No, only on the ground of the highest values one can find in a man or woman.
Are you now done with bestiality?
If so, then I think the next question is what those highest values are that you find in a potential partner. What exactly does that refer to, for example is it merely the emotional state of intense longing?
If so, then I think the next question is what those highest values are that you find in a potential partner. What exactly does that refer to, for example is it merely the emotional state of intense longing?
The official Objectivist stance on sex, or what I think of as Rand’s personal views, are pretty clear. There is no room for bestiality in that worldview.
Personally, I think it is neither moral or immoral. I think it’s a personal choice, like what ice cream flavor you like. It’s not something I’m into, but if someone can lead an otherwise healthy and Objectivist life, but just likes to pounce a goat from time to time, I don’t really think there’s a problem with it. Although I somehow can’t conceive of such a person.
Oh, wanted to point out that chimps will hump anything, including other animals and humans (whether the human is willing or not) at times. I’ve seen it on nature videos. And haven’t you ever seen a dog hump someone’s leg? Okay, that’s not technically intercourse, but I still think that qualifies as an animal attempting to have sex outside its species.
As for incest, I think there are cases where it can certainly be moral. There was a story on one of those newsmagazine shows about a man and woman who met and fell in love. After some amount of time, they somehow discovered they were long lost brother and sister. Because of society’s taboos on the issue, and because they shared those views, they broke off their romantic relationship. I think in that case you would find nothing in the official Objectivist philosophy that would call for these two people to break off their romantic relationship. If they wanted to have kids, they would just have to have them genetically tested to make sure there were no defects.
Where the people know they are related, I think it would have to be a case by case basis. In general, I think consenting adults who hold the highest value for each other could be moral. A man wanting to bang his 14-year-old daughter, maybe not so moral.
Where the people know they are related, I think it would have to be a case by case basis. In general, I think consenting adults who hold the highest value for each other could be moral. A man wanting to bang his 14-year-old daughter, maybe not so moral.
Would this be one of the cases of consenting adults we could consider an exception?
“Here is the heartwarming story of 72-year-old Pearl Carter, her lover and grandson Phil Bailey, and the $54,000 surrogate mother they have impregnated. Sorry, did I say heartwarming? I meant, oh my god get it out of my head.”
I think incest should be legal. The government should stay out of it, as long as it’s consensual. The legality of incest varies between states and countries. As does age of consent laws and age-exemption laws.
Morally, I think it’s contextual on whether or not it’s right or wrong.
Finally someone who mentioned “context”. The question “is X or Y immoral” is ill-posed if X and Y are not in and of themselves absolutely determinative of the answer. It is like asking “Is eating something red healthy or unhealthy?”. Redness “as such” is not what is healthy or unhealthy, nor is the redness of a thing absolutely indicative of “unheathyness”.
In the OP I think X and Y are rare, not something I would do (by choice), can be caused by or connected with psychological issues, but in and of themselves simply cannot be judged absolutely as moral or immoral. “Context” plays its ever important role.
I suspect WHAT makes X and Y immoral in many contexts are a combination of factors.
Bestiality is necessarily immoral because it’s a metaphysical negation of the mind; just like racism and homophobia.
Incest could only be moral between consenting adults who are truly in love with each other (not likely); all else is a negation of ones own worth, just like sleeping with someone simply because one can (or bestiality) and thusly immoral.
Bestiality is necessarily immoral because it’s a metaphysical negation of the mind; just like racism and homophobia.
Incest could only be moral between consenting adults who are truly in love with each other (not likely); all else is a negation of ones own worth, just like sleeping with someone simply because one can (or bestiality) and thusly immoral.
This is a whole lot of posit and a whole lot of not it.
Let’s not argue the animal thing because, even though your logical leap to “negating the mind” isn’t shown, I can’t really imagine a scenario where it would be a good thing to do so.
So, why is incest without love a “negation of one’s worth,” and why is the implied sex without love the same thing as “sleeping with someone simply because one can”?
Love is a response to values; not the source of such values (whatever they may be). A man who knows his own worth will only be attracted to worthwhile [to him] people.
Others sometimes pursue sex, not as an expression of such value, but as a desperate attempt to somehow acquire it.
Refer to danconia’s speech on sex in atlas shrugged. Then picture every middle aged woman whos terrified of solitude and every teenage boy whos mortified by virginity; this is what i mean by “loveless sex” and “sex simply because one can”.
Now either sex is prompted by such value or by a lack thereof, the latter being deeply immoral.
So if we assume that for someone to fall in love with a relative is relatively rare, the general immorality of incest (in most cases) follows.
I don’t think consensual incest is inherently immoral, and it should not be outlawed. Though the relationship should be legal, not all are moral, just like other relationships. For example: Are you wanting to screw your sister or daughter because they have nice figures, or is it because you are in love with them, not just in lust with them, etc.
Now either sex is prompted by such value or by a lack thereof, the latter being deeply immoral.
Here we are again trying to figure out why it’s either love or nothing at all. What about people who have sex neither out of desperation, nor with people they are very in love with? What about those who sleep with others who are just decent people and very attractive? What about well-adjusted adults who wish to have multiple or many sexual partners? Are they “deeply immoral” also? If so, why? If not, why not?
Here we are again trying to figure out why it’s either love or nothing at all. What about people who have sex neither out of desperation, nor with people they are very in love with? What about those who sleep with others who are just decent people and very attractive? What about well-adjusted adults who wish to have multiple or many sexual partners? Are they “deeply immoral” also? If so, why? If not, why not?
I have yet to see anyone make the fundamental argument as to why sex must necessarily be a grand act that expresses one’s highest values. I consider Rand’s views to be sadly regressive and emblematic of outdated socially conservative attitudes.
It would seem to be that it is against man’s nature to have intercourse with animals, but is it immoral? And what about with a family member?
With animals-it’s not immoral, just disgusting. It’s like to ask is it immoral to eat vomit? As for family members-no, it’s not immoral. But a person who sleeps with his mother obviously has deep psychological problems.
With animals-it’s not immoral, just disgusting. It’s like to ask is it immoral to eat vomit? As for family members-no, it’s not immoral. But a person who sleeps with his mother obviously has deep psychological problems.
I agree.
Immorality could stem from knowing and ignoring health concerns surrounding the act with a particular “animal” (or bit of vomit) but that specific health risk is independent of the act itself generally.
For starters, there’s nothing wrong with promiscuity as such. So long as each partner is selected morally and with everyone else’s consent [you’re honest about what you intend] it’s just as moral as monogamous love.
As for sleeping with people on the basis of their appearance, alone, that would be an expression of a lingering mind-body dichotomy.
If you wouldn’t agree to have sex with someone you’ve never seen before then you shouldn’t with someone you haven’t spoken to before.