Support for Israel

Israel is in “Temporary emergency” since 1948- did you know that? It allows the government to do outrageous things

In fact, your country is in a state of war.

What do you expect from a country with no constitution? Did you know that in Israel, Individual rights are acknowledged in the form of “basic-rules” (that are supposed to be stronger than regular rules) that can be changed or ignored if the majority of politicians at a certain point in time vote on it?

The American Constitution is akin to a “basic law.”

in Israel, there only The Israely Post Office- and it sucks! It’s illegal to start a delivery service in Israel.

Might have a lot to do with Israel’s being in a “state of war.” Security level needs to be high.

That I’d have a choice as to whether to live in a kibbutz or not is reason enough to believe that Israel is not a socialist democracy per se. Sure, the kibbutz concept is collectivist.

My proposal to Israel is this: forcibly evacuate a Palestinian city to another Arab/Muslim country; if utter peace does not magically ensue, forcibly evacuate all of the Palestinian territories.

Of course it’s violent. But it’s not initiation of force, and all harm that comes to innocent people is entirely the fault of Palestinian terrorist groups and their majority sympathizers.

The American Constitution is akin to a “basic law.”

Can you change the constitution on vote? really?? :angry:

Might have a lot to do with Israel’s being in a “state of war.” Security level needs to be high.

No, this has nothing to do with security. Come to think of it, I don’t know why the heck they don’t allow a private posting service, but they don’t.

That I’d have a choice as to whether to live in a kibbutz or not is reason enough to believe that Israel is not a socialist democracy per se. Sure, the kibbutz concept is collectivist.

How about Israel declaring itself as such, is it a a good enough reason?

Israel is a socialist democracy. Besides, calling it something else won’t change reality. The amounts of money dedicated to welfare has impoverished the country to the state that it would not be able to manage without the financial support it recieves from the US! This country has no money!


I think it’s silly for me to argue weather Israel is good or bad. The facts are that life here are practically unbearable, they are suffocating us. The people that are running our country are plain stupid. Maybe it’s the same in the US, I don’t know, is that your’e point(AutoJC)?

My point is that one shouldn’t rush into supporting Israel because he saw a picture of a railroad or a fency skyscraper(btw, we have only about 6 of them, but that’s off topic). One should understand that he must support Israel because the alternative is a primitive tribal society.

Another good reason I didn’t think of myself is

"Israel and Taiwan are the two countries that need and deserve U.S. help-not

in the name of international altruism, but by reason of actual U.S. national

interests in the Mediterranean and the Pacific." Ayn Rand-The lessons of

Vietnam in The Voice of Reason

America’s postal service also holds a legal monopoly, and America is also a socialist democracy, though to a lesser extent.

Can you change the constitution on vote? really?? <_<

In fact, in America, you can.

Amendments require ratification by 37 of the 50 states, plus passing both houses of the legislature.

The Constitution has been amended numerous times. :wink:

I think it’s pretty obvious that, of the Islamists and the Israelis, who are the aggressors. What makes it obscene is that even the murderous Islamists expect to be able to blackmail the Israelis by their virtues. They often accuse Israel of not following rules that they themselves repudiate. How can a culture which praises sending someone to blow up a school bus have the chutzpah to morally condemn Israel for getting a few civilians in the process of killing a terrorist mastermind? (When it turns out that the Palestinians lied, oh well, move forward to the next incident).

It’s clear to me that if Israel turned its armed might against the Palestinians, they could exterminate them. The fact that they have not chosen to do so should indicate something.

I have two other observations. First, Judaism is significantly less malevolent than other religions, and Islam is significantly more malevolent. It is not a coincidence, that most of the top Objectivists (starting with Ayn Rand and Leonard Peikoff) were born into Jewish families. Judaism does not demand the abject, mind-numbing, unquestioning faith that Christianity does.

Second, I am involved in the voice over IP space. I will note that there are many more Israeli companies in the market than its small population would lead one to expect. These are smart people and their products are competitive. Is Israel socialist? Yes. Is the US becoming socialist? Yes.

Compared to the Arab states (which are all murderous dictatorships), Israel is a mostly-free state.

First, Judaism is significantly less malevolent than other religions, […] It is not a coincidence, that most of the top Objectivists (starting with Ayn Rand and Leonard Peikoff) were born into Jewish families.  Judaism does not demand the abject, mind-numbing, unquestioning faith that Christianity does.

Observe that while Jews are only about 5% of the population, that Ayn Rand, Leonard Peikoff, Harry Binswanger, Peter Schwartz, Michael Berliner, Andrew Bernstein and many other leading Objectivists as well as much more than 5% of the Objectivists _you_ know were raised in Jewish families.

Why is this so?

The reason has less to do with ethnicity than with philosophy. The appeal of rational values among Jews owes little to the Hebrew religion and everything to ancient Greek ideals.

At the height of the Hellenistic Age, the Greeks ruled Palestine and brought their culture to the Jews living there. The Jews (especially the young ones) became enamored of the Greek ways, sought to assimilate, and began to abandon their Hebrew traditions. Unfortunately, the Greek conquerors tried to _forcibly_ forbid Jewish practices, and this led to the Maccabeean Rebellion which overthrew the Greeks. When the Jews reasserted their religion, there remained a strong and vital this-earthly, rational streak of Hellenism in their culture.

Because the Jews were an isolated minority, they managed to preserve the ancient Greek world-view as the rest of Western Civilization sank into the Dark Ages. Jews were forbidden to own land, so they moved to the towns and cities. When Jews were denied entry into the artisan’s guilds, they became merchants and traders. While Christians scorned life on earth, the Jews became physicians. The Church forbids the sin of usury, so Jews became the money-lenders and financiers. Like the Greeks who named their greatest city for the Goddess of Wisdom, the Jews revered learning and the “practical wisdom” that creates material prosperity.

The man who is generally considered the greatest Jewish sage, Maimonides (Rabbi Moses ben Maimon), was an avowed Aristotelian. In his book, _A_Guide_to_the_Perplexed_, he sought to combine Aristotelian epistemology with Jewish religious teachings. Later, Thomas Aquinas (who, it is believed, read Maimonides) was to attempt the same with Christianity and, in so doing, bring the light of Reason to the Dark Ages.

Reason, individualism, and this earth have been a crucial part of Jewish culture for over two millennia. It is not surprising that Jews and Objectivists have so much in common.

L’Chaim! (To Life!)

I would like to second Betsy’s post on the merit of Jewish culture, but disagree with her reasons for the prominence of Jews in Objectivism.

I have two compounding explanations for this:

(a) For historical and cultural reasons, Jews are more educated and intellectual than the average citizen, so they are more included towards participating in two the dominant philosophical trends of our time: Marxism, and it’s opposite: Objectivism. They are also more intelligent than the public (for social rather than biological reasons) so they are more likely to seek and adopt the root of the philosophical tendencies they are exposed to.

( B) A history of persecution and holding unpopular minority beliefs had led many former Jews towards more radical social solutions, especially utopian ones. (Ironically, this led Jewish intellectuals to be some of the strongest supporters of the Weimar-era philosophical and political movements that brought about Fascism. It also created the utopian socialist vision that brought about the State of Israel, for better or worse.)

Regarding Israel:

I am (ethnically) Jewish and visited Israel six years ago. I found it to be an overwhelmingly secular state similar to Western Europe in culture and politics. This is unsurprising, as the majority of Israelis emigrated (or escaped) from there.

In terms of population, it is much more secular than America, and not much more religious, if at all, in the influence of religion over government. The laws pertinent to religion are simply more visible in Israel because we tend to accept laws rooted in Christianity as a given. I have heard that 4/5 Israelis are secular, and this is consistent with my experience. Unlike America, religion tends to be an all-or-nothing thing there, and it’s mostly nothing. The Orthodox minority parties have much more power than votes, mostly because of their prestige and solidarity. Also, the Israeli Declaration of Independence and Constitution have no mention of God – contrast this to the American versions.

In terms of economic freedom, it is freer than many European countries, such as France. The major interventionist aspect of government is caused by its response to military threats, which while misguided is much more reasonable then European welfare Statism.

I have neglected to post in this forum far too long. Let me state that I support Israel and that I was pleased that Israel has finally decided to eliminate the leaders of the Hamas. I truly believe that if Israel had to worry less about its security that it would move ever further to being a secular state.

For someone to claim to support America but yet have utter disdain for Israel is an inconsistency. True Israel is not a perfect state but neither is the USA. In the whole of the Middle East there is not a nation that closely reflects the values of freedom than that of Israel.

It would be suicide for Israel to capitulate to those who are hell bent on her destruction. It is not that case that the terrorists want to remove a despotic regime (which has no rights) but it wants to obliterate a state that respects to some extent individual rights. All this so they can add one more theocratic dictatorship to the world map. This is unacceptable.

On another note I agree with previous post. While reading it I remembered that I have always been intriqued as to why there are so many “Jewish atheists”.

I would like to second Betsy’s post on the merit of Jewish culture, but disagree with her reasons for the prominence of Jews in Objectivism.

I have two compounding explanations for this:

(a) For historical and cultural reasons, Jews are more educated and intellectual than the average citizen, so they are more included towards participating in two the dominant philosophical trends of our time: Marxism, and it’s opposite: Objectivism.

I agree, but I believe the “historical and cultural reasons” for being more educated and intellectual reduce to the underlying Aristotelian epistemology and its resulting this-earthly individualism. Observe that Aristotelianism, applied incorrectly, can also lead to Rationalism: the Rationalism of the Christian Scholastics or the Rationalism of the Jewish philosopher, Spinoza. The Marxism tends to come from two sources: Rationalism and the necessity for Jews to band together and rely on the collective community to survive in a hostile world.

In a more benevolent atmosphere. like the US today, most Jews aren’t very religious, they freely intermarry with non-Jews (a huge no-no in the Old Country), and a lot of them are switching their party affiliation to the Republicans.

They are also more intelligent than the public (for social rather than biological reasons)

The “social reasons” again reduce to Aristotelian epistemology. A little bit of good philosophy does wonders for your brain. :slight_smile:

Also, the Israeli Declaration of Independence and Constitution have no mention of God – contrast this to the American versions.

Jefferson was probley a “closet” atheist, he never refered to Christian God only Nature’s God.

But yah I agree Israel it is not as religious as leftist make them out to be. Israel deserves our complete support.

I thought Jefferson, along with many of the other founding fathers, had been a deist…

Yes he was a deist and unitarian I believe but it seems like he was also agnostic.

Fix reason firmly in her seat, and call to her tribunal every fact, every opinion. Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason, than that of blindfolded fear.

Thomas Jefferson

Yeah, but being a deist is not incompatible with that statement…

And being a deist would make him not an atheist.

If he were still alive, he would now be an Objectivist.

I write this post from Haifa, Israel.

Israel is far from being perfect - and the two problems you described are serious. However both of them (the compulsory army service, and the inherent favoritism for religious jews) are both debated very heavily in Israel.

The truth is that today less than 50% of young people ever serve in the army. There is a plan to privatize the army and this is supported by many in the army and the parliament. It will take a few years at least to implement - but we’re heading there.

As to favoritism of religious jews: this is an old vestige of the Israeli welfare state, that achieved a semblance of unity when signing an agreement with religious jews back in the late 40s, sparing them from Army service, and establishing a status quo regarding many religious laws: For example - forbiding of public transportation on Saturday.

These laws are being cancelled one by one, and many government companies (the latest one being El-Al, the airline company) were recently privatized, and therefore stopped being influence by the status quo agreement and resulting laws.

As for being “the chosen people”: this is a very religious notion, and I don’t personally know ANYONE here in Israel who believes this. Only the Ultra-religious do, and they compose less than 20% of the population. Seculars are around 70%, and 10% are religious on varying degrees.

(BTW - even those few who believe Jews to be “the chosen people” see it as a mark of duty towards the other peoples, not necessarily of racial superiority. They believe jews were chosen to lead the other peoples into moral perfection. You can’t really compare it with the Nazis, who believed in a different kind of hierarchy).

Israel’s third largest party (and some say it will be the second largest by next elections), called Shinui (meaning - Change), rose to it’s current position by writing “separation of religion and state” on it’s ideological banner. This is a party which is explicitly secular, support free markets and push for abolition of many laws that force religious imperatives on seculars.

Shinui is now the second largest party in the government - they hold the ministry of interior, the ministry of justice, the ministry of science - and more!

Just to give you an example - there is a law forbidding to display bread for sale on Passover. You can sell it, but not display it in public domain. The fine for breaking this law is around 100$. Shinui couldn’t abolish this law in parliament - but they did not enforce it (the minister of interior is responsible for sending inspectors - and he, being a Shinui member, did not).

Israel still has a long way to go to reach the level of freedom in America, but when I look at America I see deterioration in this respect, while Israel is getting freer and better from year to year.

I think in terms of religion, Israel’s culture is far more secular than American. Religious people are a minority, and they are clearly marked (they wear a special skullcap, which is clearly visible, and you can avoid them pretty easily :slight_smile: ).

I plan to move to the US by this year’s end. But I want to assure you that Israeli people have in general a lot of respect for the individual, and work hard to make Israel a better, freer place. And that’s DESPITE the fact that Israel is suffering one of the worst times in its history.

P.S. (1) - Drafting a constitution is also heavily debated here in Israel, and I believe the public is in favour, and so are more secular politicians. However, the block of religious party can make passing a liberal constitution quite hard. This brings us back to Shinui party - that are one of the forces behind the idea of an Israeli constitution.

P.S. (2) - The “Foundation Law” or “Basic law” that someone mentioned is exactly like a constitution in it’s legal sense: It needs a very special majority to change (85 out of 120 parliament members), no laws can contradict it, and the courts must interpret any legal case according to them. However - these “basic laws” are built in patches, and are sometimes deliberately unclear, or even seemingly contradictory. That’s why Israel needs a new constitution to be drafted from scratch. I personally believe it will be best to wait until religious parties lose their momentum, and Shinui gains more influence.

Thank you all for the excellent information on Israel. While I have long been a supporter, I am very encouraged to learn that Israel is so secular.

On a related subject, can any of you explain why 80 - 85% of the Jews in the U.S. consistently vote Democratic in the presidential elections? Is it a reaction to the influence of Christianity in the Republican party?

Israeli needs a Constitution like the US but without the bad parts.

On a related subject, can any of you explain why 80 - 85% of the Jews in the U.S. consistently vote Democratic in the presidential elections?  Is it a reaction to the influence of Christianity in the Republican party?

Not any more!

Most of the middle-aged and younger, middle class, professional Jews I know have switched from the Democrats to the Republicans in the past ten years. Jews used to be intellectual liberals of the Old Left. With the ascendancy of the New Left and its rabid anti-intellectualism and anti-Americanism, many Jewish intellectual leaders have become Neo-Conservatives.

The growing trend seems to be the population explosion of Arabs in Israel due to high birth rates. If Jews do not wish to be supressed in their own country through the opression of democracy, maybe some will revert and publisize objectivism.

(Just wishful thinking on my part)