I write this post from Haifa, Israel.
Israel is far from being perfect - and the two problems you described are serious. However both of them (the compulsory army service, and the inherent favoritism for religious jews) are both debated very heavily in Israel.
The truth is that today less than 50% of young people ever serve in the army. There is a plan to privatize the army and this is supported by many in the army and the parliament. It will take a few years at least to implement - but we’re heading there.
As to favoritism of religious jews: this is an old vestige of the Israeli welfare state, that achieved a semblance of unity when signing an agreement with religious jews back in the late 40s, sparing them from Army service, and establishing a status quo regarding many religious laws: For example - forbiding of public transportation on Saturday.
These laws are being cancelled one by one, and many government companies (the latest one being El-Al, the airline company) were recently privatized, and therefore stopped being influence by the status quo agreement and resulting laws.
As for being “the chosen people”: this is a very religious notion, and I don’t personally know ANYONE here in Israel who believes this. Only the Ultra-religious do, and they compose less than 20% of the population. Seculars are around 70%, and 10% are religious on varying degrees.
(BTW - even those few who believe Jews to be “the chosen people” see it as a mark of duty towards the other peoples, not necessarily of racial superiority. They believe jews were chosen to lead the other peoples into moral perfection. You can’t really compare it with the Nazis, who believed in a different kind of hierarchy).
Israel’s third largest party (and some say it will be the second largest by next elections), called Shinui (meaning - Change), rose to it’s current position by writing “separation of religion and state” on it’s ideological banner. This is a party which is explicitly secular, support free markets and push for abolition of many laws that force religious imperatives on seculars.
Shinui is now the second largest party in the government - they hold the ministry of interior, the ministry of justice, the ministry of science - and more!
Just to give you an example - there is a law forbidding to display bread for sale on Passover. You can sell it, but not display it in public domain. The fine for breaking this law is around 100$. Shinui couldn’t abolish this law in parliament - but they did not enforce it (the minister of interior is responsible for sending inspectors - and he, being a Shinui member, did not).
Israel still has a long way to go to reach the level of freedom in America, but when I look at America I see deterioration in this respect, while Israel is getting freer and better from year to year.
I think in terms of religion, Israel’s culture is far more secular than American. Religious people are a minority, and they are clearly marked (they wear a special skullcap, which is clearly visible, and you can avoid them pretty easily
).
I plan to move to the US by this year’s end. But I want to assure you that Israeli people have in general a lot of respect for the individual, and work hard to make Israel a better, freer place. And that’s DESPITE the fact that Israel is suffering one of the worst times in its history.
P.S. (1) - Drafting a constitution is also heavily debated here in Israel, and I believe the public is in favour, and so are more secular politicians. However, the block of religious party can make passing a liberal constitution quite hard. This brings us back to Shinui party - that are one of the forces behind the idea of an Israeli constitution.
P.S. (2) - The “Foundation Law” or “Basic law” that someone mentioned is exactly like a constitution in it’s legal sense: It needs a very special majority to change (85 out of 120 parliament members), no laws can contradict it, and the courts must interpret any legal case according to them. However - these “basic laws” are built in patches, and are sometimes deliberately unclear, or even seemingly contradictory. That’s why Israel needs a new constitution to be drafted from scratch. I personally believe it will be best to wait until religious parties lose their momentum, and Shinui gains more influence.