Organ donation Question

I do not give blood in the United Kingdom. The government has legislated that it is not my blood. They have, in effect, claimed ownership of my blood and my organs. Just like they have claimed my wallet.

To them I have one message: come and get it.

They oblige when it comes to money, but not when it comes to blood.

My government doesn’t want my blood, they think you Europeans have infected me :slight_smile:

To get back to my original question,

Paul, you now say “I argued that if, by refusing to donate ones organs, the government will be persuaded to end the prohibition, then it would be immoral to donate ones organs”

Well isnt this like saying “if my aunt had balls”?

I could say “if, by refusing to buy gas and drive on roads, the government will be persuaded to reduce taxes, then it would be immoral to drive on roads”

Clearly its not immoral to drive on roads. Here is my original question.

"if i decide to donate my organs, freely without coercion, under the terms the govt has stipulate, I dont think this would be and immoral act. "

Do objectivists agree or disagree?

Let those who initially think themselves to be altruists consider that the logical implication of their position is that the government should sacrifice the old, the mentally incompetent, the poor etc. to take their organs and save the younger, the mentally competent, the productive etc…all for the greater good of the collective.

If only.

No, right now any mention of selling organs brings up visions of the poor, the old, the handicapped being sold as parts to satisfy the life-lust of the greedy few who could afford to buy their organs.

It’s no surprise, it’s how the altruistic intellectuals work. Are we not in the middle of a very bad financial crisis caused by government intervention in the economy? Do you hear much condemnation of the real cause of this crisis, or do you hear more about how it was the fault of under-regulated markets and banks acting with too much freedom, with little regard for the “greater good”?

That’s how much I figure an “organ crisis” would help our cause.

What we need to do is attack the notion that our bodies are not our property.

I could say “if, by refusing to buy gas and drive on roads, the government will be persuaded to reduce taxes, then it would be immoral to drive on roads”

Clearly its not immoral to drive on roads.

If I recall correctly, at the time of making the statement (on air), my thinking was that ( a ) freedom is a value to me, ( b ) the government is refusing to defend it and instead is undermining it, and ( c ) if it is the case that by refusing to donate my organs on their terms they will cease undermining my freedom to deal with my organs as I choose, it would be immoral for me to donate my organs. In other words: providing that it might be effective, not donating is the pursuit of a value that has been taken from me (even if that pursuit is not ultimately successful), and donating is the sacrifice of that value (freedom) which might have been restored to me by not donating (which donation would, itself, most usually be a sacrificial act).

That said, I did not have time - on the show - to give the more full explanation I give earlier in this thread.

With respect to your example: the driving on roads example does not work. Driving on roads may very well be a value to you (and, quite possibly, as much or more of a value than the taxes in question): it is virtuous to pursue such a value even if such pursuit means that, as a result, some bad buy won’t stop doing vicious things to you. But that is different from ( a ) sacrificing value when not-sacrificing stands a chance of restoring your freedom, or ( b ) choosing a stranger’s survival at the cost of the possibility of restoring your own freedom. Think of it this way: if you could either ( a ) try to run out of an evil POW camp just before the gate closes versus ( b ) intentionally take a bullet while the gate closes so as to save a fellow prisoner’s life, what is the moral choice? I say: ( a ), even if I fail to make it through the gate on time.

"if i decide to donate my organs, freely without coercion, under the terms the govt has stipulate, I dont think this would be and immoral act. "

Do objectivists agree or disagree?

The presence or absence of coercion does not determine whether an act is immoral: morality is not dictated by the presence or absence of freedom. Such an assertion inverts the hierarchy of philosophical knowledge (see Peter Schwartz’s excellent essay on “Libertarianism: the Perversion of Liberty”).

Do you hear much condemnation of the real cause of this crisis, or do you hear more about how it was the fault of under-regulated markets and banks acting with too much freedom, with little regard for the “greater good”?

That’s how much I figure an “organ crisis” would help our cause.

What we need to do is attack the notion that our bodies are not our property.

Two things:

  1. Sales of Atlas Shrugged have greatly increased - hence awareness of Objectivism as increased - because, in this crisis, many have done exactly what one person should do: take every opportunity to advocate the ethically correct response and to ethically condemn the cause of the mess.

  2. Self-ownership is a false concept. Your body is not your property. Your body is you. A rock does not belong to itself: it is itself. The mind and the body are one: the mind does not own the body. These notions come out of - and are most at home in - religious thinking about disembodied souls. I’ve done a blog post and video on the subject, in case anyone is interested: http://blog.paulmckeever.ca/2008/09/16/rea…self-ownership/

Sorry i dont know how to quote,

“and donating is the sacrifice of that value (freedom) which might have been restored to me not donating” But this is only correct if preceded by “I argued that if, by refusing to donate ones organs, the government will be persuaded to end the prohibition” and its this premis of your agument that i’m having a problem with. I think it the “If” part.

You would not use that premis without the “if” and If you did retract it, then I could easily disagree with that statement.

Sorry i dont know how to quote,

“and donating is the sacrifice of that value (freedom) which might have been restored to me not donating” But this is only correct if preceded by “I argued that if, by refusing to donate ones organs, the government will be persuaded to end the prohibition” and its this premis of your agument that i’m having a problem with. I think it the “If” part.

You would not use that premis without the “if” and If you did retract it, then I could easily disagree with that statement.

I’m not sure if I’m following you, but I think you are saying that if (a) there was no reason to believe that refusing to donate organs could cause the government to restore my freedom of choice with respect to the terms of organ transplants, then ( b ) donating my organs would not constitute the sacrifice of my freedom. I agree with that.

However, (a) I do not share the view that such a refusal to donate would put no pressure on the government to allow me to set the terms of my organ distribution (i.e., I think a widespread refusal to donate would pressure the government to allow the sale of organs); and ( b ) quite apart from the wrongfulness of giving up the pursuit of the value freedom, where such trade is illegal, sacrificing the value of ones organs will enable the government to continue providing organs to those who need them. It’s right, in other words, to go “on strike” (or, in the parlance of the day, to “Go Galt” with respect to ones own organs).

Alright, so we just disagree with the premise.

"There are currently approximately 1,731 people on Ontario’s waiting lists for organ transplants. It is estimated that in 1999 over 100 Ontarians died waiting for a transplant. All predictions are that the waiting lists will continue to grow, the wait for a transplant will become longer and more people will die waiting if nothing is done to improve organ and tissue donation in our Province. (7) "

http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summa…86-15534050_ITM

Organ shortage as a stratagy is not working.

Alright, so we just disagree with the premise.

"There are currently approximately 1,731 people on Ontario’s waiting lists for organ transplants. It is estimated that in 1999 over 100 Ontarians died waiting for a transplant. All predictions are that the waiting lists will continue to grow, the wait for a transplant will become longer and more people will die waiting if nothing is done to improve organ and tissue donation in our Province. (7) "

http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summa…86-15534050_ITM

Organ shortage as a stratagy is not working.

That’s right.

Here’s the government’s answer to the impracticality of evil (i.e., altruism): http://www.recycleme.org/

“Hey kids, guts are cool, so sacrifice them”.

Two things:

  1. Sales of Atlas Shrugged have greatly increased - hence awareness of Objectivism as increased - because, in this crisis, many have done exactly what one person should do: take every opportunity to advocate the ethically correct response and to ethically condemn the cause of the mess.

That’s good. But Atlas has been popular before

  1. Self-ownership is a false concept. Your body is not your property. Your body is you. A rock does not belong to itself: it is itself. The mind and the body are one: the mind does not own the body.

I do own myself, right? Both mind and body. The mind will be gone when I die. The body won’t (not right away). Therefore I can sell parts of myself, such as organs or tissues, or give them away, if I so desire.

I do own myself, right? Both mind and body. The mind will be gone when I die. The body won’t (not right away). Therefore I can sell parts of myself, such as organs or tissues, or give them away, if I so desire.

Well, technically, no. The objection to the concept “self-ownership” isn’t about freedom or property. It’s about the nature of ownership. Property is a relation. A thing does not have a relationship with itself: it simply is itself. To say: “I own my body” implies that there is an “I” which is not “my body”; ownership - a relation - implies that “I” is not “my body”. “Self-ownership” implies a mind (“I”) body (“my body”) dichotomy.

If you want to keep it clear: rather than speaking of what will be done with “your body” after “you” die, speak of what will happen to the “organs” that will continue to exist after “you” do not.

That said, I do not object per say to a person speaking about “my hands”, “my kidneys” etc., because those are references to parts of oneself. The problem arises when the concept of “ownership” is used as “ownership” per say; as property.

Paul, I don’t understand what you are on about. It seems to me you are seeing a philosophical mistake where it doesn’t exist.

A person’s body is made of parts. There are parts that can be replaced without hurting the person. The body is not a solid whole. We say “my body” so we do not have to say “my heart is mine, my liver is mine” etc.