If Objectivists are an insignificant minority, then any particular voter is a minority of one. That particular voter can make the same argument: that his vote does not really count. After all, there are hardly any elections where one guy wins by a single vote. The principle behind going to vote is to consider it as being a principle. So, if I support Obama, I would go vote for him on the principle that if every one of his supporters did so, he would win, and if everyone of his supporters thought âmy vote doesnât matterâ he would lose. So, while there is a sense in which my one vote cannot elect this genius back to the Presidency, thereâs another sense in which it is all that matters: the sense where I act a certain way, and others who agree with me do so too.
This does not imply one ought to vote. Nor does it imply that one ought to vote for one of the major parties.
The more I read about prescriptive Objectivist voting advice, and the more I think about it, the more interesting a subject it becomes to me.
The argument for voting for Obama (or for Romney) seems to be: any vote cast for a âmore appealingâ third party candidate (philosophically speaking) will be a waste, because it âdoes not really countâ in the context of the modern American political scene. We have one real choice to make: Republican or Democrat, and thus we should select the best of those two choices.
And yet the further context, which seems just as real to me â though you seem to argue against it here on âprincipleâ â is that my vote for Obama or for Romney matters just as much as my âwasted voteâ for any third party candidate. Which is to say that it does not matter. For example, I live in Oregon, and my state is going to vote for Obama. What difference will it make to the national scene if I vote for a third party candidate in Oregon? Even in a swing state, I can hardly imagine any scenario where an election would turn on my personal voteâŚ
If the response is, âwell, if everyone took that attitude, thenâŚâ, I suppose I would say that if everyone âtook my attitudeâ with respect to politics, then we wouldnât have this problem in the first place. Everyone does not and will not âtake my attitude,â and that is context, too.
I think itâs fair to say that if I was selected, perhaps by special Supreme Court injunction, to cast the one and only tiebreak between Obama and Romney, then it would possibly behoove me to try to suss out which of the two would be the lesser evil. Though even there, if they are close enough in their opposition to liberty â as I suspect is the case â then perhaps it wouldnât be worth my time even then, and I would do just as well flipping a coin. But barring that, I see no good reason not to vote âmy conscience,â by which I mean whatever candidate I actually think should take office, if any such creature actually exists. While Iâm cognizant of the fact that âmy candidateâ can hardly win in 2012 America, I also recognize that, living in Oregon as I do, my stateâs electoral votes are already as good as cast â and further, that the current difference between Republicans and Democrats is so small as to not be worth my time to study further.