol is a bit worse)

But I guess you can say it inhibits my rationality, in a sense. It however doesn’t prevent my rationality completely. For the tasks I set up to accomplish for the few hours while under the influence, I have plenty of ability to reason left.

As for doing hard stuff, heroin, coke, speed, that’s obviously wrong, under any circumstances. (because it’s addictive and it does prevent you from being rational- both the addiction and the drug)

So, the answer is that the ammount I smoked never caused me to stop thinking rationally, but it does obviously slow me down

So by that logic if someone only injected a little bit of heroin or snorted a little bit of coke it would be ok. As long as it didnt stop them from being completely rational.

As for using drugs, Ayn Rand was against using what she called “mind-altering” drugs. (at least that’s the term I think she, or Dr. Peikoff, quoting her, used) However, she wasn’t against alcohol.(in moderation)

I personally have been known to eat the occasional pot-brownie (especially when I was on a non-alcohol diet for a few months), or light a joint when someone had it.

I wouldn’t try to go out and “score” or maintain a relationship with someone who deals pot though, so for the most part I stick to beer. (Not because of what Rand said-I don’t think it’s imoral to smoke pot-, but because it’s illegal, and it’s really not worth the risk. A couple of beers relax me just fine.)

As for doing hard stuff, heroin, coke, speed, that’s obviously wrong, under any circumstances. (because it’s addictive and it does prevent you from being rational- both the addiction and the drug) Agh I sound like Nancy Reagan.

Actually, cocaine, speed, and heroin (in moderation, however small “moderation” would be in their cases) does not alter the mind in the sense Rand blasts - i.e., in the sense that it alters perception of reality as any dose of LSD high enough to affect the brain would do. To tone down heroin a bit, take classic old opium smoking - it leads to many similar physical “joys” and mental “opening-ups” as alcohol gives in relationally similar moderation.

Rand and Peikoff may not know this, but through no fault of their own - their general rejection of any drugs and the subsequent disinterest in studying how it would effect their bodies is proper. However, they’re still right; even though alcohol is addictive, it takes a much longer time and many indulgences that surpass moderation to take hold, whereas with cocaine and heroin, comparative “moderate use” (in the sense of results similar to moderate use of alcohol in singular instants) can quickly lead to one’s capacity for choice being pressed - or, if moderation is passed - completely squashed. One cannot “moderately use” heroin for a week without the chemicals blasting the body in its absence, more or less maintain its moderate use for a lifetime while avoiding addiction completely, as one can with alcohol. Thus, they are still correct in maintaining that it is improper for a rational person to use.

Should still be legal, though.

So by that logic if someone only injected a little bit of heroin or snorted a little bit of coke it would be ok. As long as it didnt stop them from being completely rational.

What logic is that?

The logic according to which one may use pot and coke interchangeably in a sentence, because there is no fundamental difference between the two? I don’t subscribe to that “logic”.

In fact I didn’t present any “logic”. I simply assessed a concrete scenario: me smoking pot from time to time. I stated what was my first hand observation of its effects on me. The only principle I applied is that “direct observation is valid”.

And what happens when someone becomes addicted to that drug and are incapable of rationally rejecting it?

Why, is that an argument for approving government regulation on drug transactions? If the “someone” here was exercising his right not to buy, he wouldn’t be addicted to begin with.

If he brought and used harmful drugs in the first place without physical threat of force from the dealers, then he only has himself to blame when he gets addicted.

Being addicted does not make a person incapable of rationally rejecting the drug. People break addictions all the time on their own.

Certain drugs may make a person incapable of being rational, but the craving and the addiction behavior takes place in the absence of the drug, between fixes.

Drugs aren’t the only things people get addicted to. Overeating, sex, porn, gambling, tv, internet, video games, etc. can mess a person’s life up, too. Doesn’t mean any of those activities, including drug use, are inherently evil. It’s the overuse of such things that’s dangerous. Recreation is great, in fact necessary, in order to live a good life, but not when it starts to hinder one’s ability to make something of his or herself.

However, some of the commonly referred to hard drugs do seem to create a physiological dependence in the user, so if one was to use them, he should know what he might be getting into.

So by that logic if someone only injected a little bit of heroin or snorted a little bit of coke it would be ok. As long as it didnt stop them from being completely rational.

Because there is no difference between the before and after mentioned substances.

Along with being a hell of a lot more dangerous, it has completely different effects on one’s mental capacity. This isn’t even good rationalism.

And what happens when someone becomes addicted to that drug and are incapable of rationally rejecting it?

Sounds like that someone made a bad decision for which they are suffering consequences.

However, some of the commonly referred to hard drugs do seem to create a physiological dependence in the user, so if one was to use them, he should know what he might be getting into.

I don’t think that some recreational drugs are really prone to “casual” use. For instance, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of or seen a “casual” crack user or meth user. Obviously that doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t exist, but the evidence I have available to me at this point suggests that one time usage is typically enough to create a dependence / addiction.

I don’t think that some recreational drugs are really prone to “casual” use. For instance, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of or seen a “casual” crack user or meth user. Obviously that doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t exist, but the evidence I have available to me at this point suggests that one time usage is typically enough to create a dependence / addiction.

Perhaps we are focusing too much on the drug itself instead of the underlying reason for using the drug. Why do people use drugs?

…for example, the only reason I’ve ever heard someone give - in essential terms now - for using pot is that it makes them “feel good”. They’re after the high. They’re after an emotional response. But that emotional response is not to any particular achievement. The value becomes - intrinsically - the drug. They are after the high for the high’s sake.

Could you say that doing drugs promotes an intrinsic value system? This may not mean much to the non-Objectivist, but the implications would be clear to one familiar with Rand.

Of course, I’ve known a few pot smokers who were essentially looking for the effect (feeling good) without the cause (achievement). In my view, while perhaps not immoral, it is self-destructive.

Of course, I’ve known a few pot smokers who were essentially looking for the effect (feeling good) without the cause (achievement). In my view, while perhaps not immoral, it is self-destructive.

Self-destruction is immoral. When getting high, on pot or whatever, becomes a person’s top value as opposed to one’s own life, he has surrendered his rational pursuit of goals to his emotional whims. Can’t get much more non-Objectivist than that.

In response to RationalBiker’s post- I agree. I don’t think there are many people who try shooting heroin and just walk away from it with no difficulties. There might be a few exceptions, but that’s my take on it.

Self-destruction is immoral. When getting high, on pot or whatever, becomes a person’s top value as opposed to one’s own life, he has surrendered his rational pursuit of goals to his emotional whims. Can’t get much more non-Objectivist than that.

In response to RationalBiker’s post- I agree. I don’t think there are many people who try shooting heroin and just walk away from it with no difficulties. There might be a few exceptions, but that’s my take on it.

I guess I was thinking in broad terms of whether or not the person’s value system was such that drugs were deemed altruistic or egoistic. But if you were upholding your life as the standard of value, which I can’t really see where you could avoid doing that (if only implicitly), I would have to agree about self-destructiveness being immoral.

I guess where the connection would have to be made is the realization or the acceptance that you cannot operate on the premise that you can “eat your cake before you have it”.

I don’t think that some recreational drugs are really prone to “casual” use. For instance, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of or seen a “casual” crack user or meth user. Obviously that doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t exist, but the evidence I have available to me at this point suggests that one time usage is typically enough to create a dependence / addiction.

I might be mistaken, but I’ve heard meth highs are notoriously long; a day or more of sleepless energetic euphoria followed by a near equal period of sleepless crash, including “tweaker naps.” I don’t think I could spend two or more days of my life doing something and call it casual. Any drug that effects the user for more than a couple of hours would seem to prohibit casual use. Of course, this doesn’t address the actual effects of the drug. Hallucinogens strike me as being across the moral line, but you can bet I’d take some kind of wonder-speed if it made me think faster and otherwise had no adverse health effects. I wouldn’t be taking this stuff casually, either.

Regardless of ill-effects and immorality, one cannot justify using force to prevent drug use. Even if a drug actually caused it’s users to violate others’ rights, it should still be legal so long as the user takes precautions to prevent himself from completing his drug-induced crimes (like self-imposed restraints or confinement for the duration of the high). I haven’t heard any substantiated claims that there are any drugs that even do this.

I actually believe drug use can be very moral. It’s really a matter of value judgment and what the objective is in using any drug, from coffee to heroin. If the goal is to evade reality there is a problem. Even MDMA was being used as an aid in therapy before being made illegal. A prostitute trying to earn her next hit of crack and a Colombian laborer chewing on coca leaves (like we may drink coffee) are taking in the same chemical, though for completely different reasons and with completely different results.

In general it’s a good idea to be suspicious about drug use. In Rand’s time drug use was closely tied to hippies, collectivism, and subjectivity and for many, many people this still holds true. But under the right situations, drug use CAN promote one’s life.

Like I’ve posted elsewhere, of all the drugs one can take to relax (this includes caffeine, alcohol, and tobacco) I prefer opiates. Under the influence of an opiate one can relax quite nicely without the fuzziness, emotional roller coaster, or poor motor judgement that occurs with alcohol ingestion. Obviously, any drug taken can be dangerous (that includes caffeine!) With opiates you can become very relaxed and enjoy yourself without succumbing to the brain fry and all the clumsy stupidness that usually accompanies alcohol inebriation. I find it odd how, for many Oists, the drug of choice is alcohol, like it’s the only one christened by objectivism. If anything, alcohol would seem to me to be the last drug of choice if one is wishing to relax.

I find it odd how, for many Oists, the drug of choice is alcohol, like it’s the only one christened by objectivism.

I think someone else touched on this, but it could have something to do with alcohol being legal and the fact that doing drugs isn’t worth the risk of going to jail.

I hold, as it’s been said before, that if used moderately and in a purely recreational way (i.e., not escapism) then drug use can be moral. Whether or not you deem this to be worth the risk of jail time is your own judgement. I view, however, that doing so is not a rational risk and is instead a sign of a problem that one is willing to risk their own liberty and right to life for a few hours of pleasure.

Also, a related question: is their any validity to certain chemical addictions (alcohol, for example) to be passed genetically, or is that simply a scapegoat for people who are addicted to cast the responsibility of their actions onto other people? I ask because I know that my family has had a long line of alcoholism, and if their is validty to this claim, then it also becomes logical (and not just a matter of personal taste) for me not to consume any alcohol or other chemical substances.

My family has a strong alcohol addiction past. I’ve drank alcohol and have not become addicted. In fact, I really don’t like it all that much.