Tito,
You’ve simply asserted, twice, as if it were an argument, that “thinking machine” is a contradiction in terms. Your assertion doesn’t make it so.
Tito,
You’ve simply asserted, twice, as if it were an argument, that “thinking machine” is a contradiction in terms. Your assertion doesn’t make it so.
But I just haven’t heard of any reason why man-made things cannot be conscious, by definition.
Do you know of a reason why they can be?
If the chemical properties of silicon don’t make it feasible, then fine. But my underlying point remains. Why can’t we build things using carbon? Essentially taking nature’s design and improving on it.
We can build lots of things using carbon. I said before it’s not a good material for microchips, but some forms of carbon may serve for superior forms of electronics. We’ll see.
My point is that comparing even today’s most complex computer to the human brain is very much a stretch, it’s not even close.
I’m not saying we can do it today…just that there’s no reason to think it’s impossible.
My reason for thinking that man-made things can be conscious? Because the unintelligent processes of nature created us. Unless there’s some reason to think that the only way consciousness can exist is in the form that nature actually made it, then there is no reason to think that we cannot make artificial consciousness.
I’m not saying we can do it today…just that there’s no reason to think it’s impossible.
I still don’t see a reason to think it’s possible.
My reason for thinking that man-made things can be conscious? Because the unintelligent processes of nature created us. Unless there’s some reason to think that the only way consciousness can exist is in the form that nature actually made it, then there is no reason to think that we cannot make artificial consciousness.
So because in unintelligent nature time only flows forward, there’s no reason to think it can be made to flow backward?
Nature also produced life. We haven’t, yet.
Atomically, there is no difference between a dead brain and a live one.
I’m not a biologist, but nevertheless, I can state with some confidence: of course there is. Blood stops supplying the brain with Oxygen molecules, so the braincells die from the lack of it. (O2 is made up of two oxygen atoms, the absence of which-among other things the blood supplies the brain with, also made up of atoms- are causing the brain to die.)
I’m not saying we can do it today…just that there’s no reason to think it’s impossible.
My reason for thinking that man-made things can be conscious? Because the unintelligent processes of nature created us. Unless there’s some reason to think that the only way consciousness can exist is in the form that nature actually made it, then there is no reason to think that we cannot make artificial consciousness.
Actually, that is not quite true - unintelligent processes of nature evolved into lifeforms - and from that, evolved into volitionally conscious beings… the difference being that the evolving of consciousness, and then volitional consciousness, came as a consequence of the increase of survivability - it was, in essence, a practical matter - and that, to be effective, had to relate to the lifeform itself as an integrated continual of surviving… it could not have come about as an ‘end in itself’… unless the ‘artificial intelligence’ is integratedly tied to a survival mode, it cannot come into being…
I know that Objectivism is the very definition of humanistic..but does anyone on this forum have any insight on Objectivism’s views on transhumanism? I’m not just talking about curing diseases or extending life. Should Objectivism encourage using technology to change a man’s brain so much that it ceases to basically be biological? If man could create a godlike artificial intelligence that could solve problems/produce/create more effectively than man, would that be ethical?
For the sake of argument, we’re assuming that articial intelligence is possible.
Another way of looking at the question is..was creating nuclear weaponry ultimately anti-human/evil, since it could very well lead to your own demise?
For the sake of argument, we’re assuming that articial intelligence is possible.
Ok, let’s assume it’s possible. Now what?
If we were specultaing for a science fiction story, we’d set arbitrary rules concerning what AI would be like. And really that’s all we can do because there is no existing AI, nor do we know what any would be like if they turn out to be possible. Suppose you asked Gregor Mendel to speculate on genetic engineering when all he knew were the baisc laws of biological inheritance. What could he possibly know or figure out which would be even close to accurate?
Another way of looking at the question is..was creating nuclear weaponry ultimately anti-human/evil, since it could very well lead to your own demise?
Tools are amoral. What matters is what use is given to them. Nukes were largely the reason the West was never overrun by the Soviets, for example. In the future nukes may power interstellar spacecraft (unlikely, but possible), they may be used in large engineering projects on the Moon (again, not very likely; though fallout on the Moon would be a smaller problem), and one day may be used to deflect an asteroid or comet from striking Earth (very likely).
I still don’t see a reason to think it’s possible.
Pretend we are 150 years ago and change “artificial intelligence” to “flight,” and we could be having the exact same conversation. We know consciousness is possible, because it exists. What reason can there possibly be to think that it is only possible in the form that nature made it? If this were the 19th century, you could have argued that flight is only possible in the way that nature produced it. The Wright brother disproved that.
The problem with AI is that “consciousness” cannot be observed by anyone except the by the conscious being itself. I can’t prove to you that I am conscious, but you assume that I am because I behave in more or less the same way that you do, and you don’t doubt that you are conscious. Your theory that artificial consciousness isn’t possible is essentially unfalsifiable. No matter how much like us a robot behaves, you can just wave it off and say “it’s programming is just sophisticated enough to where it acts exactly like a human.” What would it take for you to admit that a machine is conscious?
I’m a believer in functionalism, when it comes to AI. If you could create a neural network, made entirely of artificial components, that functions in exactly the same way as a human brain (although I suppose it doesn’t have to even be a human brain), I say it is conscious and self-aware. Once we’ve reverse engineered the human brain (which is, admittedly, in the distant future), then we will be able to understand what “consciousness” is and how it is produced. From there, it’s just a matter of replicating, in a machine, the same processes and interactions which produce our own consciousness. If carbon is the only element that is able to form the right types of chemical bonds, then so be it. Whatever elements are used doesn’t change my underlying point.
…yet.
You just made my point for me.
Pretend we are 150 years ago and change “artificial intelligence” to “flight,” and we could be having the exact same conversation. We know consciousness is possible, because it exists. What reason can there possibly be to think that it is only possible in the form that nature made it? If this were the 19th century, you could have argued that flight is only possible in the way that nature produced it. The Wright brother disproved that.
Well, the problem with that analogy is that by 150 years ago there were at least two man-made things that could fly: hot air ballons and kites. In fact in the 1860s (almost 150 years ago), the Union armies put artillery spotters in hot air ballons with a long telegraph cable.
Arguing by analaogy is risky. Arguing by analogy with me is doubly so ![]()
But you raise my point again: what would even the most learned people of the time have known about powered, heavier-than-air flight? Poets could, and did, specualte about it, perhaps (Cyrano lived a long longer ago than that), but scientists and engineers knew little or nothing. It would ahve been easy at the tiem to say “one day aircraft will fly 5,000 passengers from London to New York City in 60 minutes.” But how likely would such a prediction be? not to mention it carries no specifics at al: what’s the plane’s design, what kinds of engines does it use, what’s it made of, what fuel does it burn, etc.
The problem with AI is that “consciousness” cannot be observed by anyone except the by the conscious being itself. I can’t prove to you that I am conscious, but you assume that I am because I behave in more or less the same way that you do, and you don’t doubt that you are conscious.
There are objective means of measuring consciousness. Many were developed by neurologists to asses coma victims.
Your theory that artificial consciousness isn’t possible is essentially unfalsifiable.
I don’t think it’s impossible. I think we have no idea whether it is or not. I also think the complexity required of a mind is far, far above what we can hope to achieve in the foreseeable future. We don’t even know if electronics can successfully mimic biology. We know mechanical contraptions have a hard time doing so (that’s why we don’t have planes that flap their wings like birds).
No matter how much like us a robot behaves, you can just wave it off and say “it’s programming is just sophisticated enough to where it acts exactly like a human.” What would it take for you to admit that a machine is conscious?
There are ways of measuring such things, as I said, and for AI in particular there’s the Turing Test. Essentialy if a machine can act like a human being there’s not much differnce whether it’s truly conscious or not.
In SF the common asumption is that AI is possible and that even a rudimentary one will be smarter than a human being. Eventually this has two dramatic outcomes: we enslave or wipe out the AI or the Ai enslave or wipe us out. For a time asimov sold the notion that robots (meaning AI) could be used safely as tools. But a tool is property, an intelligent tool a slave. He recognized that much explicitly in one of his latter stories “Robot Dreams.”
All of that is science fiction, however. I don’t mean that in any perjorative sense. I love SF and even write it myself (I hardly read anything else). SF is a lot fo fun, it can be a spectacular setting fr more common drama, it tends to the Romantic at its best, but it is not a substitute for science.
Hi all,
I don’t post here often, but this is a subject that is near and dear to me. There seems to be a bit of confusion in this thread, especially in regards to the threads original question. The thread is asking should we? For some insight into the should (as well as the could) check out:
http://singinst.org/media/interviews
However, the harder question I believe is the could we? There are quite a few excellent sources on this. One of my favorite authors is Douglas Hofstadter, who is featured in one of the presentations above. For an overarching exploration through consciousness, analogy, art, perception, AI, formal logic, and the human experience read the Pulitzer Prize winning classic “Goedel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid”. For a more succinct and updated version, check out “I Am A Strange Loop”. Both are fantastic works of literature and insightful to the topics mentioned here. Kurzweil is a decent source as well, and provides a bit more rigor (and sensationalism) when considering the could question.
For arguments against artificial consciousness read anything by John Searle (the originator of the now famous “Chinese Room” argument) or Hubert Dreyfus.
For the original argument for strong AI, you can always read the original paper by Turing, which remains compelling and highly readable, even today:
http://www.loebner.net/Prizef/TuringArticle.html
I can put neither should nor could in terms of Objectivist ethics, but I hope the references are helpful.
Best
Well, the problem with that analogy is that by 150 years ago there were at least two man-made things that could fly: hot air ballons and kites. In fact in the 1860s (almost 150 years ago), the Union armies put artillery spotters in hot air ballons with a long telegraph cable.
Arguing by analaogy is risky. Arguing by analogy with me is doubly so
Okay then, 5000 years ago.
But you raise my point again: what would even the most learned people of the time have known about powered, heavier-than-air flight? Poets could, and did, specualte about it, perhaps (Cyrano lived a long longer ago than that), but scientists and engineers knew little or nothing. It would ahve been easy at the tiem to say “one day aircraft will fly 5,000 passengers from London to New York City in 60 minutes.” But how likely would such a prediction be? not to mention it carries no specifics at al: what’s the plane’s design, what kinds of engines does it use, what’s it made of, what fuel does it burn, etc.
I’m not trying to argue that it will be possible at any particular point in the future. Just that there’s no reason to say that we can’t eventually create a machine that is actually self-aware.
There are objective means of measuring consciousness. Many were developed by neurologists to asses coma victims.
Sure, in the sense of brainwaves and such, but consciousness itself is still a subjective experience. A blind man can become an optician and tell you everything there is to know about the various wavelengths that make up visible light, but that doesn’t mean he knows what it is like to experience the color red.
I don’t think it’s impossible. I think we have no idea whether it is or not. I also think the complexity required of a mind is far, far above what we can hope to achieve in the foreseeable future. We don’t even know if electronics can successfully mimic biology. We know mechanical contraptions have a hard time doing so (that’s why we don’t have planes that flap their wings like birds).
Then we were talking past each other, because I don’t disagree with what you say here.
There are ways of measuring such things, as I said, and for AI in particular there’s the Turing Test. Essentialy if a machine can act like a human being there’s not much differnce whether it’s truly conscious or not.
I don’t think the Turing test is much use, because a machine could just be so well-programmed that it perfectly mimics human behavior. This is why I place such emphasis on the reverse engineering of the brain, and understanding what particular processes produce consciousness.
In SF the common asumption is that AI is possible and that even a rudimentary one will be smarter than a human being. Eventually this has two dramatic outcomes: we enslave or wipe out the AI or the Ai enslave or wipe us out. For a time asimov sold the notion that robots (meaning AI) could be used safely as tools. But a tool is property, an intelligent tool a slave. He recognized that much explicitly in one of his latter stories “Robot Dreams.”
All of that is science fiction, however. I don’t mean that in any perjorative sense. I love SF and even write it myself (I hardly read anything else). SF is a lot fo fun, it can be a spectacular setting fr more common drama, it tends to the Romantic at its best, but it is not a substitute for science.
But today’s science fiction is tomorrows hard science. That’s been the case for years. If you buy Kurzweil’s singularity hypothesis, then things like true AI aren’t far off. I don’t know that I buy his ideas, and I suspect these things are certainly beyond my own lifetime. I just don’t think we can write them off as impossible, for some future generation.
Okay then, 5000 years ago.
Isn’t the boomerang older than that? ![]()
I’m not trying to argue that it will be possible at any particular point in the future. Just that there’s no reason to say that we can’t eventually create a machine that is actually self-aware.
There’s no reason to think we can, either. It’s a big unkown.
Sure, in the sense of brainwaves and such, but consciousness itself is still a subjective experience.
Some. There’s also measuring eye movements, reflexes, body movements, hearing, etc.
I don’t think the Turing test is much use, because a machine could just be so well-programmed that it perfectly mimics human behavior.
As the old saw has it: “If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck…” A machine that cannot be distinguished from a human being is a human being, at whatever level the similarity occurs. I mean, if a pile of circuit boards can talk on the phone with people and none can figure out it is a pile of circuit boards, then that’s a human-like mind.
But today’s science fiction is tomorrows hard science. That’s been the case for years.
Actually that happens rarely. Sure there are writers like Arthur C. Clarke who keep, mostly, to the theoretically possible, therefore they seem to be predicting future developments. But most hard SF relies on the McGuffin more often than not. Any given imaginary gizmo might well be possible to build some day, but not all of them. Aside from Ai one can mention force-fields as another SF favorite.
SF has inspired a lot of people to pursue careers in science and engineering, which does mean SF has had a hand in developing modern science and technology, but only indirectly. Aside from SF writers who are also scientists or engineers, that’s all the connection there is.
On a large enough timescale with humanity progressing in technology, i see no reason why it will not be invented.
As said we already have the building plan for creating one type of intelligence, the human DNA.
And i feel that we might be a _lot_ closer to building a real AI than a lot of people think. Check out this documentary:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6464697696665901632
This guy claims that he already build a machine that has some sort of thinking machine and his theory about the basic principle of a mind a very interesting. In fact this was the most inspiring documentary i’ve seen in years even if some of the facts are not true.
Thinking about the implications of a real AI is very interesting too. This could be the last invention men ever make, if the machine is actually smarter and there is no reason why one should not able to build a machine like that once you have discovered the principle for building an intelligence.
In fact, if some quantum theories are right, it is possible to build a machine that can do certain calculations with basically unlimited speed.
I’ve failed to find a source for that on the internet.. i read it in a book about quantum physics in found in the library and don’t have it here anymore. Maybe i’ll find something later.
I think the invention of the AI would be the one of the biggest inventions of men, a lot bigger than genetic engineering or robotics.
And i feel that we might be a _lot_ closer to building a real AI than a lot of people think. Check out this documentary:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6464697696665901632
watching…
This guy is hopeless. He is trying to make an Artificial Rationalist. Literally, consciousness conscious of nothing but itself.
He throws the word concept around, but I don’t know what he means.
Schizophrenic regions of space! Cosmic Consciousness! Dude that was rude to drop a link like that in a science thread!
This place needs a karma system. For justice.
watching…
This guy is hopeless. He is trying to make an Artificial Rationalist. Literally, consciousness conscious of nothing but itself.
He throws the word concept around, but I don’t know what he means.
Schizophrenic regions of space! Cosmic Consciousness! Dude that was rude to drop a link like that in a science thread!
This place needs a karma system. For justice.
Well yeah the thing about a space having a mind was strange, but i really liked his thoughts about how this creativity machine works. I’m still having doubts whether this thing really exists (why did i never read anything about it anywhere?!), but his thoughts about the principle of a mind were something new and inspiring to me.