Romantic Love vs. Selfless Love

One reason I think Rand in The Fountainhead wanted to emphasize the need for “I” in “I love you” is that at least in popular culture, it was ignored and should not be.

In the arena of brotherly love, people will tell you they love you, even when they know nothing about you and don’t have any interest in finding out anything about you or what you regard as important about you. I used to run into young evangelicals like that. Moreover, all they cared about you was that you were a sinner and needed to be saved. They often have erased in their conception of you that you are a definite self or that that is of any significance. In other words, they neither knew you nor respected you or your mind on matters of concern to them. It’s a sort of desecration of the word and concept love.

On the theological idea of agape, it is as you note, that that sort of love is routinely associated with the further idea of the Christ, come to be known as the Son of God, having to suffer and die, to somehow pay for moral failings of people undeserving of the sacrifice. (And perhaps, similarly, with Prometheus bringing fire because he loved man.) But I don’t think that’s the only way the idea is used within that tradition. God as creator is, I think, without addition, a creator from boundless overflowing love. On the human scale, in the secular arena, such a concept, without association of perverse sacrifice comes up in relation with human creators, as here. 

I’d say that Rand’s neglect of the “you,” such as I think true to romantic love, as in my second paragraph above, was an error, specifically, a not fully evicting yet the egocentric from the kingdom of self-esteem.  A psychiatrist friend of Ayn Rand’s has what seems to me a balanced, realistic view of love in friendship and in romance, at about 33:00–44:00 here.

 

1 Like