Martial arts don’t build up your muscles at all. That’s a myth based on a lack of understanding of how the body works. For example, there’s no such thing as “muscle tone.”
Soyou want your muscles to grow larger, but you’re not going to do any bodybuilding because you’re afraid you’re going to go from slender to “big guns” after one workout? Yeah right.
I’m just gonna put it bluntly-- you’re never going to get any noticeable results from anything other than weightlifting. Anyone who tells you otherwise doesn’t really know what they’re talking about.
That’s really untrue… another myth spawned because people who don’t do it right fail to get any results and declare it impossible. It’s fully possible for an ectomorph to go from 145 scrawny pounds to over 200 pounds of lean muscle in only a couple years of lifting.
I disagree with your assessment that nothing but weightlifting will give you muscle tone. I weigh 210lbs with not much fat and I have never lifted weights.
I would agree that lifting weights is probably the quickest and most efficient way to bulk up. For me, and others, it holds no interest. Bores me to tears in fact. So my primary means of staying fit for my whole life has been martial arts because it keeps me entertained at the same time. Admittedly it is more strenuous then most since I am into the mixed martial arts stuff, but there are still benefits to other forms of activity which do in fact create tone for people. Pilates and yoga are not all that different from tai chi and they undoubtedly work to tone your muscles. The beauty that I have found in the more strenuous systems is that the diversity of movements increase not just your muscle mass but also the integrity of your whole system with stronger joints and tendons and more sturdy bones. It also has a tendency to work whole muscle groups rather then isolated muscles. I understand that this can be done with lifting also, but martial arts does it organically. (I don’t mean that in the hippie way)
Tenure: Regarding the violence idea, she really has no idea what she is talking about. The more I and others I have known, study martial arts, the less violent we become. It is a fairly consistent fact. What basically happens is, by fighting, and learning to fight, you begin to have less and less to prove; feel more and more confident in your own abilities. I don’t know what kind of circles you run in, but what happens is when someone “steps up to you” you have a little internal, and eventually external smile, because the thought that comes to mind is "does he think he is going to hit me harder then the trained fighters I play with every week? and you say somewhat reluctantly, “ok…if you want to…” The fight or flight is lessoned and usually the fight itself stops before it begins. Most angry idiots are very uncomfortable swinging on a guy walking towards them with a grin.
What you find out is how very delicate the human body actually is and how to protect it. Not just from attackers but also from accidents and general wear and tear. Her mistake seems to be the same one pacifists make. That they can only exist because someone else(generally police and soldiers) are willing to confront the harsh fact of reality that some people are truly violent and not at all rational and that they can only be met with the same. It’s a cop out and an evasion. Like eating a hamburger and hating the killing of cows.