Attributes do not have an independent existence; they are attributes of something. You are calling that something “place,” but “place” already is well-defined as a relational concept. As a minimum you should, at least, call this something, something else.
But I mean place. The definition of place, according to the Merriam Webster dictionary includes:
1c : physical surroundings : ATMOSPHERE
2 a : an indefinite region or expanse <all over the place>
2 c archaic : the three-dimensional compass of a material object
.
.
.
6 a : a proper or designated niche…
7 b : an empty or vacated position <new ones will take their place>
Since I don’t have the presumption to have discovered a new phenomena, but simply to point out that even what is generally called “empty space” is not nothing, but something which has actual and potential attributes - I call it place. The only thing I know about it is that it has measurements, and that it can contain objects. Isn’t it the essence of place?
Please clarify the distinction you make between “physical” and “material.” What is an example of a non-material physical thing? Or, a non-physical material thing?
Sure: Energy, Speed, and Force are physical, but not material. All matter, as far as I know, occupies space (or - place) in a monopolistic way. Which means - no two objects can occupy the same place. This is obviously not true with place itself.
The distance between you and me is a measurement, a quantitative relationship between my position and yours. As such, distance cannot “contain” anything. It is possible to relate that distance to the measurements of other entities, such as the Sun that you mention, but that is a relational process, not some container within which things go.
Well, yes, speaking very loosely, you could say that, as long as you understand that the “space between us” is just a way of saying that we occupy different positions.
Well, my question will be - we occupy different positions - in what? You can’t take the fact that we occupy different positions as a primary. My current position is not a part of my attributes. It’s just a relational fact, based on the area in space that I currently occupy.
You seem to say that positions are merely relative relationships between objects. Fine - but even to say that you have to implicitly assume that there are objects, and that THERE IS AN ARRAY OF DIFFERENT POSITIONS WHICH THE OBJECTS CAN OCCUPY RELATIVE TO EACH OTHER.
And this is basically all I am saying.
Sounds like you want to have your space/place and eat it too. If something is there, it is not empty.
Well, if you accept my position on the existence of an array of different positions which objects can occupy, then you have to agree that even though this array is there - it can be empty, in the sense that it is not occupied by a material object.