Objectivists Need A Church, Too

I think there are actually many church-goers who realize that religious teaching is essentially symbolic and representational and is most valuable when not taken literally. These are usually the older ones, who live quiet, happy lives, and who derive real personal value from their religion. I’d call them the rational religionists.

[…]

The problem is, if any of these church-goers were to say “but it doesn’t matter whether Jesus actually rose from the dead; in fact, it’s absurd to think that He did. What matters is that the story inspires us to keep struggling through life’s difficulties, and to maintain a measure of hope for the future”, that church-goer would be viciously denounced as a blasphemer and un-believer. A couple experiences like this, and the rational religionist learns to keep his views to himself.

I would agree that there are many variations of Christianity that do not take The Bible and every aspect of Christianity literally, but one thing that every single person who attends church does believe in is some sort of afterlife. Aside from this, it is VERY hard (impossible) to swallow the morality that Christianity preaches. With this in mind, it would be difficult to refer to anyone who attends church as a “rational religionist”.

I’m not really talking about any particular form of Christianity. I’m talking about an attitude that can be adopted by practitioners of any form, and also of Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, and any other religion.

Religious institutions are no less vulnerable to corruption by bad philosophy than any other institution. The prevalent morality that current Christian leaders allow to be taught is a manifestation of altruism - it is not the cause. Christianity is a religion - in essence a mythology - which can and in some circles is used to express rational egoism as well as altruism.

One sort of “afterlife” is a spiritual afterlife. In this view, a person who has denied the absolutism of existence, who has turned his mind away from reality and has devoted his consciousness to evasion, rationalization and denial, is spiritually dead. If such a person were to take stock of his life and see “the error of his ways”, see that existence is all there is and that living is the only thing to do, he can be “reborn” spiritually, and return to a value-creating and life-loving existence. In this view, there is no notion of ghosts or supernatural dimensions.

I don’t think Objectivists need a new church. I think Objectivists (who have any inclination to do so) should infiltrate the churches they abandoned and, strengthened by their knowledge of Objectivism, help provide a voice for the rational religionists.

“Rational Religionists”

The word religion comes from the latin Re - Ligare which literally means ‘re-link’ or ‘to link again’. The understanding that seems to permeate all religions is that it in essence means ‘to return to god’, to link back to your creator/nature. A wider understanding might be to link back to reality.

A religion thus pertains to offer an answer, or way to re-link to whatever its understanding is of creation. To offer the term Objectivist religon would indicate a set of paths/texts leading to a greater understanding of your relation to reality. It could therefore be rational.

However: the understanding of the word religion that such an Objectivist religion would necessitate is far from the common conception of that word. In weighing up what the word religion commonly connotates with the value of applying it to objectivism I would conclude that it is a term objectivists would do well to steer clear of.

[This question was posted in Basic Questions->Has Anyone Read Jaynes ? ]

I would think that for an Objectivist “rational religionists” would be seen as a contradiction in terms, at least as far as the word rational being applied to a religion. Religion is a matter of faith, the opposite of rational. Why would an Objectivist want to “infiltrate” a church? I can understand why we would want to reclaim the tradition of scholarship in academia, but why would an Objectivist want to reclaim the “great and beautiful” traditions of the church? 

In the first place, any kind of tradition, religious or otherwise, is something that can not be built by fiat in a short time. I don’t have a full explanation for it, but it seems obvious to me that the one crucial ingredient in the formation of a tradition is time - generations of observation, and the more the better. So however much or little anyone values religious traditions, the fact that they are thus limited in number gives them a certain value. This value was created by past generations, and it’s current “owners” can no more claim exclusive rights to it than anyone can claim rights to the exclusive use of natural languages. If you go back far enough - for Christianity, I think it would be before the council of Nicea in 325 A.D., but in general you can go back to the dawn of civilization - there were no “Creeds” and “belief” requirements. I contend that power-hungry “mystics of spirit” seized this value and have held it illegitimately to be used as a bargaining tool to this day. Many of them also used force to eliminate competition. I think anyone who can derive legitimate benefit from them, and is not out to ridicule or undermine them, has a right to participate in these traditions. I find it particularly unjust that the people most vehemently denied access are the ones who take responsibility for their own minds - the best among men.

I saw religion the way you would think for about 12 years, until I began an in-depth discusson of aesthetics in my local Objectivist community group. During this discussion, I realized two things that had been lurking in my mind and that I’d been evading and trying to bury for years:

  1. while I enjoy good art, I really do not have the sense-of-life reaction that Rand describes. For me, it doesn’t “work” :

Amidst the incalculable number and complexity of choices that confront a man in his day-by-day existence, with the frequently bewildering torrent of events, with the alternation of successes and failures, of joys that seem too rare and suffering that lasts too long - he is often in danger of losing his perspective and the reality of his own convictions. Remember that abstractions as such do not exist: they are merely man’s epistemological method of perceiving that which exists - and that which exists is concrete. To acquire the full, persuasive, irresistible power of reality, man’s metaphysical abstractions have to confront him in the form of concretes - i.e., in the form of art.

  1. religious fantasy, mythology, and mysticism (the style of writing, not the epistemology) do perform this role for me - giving metaphysical abstractions the persuasive, irresistible power of reality.

This was not a particularly pleasant insight for a dedicated Objectivist.

I ascribe this to continuous religious indoctrination during the first 12 years of my life. During these crucial, non-repeatable, formative years of my developing consciousness, my capacity to respond to art was captured and redirected to religion instead. The advantage to this is that much of religious symbolism is accessible at any time and needs no physical objects to perform it’s role. The disadvantages are, well, I think quite obvious to Objectivists.

I would expect anyone who was not religiously indoctrinated as a child to be disinterested in (and probably repulsed by) the idea of infiltrating religion. But for me it’s worth trying, and I wouldn’t mind finding others who also would think so with whom to strategize (and commiserate).

For me (and I suspect others like me), the traditions of religion - the ceremonies, symbols, fictional/mythological characters, etc. are “locked in” to my consciousness, and serving a life-fulfilling role that’s being held hostage - not for simple cash or slave-labor - but for the most precious treasure any man has: his intellectual sovereignty; the right to own and direct his own perception of reality; the freedom to say “from my experience and by my understanding, this is true”.

I think most people in my situation make one of six basic choices:

  1. denounce and abandon religion, and find some kind of substitute activity that can fulfill it’s role as well as possible.
  2. continue to practice their religion, and attempt to abandon their minds to the religious authorities and evade and discount the evidence in front their own eyes in favor of the “revealed truth”.
  3. continue to practice their religion, but only pretend to believe.
  4. continue to practice their religion, but construct complex coils of rationalizations that can allow them to field and swallow every irrational, superstitious, or supernatural assertion with which agreement is demanded of them.
  5. continue to practice their religion, but secretly do so rationally: consciously aware that it’s a kind of art form, that God and His adventures are not stories of actual creatures and events, but are myths that relate real truths about reality - metaphysical abstractions - in the more beautiful, and more efficient symbolic language of allegory.
  6. continue to practice their religion, do so rationally, and don’t make a secret of it. This is the one I’m advocating.

One additional point: “faith”, as used by religion, is a package-deal. Of course we’d reject the belief in the supernatural part. But religion also includes in this package “confidence” - in oneself and in existence - the benevolent universe premise. These last are objective values.

In the first place, any kind of tradition, religious or otherwise …

I do not want to psychologize but, since you have chosen to introduce some of your personal issues, I think it fair to respond in part to that.

You say that “religious fantasy, mythology, and mysticism” perform, for you, the same role as art does for other Objectivists, and you attribute this state to the “continuous religious indoctrination during the first 12 years of my life.” But what you have written is an ode to religion, one that you consciously maintain, support, and allow to flourish today. If you do not consciously challenge the premises that you accepted in the first twelve years of your life, then it is not a surprise that you continue to have strong positive emotional responses to that which the philosophy of Objectivism rejects. If you do not identify and ferret out the subconscious source of those emotions, you will forever be in conflcit with the premises of Objectivist philosophy.

In fact, the impression I get is that you have built an elaborate mental structure of the supposed value of religion and its glorious traditions, to rationalize away your refusal to integrate Objectivist principles into all areas of your life. You characterize yourself as an Objectivist, but to accept yourself as being at the mercy of your early upbringing, not only as something that you can do nothing about, but as something that you will elevate and glorify, is quite an un-Objectivistic action in my view. I know many Objectivists who were very strongly indoctrinated into religion for far longer than just the first twelve years of their life, but they are now truly Objectivists because they refuse to accept what life offered them before their conscious convictions changed. It is a hard battle for some, and for some it may be a life-long battle of sorts, but the effort pays off in the values they gain and in the sense of life changes they achieve.

Any “solution” that rationalizes away a conflcit with Objectivist principles, is not a solution at all.

So that’s my idea.  I think even Objectivists today would benefit from – and in fact need a forum whether they interact with like-minded individuals for social, spiritual, and practical reasons.  You don’t have to call it a church – it could be called a temple or a lyceum, but the function of the institution is needed in any society.

Have you heard of The Brights?

A bright is a person who has a naturalistic worldview

I can’t believe you guys think that everyone in the future will be an extra specialist in Objectivism, that everyone will be their own private Dr. Peikoff. That didn’t exist during the Enlightenment, despite people being very educated and well-rounded. That didn’t exist during the Classical Era with the Greeks, despite the fact that they had a philosopher culture if there ever was one.

I can’t believe you guys think that everyone in the future will be an extra specialist in Objectivism, that everyone will be their own private Dr. Peikoff. That didn’t exist during the Enlightenment, despite people being very educated and well-rounded. That didn’t exist during the Classical Era with the Greeks, despite the fact that they had a philosopher culture if there ever was one.

Who said that? :confused: I’d be surprised if anyone here claimed that “everyone will be their own private Dr. Peikoff.” A supporting quote would have been nice here.

‘worthyloverofexistence’ describes how he thinks his ability to emotionally appreciate arts is dulled, and poses that it is because of yrs of religious indoctrination during the first twelve years of his life.

An interesting idea; one I would say is certainly typical if you extend it to a lot of popular culture. I think a lot of people’s taste is dulled my the mindless drip of popularized entertainment that is pumped into our minds every day since youth. The feeling many people get when they hear a piece of music in the workplace is mistaken for joy, but is more likely one of recognition. Whatever is selected for its commercial viability becomes what the masses like; if people were being truly objective in taste would they not determine what was listened too?

Masterpieces can be destroyed when they are assigned to a box of cereal in the face of millions… where the imagination should spiral off into emotional depths, it is saturated by coy images of unnecessary trivialities.

A tirade against the advertising industry? Maybe; but after so many years this is a cycle - the masses acceptance of crap breeds more crap, as the cash is raked in by men who’s own taste is more than likely effected by the society he lives in.

The general gist I’ve got from those who oppose GreedyCapitalist’s idea is that you won’t need to have a place where philosophy is explained and applied to one’s daily life, because it will so permeate the newspapers (op-eds) and everything else, that people will not be able to help but understand the philosophy.

On a separate but related note, I was watching Bravo channel the other day, and they had an hour-long show about wedding from start to finish. It was so sweet, especially about how it was in a church, sanctified so to speak by the building that embodied their highest values (if we disregard what those values were, for a moment). So I wish GC would reclaim his original view, because I emphatically support it.

And there’s nothing wrong with calling it a church, though of course other names can be used. After all, the Stoddard Temple was called a Stoddard Temple, and no one says anything bad about that choice of words.

And there’s nothing wrong with calling it a church, though of course other names can be used. After all, the Stoddard Temple was called a Stoddard Temple, and no one says anything bad about that choice of words.

There is actually a significant difference in etymology between the two. “Church” is a distinctly Christian word, which comes from the Greek ekklesia, meaning the “called out ones” – called out by Jesus out of this life – and thus hating the wordly life. So, “church” means “the place we are called out by Christ to go to in order to hate the early life.”

The world “temple” on the other hand comes from the Latin “templum,” which shares a root with “contemplation.” I believe that originally meant “a place of divination” – not necessarily a building. So a stock market could be called a “temple” – but a “church” it certainly isn’t.

On a separate but related note, I was watching Bravo channel the other day, and they had an hour-long show about wedding from start to finish. It was so sweet, especially about how it was in a church, sanctified so to speak by the building that embodied their highest values (if we disregard what those values were, for a moment). So I wish GC would reclaim his original view, because I emphatically support it.

On that note, when/if I ever get married I will look for a place that is deserving of being called a “temple” – though it will have nothing to do with organized religion. Unfortunately, the NYSE does not accept reservations :slight_smile:

On that note, when/if I ever get married I will look for a place that is deserving of being called a “temple” – though it will have nothing to do with organized religion.  Unfortunately, the NYSE does not accept reservations :slight_smile:

CalTech has beautiful rose gardens surrounded by scientific research buildings that are often the venue for lovely outdoor weddings.

just want to say I support the idea of an Objectivist Temple as well and would also love to get my wedding vows renewed there. :angry:

Which is a much more pleasing concept than what many churches typically amount to- being harangued for 45 minutes by a man who spouts unanswered questions in a rhetorical manner from a pulpit.

Madalyn Murray O’Hair (a person of horribly mixed premises) once said: after every one of my lectures, we have a question and answer period. When’s the last time your minister offered to answer questions, after his sermon?

It’s an interesting question. Given the connection between religion and philosophy, I think religious ceremonies, services, and locations serve both, in different ways. We definitely don’t want a church per se, but regular gatherings of a certain type may be a good thing.

A few less-than-complete thoughts:

What role do ceremonies play for religion? For big events in life (birth, death, marriage, transition into adulthood) there are religious services (baptism, funeral, wedding, confirmation / bar mitzvah). Keeping those tied closely to the church serves to reinforce the idea that religion is very important to your life. Everything about the ceremony, from the architecture to the fashion, is geared toward that.

Moreover, the nature of the ceremonies are keyed to a religious approach to life. A sermon, by its very nature, is proper to a dogmatic, intrinsicist authority looking to control the masses. The congregation recites memorized dogma. They pray on their knees. They bow their heads to acknowledge their willing submission. These are not good things, but ceremonies as such need not incorporate them.

By the same token, those very same big events in life could be coupled with Objectivism. I don’t think the point, though, would be indoctrination, but rather celebration of objective values (e.g., reason, pride, honesty, freedom, reality, achievement, science, etc.). While we can do that with quiet reflection in solitude, there is something gained by doing it socially.


I don’t see a need for starting a tradition of repetitive, dogmatic, concrete actions (e.g., replacing the signing of the cross with the signing of the dollar sign, or replacing “May the peace of God be with you” with “May good premises be with you”). I do, however, like the idea of regular periods of time set aside to focus one’s awareness on the “big picture” (philosophically speaking), of celebrating one’s values socially, of a location for celebrating the big events in one’s life.


If we are talking about the distant future, would there someday be a standard form of wedding ceremony? It seems like every time an Objectivist couple marries, the format varies widely. Some see a justice of the peace, some go to Vegas, some create their own vows, and so on. Is there value in having a standard one? (Not that one would be forced to use it, though.)


How about other events in life? As Objectivists, are there certain events in our lives that deserve celebration that non-Objectivists don’t have? For example, graduating from a course on Objectivism, or having a “committment” day (to celebrate that time of your life when you understood enough about Objectivism to publicly declare that you actually are now a committed Objectivist) are possiblities off the top of my head. Maybe the day you start the first job in your chosen line of work. Maybe the day you first read “The Fountainhead.”


In any case, given a life based on reason and reality (as opposed to faith and the supernatural) I don’t think some church-like entity would or should play nearly as large a role in our lives as the church does for the pious. We simply don’t share the secondhanded, parasitical need that the church pretends to satisfy, even if we appropriate and modify some things.


It’s interesting that the concept “sacred”, for most people, combines the religious element with the “deeply important” part. The church certainly benefits from that. While we want to cut out religion, recognizing and celebrating the “deeply important” part should be kept.

I think men have a need for regular focus on the sacred or the sublime. It energizes the soul with an overpowering and deep pleasure and sense of exaltation. We can get it from art (the best symphonies or books, for instance). It’s possible to get it from sex. Are those the only possible sources, or is there another? Might some elements of lectures, music, debates, and so on be available as a regular service? I don’t have anything specific in mind, but maybe someday someone else would invent something.

This is actually from a site that attempts to discredit Dr. Peikoff, but there is a quote from his radio show that is relavent on this topic

http://www.jeffcomp.com/faq/peikoff/moro.html

Quote

Moderator: Here’s a curious question from Bill in Moro Bay, California. He asks, “What would you think of someone starting a local church of Objectivism?” He is defining a local church as a small organization that regularly brings a few families in the community together to participate in strictly positive forums and lectures that celebrate life in alignment with objective principles. For the convenience of its members, it would allow Objectivism to be spoken of as a religion.

Peikoff: I’m sure they would find that very convenient. A church is a building of God, and of religion, and religion is by definition a belief in the Supernatural and self-sacrifice, on faith. This would be a total lie to call it a church of Objectivism, because we’re atheists. We don’t believe in the Supernatural, we reject faith in favor of reason, we reject every tenet of religion. This would be tantamount to saying that if you have a rational philosophy, that’s a religion. That’s what every person who attacks Objectivism claims. It would be the destruction of Objectivism. Are you then going to call me a priest? Are you then going to say that every time you sleep with your wife, this is really a higher celibacy? This is a lie on the scale of Clinton when he says it’s not sex, it’s just oral relations. The only motive for this is cowardice. It’s nothing higher or more complicated than this. This creature from Moro Bay wants to say, “Don’t be mad at me, I’m just like you. I’ve got a religion. I go to church.” That is shameful! Better to join the church than to put Objectivism into that disgusting category.

Un-quote

Considering the source, I don’t know if the quote is even accurate.

The last thing we need is a ‘church’. Churches are places of worship and are tied to the mystical. We can not untie that reality. If you mean an organized group, or a location to go to in order to meet with other Objectivists that is one thing. A church is quite another.

Chrissycrunch, you have made a key statement here–“Churches are places of worship…” The only collective way of worshipping man, or any of his virtues, that I can see would be in the singing of hymns. Religious hymns contain so many anti-concepts that the singers cannot maintain focus on reality. That is the problem with many of our national songs. How rewarding it might be to be able to sing “America”, for example, if its words were these:

America----originally by Samuel F. Smith; my revision.

My country, 'tis of thee,

Sweet land of liberty,

Of thee I sing.

Land where my Fathers’ pride,

Unbound in open stride,

From every mountainside

Made freedom ring.

My sovereign country, thee,

Land of the noble free,

Thy name I love.

I love thy cities strong,

Bright strings of lights among;

High towers rise in silent song

Through clouds above.

Now music proves the soul

Of manhood’s self-control—

His reason’s might.

Now all our hearts abound,

Each one partakes the sound,

Stands rightfully upon the ground

With fearless sight.

My Fathers’ life, to thee,

Rational Liberty,

To thee I sing.

Long shall my land be bright

With freedom’s honest light;

I guard thee day and night

In everything. :slight_smile:

Dr. Peikoff is rejecting the word “church” because he seems to be thinking of it in the strict Christian definition. I don’t believe anyone in favor of an “Objectivist church”, and certainly not me, have meant it in this sense.

I will concede that maybe “church” is a bad word here because of so much baggage associated with it. But I still endorse the topic of this thread, to get myself and others thinking about the sort of community organization that a church is (in a loose sense), and the sort of community and emotional function that it fulfills (in a loose sense).

I think that this discussion has begun at the wrong end. Before you can ask should Objectivists have temples in which to worship man, you must first ask should man be worshipped/ And if so, what would be a rational form of worship? Does worshipping one’s highest moral values fill an objective need of man’s consciousness? Worship often involves singing. Why? In hearing a song one can emotionally experience being an end in oneself. But if one sings a song oone’s own body is integrated into the experience. Have you ever been at a concert when the performer started singing a good popular song and people stood up and began singing, too? Is not the desire to do that the desire for full ownership, as if to say, "This song is not something that’s merely out there, it’s here, in me, and its meaning , beauty and pleasure is_ me, perceiving mind and living, active, expressing body, one hundred percent integration. Reading great poetry aloud can give one that experience, so can singing alone. However, singing in a large group provides a more intense experience—louder sound and perceiving your values shared and expressed by others. Now, this may not be a need of some sort, but if it adds to one’s enjoyment of life, it is a good. If so, the first thing needed is not a temple, but at least a few fully Objectivist “hymns to man”, the singing and hearing of which produces an emotional state of exaltation in a fully focused mind.

After some further thought, I’ve changed my mind on the matter.  In a rational society, the notion of a “church” as a place to study philosophy is useless – one would be exposed to philosophy on a daily basis, and have a chance to study it from traditional sources like schools and books. 

Don’t give up on your idea. It’s a good one. We DON’T live in a rational society. And there is no need to be dependent on universities and the media for ethical and philosophical guidance. That’s the last place to get it from. I would venture to guess that the majority of decent, moral people in America take what is in the media with a grain of salt and think the socialist anti-reality nonsense coming from the universities is nothing but a bunch of bored people engaged in intellectual masturbation. The decent, moral people get their values from family, from good morals - morals of which are typically given in some kind of hierarchal, structured way. I don’t understand why a “church” is such a horrific idea, but expecting all of society to conform to Objectivism and let people get guidance from there is a good one. This IS a valuable service to people - to help them frame their life, define essentials, and yes, recharge them. The people opposed to your idea have a kneejerk reaction to the word, “church.” Perhaps if you called it something else, whatever that word is, people would understand and respond better. I fundamentally believe this is a great idea that should be implemented someday, but have gotten such wrath from people that I shelved the idea for later use - until someone else also recognizes the value in it.