Iraq And Iran

It seems to be the age-old problem of great product, with poor marketing (USA), vs. poor product with great marketing (Iran). Islamofascist aplogists are falling for the marketing…

Hmm, maybe we could borrow their PR-managers to crank up the image of the US. Trade them a few intellectuals for it? B)

But on a serious note, especially over here I don’t think anyone is in favor of a war there. Most people are still whining over the war in Iraq, and I doubt there will be much support from Europe…

Is it just me, or does it seem like the lunatic Iranian leaders know more about America’s cultural state than America leaders do?

They aren’t sure how much they can get away with. So, they push the envelope with a new challenge, and they see no negative consequences, so they push some more.

See what Iran gets for its insolence (link to news-article):

Reported by Julie Stahl, CNSNews.com, Jerusalem, April 17, 2006: … Iran has been elected to a vice-chair position on the U.N.Disarmament Commission…

They aren’t sure how much they can get away with. So, they push the envelope with a new challenge, and they see no negative consequences, so they push some more.

Off topic, I know, but congratulations on your 2,505th post.

… congratulations on your 2,505th post.

At last I acheive my dream!!! I can slow down now :smiley: .

Just a question, I understand the justification of removing a dictatorship from power, however is the expense, man power and loss of American life worth liberating the Iraqi’s? They do not seem to show the want, will, or ambition to rule themselves peacefully and are constantly breaking out into secular violence. I understand that I am not over there and am not aware of every aspect of the situation, but from what I have been exposed to it seems like the Kurds are the only ones willing to rule themselves and so far is the only justification for what we’ve done. I think we could have accomplished much more by handling the situation in a way different from all out invasion like we did.

I understand the justification of removing a dictatorship from power, however is the expense, man power and loss of American life worth liberating the Iraqi’s?

The only justification for it, as a national project, is in terms of America’s interests. If the region melts down into Shiite v. Sunni chaos and a fanatical Islamist Shiite regime rises to take over the country, then that would be utterly contrary to our interest. On the other hand, if (I hate totally mythical hypotheticals) they actually turn into a semi-civilized country which is no worse than Jordan or Turkey, that would be a good outcome (at the cost of thousands of American lives and hundreds of billions of dollars of American wealth destroyed). The proper thing to have done back in 2003 would have been to recognise the existing government of Kurdistan and the Kurdish constitution as the legal government of Iraq, but that horse is out of the barn. Multiple this cost by 40 or so, and we could free Zimbabwe, Burma, Belarus, Noth Korea, Syria, Iran, Turkmenistan… The noble goal of freeing oppressed nations simply is not the proper function of government. What distinguishes Iran, North Korea and Syria is that these three nations in particular are an actual threat to the US (unlike Zimbabwe). Iraq is now a threat to the US in the way that Afghanistan is and potentially could be – an uncontrolled breeding ground for terrorist attacks against the US.

The only justification for it, as a national project, is in terms of America’s interests. If the region melts down into Shiite v. Sunni chaos and a fanatical Islamist Shiite regime rises to take over the country, then that would be utterly contrary to our interest. On the other hand, if (I hate totally mythical hypotheticals) they actually turn into a semi-civilized country which is no worse than Jordan or Turkey, that would be a good outcome (at the cost of thousands of American lives and hundreds of billions of dollars of American wealth destroyed). The proper thing to have done back in 2003 would have been to recognise the existing government of Kurdistan and the Kurdish constitution as the legal government of Iraq, but that horse is out of the barn. Multiple this cost by 40 or so, and we could free Zimbabwe, Burma, Belarus, Noth Korea, Syria, Iran, Turkmenistan… The noble goal of freeing oppressed nations simply is not the proper function of government. What distinguishes Iran, North Korea and Syria is that these three nations in particular are an actual threat to the US (unlike Zimbabwe). Iraq is now a threat to the US in the way that Afghanistan is and potentially could be – an uncontrolled breeding ground for terrorist attacks against the US.

I actually think this is a very interesting point. Give money to the rational people and help them take over. The Kurds seem to be much more rational than the best of the Islamic factions out there. I wonder what would have happended if we gave them a few billion dollars, even 30 or 40 billion… Not sure how it would have worked out but it’s an interesting idea, because I think that the way things are now in Iraq it seems likely to have a long term (and def. not a short term) positive outcome.

I actually think this is a very interesting point. Give money to the rational people and help them take over. The Kurds seem to be much more rational than the best of the Islamic factions out there. I wonder what would have happended if we gave them a few billion dollars, even 30 or 40 billion… Not sure how it would have worked out but it’s an interesting idea, because I think that the way things are now in Iraq it seems likely to have a long term (and def. not a short term) positive outcome.

Yes, I just don’t think you could ever ‘liberate’ an irrational society. We’re replacing a dictator with a secular state who wish to rule through religion. I don’t think any country should undergo our style of regime change unless it has a population base ready to take over the mantle of true freedom and a rational society.

we could free Zimbabwe, Burma, Belarus, Noth Korea, Syria, Iran, Turkmenistan…

I don’t know about the other countries, but when it comes to Belarus - the majority of citizens themselves doesn’t want to be freed.

Being in a more humorous mood…I voted for “waiting for diplomacy and the U.N.”

:slight_smile: