Taxes: Does one have to pay

Is it in my LONG-RANGE self-interest to violate a moral principle that I hold to be one of the most important?  The principle that states that no one(including government) has a right to what I produce? While there are some disadvatages to my course of action. Even if I went to jail who would be ‘morally’ at fault, me or the state?  Or should one refuse to sanction what he considers to be evil when it is convienient? Your approach smacks of Pragmatism not ‘Objectivism’.

I believe Ayn Rand herself paid income taxes. She certainly didn’t avoid it in order to make herself a self-sacrificing martyr. Her life’s purpose was to portray (in literature) the ideal man. This she could hardly have done in prison.

NIJamesHughes,

Do you mean this as an insult, or am I misunderstanding what you’re saying?

It is an insult if you commented without visiting the site. If you visited the site then it does not apply to you.

Rational_One, the people of most African nations are so poverty-stricken in large part because their governments force them to deal with each other predominantly under the table, with all the attendant consequences Betsy describes.

Luckily, government here isn’t that oppressive yet.

Moderators:

I have noticed an anomaly on this thread without explanation. It appears as if the following Post has been deleted:

"NIJamesHughes @ Jan 12 2005, 09:33 PM

I’m guessing that noone visited the site. Very disappointing, although not entirely suprising since it isn’t recommended at ARI."

It is referred to in Posts #9 and #10 with snapbacks that don’t work.

Later on NIJamesHughes admits to insulting behavior in reference to same Post:

NIJamesHughes,

Do you mean this as an insult, or am I misunderstanding what you’re saying?

It is an insult if you commented without visiting the site. If you visited the site then it does not apply to you.

I would like for you to confirm whether the aforementioned Post was deleted or not. If it was deleted, by whom and for what reason?

Thanks,

Marc

Moderators:

I have noticed an anomaly on this thread without explanation. It appears as if the following Post has been deleted:

"NIJamesHughes @ Jan 12 2005, 09:33 PM

I’m guessing that noone visited the site. Very disappointing, although not entirely suprising since it isn’t recommended at ARI."

It is referred to in Posts #9 and #10 with snapbacks that don’t work.

Later on NIJamesHughes admits to insulting behavior in reference to same Post:

I would like for you to confirm whether the aforementioned Post was deleted or not. If it was deleted, by whom and for what reason?

Thanks,

Marc

As a moderator I deleted my own post, and yes, I did inform myself via PM of that action. :pirate:

As a moderator I deleted my own post, and yes, I did inform myself via PM of that action.  :thumbsup:

Have you no shame? :frowning:

As a moderator I deleted my own post, and yes, I did inform myself via PM of that action.  :thumbsup:

Why did you delete it?

Why did you delete it six days after posting it?

Knowing that three people had replied to that particular post, why didn’t you leave some sort of note about the deletion?

Why did you delete it?

Why did you delete it six days after posting it?

Knowing that three people had replied to that particular post, why didn’t you leave some sort of note about the deletion?

That is between the poster and the moderator who deleted the post. Since the moderator is no long here, I guess all you can do is speculate.

Seriously though, I deleted it because it was inappropriate and hateful. I deleted six days after I posted it because thats how long it took me to get my attention back to it with the help of BL.

NIJamesHughes has been warned.

I did a search in the threads for the question I am asking, but came up with nothing as similiar. If there are any threads with this information, please provide me with the link. Thank you.

Have there ever been any court cases against the government (local, state, or federal) for the use of taxes? In other words, has any one ever sued the government for the force of taxes?

or, are there any courts that have spoken out about the issue - ie. supreme court.

If so, can you please provide me with the case name(s) so I can look them up online.

Have there ever been any court cases against the government (local, state, or federal) for the use of taxes? In other words, has any one ever sued the government for the force of taxes?

or, are there any courts that have spoken out about the issue - ie. supreme court.

If so, can you please provide me with the case name(s) so I can look them up online.

Here are some cases you may wish to read about:

Vivian Kellems

Oklahoma Ratification Challenge

Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R.

I was just wandering if anyone knows how safe is this forum? In terms of posting information that might not be liked by the government…

(I guess you can never be too careful…)

I was just wandering if anyone knows how safe is this forum? In terms of posting information that might not be liked by the government…

Where’s Toronro?

Where’s Toronro?

Its proably a code name, lest the real location be revealed to the agents of ZOG :wink:

I must admit that I’m not too familiar with online chat rooms and forums; therefore, it might be that my question is out of place…

Yet I will appreciate a more serious answer.

Thanks!

Yet I will appreciate a more serious answer.

There is probably an agent of the government who, at some indirect level, processes some of what’s posted here with some data-mining program, sniffing for terrorists. If you plan on posting classified secrets, I would think twice about that. But if you want to make nasty comments about the government (yours or ours), it will have no consequences for you unless you plan on running for public office. Oh, wait, Canadian law is somewhat less tolerant of politically incorrect speech. Be cautious.

Firstly, the board is based in a country where the freedom of speech is deeply enshrined in the law. Every day, on almost every TV channel, people criticize the government and comedians poke fun of politicians. Across the country there are peaceful political meetings and political rallies, probably every week. Even as we speak, there is an “anti-war” group camping near the president’s house. In summary: the U.S. government does not persecute people for political protest.

Secondly, we are not anarchists here. If you search the forum, you will find some discussions on the “Rule of Law”. You will be hard-pressed to find a member advocating overthrow of the government outside the political process. Indeed, many members are so strongly supportive of a rule of law that they are willing to comply with laws that they themselves believe to be immoral, not just because they might get caught, but out of respect for the principle of having a rule of law. In summary: this is not an anarchist board.

If you want to discuss why some government action is right or wrong, or if you want to criticize some politician, then I do not see why you would worry. If you want to argue about the principle of why one should or should not comply with the law, then I do not see why you would worry. However, if you want to (say) plan a bank robbery or something like that, then you’d probably have more than a few members (myself included) criticizing you and – if practical – reporting it to the authorities.

I was just wandering if anyone knows how safe is this forum? In terms of posting information that might not be liked by the government…

(I guess you can never be too careful…)

Which government are you concerned about, in particular?

Yes, you are right to be careful, but I know of no reason for an objective person, applying Objectivism to all of his actions and following the Forum Rules for this forum, to worry about government retaliation.

As a general rule, however, I would suggest that any time anyone participates in an open discussion group like this one, the writer should assume that some government official somewhere is watching. The same caution goes for “private” crazies too.

Be careful? Yes. But I see no reason to not participate in Objectivism Online.

Thank you for the replays.

I can assure you that neither anarchism, nor bank robbery are of interest to me.

The reason I asked was because I have learned an issue on which, I hoped, I might find some more information…Yet; I believe that it is not to be discussed here.

Aside from that I will most definitely participate in the forum.

Thanks again!

The reason I asked was because I have learned an issue on which, I hoped, I might find some more information…Yet; I believe that it is not to be discussed here.

If you haven’t seen the guidelines, take a look here. So for example promoting religion or communism is contrary to the purpose of this board (and is proscribed behavior). This does not mean that if you are genuinely confused about why Objectivism is incompatible with Christianity that you cannot ask such questions (though reading Rand’s writings is the best way to learn the answer to that question, and I think most people would be rightly impatient with a person who cannot see the answer from some basic reading of Rand).

This part of the rules may be most useful (emphasis added): ‘participants must not use the website to spread ideas contrary to or unrelated to Objectivism. Examples include religion, communism, “moral tolerationism,” and libertarianism. Honest questions about such subjects are permitted. However, since the focus of this forum is the philosophy of Objectivism, such questions are not encouraged.’