Kant and Aesthetics

I’ve taught art from the fourth grade level to adults. I assure you, anyone can paint a Pollock.

Show me proof. Show me video footage of four-year-olds achieving the graphic rhythm of a Pollock.

Any names? I only know of one self-styled “Objectivist artist”, and he hasn’t tried to paint a Pollock.

Here’s one example. He failed miserably in his attempt to show that “anyone can Pollock.”

I’ll post more examples if I find them.

I don’t claim that my “personal lack of response” is the standard of objectivity and of psychological health. Straw man.

I didn’t say that you made such a claim. I was only suggesting that you act as if your own personal lack of response to one art form or another is the standard of objectivity and psychological health.

I don’t agre with your premises. A kid whistling a melody of his own making is hardly on the same level as a Mozart – unless, of course, that kid happens to be as gifted as Mozart was. And I don’t agree that music is pure relativism at all.

You don’t agree with my premises? So then are you saying that if I were to post a variety of melodies, some of which were created by kids, and some of which were created by professional composers, and I were to give you no access to any “outside considerations” (such as the names of the pieces of music or the names of the composers, etc.), you believe that you’d be able to identify which melodies were created by the children and which were created by the adults, and you believe that you’d be able to identify the “artists’ meanings” in adults’ compositions?

I’ve been a painter all my life. I know talent when I see it, no matter what particular style or genre it is exhibited in. And I am also quite capable of recognizing crap and mediocrity as well – and much of modern “art” is just that – pretentious crap. I will say that some of it can be considered “decorative” – one might buy and display it because it has colors that please one’s taste or matches one’s decor.

With your listing of your teaching and painting experience, it sounds as if you want to be taken as an authority.

I did a quick search here on OO to see if you’ve posted samples of your work. I didn’t see any, but I did find this post of yours interesting:

I’d have to see your work and judge it equal to those artists before I can take your assertion seriously. I’ve been a painter for over 40 years: what are your qualifications?

I feel exactly the same way: I’d need to see your work before taking any of your assertions seriously. Let’s see what you’ve got.

I’ve been a painter all my life. I know talent when I see it, no matter what particular style or genre it is exhibited in. And I am also quite capable of recognizing crap and mediocrity as well – and much of modern “art” is just that – pretentious crap. I will say that some of it can be considered “decorative” – one might buy and display it because it has colors that please one’s taste or matches one’s decor.

The above is a good example of what I’m talking about when I say that “you act as if your own personal lack of response to one art form or another is the standard of objectivity and psychological health.” Your attempt to universalize your own lack of response by stating how “one” will respond to a work of art is hilarious.

J