Original work on Objectivism from non-Objectivists never goes over well.
2 minutes ago, Ogg_Vorbis said:
Original work on Objectivism from non-Objectivists never goes over well.
I have my readers. Yes.
1 minute ago, Boydstun said:
I have my readers. Yes.
“Yes” demonstrates to me that you are a philosopher, even if an amateur, and that you can think for yourself.
But then again, you’re not exactly an Objectivist, as you stated.
Parmenides dealt with the question of Being and Existence. Your viewpoint is very similar to his, although Parmenides emphasized Being (permanence) over Existence (change, Heraclitean flux).
The concept and referent mass-energy is able to hold both. Its amount is constant although mass can be at rest or moving uniformly or accelerating or being turned into pure energy by collision with its corresponding anti-matter. So let the philosophers catch up and get with the scientific program.
Rand/Peikoff took all of these to be existents: baseball, its striking the bat and motion to right field, the spin on the ball, and the materials of which it was made. I agree.
The shift from Scholastic talk of being to existence is good. One way in which being was divided was as unqualified being (also called absolute being) and qualified being. I’m with Rand/Peikoff and others in thinking there is no such thing as unqualified being (other than non-being, one might sputter). Anything that is is with qualifications, i.e., with identity. We are univocal in our view of existence, as Scotus was in his view of being. I have an Objectivist philosopher friend who disagrees. Against our univocal-existence view, I should try to understand more fully Kris McDaniel’s The Fragmentation of Being (2017).
When someone says there is at least one absolute being, they are mistaken. Even the totality of existence, i.e., the universe, is qualified by having a certain total mass-energy.
Kant agreed with shifting away from Being.