Self-Image

Great. :confused:

Can you answer my question, or more accurately, her point, about the martial arts necessarily leading to a violent thought process, because of it being aimed at the ‘destruction of life’.

Sure, it’s complete bunk. Martial arts generally focus more on the preservation of self, rather than the destruction of life. Through long term study and training in conditioning and techniques that allow this. They are sports for crying out loud.

Nighty night, T.

In fact, I like having a fairly slim physique, and I would like to grow *some* muscle, but not lots.

That’s probably a good thing because, if you have a “slim physique” (ectomorph) then it is likely impossible, genetically speaking, for you to become particularly muscle-bound. Barring steroid abuse.

Interesting - I like the idea of doing a Martial Arts for the very reasons you describe. Does regular practice mean ones muscles and tonality build up, due to the regular use of those muscles? Is this also true of the slower paced Martial Arts. I’m thinking specifically Tai Chi - the whole concept of which attracts me, in its slow study of moves, building up to a greater whole.

Martial arts don’t build up your muscles at all. That’s a myth based on a lack of understanding of how the body works. For example, there’s no such thing as “muscle tone.”

Soyou want your muscles to grow larger, but you’re not going to do any bodybuilding because you’re afraid you’re going to go from slender to “big guns” after one workout? Yeah right.

I’m just gonna put it bluntly-- you’re never going to get any noticeable results from anything other than weightlifting. Anyone who tells you otherwise doesn’t really know what they’re talking about.

That’s probably a good thing because, if you have a “slim physique” (ectomorph) then it is likely impossible, genetically speaking, for you to become particularly muscle-bound. Barring steroid abuse.

That’s really untrue… another myth spawned because people who don’t do it right fail to get any results and declare it impossible. It’s fully possible for an ectomorph to go from 145 scrawny pounds to over 200 pounds of lean muscle in only a couple years of lifting.

Martial arts don’t build up your muscles at all. That’s a myth based on a lack of understanding of how the body works. For example, there’s no such thing as “muscle tone.”

Soyou want your muscles to grow larger, but you’re not going to do any bodybuilding because you’re afraid you’re going to go from slender to “big guns” after one workout? Yeah right.

I’m just gonna put it bluntly-- you’re never going to get any noticeable results from anything other than weightlifting. Anyone who tells you otherwise doesn’t really know what they’re talking about.

That’s really untrue… another myth spawned because people who don’t do it right fail to get any results and declare it impossible. It’s fully possible for an ectomorph to go from 145 scrawny pounds to over 200 pounds of lean muscle in only a couple years of lifting.

I disagree with your assessment that nothing but weightlifting will give you muscle tone. I weigh 210lbs with not much fat and I have never lifted weights.

I would agree that lifting weights is probably the quickest and most efficient way to bulk up. For me, and others, it holds no interest. Bores me to tears in fact. So my primary means of staying fit for my whole life has been martial arts because it keeps me entertained at the same time. Admittedly it is more strenuous then most since I am into the mixed martial arts stuff, but there are still benefits to other forms of activity which do in fact create tone for people. Pilates and yoga are not all that different from tai chi and they undoubtedly work to tone your muscles. The beauty that I have found in the more strenuous systems is that the diversity of movements increase not just your muscle mass but also the integrity of your whole system with stronger joints and tendons and more sturdy bones. It also has a tendency to work whole muscle groups rather then isolated muscles. I understand that this can be done with lifting also, but martial arts does it organically. (I don’t mean that in the hippie way)

Tenure: Regarding the violence idea, she really has no idea what she is talking about. The more I and others I have known, study martial arts, the less violent we become. It is a fairly consistent fact. What basically happens is, by fighting, and learning to fight, you begin to have less and less to prove; feel more and more confident in your own abilities. I don’t know what kind of circles you run in, but what happens is when someone “steps up to you” you have a little internal, and eventually external smile, because the thought that comes to mind is "does he think he is going to hit me harder then the trained fighters I play with every week? and you say somewhat reluctantly, “ok…if you want to…” The fight or flight is lessoned and usually the fight itself stops before it begins. Most angry idiots are very uncomfortable swinging on a guy walking towards them with a grin.

What you find out is how very delicate the human body actually is and how to protect it. Not just from attackers but also from accidents and general wear and tear. Her mistake seems to be the same one pacifists make. That they can only exist because someone else(generally police and soldiers) are willing to confront the harsh fact of reality that some people are truly violent and not at all rational and that they can only be met with the same. It’s a cop out and an evasion. Like eating a hamburger and hating the killing of cows.

BTW this is a pic of my brother in law from his competition few months ago which I attended.

Wow! What a cool shot! Now all it needs is a globe super imposed onto his back and you’ve got the new cover for AS! :confused:

That’s really untrue… another myth spawned because people who don’t do it right fail to get any results and declare it impossible. It’s fully possible for an ectomorph to go from 145 scrawny pounds to over 200 pounds of lean muscle in only a couple years of lifting.

That’s not what I meant: an ectomorph is still going to look like an ectomorph. A guy with a 5 7/8" wrist is just not going to look like Sophia’s brother. The genetics won’t allow for it. If you’re an ecto-mesomorph who’s just never worked out, then maybe. But the muscles will still never become wider then the length of the muscle bellies themselves. This is a physiological hard limit.

That said, if you know any true ectomorphs - 6 foot tall or more with small frame wrist measurements - that went from 145 to over 200 without a lot of that being fat, then do share what methods they used, etc. I’d be interested to hear it.

I agree with the rest of what you said, about tone being a myth and the “never going to get any noticeable results from anything other than weightlifting.”

Pilates and yoga are not all that different from tai chi and they undoubtedly work to tone your muscles.

They don’t “tone” muscles; they grow them in the same way that bodybuilding does. It’s the exact same physiological reaction, so using a different word for it only serves to turn it into an anti-concept.

What they do is work the small, supporting and balancing muscles by applying the body’s weight. Just like a chin up or a dip. Same thing. There is no “tone.”

That’s not what I meant: an ectomorph is still going to look like an ectomorph. A guy with a 5 7/8" wrist is just not going to look like Sophia’s brother. The genetics won’t allow for it. If you’re an ecto-mesomorph who’s just never worked out, then maybe. But the muscles will still never become wider then the length of the muscle bellies themselves. This is a physiological hard limit.

That said, if you know any true ectomorphs - 6 foot tall or more with small frame wrist measurements - that went from 145 to over 200 without a lot of that being fat, then do share what methods they used, etc. I’d be interested to hear it.

I agree with the rest of what you said, about tone being a myth and the “never going to get any noticeable results from anything other than weightlifting.”

They don’t “tone” muscles; they grow them in the same way that bodybuilding does. It’s the exact same physiological reaction, so using a different word for it only serves to turn it into an anti-concept.

What they do is work the small, supporting and balancing muscles by applying the body’s weight. Just like a chin up or a dip. Same thing. There is no “tone.”

I understand the similarity. I don’t think it is an anti concept exactly though. It does describe what tenure is looking for in physical outcome. That is, create a strong tight look without bulk. I do agree with you that he would not have to worry about getting too bulky with lifting based on his description of himself.

The important thing about this for tenure, is whether or not he will do it. I suggest that martial arts or pilates are going to be far more effective then lifting if it causes him to actually do it. Lifting is undoubtedly quicker for creating size, but only if you are willing to show up. I never was, so it didn’t help me build much mass.

I don’t think it is an anti concept exactly though. It does describe what tenure is looking for in physical outcome. That is, create a strong tight look without bulk.

It does describe what happens - but only by implying that a different physiological process goes on. (“Bulk” vs “tone.”) That’s what makes it an anti-concept. Because there is no such distinction. What people call “tone” is only the growth of the smaller, supporting muscles and (usually) the loss of fat around them so you can see them better. You are “bulking” when you “tone.” You’re just bulking different muscles.

It does describe what happens - but only by implying that a different physiological process goes on. (“Bulk” vs “tone.”) That’s what makes it an anti-concept. Because there is no such distinction. What people call “tone” is only the growth of the smaller, supporting muscles and (usually) the loss of fat around them so you can see them better. You are “bulking” when you “tone.” You’re just bulking different muscles.

So isn’t that enough to differentiate them? If I wanted to bulk up small balancing muscles and everyone knows that means the same thing as “tone” then it would still be ok to say I want to get toned. If a gal came and said,“I want to bulk up,” I would think was was ready to get on some roids. If she said, “I want to get toned,” I would (now that you’ve explained it) think, oh, she wants to build up strong balancing muscles.

So isn’t that enough to differentiate them?

Not really. Building muscle is building muscle. If you want to only build to a certain point or mostly build certain ancillary muscles without hitting the big ones too much, then say that. But “tone” implies that there is a different kind of growth (“toning”) that is achieved with high-rep-low-weight (or no weights) which simply is not true.

Simply put, the conventional way of understanding this (as “bulk vs tone”) is flatly wrong.

Deal with it like you would people using terms out of Marx like “economic power.” Explain what it means and then warn against using the term at all because it injects confusion into a discussion.

I disagree with your assessment that nothing but weightlifting will give you muscle tone. I weigh 210lbs with not much fat and I have never lifted weights.

Nothing will ever give you “muscle tone” because that concept as people generally understand it does not exist.

Your muscles will slightly inflate with additional water because of increased glycogen storage from the strain put on them by martial arts, and thereby grow a tiny bit. You will not -EVER- gain any additional muscle from anything other than lifting weights.

Your entire conception of how muscles work is wrong.

That’s not what I meant: an ectomorph is still going to look like an ectomorph. A guy with a 5 7/8" wrist is just not going to look like Sophia’s brother. The genetics won’t allow for it. If you’re an ecto-mesomorph who’s just never worked out, then maybe. But the muscles will still never become wider then the length of the muscle bellies themselves. This is a physiological hard limit.

Who said there is any need to change your body type? Haven’t you ever seen an extremely muscle-bound ectomorph?

That said, if you know any true ectomorphs - 6 foot tall or more with small frame wrist measurements - that went from 145 to over 200 without a lot of that being fat, then do share what methods they used, etc. I’d be interested to hear it.

First of all, you absolutely don’t need to be “6 foot tall or more” to be an ectomorph.

www.johnstonefitness.com is one example of an ectomorph, and this guy isn’t even that hardcore. If he can do it, anyone can. His kinds of results, and better, are very common all throughout natural bodybuilding forums if you search for it.

Who said there is any need to change your body type? Haven’t you ever seen an extremely muscle-bound ectomorph?

Not too many. But they don’t look a thing like a muscle-bound mesomorph; I can tell you that. That’s my point - the “muscle bound” that people don’t want to be is the kind of person that’s on the cover of the supplement - I mean bodybuilding magazines these days. Those are mesomorph steroid users. And if you’re not a mesomorph and not a steroid user, then it is impossible to look like that so there is no need to fear such an outcome. That’s what I was getting at.

First of all, you absolutely don’t need to be “6 foot tall or more” to be an ectomorph.

No, absolutely you don’t have to be. My point was to illustrate how skinny some folks can be. A weight doesn’t tell the story without a height. 145lbs is one thing - 145lbs at 6 foot is quite another. When I started out, I was less than 145 lbs at six foot.

www.johnstonefitness.com is one example of an ectomorph, and this guy isn’t even that hardcore. If he can do it, anyone can. His kinds of results, and better, are very common all throughout natural bodybuilding forums if you search for it.

Impressive. Does he list his height and wrist measurements (or other before-after measurements) anywhere so I can get an idea of the scale?

Nothing will ever give you “muscle tone” because that concept as people generally understand it does not exist.

Your muscles will slightly inflate with additional water because of increased glycogen storage from the strain put on them by martial arts, and thereby grow a tiny bit. You will not -EVER- gain any additional muscle from anything other than lifting weights.

Your entire conception of how muscles work is wrong.

Actually, now that I think about it, both our conceptions are wrong. The truth is that the magic muscle fairy put 60lbs of muscle on my frame without my lifting weights. I just woke up one morning and there it was.

Actually, now that I think about it, both our conceptions are wrong. The truth is that the magic muscle fairy put 60lbs of muscle on my frame without my lifting weights. I just woke up one morning and there it was.

That’s called natural growth due to age, water weight, and probably fat as well if it was that much weight.

That’s called natural growth due to age, water weight, and probably fat as well if it was that much weight.

No…your wrong…It’s definitely the muscle fairy.

No…your wrong…It’s definitely the muscle fairy.

Well, you’re right in a way.

Blessed and Accursed–Some Have It, Some Don’t–Posted 8/20/07

Not often - (but enough to be remarkable) - while I am explaining the role of genetics in bodybuilding at a seminar or to a phone consultation client, someone complains, refusing to accept the fact that the extent to which muscles can be developed is strictly, inherently limited. And, while most bodybuilders today are at least aware of the issue of genetics, very few know precisely how crucial a role it plays, or much about specific, phenotypic (i.e. genetic materials’ physical) expressions.

As a youth, walking the main streets of my small hometown of Ephrata, Pennsylvania, I would regularly see non-trained women who exhibited ordinary muscular development otherwise, yet had calves on par with those of an advanced bodybuilder. Not much later, while in Air Force boot camp, I encountered two different individuals on separate occasions with muscular physiques. Upon asking each how he trained, both responded in essentially the same fashion, “Everyone thinks (I) am a bodybuilder; but I’ve never worked out in my life.”

Mike Mentzer

Just because you have gained muscle - especially when young - does not mean that you are practicing effective or even remotely useful training techniques. That is, effective for anyone who doesn’t share your genetic proclivity to put on muscle or effective when compared to weight lifting.