How much danger are we in? What can we do?

On 12/23/2017 at 5:09 PM, Grames said:

At any rate the effect of this “hack” was to reveal the truth about the inside workings of the DNC.  I welcome such hacks and wish for more of them.  It helps voters make better decisions.

No, what would’ve helped voters make better decisions was if both parties private mail was released at the same time. Including Trump Jr.'s correspondence with WikiLeaks. (all the stuff described in this article: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/11/the-secret-correspondence-between-donald-trump-jr-and-wikileaks/545738/) Tax records too, while we’re on the subject. 

Then voters would’ve had the information needed to decide which of the two bad choices is worse: the Hillary camp colluding with each other to handicap Sanders, or the Trump camp, colluding with Wikileaks and Russia, to handicap Clinton.

Having the Russian government decide which dirty secrets to release and which not to doesn’t help American voters make good decisions. It’s an absurd suggestion.

11 hours ago, Nicky said:

It’s telling that you cut off that Nathaniel Freitas quote right before he said the exact opposite: that metadata doesn’t exclude the Russians, far from it. From Wikipedia:

The Guardian Project founder Nathaniel Freitas independently reviewed Lawrence’s article on behalf of The Nation, concluding that while “the work of the Forensicator is detailed and accurate,” it did not prove the conclusions VIPS and Lawrence derived from it. Freitas stated that the high throughput suggested by the relevant metadata could have been achieved by a hacker under several different scenarios, including through the use of a remote access trojan, and that the leak hypothesis also requires “the target server … to be physically on site in the building”: “If the files were stored remotely ‘in the cloud,’ then the same criticism of ‘it is not possible to get those speeds’ would come into play.” In sum: “At this point, given the limited available data, certainty about only a very small number of things can be achieved.”

So the only guy with credentials and a history of cyber security, in this whole thing, is telling you that your conclusions are wrong. Why are you still going with this? Why would you post an obscure blog even the one professional who bothered to acknowledge it said was wrong?

What’s telling is that there was no point arguing what the facts mean until you could understand and accept what the facts were.

Freitas is certainly not the only guy with credentials weighing in here, and the topic at hand is simple enough (dividing sum of file sizes by time elapsed) that credentials hardly even matter.  I included Freitas to show that objectively even a subject matter expert that won’t make the same conclusions and inductions as Forensicator could understand and agree that the methods used by Forensicator were sound, accurate and not unintelligible.

5 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

The ends justify the means?

When a thief steals from a thief it is a kind of vigilantism. 

18 hours ago, Grames said:

  Freitas is certainly not the only guy with credentials weighing in here, and the topic at hand is simple enough (dividing sum of file sizes by time elapsed) that credentials hardly even matter.

It’s not simple. It’s fairly complex. You made it simple by ignoring everything that disproves your simplistic, ignorant theory.

Freitas dismantled the whole thing in a sentence. You should read that sentence, instead of going on about “dividing sum of file sizes by time elapsed”.

 

Lots. Heaps.

5 hours ago, Nicky said:

It’s not simple. It’s fairly complex. You made it simple by ignoring everything that disproves your simplistic, ignorant theory.

Freitas dismantled the whole thing in a sentence. You should read that sentence, instead of going on about “dividing sum of file sizes by time elapsed”.

 

Really?  Which sentence was that?

5 hours ago, Nicky said:

It’s not simple. It’s fairly complex. You made it simple by ignoring everything that disproves your simplistic, ignorant theory.

Freitas dismantled the whole thing in a sentence. You should read that sentence, instead of going on about “dividing sum of file sizes by time elapsed”.

 

It is not my theory, credit to Forensicator.   Freitas hesitates to go where Forensicator does but can’t rule it out either.

Meanwhile, it appears what little malware was reportedly found the DNC server may have been planted by CrowdStrike, the computer security firm that was hired by the DNC.  Full story here by Adam Carter. 

At any rate, whether or not that story pans out we get dates laid out for when CrowdStrike was involved relative to when the Wikileaks data was liberated.  The latest dates of Wikileaks emails were 25 May 2016 but CrowdStrike were on the case and getting paid for it before then.  Rebooting a backup server with a Linux distro on a USB stick and copying the data to that same USB stick would then be safest way for an insider to get the data out.  A remote hacker wouldn’t care about leaving evidence in logs pointing to a compromised user account but an insider would.   Rebooting a backup server from a USB stick bypasses user account controls.

That scenario of an insider rebooting a server from a USB stick is Forensicator’s, I am just claiming that it makes sense.  

On 12/24/2017 at 3:14 PM, Grames said:

Of all the reporting done on this angle to the story there is really only one original source which is The Forensicatorwebsite, a wordpress blog.  Read up on what is there and you will know all that I know. 

Why should I trust this site as a good source?

1 hour ago, Eiuol said:

Why should I trust this site as a good source?

You don’t need to trust it.  As Freitas wrote, “The Forensicator has worked carefully with the limited set of data available, providing the means necessary for anyone to reproduce the work and analysis.” You either have the background knowledge to understand his calculations to the point of being able to check them or you don’t. 

At some point the data was transferred to a USB memory stick.   It cannot be proven where or when in the chain of custody from the DNC to Wikileaks that happened but the inference that looks most plausible was when it was removed from the DNC’s possession or its backup server location.

2 hours ago, Grames said:

At some point the data was transferred to a USB memory stick.

That’s it? A USB stick? Why not say the color too? If you’re going to make stuff up, you might as well give it a color. Was it red? I bet it was red. I can tell by the way the file smelled when I opened it.

There’s no evidence of a USB stick. You can’t divine what a file was stored on by looking at it, it’s silly talk.

Quote

You either have the background knowledge to understand his calculations to the point of being able to check them or you don’t. 

There’s no need for special expertise to dismantle most of what he’s saying. Let’s take the way he divined the mythical USB stick, for instance, since you brought it up: " This transfer rate (23 MB/s) is typically seen when copying local data to a fairly slow (USB-2) thumb drive. "

That’s it. That’s the only attempt at backing up the whole USB stick story. You really don’t need to be any kind of computer expert to know that an old USB stick is not the only thing you’ll see 23 MB/s speed on. Or that most old USB sticks don’t even have that speed, there’s a huge variance in transfer speeds.

Freitas made assumptions that he didn’t test… so I tested them for him.

http://g-2.space/thenation/

Foreniscator didn’t just get USB stick usage from the speed (reliable peak was 38MB/s fwiw, outlier peak of 49MB/s) - there were also indicators of FAT filesystem use.

There was also the Eastern Time observation too (ie. the main archive was created in September by some whose computer had eastern time set as their timezone)

So he’s not “making stuff up”, the USB stick is very likely rather than “mythical” and there are certainly multiple indicators of USB stick usage compared to your "There’s no evidence of a USB stick ".

Hi Nicky,

“His intelligence services hacked the DNC”

APT29 malware was there since the Summer 2015, IC suspects it’s related to RU intelligence but nothing solid demonstrating that.  APT28 malware was apparently compiled just before and during CrowdStrike’s visit in early May, IC suspects APT28 is related to RU intelligence too due to array of targets exposed by Fidelis (which is considerably more compelling than APT29 attribution) but the compile dates and significantly outdated C2 server IP addresses in the APT28 malware raise doubts about the authenticity of it).

Furthermore, CrowdStrike, despite having Falcon installed across the DNC network by the May 11, 2016 and the emails being acquired at least 8 days later - only managed to release out-of-context IOCs and malware code samples - there was no incident specific evidence, something they should have had thanks to their monitoring capabilities at that time.

CrowdStrike have never been able to explain how or when any of the malware discovered interacted with emails or transferred any significant data to remote hosts.

“released compromising information to Wikileaks in order to prevent a Clinton victory.”

We don’t know who gave WikiLeaks the emails.

“This was an unprecedentedly hostile act. While espionage, including hacking, is par for the course between competing world powers, none of them have dumped the information they obtained through espionage onto the web, to influence elections, before. As such, this is a new level of hostility, which warrants an equally hostile response.”

The DNC is a private organization, attacking them is not an attack on the state (the law may change on that in future but for now, they aren’t technically part of the government).  We also don’t have any hard evidence that they were complicit, so you’re essentially demanding a hostile response on the basis of what is assumed but not demonstrated.

“No, what would’ve helped voters make better decisions was if both parties private mail was released at the same time.”

There’s no indication WikiLeaks had RNC emails or the tax returns but I do agree that it would have been nice if those were leaked to WikiLeaks and then published at the same time.

“Having the Russian government decide which dirty secrets to release and which not to doesn’t help American voters make good decisions. It’s an absurd suggestion”

There’s nothing to show WikiLeaks obtained the emails that they published from Russia or any other state.

“Freitas dismantled the whole thing in a sentence.”

Freitas was using the average rate rather than peak rate and his alternate hypotheses (pivot server theory, etc) would inherently have made the hack needlessly easier to detect, something most hackers would typically avoid (it’s more of a convenient way to explain the bitrate than be something hackers would typically do or choose to do).

To try to explain away the FAT32 anomalies Freitas has suggested that a server may have an NTFS primary drive and FAT32 secondary (possible but very rare these days).  It would be a completely unnecessary risk of detection moving gigabytes of files to a secondary drive at those rates.

While Freitas is pointing out possibilities, they are already significantly less probable scenarios than those stated by Forensicator.

Freitas also suggests that, using the RAT, hackers may have archived the files.  Again, triggering a CPU and disk intensive process… something that is inadvisable for anyone wanting to remain stealthy.

Most of the other things he mentioned after that point are addressed in the article that I linked to in my previous post..

Well hello to Adam Carter and welcome to this forum.  I don’t know you nor had I ever heard of you before reading about this story and had not issued you any invitation to come here, so how did you find out about this forum and thread mentioning you?  

If it was an inside job, what are the prospects of identifying the perpetrator?

4 hours ago, Doug Morris said:

If it was an inside job, what are the prospects of identifying the perpetrator?

Ask Julian Assange what the prospects are of him identifying his source.   I don’t think there is a chance of any other method working after this much time has passed.   The FBI was never permitted to examine the servers, so there is no evidence now beyond the files themselves.

Assange has been coy about using the unfortunate Seth Rich as his source.  But Assange could as well be using Seth Rich as a cover for the real source which he continues to protect.   We can’t know until Assange comes clean in some way that is reliable testimony and not trolling.

On 1/1/2018 at 10:30 PM, Adam Carter said:

The DNC is a private organization, attacking them is not an attack on the state (the law may change on that in future but for now, they aren’t technically part of the government).

Good one. I guess 9/11 wasn’t an attack on the US either, since the towers were owned by the NY Port Authority. I don’t see why the federal government decided to get involved, they should’ve just let the owner fight it out with Al Qaeda.

Quote

There’s nothing to show WikiLeaks obtained the emails that they published from Russia or any other state.

Except for all the overwhelming evidence. We have that. But, other than that, nothing.

On 1/6/2018 at 5:02 AM, Doug Morris said:

If it was an inside job, what are the prospects of identifying the perpetrator?

Circumstantial evidence points to an orchestrated effort to remove Debbie Wasserman Schultz and her friends in the DNC. People try to link the DNC email theft to an attack on Hillary, but it was aimed at the DNC leadership, and resulted in the resignations of several top DNC officials. The stolen emails were dated up to May 25, 2016, which happened to be during the very vocal campaign to undermine DWS’s position as DNC chair. Consider this CNN article, DNC Chair On Thin Ice, which was published (coincidentally?) on May 25, and near the end cites three anonymous “Democrats with ties to the party’s power centers.”

Quote

 

Three Democrats with ties to the party’s power centers – President Barack Obama, Clinton and Sanders – made clear that few are rooting for Wasserman Schultz’s survival at the DNC.

“If this is the one thing that provides unity, they would take that trade,” said one senior Democratic strategist, who has spoken to the White House. “Nobody is rushing to keep her.”

Another Democratic adviser close to Clinton said “there is an exhaustion that comes with dealing with her.”

The Democrats close to Obama and Clinton both acknowledged that removing Wasserman Schultz would be “messy” and “wouldn’t happen easily,” but it could certainly be done.

A DNC member told CNN Wasserman Schultz expects to leave by the end of the year but “doesn’t want to be looked at as sacrificed at Bernie’s altar.”

There had been quite conversations over the last couple of months, the source said, about finding a place for Wasserman Schultz to “segue to” in order to make leaving the DNC palatable. But that didn’t happen.

 

Two months later DWS was gone, indeed, after a very “messy” ordeal during the national convention. And her departure was very much seen as a sacrifice to Bernie’s altar. Hillary was then immediately allowed to hire DWS for her campaign, and Bernie supported Hillary. On the surface the Party was one big, happy family again.

So, I guess the Democrats should be thanking the Russian hackers for intervening and helping get rid of unwanted Party leaders who might have cost Hillary even more Berniebot votes in November.

On 1/6/2018 at 5:11 PM, Nicky said:

Good one. I guess 9/11 wasn’t an attack on the US either, since the towers were owned by the NY Port Authority. I

The hack still not an attack on the state. It still seems like the intent was to harm the DNC, not the government or its institutions. It’s bad and malicious, but not an attack on the state. The intent of 9/11 was to harm the state as an act of war.

On 1/6/2018 at 2:11 PM, Nicky said:

I guess 9/11 wasn’t an attack on the US either, since the towers were owned by the NY Port Authority. I don’t see why the federal government decided to get involved, they should’ve just let the owner fight it out with Al Qaeda.

Let’s not forget the other targets of 9/11: the Pentagon and the White House.

7 hours ago, Eiuol said:

The hack still not an attack on the state. It still seems like the intent was to harm the DNC, not the government or its institutions. It’s bad and malicious, but not an attack on the state. The intent of 9/11 was to harm the state as an act of war.

So, what’s the key to your definition of “act of war”: intent to harm the state? 

If Nordic invaders conduct pillaging raids on the villages of England, are those not acts of war?