If you want to say its arbitrary, thats something entirely different from the normal claim that it ‘violates the law of identity’. If your position is just that its arbitrary, thats fine.
Being arbitrary is, in some ways, a more damning indictment than violating an axiom.
In any event, I am not familiar with the arguments you have encountered regarding the law of identity.
I can see an argument along the following lines: Instantaneous travel means that an object is both at its departure point and at its arrival point at the same time. However, if a thing is what it is, and not something else, at the same time and in the same respect, then a thing is also where it is, and not somewhere else, at the same time and in the same respect.
What evidence do you believe there is for TEW out of interest? It has the exact same level of observational support as every other interpretation of quantum theory, and is surely equally arbitrary.
What distinguishes TEW from *some* QM theories is that it does not violate the fundamental axioms of philosophy.
The problem with QM is not the “interpretations of quantum theory”; the problem is the interpretations of the experimental observations, certain of the interpretations, anyway. Modern skeptics have latched onto what they claim are “conclusions” of quantum mechanics to attack Objectivist metaphysics and epistemology.
We are told, for example, that the fact that things can be both particles and waves at the same time means that the law of identity does not hold. We are told that since a cat can be both dead and alive at the same time, and is only forced into one state or the other by our observations, then the primacy of existence does not hold and consciousness determines reality. We are told that since the act of measuring one property of a particle affects another property of that particle, that man’s means of gaining knowledge is limited and uncertain.
(For what it is worth, Stephen Speicher has said repeatedly that the more “bizarre” interpretations of experimental observations are not held by many practicing physicists; that they are left at the door of the laboratory where the real science begins. )
TEW is an attempt to explain the experimental observations of QM within the confines of philosophic axioms. If it does not explain all of the experimental observations, then it is either incomplete or incorrect. Either way, its approach, i.e. its attempt to explain observations in compliance with the axioms of philosophy, is surely correct. The fact that we cannot, at the moment, explain certain experimental observations does not refute the axioms of philosophy. Nor does it justify an “anything goes” approach to forming a proper theory.
I don’t know if TEW is correct or not. Frankly, I have a difficult time believing it is “foolish crackpot nonsense”; I know it is not arbitrary.
I also have a difficult time believing that relativity is wrong. I understood that a vast amount of experimental evidence supported relativity. I suppose time will tell.