I see, I thought as much then. Though I wish it were different.
Within the confine of rights, what ultimate purpose an individual chooses to pursue is wholly subjective.
I see, I thought as much then. Though I wish it were different.
Within the confine of rights, what ultimate purpose an individual chooses to pursue is wholly subjective.
Why do you wish it were different? It’s up to an individual, yes, and there are reasons to say life is pursued developmentally speaking. “Wholly subjective” seems to say there is no reason at all. I don’t see any bad implications of what I explained.
Say if you are trying to convince someone to a more healthier lifestyle. I had a friend who regularly smokes. He knows the risks and all the potential health problems associated with smoking, down the to exact statistics figure (he actually works in stats). But this guy consciously choose to trade health for the pleasure of a cigarette/cigar. You simply can’t reason people out of decisions like that. I certainly tried.
This is just one example. There are people out there who pursues (within the confine of their rights) uncounted variations of what would be considered immoral values by Objectivism standard. You can say, given the objective nature of an individual’s psychology, the anti-values they pursue will not lead them to the kind happiness that a proper Objectivist life would. Be that as it may, but how do you objectively compare the happiness gained from a proper-Obj life to say the pleasure gain from drug usage? It’s like comparing vanilla vs chocolate.
And that’s why I said I wish it was different. Because if it was, then reason would have the power to convince another to change the ultimate end goal they pursue. As it stands, it only have the power to convince others that certain values they are pursuing is counter-productive toward their end goal.
I see, I thought as much then. Though I wish it were different.
Within the confine of rights, what ultimate purpose an individual chooses to pursue is wholly subjective.
It is objective. It is subjective within a context defined by reason.
For example, I work in transportation. If I wanted to be a smuggler that would not be within my rational self-interest. Working in trucking is. From there what capacity is subjective as defined by my interests and what makes me happy but still delimited to other reasonable contexts as well. For example, It would unreasonable for me to be a truck driver if I was blind.
There is subjective elements by definition of us having free will, therefore each individual has personal interests, but they are always limited by reality.
If it were possible to be entirely self-sufficient, to live without any interaction with others, then ethics would be irrelevant. One wouldn’t say, for example, “gee, I wonder if it’s OK for me to do such and such”, one would simply act. It’s only in consideration of the consequence of interaction with others that an ethical view (of proper action) becomes relavent.
To live, or not to, is a choice. To pursue happiness is a choice. To live for the happiness of others is a choice. Choice is what makes deliberate action possible, which when directed towards others makes ethical evaluations relevant according to whatever impediments to choice ones action creates for others.
DA, I don’t know the point of the first part? Are you saying morality is dependent on interaction with other people, and if we analyze it without the social part, it’ll be unavoidably subjective or meaningless? That is only a plausible angle to explain why the concept “morality” grew and developed, as opposed to an explanation of morality. Even if it were true that it explains morality itself, we still run into VECT’s question: Why use this standard as opposed to another?
Why wouldn’t someone wonder if it’s okay to do an act if they were alone? “Simply acting” is not any promise something beneficial will happen, so at the least, it’s plain stupid to “simply act”. A hidden premise here appears to be psychological egoism, where people always pursue their self-interest. If that were true, simply acting would always be in your interest, so morality would be irrelevant - you do what’s in your interest anyway. The problem is, many people really do ignore their interests or fail to consider their interest, so end up doing something besides what is in their interest. We don’t even have a meaning to “self-interest” by which to act, it is a moral concept that doesn’t happen automatically. Ethics is still meaningful before we start talking about social topics, partly why it’s a separate topic than political philosophy.
Of course if someone really is alone is unlikely, and looking for a social basis for ethics to the root of ethics is going to overlook life as the root to that social basis being relevant! Taking a social basis will be other-centric, because you already rejected ethics as being self-centric. The issue there is altruism at least implicitly, where we must act with regard to what other people may say or do in response to you. Then, out of guilt, you’d wonder “is it okay for me to do such and such?”, not just out of a need to think and evaluate.
All I agree with is that choice is what makes deliberate action possible. The choice need not be deciding one day “I must live!” It only needs to orient our action. Rand brings out a fundamental choice, but it isn’t saying what we ought to choose. That happens developmentally - Rand’s explanation is rooted in pleasure/pain, and other explanations may be possible as to why babies don’t need to be instructed to live. Values will arise in life-furthering action, just by nature of living. Foods, activities, and so on. It’s possible to declare “I don’t want to live!”, and there’s no “duty” to avoid it. But it involves deliberately denying or evading existing values. Nihilism perhaps.
If you want to persuade a person to further their life, it requires pointing out their values and how it goes along with happiness. Reason has power there - I can guarantee your friend VECT, does have values to pursue, and grasps why it matters. It takes noting how drug users fail to lead a good life - real world evidence.
For clarity Eiuol, my point is that ethics requires some referant other than oneself for the same reason politics does. One will certainly act in any case, but without reference to the actions of other actors, what benchmark of proper behavior is being used? You could say, “every day I survive on my own proves my ethical behavior is correct”, but compared to what??
Yes, choice is what makes deliberate action possible, but ethical behavior is only relevant to interactions with others.
How does it follow from “I know what is bad for me in reference to others” to “ethics becomes relevant when I consider the consequences of interacting with others”? All you’re saying now is that I need to observe others to be able to know what is good or a bad - a perfectly legitimate claim that I agree with. Aristotle’s Golden Mean is basically that, where we look to others to see how a virtuous person acts. If living in total isolation, you’d have no information to work with to help you figure out how to be virtuous.
This is totally different than saying morality is only an issue in social settings with consequences - which always leads to moral relativism I described earlier. Social consequences makes for varying moral systems depending on the society and time period. To judge moral systems, we need a standard to measure them that can apply man qua man rather than man qua society. A more sensible standard is where we start developmentally and by nature, which is aiming for life. That isn’t “it’s good because it’s natural”, it’s that it’s the only standard and time to need a code. It provides the means to happiness, that’s the purpose ethics serves.
I appreciate your reference to Aristotle’s Golden Mean (the virtues of moderation), but I think the following observation by Aquinas more closely represents my position in this case:
“The highest manifestation of life consists in this: that a being governs its own actions. A thing which is always subject to the direction of another is somewhat of a dead thing.”
Individuals don’t will themselves into existence; that much has been accomplished for them. What does concern them is the measure of control (choice) they have over their existence. This where ethics becomes relevant in some form of, “do as you’re told” vs “you’re not the boss of me”. Self-governance is the ideal and ethics (governing interaction with others) provides a means to happiness, where happiness is defined as maintaining peace between self-governing individuals.
The only necessary element to ethics, the only necessary good if you will, is choice, e.g., to continue living, or not to, to become a member of, or to stand alone. So it follows that evil is primarily represented by impediments to choice. I think this view is compatible with Objectivist ethics and responds to Vect’s subjective choice, which is primarily subjective because an individual can choose to opt out for any number reasons that are only important to that individual.
All you’re describing is the Objectvist view on rights. And redefined happiness for no reason as “maintaining peace”.
“It’s only in consideration of the consequence of interaction with others that an ethical view (of proper action) becomes relavent.”
isn’t what you are saying now:
"What does concern them is the measure of control (choice) they have over their existence. This where ethics becomes relevant in some form of, “do as you’re told” vs “you’re not the boss of me” "
You are saying different things. But then you throw in “some form of” that doesn’t follow. You are saying ethics is primarily about choice, and it is primarily about impediments to choice. There is more to choice than impediments, and two primaries is impossible. Then you avoid the OP’s question anyway by saying “oh, some people have reasons to opt out”. That’s the topic of the thread: why not opt out?
The view that ethics depends on and derives from interaction with others is called by Oism the “Social Primacy of Conciosuness” view of ethics.
1976 lectures lect. 7:
Social primacy of consciousness
“society demands that we act a certain way. Other men issue arbitrary commandments and that is the source of ethics. On this view you get the bromide that there is no ethics on a desert island because there’s no society or social authority there. This desert island bromide, as you can see, is simply the secularization of the religionist viewpoint”
TPO
“A ‘right’ is a moral principle defining and sanctioning a man’s freedom of action in a social context.” ~ ARL, Individual Rights
All you’re describing is the Objectvist view on rights. And redefined happiness for no reason as “maintaining peace”.
…
Unless Objectivist ethics are devoid of moral principles, I fail to see how ethics and politics are unrelated in this regard. I am saying that ethical standards are only relevant to promoting as large a measure of self-governance (choice) as possible in a social context, that that is the ethical good being promoted. I would also say that a moral principle that doesn’t allow for dissent becomes a moral duty which transforms choice to obligation, which is bad.
That ethics is primarily about choice isn’t contradicted by efforts to minimize reductions of choice, so long as the individual can choose to opt out. I’m not sure how to make that point clearer… I’ll think about it and get back to you. My use of the phrase “some form of” was intended present an ethical range between social permissions and prohibitions. If it’s your position that O’ist ethics is only concerned with identifying moral absolutes, e.g., one ought to choose to live because morality demands it, then I’m clearly off base here, not being able reconcile oughts with absolutes while maintaining choice.
The view that ethics depends on and derives from interaction with others is called by Oism the “Social Primacy of Conciosuness” view of ethics.
…
Thank you for the link. I’ll look into this, but my position doesn’t dispute the need for morality on a desert isle, or anywhere else. Moral individuals adopt (social) ethical standards in order to interact socially. However if an individual is operating outside the scope of social interactions, which is to say he is having no affect on others, what is the relevance of maintaining an ethical (social) standard. Who exactly is he being social with??
Incidentally, this is one of the differences between OPAR and TPO 1976 lectures.
Ayn Rand said:
A group, as such, has no rights. A man can neither acquire new rights by joining a group nor lose the rights which he does possess. The principle of individual rights is the only moral base of all groups or associations.
Any group that does not recognize this principle is not an association, but a gang or a mob . . . .
The notion of “collective rights” (the notion that rights belong to groups, not to individuals) means that “rights” belong to some men, but not to others—that some men have the “right” to dispose of others in any manner they please—and that the criterion of such privileged position consists of numerical superiority…
It is not society, nor any social right, that forbids you to kill—but the inalienable individual right of another man to live. This is not a “compromise” between two rights—but a line of division that preserves both rights untouched. The division is not derived from an edict of society—but from your own inalienable individual right. The definition of this limit is not set arbitrarily by society—but is implicit in the definition of your own right.
Within the sphere of your own rights, your freedom is absolute.
I never argued that they’re unrelated. You’re talking about rights, then somehow saying ethics is only relevant in a social setting. Ethics is broader, it applies to all actions. Rights are a type of moral principle, not a principle that makes morality relevant… Again, you are talking about rights, all by saying ethics is only about social context. Your point isn’t clear because your posting is rife with equivocating rights to morality.
"Thank you for the link. I’ll look into this, but my position doesn’t dispute the need for morality on a desert isle, or anywhere else. "
You said the exact opposite in post #29:
“If it were possible to be entirely self-sufficient, to live without any interaction with others, then ethics would be irrelevant.”
OK Eiuol, I can see the confusion my initial post generated. I have been distinguishing between ethical standards and moral belief, the former being primarily relevant to a social context and the latter expressing individual values. For example, a lawyer who is morally opposed to murder still represents a accused murder according to an ethical standard of being innocent until proven guilty.
It would be helpful to me if you could identify what distinction, if any, exist between ethics and morality.
The following is a fair representation of the kind of distinction I see:
Contrary to the reference page on the difference between ethics and morals, Rand refers to ethics as a science, rather than a political application of morality.
What is morality, or ethics? It is a code of values to guide man’s choices and actions—the choices and actions that determine the purpose and the course of his life. Ethics, as a science, deals with discovering and defining such a code.
To restate your example: why not;a lawyer, morally opposed to murder, still represents an accused murderer according to a political standard of being innocent until proven guilty, where innocent until proven guilty emanates from the the moral principle of individual rights?
The moral lawyer is still adopting an ethical standard of practice by a group, is he not? Even if it emanates from his own morality and just happens to agree with the morality of others, the ethical standard is only relevant to a group practice of law. It wouldn’t, for example, be relevant to a moral lawyer on a desert isle where there were no others to practice with. At least that was the distinction I was working with in my initial post #26.
Perhaps you could provide an example of an ethical standard that is relevant to the life of a moral individual on a desert isle?
OK Eiuol, I can see the confusion my initial post generated. I have been distinguishing between ethical standards and moral belief, the former being primarily relevant to a social context and the latter expressing individual values. For example, a lawyer who is morally opposed to murder still represents a accused murder according to an ethical standard of being innocent until proven guilty.
Okay, that explains a lot! What you’re saying makes sense. But I have to say, I don’t think the OP is talking about “ethical standards”, it’s talking about the basis or reason to choose to live in the first place. I’d argue that your moral/ethical distinction only opens the door to an altruistic or duty-bound society. I treat the words as a synonym. That’s a topic for another time, though.
I took the OP’s ultimate conditional to refer to the Pursuit of Happiness, as described by Ayn Rand in the Lexicon, Pursuit of Happiness, Right to, and generally accepted that the only way to achieve happiness is to live to enjoy it. However, I don’t believe a subjective choice is impermeable to reason, and I responded that an individual’s choice is subjective in the sense that there can be any number of reasons that are only important to that individual. But Vect’s IF/THEN conditional raised an interesting issue for me.
Life is conditional, but the choice to live means the choice to continue living. You never had the choice to be born, that was another’s choice, and no small amount of another’s labor went into getting you to the point where you could consider any choices. So when it comes to choosing life as ones ultimate value, there remains some argument as to who actually owns that life as a result of creation and/or labor to maintain.
In an altruistic or duty-bound society, the title to ones life is paid for by returning a service to others, and the issue is further complicated by a need to interact with others in order to survive. So the only real check on any ethical standard is having the ability to choose otherwise (to opt out), and that is provided by the individual who either endorses or rejects that standard. Thus the necessary distinction between ethics (as a science, or a religion, or a political arrangement) and moral__ity (of its interactive members).
So even though life precedes choice, I believe the ultimate value is choice, without which not else matters.
I took the OP’s ultimate conditional to refer to the Pursuit of Happiness, as described by Ayn Rand in the Lexicon, Pursuit of Happiness, Right to, and generally accepted that the only way to achieve happiness is to live to enjoy it. However, I don’t believe a subjective choice is impermeable to reason, and I responded that an individual’s choice is subjective in the sense that there can be any number of reasons that are only important to that individual. But Vect’s IF/THEN conditional raised an interesting issue for me.
Right. This is moral relativism. As I said before. And exactly why it fails to address Vect. What you said “makes sense” now, but it is still a lot of equivocation that avoids the clear context of Rand’s essay “Objectivist Ethics”.