It’s an interesting question. Given the connection between religion and philosophy, I think religious ceremonies, services, and locations serve both, in different ways. We definitely don’t want a church per se, but regular gatherings of a certain type may be a good thing.
A few less-than-complete thoughts:
What role do ceremonies play for religion? For big events in life (birth, death, marriage, transition into adulthood) there are religious services (baptism, funeral, wedding, confirmation / bar mitzvah). Keeping those tied closely to the church serves to reinforce the idea that religion is very important to your life. Everything about the ceremony, from the architecture to the fashion, is geared toward that.
Moreover, the nature of the ceremonies are keyed to a religious approach to life. A sermon, by its very nature, is proper to a dogmatic, intrinsicist authority looking to control the masses. The congregation recites memorized dogma. They pray on their knees. They bow their heads to acknowledge their willing submission. These are not good things, but ceremonies as such need not incorporate them.
By the same token, those very same big events in life could be coupled with Objectivism. I don’t think the point, though, would be indoctrination, but rather celebration of objective values (e.g., reason, pride, honesty, freedom, reality, achievement, science, etc.). While we can do that with quiet reflection in solitude, there is something gained by doing it socially.
I don’t see a need for starting a tradition of repetitive, dogmatic, concrete actions (e.g., replacing the signing of the cross with the signing of the dollar sign, or replacing “May the peace of God be with you” with “May good premises be with you”). I do, however, like the idea of regular periods of time set aside to focus one’s awareness on the “big picture” (philosophically speaking), of celebrating one’s values socially, of a location for celebrating the big events in one’s life.
If we are talking about the distant future, would there someday be a standard form of wedding ceremony? It seems like every time an Objectivist couple marries, the format varies widely. Some see a justice of the peace, some go to Vegas, some create their own vows, and so on. Is there value in having a standard one? (Not that one would be forced to use it, though.)
How about other events in life? As Objectivists, are there certain events in our lives that deserve celebration that non-Objectivists don’t have? For example, graduating from a course on Objectivism, or having a “committment” day (to celebrate that time of your life when you understood enough about Objectivism to publicly declare that you actually are now a committed Objectivist) are possiblities off the top of my head. Maybe the day you start the first job in your chosen line of work. Maybe the day you first read “The Fountainhead.”
In any case, given a life based on reason and reality (as opposed to faith and the supernatural) I don’t think some church-like entity would or should play nearly as large a role in our lives as the church does for the pious. We simply don’t share the secondhanded, parasitical need that the church pretends to satisfy, even if we appropriate and modify some things.
It’s interesting that the concept “sacred”, for most people, combines the religious element with the “deeply important” part. The church certainly benefits from that. While we want to cut out religion, recognizing and celebrating the “deeply important” part should be kept.
I think men have a need for regular focus on the sacred or the sublime. It energizes the soul with an overpowering and deep pleasure and sense of exaltation. We can get it from art (the best symphonies or books, for instance). It’s possible to get it from sex. Are those the only possible sources, or is there another? Might some elements of lectures, music, debates, and so on be available as a regular service? I don’t have anything specific in mind, but maybe someday someone else would invent something.