Peikoff says vote Democratic, from 1992

Ninth Doctor, there is plenty of room here to add text commentary. Fire away.

I pulled this off the old VHS I have of this talk at the same time I did the video about John Allison. It was something I remembered vividly from the time. I’m probably going to use small excerpts from it for another video, but much as many people here don’t like my critiques of Peikoff, hopefully you all give me credit for providing good citations and not quoting him out of context. This material is probably not familiar to anyone who wasn’t around Rand-land at that time, so if I’m going to quote from it I need to first provide the whole shebang, and it’s pretty long for a YouTube video just by itself.

Sounds like you’re prompting for me to offer a critique, and the fact is my real critique has more to do with his later voting advice. Here he gives a good number of reasons for his view, and ends by urging people to think independently, that “philosophies don’t back candidtates”, and so on. His 2006 statement, in particular, was a very different animal. My position has long been vote Libertarian, so of course I disagreed with what he said in 1992, and I don’t think I need to articulate the reasons, you should be able to fill in the blanks. Even Nicky, the chief of my booing section, who I see is sporting Gary Johnson’s face as his avatar, probably knows without my explaining it.

I have other old tapes, I might go hunting one of these days for forgotten quarry. This was really about my memories of that “unfriendly question” on the other video.

But here’s one point, re his raising the Salman Rushdie affair. Remember that Rushdie is a British citizen, and Britain broke off diplomatic relations with Iran over the affair. The US didn’t have diplomatic relations, so, just what he thought the Bush administration was supposed to do is not so clear (invade, nuke 'em?). It calls to mind what the second President Bush once said about Iran, when he noted that we don’t have any more sanctions left to impose.

Was he better President than GWBush?

As to Clinton being better, remember the first two years of his administration were very similar to Obama’s. I think Obama (and company) studied what happened then, and this is why they forced Obamacare through the way they did.

With 20/20 hindsight, Clinton got the benefits of fewer foreign military entanglements following the collapse of Communism (a “peace dividend”), coinciding with a technology boom, and a dot com bubble which burst just as the subsequent (Republican) administration was taking office. Alas, the albatross population is in no danger from the neckwear industry over the economic statistics of the Clinton presidency, contrary to Peikoff’s hopes. But this doesn’t mean Clinton was really better, one could (justifiably?) credit the Republican House from '94 on. Or one could concede that the President really doesn’t deserve credit (or blame) for everything that happens in the country (and world) during his administration.