Nukes and Copyrights

If we wreak sufficient destruction to their military, government, economic and transportation infrastructure, it will not matter what happens in the aftermath.  They will not be a threat for many years to come.

We can do this at a fraction of the cost of an Iraq-style invasion and with little or no loss of American life.

Another question we should answer is, if we attack N.Korea, what will China do?

We can go in and destroy the N.Korean government and leave, but then China could enter and take N.Korea over. China wants to invade Taiwan, what makes us think the wont invade N.Korea? They have done it before.

The best policy with N.Korea is to isolate is as much as possible, and also isolate the people who don’t want to isolate N.Korea.

Another question we should answer is, if we attack N.Korea, what will China do?

We can go in and destroy the N.Korean government and leave, but  then China could enter and take N.Korea over. China  wants to invade Taiwan, what makes us think the wont invade N.Korea? They have  done it before.

The Chinese came to the aid of North Korea during the Korean War, after McArthur pushed the NK army back across the border and started advancing into North Korea. Other than this, have they actually invaded North Korea at any other time?

Why would they want to invade N.K. and assume the problems of 20+ million starving peasants?

Would it really matter if they did invade North Korea?

The best policy with N.Korea is to isolate is as much as possible, and also isolate the people who don’t want to isolate N.Korea.

The problem I have with this is the possibility of N.K. selling nuclear weapons and missile delivery systems to terrorists or nations like Iran. The longer we allow them to exist, the more desperate their situation becomes and the more likely they are to export weapons technology.

Can you elaborate on how isolation would address these problems?

Another question we should answer is, if we attack N.Korea, what will China do?

My guess is, not much. They have no serious interest in North Korea, and plenty of interest in the US. With Taiwan there is a serious face issue, but there is no such issue with Korea.

The best policy with N.Korea is to isolate is as much as possible, and also isolate the people who don’t want to isolate N.Korea.

North Korea is isolated and has been for 50 years, and nothing good has come of that. The only stronger thing we could do is drop nukes on Germany and South Korea when they try to send aid to North Korea the next time they have a major famine. But even that will have no effect on the North Korean dictatorship.

The Chinese came to the aid of North Korea during the Korean War, after McArthur pushed the NK army back across the border and started advancing into North Korea.   Other than this, have they actually invaded North Korea at any other time?

Why would they want to invade N.K. and assume the problems of 20+ million starving peasants? 

Would it really matter if they did invade North Korea?

If we attack N.Korea a huge power vacuum would be created, don’t you think China would be at least “kind of” interested in who comes out on top?

They could also get involved to showcase Chinese military power. They would show that China could do what the U.S. is doing in Iraq now;and that is, create a new government in a foreign country. That’s a big propaganda tool, and less costly then an invasion of Taiwan.

The problem I have with this is the possibility of N.K. selling nuclear weapons and missile delivery systems to terrorists or nations like Iran.  The longer we allow them to exist, the more desperate their situation becomes and the more likely they are to export weapons technology.

Can you elaborate on how isolation would address these problems?

The same way it would have addressed the problem with the Soviet Union during the Cold War. But after further consideration I think that this option should have been done a long time ago, it may be too late now.

If we attack N.Korea a huge power vacuum would be created, don’t you think China would be at least “kind of” interested in who comes out on top?

“Who comes out on top”..?!

If they want to help the starving peasants, let them. That huge drain on China

would be welcome by China’s competitors, especially if the drain is taken on

voluntarily. If they want to institute a government based on their form of

government, they’re more the welcome to try. That would be the equivalent of

annexing the country, because their form of government is not “transportable”. It

is not capitalism, which is the only successful thing that is transportable as a

societal principle. Tyrany is also a transportable principle, but it is never a

successful one.

And they would simply be replacing one cult-of-personality (Kimism) with another

(Maoism). Why would we care if they did this?

They would show that China could do what the U.S. is doing in Iraq now;and that is, create a new government in a foreign country.

They’ve already created a “new government” in Tibet. Once again, why would we

care if they do this?

{{Re “isolation” as a tactic}} The same way it would have addressed the problem with the Soviet Union during the Cold War.

So called “isolation” does not work because it’s not actually isolation. It’s

placation. And placating evil simply furthers evil’s purpose.

As two cases in point, look at Iraq pre-invasion (after the “sanctions”), and North

Korea now.

“Isolation” as you mean it, and has been practiced, is meaningless.

-Iakeo