Raising Kids & Objectivism

Great post aEqualsA.

Usually, when people raise this issue, they’re thinking of some form of “spanking” as the alternative to “natural consequences”. So, I’d like to add that there are non-physical punishments that are “non-natural” as well, and these too should be avoided. For instance, visualize a parent who uses lies, faking and emotional trickery to get a child to do what he or she wants. This is not punishment, but once again it is the wrong type of motivation. Indeed, a little spanking can seem almost clean compared to the worst cases of emotional blackmail.

Thanks, and yes. I would go further and avoid as much as possible most punishments. Time out for example creates a similar emotional effect on the child as more corporal punishment. The understanding is the same, “If you do something to displease me I will be angry with you and use force to make you unhappy.”

What if the natural consequence is potentially life threatenig to the child and there is urgency in teaching this lesson?

(ie “Don’t race your bike down the drive way darting across the street” is being ignored.)

I’m not suggesting beating, but ignoring the action and praising other positive actions will not suffice here.

I didn’t mean to imply that a child ought to be allowed to experience serious pain or trauma as a learning experience. In the moment, restraining the child or carrying him away from the situation is fine. Especially if complimented by explanations once the immediate danger has passed.

Thanks, and yes. I would go further and avoid as much as possible most punishments. Time out for example creates a similar emotional effect on the child as more corporal punishment. The understanding is the same, “If you do something to displease me I will be angry with you and use force to make you unhappy.”

Also, the idea of using the “natural motivation” (i.e. the actual value or dis-value) resulting from the action is true not just of punishment, but also of reward. Offering a child money to ace a test is an external inducement that is unrelated to the value that is derived from the actual study.

Of course, there are times when external rewards and punishments can be used, but the overall policy ought to be to avoid them if possible.

What if the natural consequence is potentially life threatenig to the child and there is urgency in teaching this lesson?

(ie “Don’t race your bike down the drive way darting across the street” is being ignored.)

I’m not suggesting beating, but ignoring the action and praising other positive actions will not suffice here.

This is one of those times when a parent must look deeply at the efficacy of his/her communication skills, because if your child doesn’t trust your judgment, and also hasn’t enough life experience to make his own good judgment, you have failed. Shriek, wave your arms, chase him as far as you can, then go inside to obtain bandaging material, and grab your phone on your way back outside. Learn the lesson.

Stop lying to your kids about your continuously unproven skills as a medium. Don’t tell them they’ll get hurt when it’s not absolutely true. Don’t promise them injuries they don’t get doing things that aren’t actually dangerous. Let them use their bodies the way they want to from infancy (using good judgment and lots of care of course), and they’ll know their actual limitations. Then they won’t dart into traffic on their bikes at break-neck speed. They would have learned the precursory lessons long before they could ride a bike, if you had not hindered their progress with hysterical precautionaries until that point.

Discipline is all about communicating reality. Otherwise, it’s creating an illusion that a child will fight against because the evidence of reality is continuously available to inquiring minds; children are nothing if not that. They will discover that you have not been honest with them, but have been infesting them with your own irrational fears, presented as facts.

If that child doesn’t die from darting across the street, and you have told him a million times that he will, who is the one grasping reality? Parenting from fear is a lose-lose situation. Be honest. Even with children. ESPECIALLY with children.

Also, the idea of using the “natural motivation” (i.e. the actual value or dis-value) resulting from the action is true not just of punishment, but also of reward. Offering a child money to ace a test is an external inducement that is unrelated to the value that is derived from the actual study.

Of course, there are times when external rewards and punishments can be used, but the overall policy ought to be to avoid them if possible.

I absolutely agree again. Token economies, such as those they often set up in psych wards and prisons are amazingly effective, while inside them. As soon as they leave the token economy almost no long term changes are made. The problem with the approach is so obvious that it’s funny. As all good objectivists ought to know, people are different from dogs in that we possess significant reasoning capacity, so when they leave the token economies, they immediately realize that there are no more Scooby Snacks and they stop maintaining the desired behavior.

Children lack a lot of reasoning skills and the ability to hold broader concepts. Helping them understand causation, what the effects, short and long term, their actions will have, is far more beneficial. Especially in the context of understanding those things which they have experienced first hand.

Quote

 

It’s been 5 years since this thread was last active (that by itself i find very strange indeed). I’m curious if there are any new books for kids/teens based on Objectivist Ideals? Strange that nobody (to my knowledge) has yet written a teen/children’s book on Objectivism. 

14 hours ago, Tom Hess said:

It’s been 5 years since this thread was last active (that by itself i find very strange indeed). I’m curious if there are any new books for kids/teens based on Objectivist Ideals? Strange that nobody (to my knowledge) has yet written a teen/children’s book on Objectivism. 

Objectivist Richard Gleaves writes fiction for a younger reader. Review excerpt from one of his books:

Quote

Though many of the characters are teenagers, making this story accessible to the YA fiction readers, it also tackles important themes of individuality, rationality and learning to trust one’s best judgement even in the face of horrors and self doubt.

21 hours ago, Tom Hess said:

I’m curious if there are any new books for kids/teens based on Objectivist Ideals? Strange that nobody (to my knowledge) has yet written a teen/children’s book on Objectivism. 

Do you mean fiction for kids/teens? Not quite the response you were looking for, but there’ve been a couple of earlier thread asking for book recommendations for kids. Here’s one (and it links to the other).

A casual look through the current and related threads raises the question: do the books we read, or that people read to us, when we’re children have any effect on our character, beliefs or behavior later on? Has anybody, Objectivist or not, tested such claims empirically? A good test would, among its other accomplishments, give us a way to distinguish between the book had this effect on children and children of a certain character were drawn to this book,iked it as children land remember it as adults.

Anecdotes are better than no evidence at all, but not entirely convincing.

2 hours ago, Reidy said:

… Has anybody, Objectivist or not, tested such claims empirically?..

Anecdotes are better than no evidence at all, but not entirely convincing.

I’ve often wondered if there’s good research about a whole lot of child-rearing advice. Usually people will offer anecdotal evidence for something. I do so too, based on the experience of rearing one kid (not exactly a large sample size).