I don’t think you’re getting my point.
Perhaps. Or maybe I just disagree.
Perhaps not being artists, some of you have no appreciation for the level of importance that good artists, Rand most emphatically included, place on independent originality. They see their art as being a very personal thing which reflects their uniqueness. If your goal is to create art for the purpose of promoting someone else’s ideas, then you don’t get it. You’re not an artist. Maybe a teacher, propagandist or fanboy, but not an artist.
What you call “someone else’s ideas,” I’m saying are not someone else’s ideas.
If you have ideas that are the same as Ayn Rand’s, or anyone else’s, then they are your ideas. And it doesn’t matter if you got those ideas from reading The Fountainhead or whatever. Once you believe them – once they’re your ideas – then they’re yours.
And this doesn’t discount any value of “originality.” A person can express universal themes or ideas found in The Fountainhead or X other work (which are, in that sense, “unoriginal”) through original plots, characters, etc.
So I’m saying that Novak here might not have a goal “to create art for the purpose of promoting someone else’s ideas,” but perhaps he wishes to create art for the purpose of promoting his own ideas, which are yet-Objectivist. Or, were I Norton Juster, and I wrote The Phantom Tollbooth to promote “rhyme and reason” in the world, I would not have invented those virtues, but it would still be my original art.
Can you see Howard Roark wanting to design buildings based on some other architect’s ideas?
I think if Roark saw some architectural feature which he judged to be the best fit for his own project, that he would be a fool to “be original for its own sake” and refuse to design the best possible building by his own judgement. I think Roark went to school for architecture and studied many different forms and types of building, and it is based on that knowledge that his own “original” designs spring – bits and pieces found elsewhere originally, but guided to a unique and new development by his personal aesthetic and the context of his projects. Roark did not invent windows, doors, ceilings, buttresses, etc. None of those elements are “original” to him. And if someone writes a new fiction expressing established Objectivist themes, it will be much the same.