Peikoff on upcoming election

If Objectivists are an insignificant minority, then any particular voter is a minority of one. That particular voter can make the same argument: that his vote does not really count. After all, there are hardly any elections where one guy wins by a single vote. The principle behind going to vote is to consider it as being a principle. So, if I support Obama, I would go vote for him on the principle that if every one of his supporters did so, he would win, and if everyone of his supporters thought “my vote doesn’t matter” he would lose. So, while there is a sense in which my one vote cannot elect this genius back to the Presidency, there’s another sense in which it is all that matters: the sense where I act a certain way, and others who agree with me do so too.

This does not imply one ought to vote. Nor does it imply that one ought to vote for one of the major parties.

The more I read about prescriptive Objectivist voting advice, and the more I think about it, the more interesting a subject it becomes to me.

The argument for voting for Obama (or for Romney) seems to be: any vote cast for a “more appealing” third party candidate (philosophically speaking) will be a waste, because it “does not really count” in the context of the modern American political scene. We have one real choice to make: Republican or Democrat, and thus we should select the best of those two choices.

And yet the further context, which seems just as real to me – though you seem to argue against it here on “principle” – is that my vote for Obama or for Romney matters just as much as my “wasted vote” for any third party candidate. Which is to say that it does not matter. For example, I live in Oregon, and my state is going to vote for Obama. What difference will it make to the national scene if I vote for a third party candidate in Oregon? Even in a swing state, I can hardly imagine any scenario where an election would turn on my personal vote…

If the response is, “well, if everyone took that attitude, then…”, I suppose I would say that if everyone “took my attitude” with respect to politics, then we wouldn’t have this problem in the first place. Everyone does not and will not “take my attitude,” and that is context, too.

I think it’s fair to say that if I was selected, perhaps by special Supreme Court injunction, to cast the one and only tiebreak between Obama and Romney, then it would possibly behoove me to try to suss out which of the two would be the lesser evil. Though even there, if they are close enough in their opposition to liberty – as I suspect is the case – then perhaps it wouldn’t be worth my time even then, and I would do just as well flipping a coin. But barring that, I see no good reason not to vote “my conscience,” by which I mean whatever candidate I actually think should take office, if any such creature actually exists. While I’m cognizant of the fact that “my candidate” can hardly win in 2012 America, I also recognize that, living in Oregon as I do, my state’s electoral votes are already as good as cast – and further, that the current difference between Republicans and Democrats is so small as to not be worth my time to study further.

And yet the further context, which seems just as real to me – though you seem to argue against it here on “principle” – is that my vote for Obama or for Romney matters just as much as my “wasted vote” for any third party candidate.

No, I did not mean to imply that. I was focusing only on the single idea of “being a minority”.

That’s why I added the (admittedly inadequate) caveat to my post, saying: "This does not imply one ought to vote. Nor does it imply that one ought to vote for one of the major parties.

Firstly, I can easily see someone conclude that Romney vs. Obama will make little net difference, particularly over the long haul. In that case, it would not make sense to vote for either.

Second, I agree with what you say about any particular voter’s context. If a particular voter knows that his district/state (or other lowest unit to which votes get aggregated) will surely vote one way or the other, then his vote has no practical meaning: the surer one is of this, the less relevant is the individual vote.

Putting it all together, I’d say that if one is in a “swing district” within a “swing state” and if you actually do think that Obama or Romney will be better than the other in their long-term impact, then it makes sense to vote for that person. Here too, I would make an exception: if you really think both candidates have crossed some line that you have drawn in your mind – where they stand like two cannibals asking you which of them you wish to eat you – there’s no reason to vote for either.

I’d summarize things thus: if I am going to wake up the day after not voting in the election,and I see Mr. XYZ has won narrowly, and narrowly in my “effective district”, and if seeing this I’m going to dislike the outcome and wish the other guy won, then I ought to have voted.

1 Like

No, I did not mean to imply that. I was focusing only on the single idea of “being a minority”.

That’s why I added the (admittedly inadequate) caveat to my post, saying: "This does not imply one ought to vote. Nor does it imply that one ought to vote for one of the major parties.

Firstly, I can easily see someone conclude that Romney vs. Obama will make little net difference, particularly over the long haul. In that case, it would not make sense to vote for either.

Second, I agree with what you say about any particular voter’s context. If a particular voter knows that his district/state (or other lowest unit to which votes get aggregated) will surely vote one way or the other, then his vote has no practical meaning: the surer one is of this, the less relevant is the individual vote.

Putting it all together, I’d say that if one is in a “swing district” within a “swing state” and if you actually do think that Obama or Romney will be better than the other in their long-term impact, then it makes sense to vote for that person. Here too, I would make an exception: if you really think both candidates have crossed some line that you have drawn in your mind – where they stand like two cannibals asking you which of them you wish to eat you – there’s no reason to vote for either.

I’d summarize things thus: if I am going to wake up the day after not voting in the election,and I see Mr. XYZ has won narrowly, and narrowly in my “effective district”, and if seeing this I’m going to dislike the outcome and wish the other guy won, then I ought to have voted.

Agreed.

Here too, I would make an exception: if you really think both candidates have crossed some line that you have drawn in your mind – where they stand like two cannibals asking you which of them you wish to eat you – there’s no reason to vote for either.

I have to say, that is a great line.

I have to say, that is a great line.

I agree.

Right, a lot of these arguments seem to assume from the beginning that we have to vote in the first place, but I see no reason for that. At least in the context of Obama v Romney, it should be proven before the case for voting for a particular candidate proceeds.

It’s a short article, not a doctoral thesis. Which assertions are you disputing, specifically?

Short articles can have citations and evidence too. I just wanted an example of why Obama is an “anti-entity”.

Maybe a comparison between FDR and Obama could show why Obama is so bad, rather than just another tool in the whitehouse.

The more I read about prescriptive Objectivist voting advice, and the more I think about it, the more interesting a subject it becomes to me.

The argument for voting for Obama (or for Romney) seems to be: any vote cast for a “more appealing” third party candidate (philosophically speaking) will be a waste, because it “does not really count” in the context of the modern American political scene. We have one real choice to make: Republican or Democrat, and thus we should select the best of those two choices.

I’d like to suggest the following presentation, and particularly the second speaker, who starts at 13 minutes in, for another way of thinking about this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-2YhzC-PnA

You being in Oregon, IMO, or rather if I were in your place, I’d be voting for Johnson. Since I’m in Florida I feel I’m pretty well stuck with voting Romney, and I’m someone who has voted Libertarian every time for decades. Your vote for Romney really doesn’t count, in that he’s not counting on it to win. Further, even if the polls are totally wrong and Romney pulls such a sweep that he even takes the left coast, it would be a bad thing because he’d then claim he has a mandate. For repealing Obamacare, ok, I want him to have a mandate, but for the rest I don’t expect much that’s good, so let’s keep DC gridlocked like it’s supposed to be. I’d like to see the Senate split exactly 50/50, while retaining the Republican majority in the House.

Short articles can have citations and evidence too. I just wanted an example of why Obama is an “anti-entity”.

The article is on his website, for people who visit it. It wasn’t emailed to you, asking for your consideration. If you look around the same website, I’m sure you’ll find reasons why Obama is an anti-entity.

Maybe a comparison between FDR and Obama could show why Obama is so bad, rather than just another tool in the whitehouse.

What are you basing that on? You just finished explaining how you know nothing about Obama yesterday.

The article is on his website, for people who visit it. It wasn’t emailed to you, asking for your consideration. If you look around the same website, I’m sure you’ll find reasons why Obama is an anti-entity.

Lacking sources/citations/mentions of real events suggests low credibility. This applies to any and all articles and op-eds. I have no idea, after reading it, how Obama is “anti-entity” any more than Romney. The whole article I did not find useful, nor would I link it to anyone else who is looking for varied thoughts on the election. No, I wasn’t forced to read the article, I chose to read it to see what Peikoff is saying. And he didn’t seem to be saying much at all.

1 Like

Lacking sources/citations/mentions of real events suggests low credibility. This applies to any and all articles and op-eds. I have no idea, after reading it, how Obama is “anti-entity” any more than Romney. The whole article I did not find useful, nor would I link it to anyone else who is looking for varied thoughts on the election. No, I wasn’t forced to read the article, I chose to read it to see what Peikoff is saying. And he didn’t seem to be saying much at all.

Your post is lacking sources/citations/mentions of real events. You must be lying.

Your post is lacking sources/citations/mentions of real events. You must be lying.

Are you an asshole in real life too? Honestly this forum has real people in it, and isn’t a dumping ground for your emotional problems. If you want to discuss things with people here you should be more respectful of them and not approach them in such a sarcastic, obtuse, and disrespectful way. If you refuse to interperet people’s words in a sensible way, then you should go to RevLeft or Mises. Those people would suit your personality better.

Are you an asshole in real life too? Honestly this forum has real people in it, and isn’t a dumping ground for your emotional problems. If you want to discuss things with people here you should be more respectful of them and not approach them in such a sarcastic, obtuse, and disrespectful way. If you refuse to interperet people’s words in a sensible way, then you should go to RevLeft or Mises. Those people would suit your personality better.

I’m sorry, I meant that his post “suggests low credibility”. Because that’s not exactly the same thing as insulting someone by calling them a liar.

I’m sorry, I meant that his post “suggests low credibility”.

I didn’t say anything that required further explanation, because I mentioned a fact most people here would know (about how credibility works) and how I personally don’t understand Peikoff. Presumably, I am part of his audience, so he should have explained.

I’m sorry, I meant that his post “suggests low credibility”. Because that’s not exactly the same thing as insulting someone by calling them a liar.

Sorry for blowing up on you.

Look can you just explain what an anti-entity is? I really can’t find anything on his website. If you know what he is saying all I want is a quick little explanation of how Obama is different from some of the other bad presidents we have had.

My least favorite presidents in all of history are Woodrow Wilson and LBJ. If Obama is some how worse than those guys I can see why peikoff thinks the way he does, but honestly LBJ and Wilson were really really evil.

Look can you just explain what an anti-entity is?

I would wager he means a nihilist, a D2, Kantian anti-identity… Why dont you shoot him an email about it?

Peikoff Podcast on Obama as a nihilist

I agree with Dr. Peikoff. Romney winning would get us more time to teach people Objectivism.

Sorry for blowing up on you.

Look can you just explain what an anti-entity is?

I don’t have to, it’s explained in the article. You’re making it sound like he just threw out the term “anti-entity” without explanation, but he didn’t.

As I have explained in The DIM Hypothesis, Obama is in essence a destroyer for the sake of destruction, a nihilist, the first such to become President. The object to be destroyed is America.

…

Many evils are in store for us if Obama wins a second term, ranging from crippling taxation and Obamacare to the war on energy and the imminence of economic collapse.

…

The political choice in November is: non-entity vs. anti-entity. Or: a man who is nothing vs. a man who wants to mass-produce nothings.

It means that he is looking to spread his ideology (which is anti-American, racist and opposed to even the last bastions of American freedom: free speech and gun rights), to plant a seed that will lead to the unavoidable growth of a racist, multiculturalist society, and a socialist economy, in the future. As far as I’m concerned, the truth value of that statement borders on obvious. It is laid out in speeches and writings Obama produced throughout his career and in the writings of leftist ideologues he has subscribed to over his career.

My only point of disagreement with Peikoff is not in how evil Obama is, it’s on how much power he would have in this second term to carry out his plans. I think Peikoff overestimates his power (given a Republican Congress). I think he also underestimates the harm Romney could do (compared to a lame duck President who would accomplish almost nothing) with a Congress he can dictate to. I think new legislation and regulations would be rolling out of a Romney admin on a conveyor belt, while an Obama admin would continue at the pace of the last two years (with barely enough agreement between the parties to avoid near misses on government gridlock).

P.S. While I’ll concede that even with a friendly Congress, a Romney admin would be slightly preferable to an Obama one, I think the difference is negligible, and my vote will be better spent as an expression of support for the laissez-fair candidate, Mr. Johnson.