Some Questions For Objectivists

But to answer your question, yes, the initiation of force is fundamentally life-denying; it is a great harm and never a benefit to the initiator, and anyone who is truly selfish would consider it evil.

Of course why it is never a benefit is a longer subject and is best covered by The Virtue of Selfishness and also Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand.

After rereading, I see what you mean, then.

What I am getting at is that if it is good that each person be self-interested, it would be ideally moral to uphold others’ right to other lawful self-interest, within reason, for reasons that do not revolve around our own benefit. The reason for this would be very abstract, but would revolve around the idea of making an ethical principle universally realized. If in another sense, it is our good that we be self-interested, it is our duty to uphold our own desires. Truthfully, the earlier makes more sense to me than the latter, but this is a huge, sweeping and critical distinction.

The principle that it can never be of self-interested personal net benefit to murder a person who has not wronged you is demonstrably false. I am not making an argument, but I am saying, surely neither you nor rand mean this, do you? It would be very silly for a philosophy to make demonstrably false claims that are effectively falsified by the real world. I am not saying it is smart to kill people willy-nilly, but one in a thousand people might rationally receive benefit from killing someone who did not wrong them. So the principle is very important.

This is why I make this distinction, as it would give objectivists a much better metaphysical basis for their principles, it seems to me. This is decent as a rule, but not a principle, as I can create a situation and demonstrably show you that murdering another person can be to ones rational self-interest if all they care about is their own happiness.

If your flat response to the question “Would you hypothetically kill someone innocent if, by extraordinary circumstances, you were positive it were to your net benefit” were “yes” I am not sure what to say. It still seems reasonable for me to ask you to answer a hypothetical question, though, even if you are convinced such a situation can never occur.

I guess you might make an interesting abstraction about morality by answering “yes” but because “By giving me that opportunity, they have inadvertently or intentionally done something stupid and / or immoral, so I can consider their action ‘evil’”. This would make the principle tautologically legitimate by way of showing that if a person has given us benefit by killing them, they have acted immorally, and so the killing is a priori justified for reasons that regard the failings of the other person rather than the morality of the self.

At the same time, I do not think Rand would have answered “Yes” to this question and I do not think she would have been lying. I guess I could be mistaken, and truthfully, that would be disturbing.

The main point is that Objectivism is against the initiation of force, not the retributive variant. However, we also understand that it would not be a good thing if everyone were to go out and play judge for himself; this is one of the reasons there should be a government.

So yes, it would be good to kill a murderer, but it is not up to an individual person to do so. That is, unless there’s an emergency situation and you need to defend yourself right there or die; but in general cases you should probably leave it to the police to catch the murderer, it’s their job after all.

What I am getting at is that if it is good that each person be self-interested, it would be ideally moral to uphold others’ right to other lawful self-interest, within reason, for reasons that do not revolve around our own benefit. The reason for this would be very abstract, but would revolve around the idea of making an ethical principle universally realized.

This reasoning strikes me as more Kantian than Randian. Kant was very big on the notion that moral actions had to be based on maxims that could be universalized. That’s not Rand’s argument. She argues that each individual should pursue his own self-interest, and that in fact it is in the self-interest of each agent to also encourage others to pursue their own self-interest as well.

The key point here, which I think has not yet been mentioned in this discussion, is something Objectivists call the “harmony of interests”. The claim here is that the rational self-interests of different people do not conflict with each other, which means it is possible for everybody to pursue their interests without harming others. Rejection of this principle is a powerful driver towards viewing ethics as requiring altruism. If my pursuit of my interests necessarily harms other people, and other people pursuing their interests necessarily harms me, then ethics turns into a system for balancing the pursuit of interest across society, so that everybody gets some values while minimizing overall harm. Such a conception of morality is necessarily social (because its purpose is to solve a problem that would not arise apart from other people) and altruistic (because its guidance is to tell people not to pursue their self-interest because it allegedly harms others).

Typically, objections to the harmony of interests principle are rooted in misconceptions about what actually is in a person’s self-interest.

If in another sense, it is our good that we be self-interested, it is our duty to uphold our own desires.

And this is one of those misconceptions. Our self-interest is not defined by our desires. Sometimes satisfying a desire is bad for us. I may desire to stay up late watching “Alias” on DVD, when it would really be in my self-interest to go to bed and get a good night’s sleep in preparation for a major presentation at work the following day. I may desire to get drunk to mask my pain at a disintegrating romantic relationship, when it would really be in my self-interest to go to marriage counseling. And does anybody ever desire to go to the dentist, even though having healthy teeth is clearly in their self-interest? Such examples can be multiplied endlessly.

It is obvious that people have conflicting desires. But desires are not the proper standard for measuring interest.

The principle that it can never be of self-interested personal net benefit to murder a person who has not wronged you is demonstrably false. I am not making an argument, but I am saying, surely neither you nor Rand mean this, do you?

Yes, Rand (and I, and I expect the other Objectivists in this thread) really are making that claim. Murdering the innocent is never in your self-interest.

If that’s demonstrably false, then demonstrate it.

It would be very silly for a philosophy to make demonstrably false claims that are effectively falsified by the real world. I am not saying it is smart to kill people willy-nilly, but one in a thousand people might rationally receive benefit from killing someone who did not wrong them. So the principle is very important.

It is possible post-facto for an immoral action to have limited destructive consequences, though luck or coincidence. But to take such instances as demonstrating that a policy of taking immoral actions is justifiable does not follow. Suppose that you jump off a building and, instead of breaking your leg, you land in a passing truck filled with hay and thus sustain no injury. Does that mean that jumping off the building was a good idea, or does it just mean that you got lucky? Morality doesn’t provide guidance after the fact, it provides guidance prior to acting.

In effect, you are proposing to replace the moral principle “Don’t kill the innocent” with the pseudo-principle “Don’t kill the innocent unless you can get away with it.” The latter, though, is not actually a principle at all. The guidance it provides would lead anyone who accepted it to be constantly on the lookout for cases where he could kill and get away with it. What would such an outlook do to the other aspects of that person’s life? He would view people not as potential values, but as potential prey. This would severely restrict his ability to build fruitful relationships with those other people. It would hamper his ability to engage in long-term planning (because that once-in-a-lifetime chance to kill and benefit could crop up at any time). Etc. That’s not a good strategy for survival and flourishing.

I can create a situation and demonstrably show you that murdering another person can be to ones rational self-interest if all they care about is their own happiness.

No, I really don’t think you can. It only looks to you like you can because you’re ignoring the consequences to a person’s life of abandoning principle in favor of perceived short-term gains.

If your flat response to the question “Would you hypothetically kill someone innocent if, by extraordinary circumstances, you were positive it were to your net benefit” were “yes” I am not sure what to say. It still seems reasonable for me to ask you to answer a hypothetical question, though, even if you are convinced such a situation can never occur.

I disagree with the premise of the question. Killing the innocent is not in one’s self-interest. We can debate the premise, but I see no point in pretending to accept a premise I think is false, just to debate what would follow. That would be like discussing what would happen if 2 + 2 equalled 5. What would be the point, given that 2 + 2 is not in fact 5, but 4?

At the same time, I do not think Rand would have answered “Yes” to this question and I do not think she would have been lying. I guess I could be mistaken, and truthfully, that would be disturbing.

You are correct. Rand’s view was quite clear; she did not think that it was possible to benefit by killing the innocent (or, more generally, by violating valid moral principles in contexts where they applied).

At the same time, I do not think Rand would have answered “Yes” to this question and I do not think she would have been lying. I guess I could be mistaken, and truthfully, that would be disturbing.

Am I following you correctly here? You started off this topic with a story about a guy that treated you badly who claimed to be an Objectivist. This gave you a bad impression of the philosophy. But now you find it disturbing that an Objectivist would not kill an innocent?

Another question. How steeped are you in Kantian philosophy? These conversations are going to get pretty twisted since the 2 philosophies are diametrical opposites.

I’m jumping into this a little later than I would have liked. I’ll answer the questions in your first post as best I can after making a few points:

I would not call myself an Objectivist, but only because I have found obscure quotes from Ayn Rand that I disagree with, and I am not yet sure if they are philosophical or technical in nature.

The guy in the situation you describe sounds like a serious @-whole. The people I have met that are Objectivists or closely identify with Objectivism are just as courteous and considerate (if not more so) as anyone else I’ve met.

Objectivism rejects the dichotomy between the practical and the moral. Therefore, if you ask an Objectivist to answer an hypothetical question regarding situations where you think it might be beneficial for one party to violate the rights of another, you will gain no knowledge of Objectivism.

Murder will always be contrary to the best interests of the murderer. If you think there is a specific situation where this is not true, I would bet that somebody here would be willing to show you why you are wrong (I’d rather not take the time). Check out the thread about the Prudent Predator Principle for more information.

1.) Not all evil behavior is stupid behavior, nor is all stupid behavior evil, correct?

2.) It is not moral to accept many things from people with communal personalities and refuse to help at all in return, correct? I understand this rule is applied to governments, but individual entities are treated differently than governments in this situation, right?

3.) It is not moral to mistreat stupid people simply because they are stupid, correct?

4.) It is not immoral to help someone without expecting anything in return, correct? (E.g., it is immoral to promote this as an imperative instead)

5.) Is the moral normative more of a positive description of how species behave, or is it a real metaphysical normative?

6.) From a secular, neurological perspective, it seems more reasonable to view morality as an emergence of empathetic centers of the brain which reinforce and punish “socially approved” and “socially unacceptable” behaviors, respectively, rather than “beneficial” and “non-beneficial” behaviors. E.G., morality seems more sensibly modeled as a function of the superego. Are any of you guys bothered by this sort of positive description of morality, or do you consider it more adequate than “socially approved” and “socially unapproved” models?

7.)Do you consider the distinction between “socially approved” and “personally beneficial” behavior less-than-meaningful or unimportant?

And just out of curiosity,

8.) What is more important in a friend: their maturity or their intelligence?

9.) Do you like kids?

10.) Leonard Nemoy or William Shatner?

1.) If the evil is any action contrary to the goal of living as a rational animal which is consciously chosen, no claim regarding intelligence is made. So, in other words, you are correct.

2.) Correct. Inspector’s post regarding the trader principle is spot-on. I would like to re-iterate that the value that one ‘trades’ does not have to be material - in other words, you may simply help somebody because you respect them and want to see them thrive. For instance, I have helped four friends move in the last six months, and I could care less about the food and drink they gave me in return.

3.) Correct. However, willful mistreatment is always wrong. It is proper to punish someone who deserves it, just as it is proper to reward someone who deserves it. A failure to do either is mistreatment. Just because someone is unintelligent does not mean that they deserve to be rewarded or punished.

4.) It is not necessarily immoral to help someone and expect to receive nothing material in return. If you expect no value whatsoever in return than it is immoral, so long as there is anything else you could be doing that would give you value. It is immoral to promote something that runs contrary to the trader principle.

5-6) After reading the thread, I am still confused on these two.

7.) Unimportant? No. The fact that you draw a false dichotomy is important, but again, Objectivism rejects that dichotomy.

8.) I would say that there must be a balance, but maturity is more important. This is a personal choice and says nothing about other people who closely identify with Objectivism or are Objectivists.

9.) I like some kids and am seriously annoyed by others. I intend to have one or two of the kind I like when I am 35 or 40 (about 15 years from now).

10.) Shatner continues to portray entertaining characters.

Edit: DENNY CRANE!

“Am I following you correctly here? You started off this topic with a story about a guy that treated you badly who claimed to be an Objectivist. This gave you a bad impression of the philosophy. But now you find it disturbing that an Objectivist would not kill an innocent?”

I mean to say (and I hope it can be seen in my semantics) that I would be very disturbed were I mistaken; I.E., I would be very disturbed if Ayn Rand said that she would kill someone innocent. I doubt she would say this, as well, of course. So for clarification, I mean exactly the opposite of what you have inferred.

“Another question. How steeped are you in Kantian philosophy? These conversations are going to get pretty twisted since the 2 philosophies are diametrical opposites.”

I dislike Kant for some of his strange metaphysical claims, and Kantian work has been pretty irrelevant to my life’s persuit of philosophy. That said, this strikes me as a very strange question.

I am also curious that if you ask this question to evaluate whether I am moral, how do you make a distinction between the beliefs of a person and their intentions? Or is the distinction moot? I have to admit that mere ideology has always struck me as a very strange and impractical way to evaluate someone’s character, as it does not account for intentions, information they have received, emotional maturity, and the subconscious. This is a serious beef with Objectivism that I do have, admittedly.

TBH, my philosophies of living are not very applicable to either philosophy and they definitely can’t be put on an axis between the two. My political and epistemological philosophies are much like those of Objectivism, but my moral philosophy is very different and disctinctly independent of either.

My political and epistemological philosophies are much like those of Objectivism, but my moral philosophy is very different and distinctly independent of either.

If you understand why there is no difference between the two, you’ll understand how one can evaluate a person on the simple basis of their beliefs/philosophy.

Philosophy is the operating system of the rational animal we call man. Whether one is talking of epistemological issues, political issues, or moral issues they stem from the same basic root, the philosophy and/or set of principles one lives by; whatever they may be.

This is why an Objectivist, being one who understands why this is true, has an easy time judging people. The very words out of one’s mouth and the meanings they convey (if any) are a window to the very basic foundations of that person’s mind.

What I am getting at is that if it is good that each person be self-interested, it would be ideally moral to uphold others’ right to other lawful self-interest, within reason, for reasons that do not revolve around our own benefit.

I disagree. The ideal is a harmony of interests. If my interests do not involve stepping on anyone else’s. Happily, this is in fact the case, so long as both myself and the other fellow are being entirely rational about it.

But you don’t seem to think that’s the case. Well, suffice to say: The philosophy of Objectivism does.

If in another sense, it is our good that we be self-interested, it is our duty to uphold our own desires.

Desires are simply unexamined emotions. Under rational scrutiny, they can be found to be either in our actual best interests or in fact rather against them. Desires, therefore, are not a proper guide to action, but rather a rational examination of the facts, is.

Also, Objectivism does not recognize “duty.” Objectivist ethics take the form of “if-you-want, then-you-must.” There is no categorical imperative.

The principle that it can never be of self-interested personal net benefit to murder a person who has not wronged you is demonstrably false.

Is it? Then, demonstrate. Actually, don’t bother. There’s a huge thread on it. Instead, read that thread and also pick up Tara Smith’s book and re-read the Virtue of Selfishness, and then read OPAR and then come back here if you still think that’s true. (It’s not.)

I am not making an argument, but I am saying, surely neither you nor rand mean this, do you?

I mean it and I am pretty sure that she did as well.

So the principle is very important.

Oh, I very much agree that the principle is important…

If you understand why there is no difference between the two, you’ll understand how one can evaluate a person on the simple basis of their beliefs/philosophy.

Weeellllll, yes and no. Just because someone talks a certain talk, it doesn’t mean that they’ll walk that walk. Mind you, if they’re spouting pure evil, the good bet it that they’ll act that way. But a lot of neophyte Objectivists can be too trusting of someone simply because of their professed beliefs. If that’s what Arkanin was referring to, then he’s got a point.

I don’t understand.

Of course people lie and mislead. I was still assuming that was the case.

It’s in the context of truthful discourse I should say, that it’s very easy to judge a person at a basic level. Given you’re talking about such things, as in this environment right here.

That aside, I say again that the basis of one’s beliefs and values are rooted very intimately in the basic principles one holds, and that it’s correct to assume that link.

That aside, I say again that the basis of one’s beliefs and values are rooted very intimately in the basic principles one holds, and that it’s correct to assume that link.

Yes, I agree. But it isn’t always a good idea to assume that a person has indeed subconsciously integrated the principles that he speaks of and actually acts like what he sounds like.

Oh, and as for the rest:

intentions, information they have received, emotional maturity, and the subconsciou

  1. Intentions follow directly from stated principles, so that’s invalid. One is responsible not only for “good intentions,” but also for the results, in reality, of their actions

  2. Objectivism most certainly DOES alter judgement based on “information they have recieved;” it is called the difference between an error of knowledge and a moral breach and it was described earlier in this thread

  3. I know that I hold adults responsible for their emotional maturity and as I said earlier it doesn’t matter to me how smart someone is, if they don’t have the character to back it up. I don’t see how this is connected to Objectivism, as such.

  4. I think I’ve covered that above. It’s not a flaw of the philosophy itself.

All of the above is assuming that I’ve correctly divined what you mean by that statement. Your way of speaking is very non-specific and so I might have your meaning wrong. That may be why you were asked if you were a Kantian, BTW… you just have a very vague writing style.

Philosophy is the operating system of the rational animal we call man. Whether one is talking of epistemological issues, political issues, or moral issues they stem from the same basic root, the philosophy and/or set of principles one lives by; whatever they may be.

This is why an Objectivist, being one who understands why this is true, has an easy time judging people. The very words out of one’s mouth and the meanings they convey (if any) are a window to the very basic foundations of that person’s mind.

Thank you for your polite response.

Still, this is troubling for me, as taken literally, it would fly in the face of modern psychology. One’s rational beliefs do not account for the myriad psychological factors that define the nature of a person’s inner workings. If this is actually your position, I will be respectful and try not to argue with you further, but I would also be very surprised to hear this is what you mean.

I do understand the difference between having a sincerely mistaken belief and a dishonest belief, but it would seem there is a more important problem. Particularly, sincere or insincere, our conscious beliefs are only one factor in our individual personality that defines our decision-making processes.

“Is it? Then, demonstrate. Actually, don’t bother. There’s a huge thread on it. Instead, read that thread and also pick up Tara Smith’s book and re-read the Virtue of Selfishness, and then read OPAR and then come back here if you still think that’s true. (It’s not.)”

Why do you give me a task and then tell me not to bother? There is a backspace key on your keyboard. So I would imagine that you must want me to demonstrate, or you would not say such a thing. True story: my grandfather was a professional hitman who did not ever even have a slight risk of getting caught. His options were that or die in a slum. He ended up saving his money, getting an education for himself, and moving to the states… on the money he made killing people.

Mind you, I’m not sure any objectivists would make good self-interested murderers. The point is just that in principle, they exist, and one of them was my grandfather. In conclusion, either you are defending an extraordinary claim or I do not understand the nature of your position. If I do not understand it, let me know where my logic goes awry.

All of the above is assuming that I’ve correctly divined what you mean by that statement. Your way of speaking is very non-specific and so I might have your meaning wrong. That may be why you were asked if you were a Kantian, BTW… you just have a very vague writing style.

I’m sorry if you do not find my style of communication pleasing. If I seem vague, it is because I consider it important that I don’t actually say anything I don’t mean to say. As a result, I often feel obliged to pad my words carefully, because I might otherwise say something I don’t mean to say. I will do my best to be more precise, all the same.

TBH, I receive the impression I am not being viewed in a positive light. I am not comfortable feeling scorned for having sincere philosophical criticisms, especially when I admit that I do not adequately understand the philosophy after having read many books about it.

True story: my grandfather was a professional hitman who did not ever even have a slight risk of getting caught. His options were that or die in a slum. He ended up saving his money, getting an education for himself, and moving to the states… on the money he made killing people.

You should be careful to distinguish between self-interest and rational self-interest. Though rational self-interest is a bit redundant, because it is always in one’s self-interest to be rational, it is an important distinction to make in light of the way people today inaccurately use “selfish” and “self-interest.” Killing people, or stealing, or doing anything merely because you want to does not mean that it is in your self-interest. If you understand that, it should be easy to understand (at least in general terms) that your grandfather was probably not acting in his self-interest because his actions were probably irrational.

Of course, I say “probably” because I am not aware of the full context of his actions. Where did he live? What was it like? Who was he killing? I could see how it would be moral to be a professional “hitman” in the following example: A country’s legal system is a complete sham. Laws are nonobjective in both substance and enforcement. People are killed by whomever for whatever reason. In such an anarchist environment, being a professional “hitman” could be moral if the ones he “hit” were the ones committing unjust murder, rape, and so forth. Those would be acts of vengeance made necessary by the complete, I mean complete, breakdown of civilization.

So, if you care to share it, provide some context about your grandfather’s situation. This, along with your loose, but common, usage of “self-interest” could help us and you determine where you are in error.

Why do you give me a task and then tell me not to bother?

Because I think that

  1. You will not be able to demonstrate this.

  2. I suspect that you might try to do so and your example will only bring up larger and larger issues that extend this into a debate. Ultimately, I know that if you’re honest you will see what we mean, but I think it would be a lot easier if you glean this information from some well-written books rather than here.

  3. I wanted you, especially, to look at the thread on this board (I think it has the name “prudent predator”) which discusses this very topic, before creating a redundant thread here.

I’m personally not interested in debating the point, but I’m sure there are plenty here who will. However, in deference the thread continuity, I would suggest you continue that discussion in the appropriate thread. (the mods will likely move it there, anyway)

As for the answer that is relevant to this thread: Objectivism holds that it is never in your best interests to initiate force. Agree or disagree with it, but that is it.

I’m sorry if you do not find my style of communication pleasing. If I seem vague, it is because I consider it important that I don’t actually say anything I don’t mean to say. As a result, I often feel obliged to pad my words carefully, because I might otherwise say something I don’t mean to say. I will do my best to be more precise, all the same.

If I may, I have the following constructive criticism:

It’s not a matter of if I find it pleasing; it’s a matter of the fact that I don’t find it intelligible. When you speak in approximates, you might lose the danger of accidentally saying something you don’t mean… but it’s at the cost of not saying anything at all (or worse, having people assume you mean one possible interpretation of what you said which was not in fact the interpretation you intended).

TBH, I receive the impression I am not being viewed in a positive light.

Depends on what you mean by that. (again, precision!) If you mean that we don’t agree with you, or that we are a bit passionate in the defense of our ideas, then I guess I’m guilty as charged. If you mean that the lynch mob is being prepared, then no, you’re not coming across that badly.

TBH, I find this dialog childish. If you want to discuss something else, happily, but I otherwise think it would be best I spoke with someone else.

If you find the rational composition of meaning in communication childish then you, my friend, are in the wrong place.

Because that is in fact what we are trying to do, determine what it is you actually mean to the end of engaging in a valuable intellectual exchange.

After all, you are the one asking the questions and most have made an honest effort to address them.

If you find the rational composition of meaning in communication childish then you, my friend, are in the wrong place.

Because that is in fact what we are trying to do, determine what it is you actually mean to the end of engaging in a valuable intellectual exchange.

After all, you are the one asking the questions and most have made an honest effort to address them.

I imagine you realize that “the rational composition of meaning in communication” is not what got under my skin and it is disrespectful to put words in my mouth, so I would ask you not to do so again. I’m annoyed by Inspector’s last post. I was annoyed by the one before, too, but the second one feels like “Yes, if you’re wondering, I’m trying to be condescending on purpose” when you set aside pedantic BS. I did not come here to start a flamewar, so if anyone asks about anything I said in this paragraph, it’s best I don’t answer.

At any rate, I do appreciate the comments that you made earlier. Getting back on topic – and I should have asked this earlier – are many of the positions Peikoff or Rand defend in Objectivist works considered unnecessary for objectivism? For example, I just finished reading a paper by Peikoff supporting the position that some ideas themselves are inherently dishonest and that if a person holds that idea, they are automatically party to intellectual dishonesty. Is that considered central to objectivism? It wouldn’t seem so to me, but I’m curious.

TBH, I find this dialog childish. If you want to discuss something else, happily, but I otherwise think it would be best I spoke with someone else.

Well, I was going to answer his questions for me, but I guess he jumped ship!

Of course, I say “probably” because I am not aware of the full context of his actions. Where did he live? What was it like? Who was he killing? I could see how it would be moral to be a professional “hitman” in the following example: A country’s legal system is a complete sham. Laws are nonobjective in both substance and enforcement. People are killed by whomever for whatever reason. In such an anarchist environment, being a professional “hitman” could be moral if the ones he “hit” were the ones committing unjust murder, rape, and so forth. Those would be acts of vengeance made necessary by the complete, I mean complete, breakdown of civilization.

So, if you care to share it, provide some context about your grandfather’s situation. This, along with your loose, but common, usage of “self-interest” could help us and you determine where you are in error.

Sure, I will be happy to tell you that story (it’s kind of an interesting one, too, as are most stories involving hitmen :wink: ). Before I go further, I would ask you to clarify about something.

In such an anarchist environment, being a professional “hitman” could be moral if the ones he “hit” were the ones committing unjust murder, rape, and so forth. Those would be acts of vengeance made necessary by the complete, I mean complete, breakdown of civilization.

Morality would not be entirely dependent on self-interest if another person’s past actions (rape, murder, and so on) were a factor when deciding if it is moral to do a certain thing to that person. For example, let’s propose two universes:

World A: “Steven is a professional drug-dealer who lives alone in a mansion. You will get paid $100,000 for killing him.”

World B: “Steven is not a professional drug-dealer who lives alone in a mansion. You will get paid $100,000 for killing him.”

Let’s say that in either case, Steven is fairly well-liked by the community and all other factors are held constant. If your chances of getting caught, the penalties for getting caught, and the odds of receiving payment are the same in both situations, is it possible for one choice to be moral and the other immoral? (And if you would answer “yes”, could you explain why?)

At any rate, on to my grandfather. He grew up in Mexico City which (believe me) is not the nicest place for a kid in his time. These were very bad times, before the big decades of mexican economic growth. He became involved in booze and drug smuggling and found out that killing people in the states payed well. He managed to make enough money to illegally get into the US, where he pretty much killed people for a living (he was better at killing people than smuggling). He was careful, talented, and took his job seriously, so he got a good professional reputation. After making quite a bit of money, he laundered it, made an agreement with his boss to “get out”, and then used the money to open a Mexican restaraunt in Texas with my grandmother.

Let’s say 95% of criminals are dumb and get caught. Of the ones who are smart, most of them don’t have the instincts and talent necessary to be a very good criminal, so a good 90% of the smart 5% probably get caught too. Of the ones who are good criminals, they usually behave impulsively and stupidly anyway, so they aren’t that rationally self-interested, either. At the same time, it would seem that even if a minute fraction of a percentage of killers do so out of rational self-interest, they exist all the same in principle.

At that, it seems indisputable that a person can be born into this kind of hopeless poverty in a society with no “safety net” as libertarians like us propose. I am a libertarian but I do acknowledge this as an innate flaw in capitalism (I regard capitalism as “horribly inefficient but still far more efficient than everything else” :wink: )

Well, I was going to answer his questions for me, but I guess he jumped ship!

That’s a negatory, by all means please go ahead :wink:

Morality would not be entirely dependent on self-interest if another person’s past actions (rape, murder, and so on) were a factor when deciding if it is moral to do a certain thing to that person.

You need context to determine self-interest. Self-interest is not just something you declare on a whim. It requires consideration of the relevant facts. Considering another person’s actions can of course be relevant sometimes. If someone comes storming after you with a meat cleaver, can you not consider that fact when determining whether it is in your rational self-interest to shoot him? This is rhetorical, of course.

Let’s say that in either case, Steven is fairly well-liked by the community and all other factors are held constant. If your chances of getting caught, the penalties for getting caught, and the odds of receiving payment are the same in both situations, is it possible for one choice to be moral and the other immoral?

His reputation is irrelevant here. Chances of getting caught, possible penalties, etc. are relevant only if the action is otherwise moral. I can not think of any circumstances in which it would be moral to kill a drug dealer only on the basis that he deals drugs.

He managed to make enough money to illegally get into the US, where he pretty much killed people for a living

I can not think of a single circumstance in which it would be moral to be a hitman on United States soil.

At the same time, it would seem that even if a minute fraction of a percentage of killers do so out of rational self-interest, they exist all the same in principle.

Be especially careful talking about rational self-interest and killing for hire. The circumstances in which it would be in one’s self-interest to kill for hire are extremely limited and would not exist in the United States.

At that, it seems indisputable that a person can be born into this kind of hopeless poverty in a society with no “safety net” as libertarians like us propose. I am a libertarian but I do acknowledge this as an innate flaw in capitalism

There are threads discussing the differences between Objectivists and libertarians. It is not a good idea to say “libertarians like us” here.

What exactly are you saying is an innate flaw in capitalism?