On 4/27/2017 at 8:43 AM, epistemologue said:
The appeal to there being strict rules without any room for arbitrary whim does not mean that the formation of a category is not ultimately justified subjectively (especially if it’s admitted there’s room for optionality, as in p. 70-73) - it is still subjective as long as the formation is based on your own subjective, pragmatic requirements, rather than on the objective requirements dictated by the objects in reality (p. 43, 70-71).
I tried to be very gentle in my last post, but it just occurred to me that you’ve been reading the ITOE; you already have the Rosetta Stone of my language. So in this post I’ll hold you to the same standards I hold myself to. Just a head’s-up.
Let’s assume that everything you said, in the preceding quote, is correct. The proposition that “roses are red” is not universally true of every rose; there are other possible colors (and let’s even call it “subjective” and “pragmatic” to boot).
What about a single, concrete rose, though? If I call it “red” that’s only because my own personal, subjective eyes make it look that way to me. What if I’m colorblind? The same for texture; the same for shape, smell, taste, length, and any other attribute one could ever find in a rose: I only know about them from my own, subjective point of view. My own senses are completely subjective. So by what method can I ever discover “the objective requirements dictated by the objects in reality”? Even if I had some form of ESP, any information it gave me would also be “subjective” by the absolutely-necessary identity of my subjectively-experienced, first-person kind of consciousness.
So whatever this “knowledge” thing is, it doesn’t sound like something you or I could ever do. Which means that you cannot possibly have any good reason for your assertions in the OP, which also happens to disprove your own position. That point doesn’t matter too much, though; anything beyond the impossibility of knowledge, itself, is really just gravy.
“Man is blind - because he has eyes”.
On 4/27/2017 at 5:53 PM, epistemologue said:
And that *does* imply that everything is “true for you” - because every concept you use has a definition which is based on subjective and pragmatic criteria, so it’s “true for you, for now” - but that definition can and does change; the concept has no universal metaphysical referent to hang on like she tries to make it out to.
Yeah; knowledge is contextual. You can only take account of your own, personal knowledge and there are never any guarantees of its accuracy; even if all of your conclusions are perfectly rational and you never indulge yourself in a single deliberate mistake, you might still be wrong.
That’s not a hidden flaw in Objectivism; Ayn Rand herself explicitly asserted it multiple times, outlined its role in related ideas (from the possibility of rational men holding contradictory opinions to the impropriety of the death penalty) and even declared, on no uncertain terms, that the sort of objections expressed in the OP stem from a deep misunderstanding of what “knowledge” actually is. That is why, when StrictlyLogical posted:
On 4/27/2017 at 8:58 AM, StrictlyLogical said:
This is not a critique. It attempts to be one but it fails.
Those of us who’ve been chewing on this material immediately knew what he meant and why he tossed your conception of “knowledge” aside as arbitrary. Just as when Grames posted:
On 4/27/2017 at 10:06 AM, Grames said:
A metaphysically given abstraction is a contradiction in terms.
We knew that “a metaphysically-given abstraction” means “an unalterable and inescapable result of a voluntary process”, which is a self-contradictory description of non-knowledge. Just like when I say “man is blind - because he has eyes” they’ll know that I’m pointing out your post’s tacit acceptance of Kant’s noumenal-phenomal distinction, which annihilates it once again on a third level.
In fact there are many different problems with the OP which I won’t enumerate any further. If you genuinely didn’t see them - reread the ITOE. It contains much more than it may initially appear to.
P.S:
If you truly didn’t know and you need some time to catch up, I won’t hold that against you. Part of me wanted to demonstrate what sort of mental rigor this “subjective, pragmatic and arbitrary” epistemology demands; what it takes to “speak my language”. I think I’ve accomplished that.
It’s worth it, though.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNBBFHJyLXE