Is space, devoid of matter, nothing?

Stephen Speicher,

What’s your position on plasma cosmology? I’ve only read a little bit into it, but it seems like a rational alternative to the big bang cosmology. (Not to mention, it seems to have been originated and most supported by plasma physicists and electrical engineers, who are definitely more reality-oriented than some theorical physicists)

Plasma Cosmology doesn’t posit non-obeservable, non-existent, exotic entities such as “dark matter”, “black holes”, etc…Instead, the structure and formation of galaxies and stars, as well as a host of other cosmological phenomena are easily accounted for by the complex behavior and interaction of plasma through the eletromagnetic force. It also doesn’t posit any “age” of the universe–it simply assumes that the universe has always existed.

Admittedly, I know nothing about electromagnetic field theory so this may be false. But it seems like its underlying assumptions are quite sound and rational, not to mentioned backed by facts.

Please do not expect me to participate in such a thread.

No problem, I’ll do the thread anyway, and you can laugh or apply the knowledge for your benefit.

I have to do other threads on critical thinking and what I call hardcore reductionism, ie, the exact reason why otherwise decent and clever doctors can reject the “alternative medicine” rubbish.

Keep up the good work anyway :smiley:

What’s your position on plasma cosmology?

In general I am sympathetic to plasma cosmology, though primarily for their valid criticism of the standard theory. The early work of the originators, people like Alfven and Klein, has now been substantially refuted by observation, especially in regard to the CMBR (Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation). Likewise with the next generation; Don Melrose (currently head of the Research Centre for Astrophysics at Sydney, who was part of a radio debate with his colleague against myself and Lewis Little) wrote a two-volume set Plasma Astrophysics published in 1980 as a review of the field, and it was subject to much valid critiicsm.

But the new generation has been offerring more substantial arguments, along with some tantalizing models that seem to reflect structures in the cosmos in a much less ad hoc manner than the standard theory. I usually read a number of the papers emanating from this bunch, and I think that they have a number of good ideas, but their theories are still riddled with holes (and I do not mean black ones! :smiley: ). Perhaps a brilliant thinker will come along and put that work on a better platform, but until that is done I remain skeptical, though intrigued.

Since I mentioned on this thread that there was a song about “nothing” that I heard years ago (perhaps a couple or three times during a drive in Colorado, and only then), and liked for the play on the word, “nothing,” I’ll post it here even though it truly doesn’t relate to the topic.

Of course, it would be more enjoyable listening to the actual song, but…

“Nothing” by Edie Brickell and New Bohemians (on their 1988 album, “Shooting Rubberbands At The Stars”)

Are you in [a] bad mood?

Don’t you wanna talk about it?

Did I say somethin’ rude?

You don’t have to cry about it.

Aren’t you feelin’ okay?

Would you like a little company?

Or did you have a bad day?

Are you mad at me? – let it show

Don’t tell me nothing – I don’t wanna know

There’s nothing I hate more than nothing

Nothing keeps me up at night

I toss & turn over nothing

Nothing could cause a great BIG fight

Hey – what’s the matter?

Don’t tell me nothing.

==================

Edited: Added an apparently missing “a.” Lyrics from an online site, copied and pasted. Either there was a typo, or the “a” is only implied.

Steven, I thought more about what it was I was trying to say and realised that I was mistaken. I was subconsiously thinking in terms of a certain model of the universe, even though I actually knew that said model wasnt technically correct. I was essentially viewing the universe as consisting of lots of ‘space’, in which certain things existed (ie space was a primary). Saying that ‘nothing’ exists in a given region just meant that there would be no material things occupying that region of space (ie it would be completely empty). Obviously this presupposes a certain view of space which certainly can’t be assumed a priori, and (as far as I know) is even invalidated by modern physics.

Steven, I thought more about what it was I was trying to say and realised that I was mistaken. I was subconsiously thinking in terms of a certain model of the universe, even though I actually knew that said model wasnt technically correct. I was essentially viewing the universe as consisting of lots of ‘space’, in which certain things existed (ie space was a primary). Saying that ‘nothing’ exists in a given region just meant that there would be no material things occupying that region of space (ie it would be completely empty). Obviously this presupposes a certain view of space which certainly can’t be assumed a priori, and (as far as I know) is even invalidated by modern physics.

Thanks for clarifying, even though I am not sure I follow. :dough:

But, anyway, the real culprit is the reification of space, a notion that causes endless trouble.

p.s. It is “Stephen,” not “Steven.”

Stephen,

Gee, this is a real Seinfeld thread; “a thread about nothing”, huh?

My husband is an MIT physics grad and a professor of optics. I’m just a computer science PhD with a common-sense viewpoint of physics. So, as you can imagine, we have our disagreements. If you’ve got the time, I wonder if you’d entertain a couple of questions?

  1. I don’t get what you mean about space not being empty anywhere. Isn’t a vacuum an area that doesn’t have anything in it, i.e. no atoms whatsoever?

  2. What is your view of relativity? (while standing on one foot, please! :smiley: ) From the little I have read about it, I come away with the impression that Einstein was right, but that many people who try to explain relativity end up making it sound nonsensical because of the way they word their explanations: “space-time is curved”, or “time slows down if you’re going near light-speed” for example.

A sensible person like me responds that space can’t be curved, only STUFF can be curved, and space is NOT STUFF. Likewise time can’t slow down, but EVENTS can happen faster or slower IN time (or at least appear to). So, is there a way to explain relativity in words without the “reification” of space or time that most people resort to?

1)  I don’t get what you mean about space not being empty anywhere.  Isn’t a vacuum an area that doesn’t have anything in it, i.e. no atoms whatsoever?

Bound any 3-dimensional area that you like, and specify as small a density of atoms as you like. Do you literally think that within that bounded area there is nothing where the atoms are not? If there was nothing in the separation between atoms then why would the atoms be separated? Would not the locations of the atoms just collapse between themselves? The philosophic idea of the plenum simply says that the universe is full, and it leaves it to physics to specify the detailed nature of that which fills the world. It would be proper, as a physicist, to say “I do not know the nature of that which exists where nothing else is,” but it is not proper for a physicist to say that there is some bounded area within which, literally, nothing exists.

2)  What is your view of relativity?  (while standing on one foot, please! :smiley: )  From the little I have read about it, I come away with the impression that Einstein was right, but that many people who try to explain relativity end up making it sound nonsensical because of the way they word their explanations: “space-time is curved”, or “time slows down if you’re going near light-speed” for example.

Einstein’s relativity was a brilliant achievement, one of the great intellectual accomplishments of all time. While I agree that the wording “time slows down” is improper, I do not understand your concern about the curvature of spacetime. The spacetime manifold is a mathematical abstraction, not a physical existent, and curvature of the manifold is perfectly well defined.

A sensible person like me responds that space can’t be curved, only STUFF can be curved, and space is NOT STUFF.

Yes, I agree with this. But here you speak about the curvature of space, not the curvature of spacetime. These are two different things.

Likewise time can’t slow down, but EVENTS can happen faster or slower IN time (or at least appear to).

I think your correction suffers from the same lack of precision and physical meaning as the notion that you attempt to correct. Events do not happen “faster or slower IN time” any more than “time slows down.” Nor is this an issue of appearances. Time is a relational concept, specifically a change in relationship, and in relativity the measurement process establishes a relationship between an observer and that being measured. That such measurements vary according to relative motion between the two is simply an objective fact of reality due to the means by which we make our measurements.

So, is there a way to explain relativity in words without the “reification” of space or time that most people resort to?

Yes. Both special and general relativity are given a proper physical base in a new quantum theory. Try Chapters 6 and 7 in Lewis Little’s 1996 paper, available at http://www.yankee.us.com/TEW/

Should you want to discuss any details of the physics involved, there is an appropriate forum for such discussion that is pointed to on that site.

If there was nothing in the separation between atoms then why would the atoms be separated? Would not the locations of the atoms just collapse between themselves?

Why?

(A1. For the same reason that they were separated when there was something, or, separation does not depend on the existence of some third object.

A2. No. Why would they? And what does that even mean?)

I think in this context it is better to use the term place, not space. Place is an existent with an identity of its own. Space is a false concept.

There can be a place with nothing in it, but it is still a form of existence.

Why?

(A1. For the same reason that they were separated when there was something, or, separation does not depend on the existence of some third object.

A2. No.  Why would they?  And what does that even mean?)

Look, we went through this months ago. If you still cannot grasp why the universe must be full – why there cannot be any gaps, or holes, places where, literally, nothing exists – then I really cannot help any further.

I think in this context it is better to use the term place, not space. Place is an existent with an identity of its own.

Huh? What does this even mean? Are you saying that “place” is some sort of physical existent, not a relation among existents?

Space is a false concept.

Space, like “place,” is a perfectly valid relational concept. The only problem that arises is with those who reify space.

There can be a place with nothing in it, but it is still a form of existence.

I do not understand what you are trying to say. We can say, speaking loosely, that “there is nothing in that box,” by which we mean there are no directly perceivable objects in the box. But, we do not mean that, literally, there is “nothing” in the box. There must be something in the box, but whatever that something is, it is not a directly preceivable object. The universe is full, there are no gaps or holes with “nothing.”

Yes, I mean that there is a separate entity called place, which is not merely a relationship among existents.

The empty place clearly exists even when no object occupies it: it can be occupied at any point and by any object, and the place (or space) between point A and B must be crossed to reach from one to the other.

There is “something” between point A and B, but it is not a physical object, but something that can “contain” a physical object. I call that something “place” - and I do believe other Objectivists have reached a similar conclusion.

I agree that the universe is full. I think it is full of places - actual, real existents that can contain physical objects or not. If there was an actual “space”, a nothingness, between objects, then it could not have properties such as length, width, height. Only “something” can have properties, and I call that something “place”.

Yes, I mean that there is a separate entity called place, which is not merely a relationship among existents.

And what is the nature of this separate entity? What characteristics does it possess? What are its attributes? In short, what is the identity of this “separate entity called place.”

The empty place clearly exists even when no object occupies it: it can be occupied at any point and by any object, and the place (or space) between point A and B must be crossed to reach from one to the other.

Note how, when you actually tried to concretize “place,” you did so as a relational concept, i.e., as “between point A and B.” It is only by reference to actual or imagined entities that “place” has meaning. “Place” does not have an independent existence.

There is “something” between point A and B, but it is not a physical object,

It may not be an “object,” as in directly perceivable objects like chairs, tables, cars, etc., but why do you think it is not physical?

but something that can “contain” a physical object. I call that something “place” - and I do believe other Objectivists have reached a similar conclusion.

Do you have a reference?

I agree that the universe is full. I think it is full of places - actual, real existents that can contain physical objects or not. If there was an actual “space”, a nothingness, between objects, then it could not have properties such as length, width, height. Only “something” can have properties, and I call that something “place”.

I must admit this is a first for me. Instead of the often made error of reification of “space,” you seem to have reified “place.” You describe the world as a container, something full of “places,” into which physical objects are then put. This is very wrong.

And what is the nature of this separate entity? What characteristics does it possess? What are its attributes? In short, what is the identity of this “separate entity called place.”

The attributes of place are: position, dimensions, and the ability to contain a physical object.

It may not be an “object,” as in directly perceivable objects like chairs, tables, cars, etc., but why do you think it is not physical?

Well, it may be physical - but it’s not material.

Do you have a reference?

I saw a reference to Space vs. Place in one Objectivist lecture about physics. I searched again in AynRandBookstore but couldn’t find it. Perhaps I was wrong. Anyway, the idea of space being a separate entity is my own, as far as I know.

I must admit this is a first for me. Instead of the often made error of reification of “space,” you seem to have reified “place.” You describe the world as a container, something full of “places,” into which physical objects are then put. This is very wrong.

Well, at least I’m original! :wink:

Now seriously: between me and you there is a certain distance. That distance, even if we are in empty space, has a specific identity of its own. It can contain some things, but not others (for example - it is to small to contain the Sun). It has dimensions which are not attributes of me or you - but of the DISTANCE between us.

You can say that there is a potential in the space between us, to contain objects which are currently not there.

Now the important part: nothingness does not exist. Nothingness cannot have a potential, or a dimension. If there is NOTHING between point A and B - it will take NO TIME to cross, and there will be NO DISTANCE. Obviously SOMETHING is there. Even if it is just empty space, or what I’d like to call “empty place”.

The attributes of place are: position, dimensions, and the ability to contain a physical object.

Attributes do not have an independent existence; they are attributes of something. You are calling that something “place,” but “place” already is well-defined as a relational concept. As a minimum you should, at least, call this something, something else.

Well, it may be physical - but it’s not material.

Please clarify the distinction you make between “physical” and “material.” What is an example of a non-material physical thing? Or, a non-physical material thing?

Now seriously: between me and you there is a certain distance. That distance, even if we are in empty space, has a specific identity of its own. It can contain some things, but not others (for example - it is to small to contain the Sun). It has dimensions which are not attributes of me or you - but of the DISTANCE between us.

The distance between you and me is a measurement, a quantitative relationship between my position and yours. As such, distance cannot “contain” anything. It is possible to relate that distance to the measurements of other entities, such as the Sun that you mention, but that is a relational process, not some container within which things go.

You can say that there is a potential in the space between us, to contain objects which are currently not there.

Well, yes, speaking very loosely, you could say that, as long as you understand that the “space between us” is just a way of saying that we occupy different positions. Otherwise, you are reifying space. Space is a relational concept.

Now the important part: nothingness does not exist. Nothingness cannot have a potential, or a dimension. If there is NOTHING between point A and B - it will take NO TIME to cross, and there will be NO DISTANCE.

Okay. We agree that the universe is a plenum – there are no gaps or holes in existence. No reason to keep bringing it up if that is what you agree to.

Obviously SOMETHING is there. Even if it is just empty space, or what I’d like to call “empty place”.

Sounds like you want to have your space/place and eat it too. If something is there, it is not empty.

Attributes do not have an independent existence; they are attributes of something. You are calling that something “place,” but “place” already is well-defined as a relational concept. As a minimum you should, at least, call this something, something else.

But I mean place. The definition of place, according to the Merriam Webster dictionary includes:

1c : physical surroundings : ATMOSPHERE

2 a : an indefinite region or expanse <all over the place>

2 c archaic : the three-dimensional compass of a material object

.

.

.

6 a : a proper or designated niche…

7 b : an empty or vacated position <new ones will take their place>

Since I don’t have the presumption to have discovered a new phenomena, but simply to point out that even what is generally called “empty space” is not nothing, but something which has actual and potential attributes - I call it place. The only thing I know about it is that it has measurements, and that it can contain objects. Isn’t it the essence of place?

Please clarify the distinction you make between “physical” and “material.” What is an example of a non-material physical thing? Or, a non-physical material thing?

Sure: Energy, Speed, and Force are physical, but not material. All matter, as far as I know, occupies space (or - place) in a monopolistic way. Which means - no two objects can occupy the same place. This is obviously not true with place itself.

The distance between you and me is a measurement, a quantitative relationship between my position and yours. As such, distance cannot “contain” anything. It is possible to relate that distance to the measurements of other entities, such as the Sun that you mention, but that is a relational process, not some container within which things go.

Well, yes, speaking very loosely, you could say that, as long as you understand that the “space between us” is just a way of saying that we occupy different positions.

Well, my question will be - we occupy different positions - in what? You can’t take the fact that we occupy different positions as a primary. My current position is not a part of my attributes. It’s just a relational fact, based on the area in space that I currently occupy.

You seem to say that positions are merely relative relationships between objects. Fine - but even to say that you have to implicitly assume that there are objects, and that THERE IS AN ARRAY OF DIFFERENT POSITIONS WHICH THE OBJECTS CAN OCCUPY RELATIVE TO EACH OTHER.

And this is basically all I am saying.

Sounds like you want to have your space/place and eat it too. If something is there, it is not empty.

Well, if you accept my position on the existence of an array of different positions which objects can occupy, then you have to agree that even though this array is there - it can be empty, in the sense that it is not occupied by a material object.

erandror, I think we are on two different wavelengths in this discussion, so I will just leave it at that.

Strange, I thought we were agreeing on most things. :blink:

Anyway - I am open to persuasion. This theory is a part of something I’ve been thinking about for some time, and I will be happy to hear further criticism.

erandror ,

Imho, your position is indeed a relational fact: in relation to all other physical existents.

Imho, most of the definitions you cite are geometrical, ie, concepts of method. Place does not have actual or potential attributes: it has mental attributes.