The "How many past partners have you had?" question

I think it matters, at least if being more certain is important to you. I guess as a scientist it’s sort of ingrained in me not to jump to conclusions about the facts and apply that attitude to people too. For example, I frequently discard my first impression of someone and tend to rely far more on continued interaction with them. But I know that I am anomalous in this regard.

I guess i’m more inclined to trust my first impression of people. I agree of course that it’s important not to jump to conclusions and discard that first impression if it proves to be wrong. But I tend to be able to rather quickly form an accurate impression of people(I think it might be something i’ve learned from being more of a quiet and observing type).

I admit that I am not always good at picking up on someone’s intentions. Being deliberately deceived is one thing - that’s not hard to catch. It’s the people who don’t know what they want themselves and tell me one thing but then do another, not maliciously but more just out of a general personality-fail, that really dick me over. And I am also naturally mistrustful of people in general. These factors all probably contribute to me being a bit more cautious.

Hehe, i’m probably the exact opposite - trustful bordering to the naive. :smiley:

What you mention here sure is a common problem though. Kind of hard to know someone who doesn’t know himself.

Another problem can also be when the other person makes the wrong assumptions about you. I mean, it’s all well and good if i’m getting to know the other person, but it has to go both ways. Sometimes it can be hilariously fun though when it doesn’t.

I don’t agree that there’s less risk involved for a man, unless you don’t have access to birth control and/or abortion services. Maybe in some sense there is but I generally don’t see it that way. I mean, sex is a response to one’s highest values when it is done for the right reason. Wouldn’t you feel terribly cheated if you thought you were showing, honestly and openly, your affirmation of someone, your high regard for them, only to find that they never deserved it? I can’t imagine what it must feel like to wake up next to someone one morning and realize they’re nothing like what you thought they were, that they didn’t earn you. It’s something I hope to never find out about.

For women there’s also the risk of getting beaten and raped if they attract the wrong guy. Therefore I think it’s also wiser for women to require a higher degree of trust before sleeping with a man.

I can’t say for sure how I would feel about that situation as it has never happened, but I don’t think i’d have any problems with it. My actions would be in response to the values I see. But, I don’t act by giving anything away. I don’t regard it as a gift or anything like that, it’s more like obtaining a value. If it turns out she doesn’t actually live up to that, that would be disappointing but i’ll just make sure to find someone better next time. Whatever she got from it must be as gratifying as having sex with a person who’s thinking of someone else(besides, that someone else would eventually get what she couldn’t).

Of course, if this literally happens the very next morning then i’d take a serious look at what the hell I was thinking. Because I think that would indicate a very bad judgement.

Well, I don’t have a puritan view of sex. I think masturbation is fine and normal (depends on why you do it, of course), and I think two consenting people should do whatever they want during sex. But I do have my own preferences that I won’t go into because that’s too personal. I also don’t hate people who watch hard-core pornography, even though I personally never have and never will. I’ve always been that way.

It’s also not that I lack confidence with women. I’m quite confident, in fact. Not an a**hole, not cocky, but confident. If I’m attracted to someone, I don’t hesitate in showing that at all. I also know exactly what I want in a woman. I’ve formed a very detailed picture of that in my head over the years.

Finally, I’m not uncomfortable with sex. It’s a natural development of a relationship and it’s one of the greatest forms of pleasure on earth *if* treated right, but I just don’t think it should be taken so lightly. Maybe it’s just personal, but I attach more significance to sex. If I want to tell someone I’m attracted to them on the first few dates, I’ll kiss them, hold hands, something less rash than going straight for the bedroom. Sex is just such a huge commitment, something that I can’t commit to after a couple of dates.

I think that sounds very good. I just wan’t to clarify, in case you took my post the wrong way, that I just wanted to explain why I hold my approach to it. I wasn’t trying to make any assumptions about you(that would have been very rude). :smiley:

Frankly, I’m not sure I see the problem with casual, safe sex.

You don’t gain as much from it as you do when you are in a great relationship, but you don’t lose anything either (provided you are attracted to the other party, and you take a few precautions)

Even if you later think that it is a person that, on reflection, isn’t good enough to have slept with – the only real loss is the time you spent.

Of course it’s also important to approach the whole thing honestly: both honesty to yourself, and to the other party.

Frankly, I’m not sure I see the problem with casual, safe sex.

Why?

What is “casual sex”? Sex with someone whom you don’t expect to have a relationship with outside the bedroom. Sex just for the physical pleasure? If you’re just having sex for the physical pleasure, then why not masturbate? It’s the same thing and there’s no danger of hurt feelings, regret, abortions, or STDs. If the only thing you appreciate about your partner while having sex is his/her body, then it’s not true sex. I think Rand would agree…

Why?

What is “casual sex”? Sex with someone whom you don’t expect to have a relationship with outside the bedroom. Sex just for the physical pleasure? If you’re just having sex for the physical pleasure, then why not masturbate? It’s the same thing and there’s no danger of hurt feelings, regret, abortions, or STDs. If the only thing you appreciate about your partner while having sex is his/her body, then it’s not true sex. I think Rand would agree…

I don’t accept your definition of casual sex. Casual sex would be sex where you do not expect to have a romantic relationship. You may well be friends or have some other sort of relationship – or it could just be in the bedroom.

Physical pleasure is not the only thing one gains from sex, even outside of romance, just like exercise isn’t the only thing you gain from playing sport. You bring up four possible negative outcomes:

  • Hurt Feelings: Casual sex does not mean sex between idiots. Both parties should, of course, understand the nature of the situation. This is by no means a problem.
  • Regret: Sure, you can feel regret, maybe at a later date you no longer think they were worth it. Just like you can feel regret about a romantic relationship that doesn’t work out, or feel regret about a career move, or a friendship. Fear of regret is never a good argument to hold back from doing something. Good analysis minimises the chances of regret, but as fallible beings we cannot be sheltered from it. We can learn from it, and get over it.
  • Abortions: Thanks to modern technology, birth control is both cheap and effective.
  • STDs: See above

As for your comment on Rand, even if she were alive to give your theory her stamp of approval, her doing so would not change my mind one bit. Unless better arguments for your case can be presented : the imagined sanction of a dead genius does not constitute proof.

Frankly, I’m not sure I see the problem with casual, safe sex.

You don’t gain as much from it as you do when you are in a great relationship, but you don’t lose anything either (provided you are attracted to the other party, and you take a few precautions)

Even if you later think that it is a person that, on reflection, isn’t good enough to have slept with – the only real loss is the time you spent.

Of course it’s also important to approach the whole thing honestly: both honesty to yourself, and to the other party.

I think it depends on what you refer to as casual sex, and the context.

If it’s something based on real values and not just some form of hedonistic pleasure, then I don’t see a problem with it either. The context can also be such as your ideal romantic partner is not available, and you’re in a situation where you can’t do much about it. In that case I see nothing wrong with having sex with someone you value, regard highly, find attractive and respect - even if you don’t intend to start a serious romantic relationship. A more hedonistic approach would on the other hand be more like “it feels good, therefore it is”, with no regard to other values than gaining a moment of pleasure.

Even if this is done for the right resons there are potential problems though. Things can get complicated and you migh end up ruining something that could have been a good friendship. Also, contraceptives don’t always work, and some act irrationally when facing the choice of abortion. This does of course not make the whole concept bad, but they are good reasons for not treating the subject lightly.

I think it depends on what you refer to as casual sex, and the context.

If it’s something based on real values and not just some form of hedonistic pleasure, then I don’t see a problem with it either. The context can also be such as your ideal romantic partner is not available, and you’re in a situation where you can’t do much about it. In that case I see nothing wrong with having sex with someone you value, regard highly, find attractive and respect - even if you don’t intend to start a serious romantic relationship. A more hedonistic approach would on the other hand be more like “it feels good, therefore it is”, with no regard to other values than gaining a moment of pleasure.

Even if this is done for the right resons there are potential problems though. Things can get complicated and you migh end up ruining something that could have been a good friendship. Also, contraceptives don’t always work, and some act irrationally when facing the choice of abortion. This does of course not make the whole concept bad, but they are good reasons for not treating the subject lightly.

I agree with all of the above. Sex, just like the rest of life, shouldn’t be treated lightly.

It goes without saying that one should judge the costs, risks and values involved before making any choice.

Though I don’t think it needs to be confined to situations such as when your ideal partner is not available. Even if you were in a great committed relationship, I can’t see any reason why sexual exclusivity needs to be treated as a moral axiom: it is fine, given the appropriate context.

I guess i’m more inclined to trust my first impression of people. I agree of course that it’s important not to jump to conclusions and discard that first impression if it proves to be wrong. But I tend to be able to rather quickly form an accurate impression of people(I think it might be something i’ve learned from being more of a quiet and observing type).

That makes sense. I totally get that then. In contrast to you, I tend to be sort of an in-your-face type that attracts a lot of attention without even trying. I get a lot of, “Oh, of course I’ve heard of you.” LOL And random people tend to just come my way (not that this is a bad thing, I have my lovely mate and two fantastic friends because of this). For better or for worse, I have a weird brand of charisma, a sort of anti-popular notoriety.

For women there’s also the risk of getting beaten and raped if they attract the wrong guy. Therefore I think it’s also wiser for women to require a higher degree of trust before sleeping with a man.

I can’t say for sure how I would feel about that situation as it has never happened, but I don’t think i’d have any problems with it. My actions would be in response to the values I see. But, I don’t act by giving anything away. I don’t regard it as a gift or anything like that, it’s more like obtaining a value. If it turns out she doesn’t actually live up to that, that would be disappointing but i’ll just make sure to find someone better next time. Whatever she got from it must be as gratifying as having sex with a person who’s thinking of someone else(besides, that someone else would eventually get what she couldn’t).

I see what you’re saying now. I admit I wasn’t thinking about that, but I certainly do know enough women who’ve had that sort of thing happen, usually when alcohol is involved. It’s not as big of a concern for me because I rarely drink and almost never get drunk, and I’m sort of big and scary for a woman so most guys would know better than to pull that crap with me. :smiley: In contrast to you, I do feel like I give someone something when I sleep with him. It’s a concretization of a kind of ownership over me. And I take something for myself in return. I take ownership of him too, take everything I want from him and leave him in a heap. I guess that’s why it’s a bigger deal for me. I understand that not everyone feels that way and there’s nothing wrong with people who don’t.

I also operate from the somewhat unusual context of only having been with one person, but for years and years now. So that probably affects my perspective. Your take on things makes good sense from your POV.

All this ‘reasoning’ about casual sex, is starting to look a little thin. Look, if you a have an itch, and the opportunity to get it scratched, there isn’t necessarily any harm - in the short term.

However, unless you have armor-plated self- esteem, it can, and will, catch up with you in the long run. And nobody has.

We are all cocky enough at first to believe we can handle anything, but it’s only on looking back that we know we couldn’t.

All this ‘reasoning’ about casual sex, is starting to look a little thin. Look, if you a have an itch, and the opportunity to get it scratched, there isn’t necessarily any harm - in the short term.

However, unless you have armor-plated self- esteem, it can, and will, catch up with you in the long run. And nobody has.

We are all cocky enough at first to believe we can handle anything, but it’s only on looking back that we know we couldn’t.

Yes! Thank you for stating my point so eloquently.

Look, we’re not talking about casually eating too much over the holidays. Most people rationalize that and then they have to loose the weight. But that’s not as serious as sex. I’ve already mentioned the physical risks of casual sex. Protection is not 100% effective, and an abortion may be necessary. What if this woman doesn’t want to have an abortion? You’re suddenly up shit creek all because of something that was “casual.” But what about the psychological effects? It’s one thing to, say, regret becoming addicted to porn, but it’s a *completely* different matter to regret having sex with someone you knew for a couple of days, were only vaguely attracted to, and had sex with on a whim. WHY IS THAT A GOOD IDEA!!! All those idiotic teenagers who just couldn’t wait to have sex, porked some chick, got her pregnant, and now have a family at 16…oh yeah, I bet they LOVE the idea of casual sex now.

Have you heard of masturbation? Maybe you should try it to relieve some of those “urges” or “itches.”

Sex is supposed to express the awesome depth of feeling you have for someone else - how much you admire them for their virtues, how much you love every aspect of their being. Sex is supposed to be an expression of *LOVE*. Not an expression of, “Oh hey I saw you from across the room and I’ve talked with you for 5 minutes. I barely know anything about you except the few anecdotes you’ve told me. Let’s fuck.” You can’t fall in love with someone in one date or two. Love takes time and so therefore, so should sex.

Tito is not recommending that you sleep with random strangers or people you’ve known for only a few days. He is saying that there’s nothing wrong with having a sexual relationship with someone you, say, don’t intend to form a PERMANENT attachment to. These relationships can be very enjoyable and are an excellent option for, say, people who have not found anyone who really suits them completely. Masturbation is fun, but it doesn’t fulfill one’s desire for companionship or shared values.

The world can be a hard place and real companionship a rare thing. *Good* opportunities should be seized, not bypassed because they aren’t perfect. Selection is important, but it does not imply that one must therefore live the life of an ascetic.

God, has the whole world gone insane?

Saying that fulfilling, long-term relationships are rare is *not an argument*!! I’ve had two in my life, and I waited 4 years in between. I dated, of course, in an attempt to find my next long-term partner. But I didn’t stick around even if there was some compatibility.

Maybe it’s just personal preference, but I have to have long-term relationships. They’re too much fun to give them up for a bunch of short-term flings.

Maybe it’s just personal preference, but I have to have long-term relationships. They’re too much fun to give them up for a bunch of short-term flings.

Did anybody suggest that a long-term relationship should be given up for a short term relationship?

You’re taking my wording far too literally. I mean that I’m not willing to have any short term relationships because I much prefer long-term ones, even if that means waiting years and years without relationships beyond friendship, I’m fine with that. That’s what I’ve already done for the past 4 years anyway and I never felt this so-called urge or itch to have sex with someone. I obviously wanted companionship, but it’s just not enough companionship if it only lasts a few weeks or a month or two.

You’re taking my wording far too literally. I mean that I’m not willing to have *any* short term relationships because I much prefer long-term ones.

wonder if I’m really taking you too literally , because your clarification seems to posit the same choice (“short-term relationship” versus “long-term relationship”). Using your clarification, I’d change my question to: who said they preferred short-term relationships to long-term ones?

Are you saying that only when you are fairly sure that the relationship is going to be long-term, then and only then are you willing to make it sexual? If so, what do you mean by long-term? Are you speaking about a partner for life, or something less than that? If you really mean that the relationship must reach a certain depth, then is that any different in principle from what Tito is saying?

Yes, I am saying I’m only willing to make it sexual if I’m fairly sure it’s going to be long-term, and by long-term I mean years and yes, hopefully partner for life. That implies reaching a certain intimacy with the other person - an appreciation of their personality, their virtues, their interests, their goals, the way they work and think about life and bigger issues, and even a knowledge of some vices (if there are any). Most of all there *must* be mutual understanding of each others’ sexual preferences.

EDIT: For instance, what if you have sex with someone and you find out they’re into S&M? Would it have killed you to get an intimate knowledge of your partner’s views on sex before you went to the bedroom? Although I know some Objectivists think S&M is OK…whatever.

As Jen and SNerd pointed out, I’m not suggesting any sort of prioritisation of casual sex over long term relationships, neither am I suggesting sex with people you don’t know.

Sexually transmitted diseases, pregnancy, discovering your partner is a maniac, etc. are all risks associated with *all* sex. You may know somebody for 5 years, then have a casual relationship, yet I doubt you would object to a sexual relationship between a romantic couple who knew each other for just 1 year. The two aren’t even exclusive.

As Jen and SNerd pointed out, I’m not suggesting any sort of prioritisation of casual sex over long term relationships, neither am I suggesting sex with people you don’t know.

Sexually transmitted diseases, pregnancy, discovering your partner is a maniac, etc. are all risks associated with *all* sex. You may know somebody for 5 years, then have a casual relationship, yet I doubt you would object to a sexual relationship between a romantic couple who knew each other for just 1 year. The two aren’t even exclusive.

It sounds like the question is really coming down to whether it is OK to sleep with someone for whom you have a lot of affection but know you have no future with. Then it comes down to what you are comfortable with, I think. For example, take a college student. What if you love your boyfriend but are fairly sure that life circumstances are going to take you your separate ways at graduation? Should you then never have been with him? I think that’s a bit silly.

I do think it’s probably not so kosher to know beforehand that you’re not going to have much to do with someone after a week and then still sleep with them, but this is rarely knowledge that is certain unless you plan it out that way. On the other hand, it seems excessive to me to posit that someone has to be a life-partner candidate before you sleep with them. I think love or great affection and fondness is enough, even if it’s not forever.

This issue comes up over and over again on the boards because nitwits are constantly assuming that people who say they aren’t worried if a relationship isn’t forever are just jumping in and out of the sack with anyone who comes along. Krattle, I’m looking at YOU. This is a fundamentally immature view that wipes out the huge complexities that can attend romantic relationships and replaces them with a false either/or view that does not even come close to applying to everyone.

The thing that I find amusing is that I oftenest see this viewpoint from people who have very “standard” relationships . . . i.e. people who date. Me, I don’t date. Almost all of my friends live hundreds if not thousands of miles away and most of them I’ve never met in person. I have spectacularly eclectic interests and achieving a meeting of minds with someone just to establish a FRIENDSHIP is INCREDIBLY difficult and rare for me.

So, yes, if the opportunity to, say, attend OCON and hook up with a distant but dear friend who I’ll probably not get to see again for a lengthy period of time comes along, you can bet I’m going to carpe the hell out of that diem. :dough:

True, romantic relationships are very complex and varied, but there still have to be principles.

Anyway, I like how *you* make an assumption about *my* dating habits. Maybe if you did date, you’d find there are more people out there with similar mindsets than you’re willing to admit. Besides, the only way to find compatible people is to be out there, talking with people, dating. If you fail 20 times but succeed once, you still succeeded in the end.

I also do not “date” in that sense of just dating for the sake of dating. I date in the hopes of finding someone compatible. How the hell else am I going to do it? Just sit around and mope about how lonely I am. Of course not.