True, Original, Important

Ruveyn,

One element in Rand’s metaphysics that is along your lines of affirming a conformance to external reality and having been maintained by others before her would be: “A consciousness conscious of nothing but itself is a contradiction in terms: before it could identify itself as consciousness, it had to be conscious of something” (_AS _1015). That thought has some predecessors in Plato, Brentano, Husserl, and Sartre, as I recall.

In Theatetus Plato has Socrates say “I must necessarily become percipient of something when I become percipient; it is impossible to become percipient, yet percipient of nothing” (160b). Plato was there speaking only of the percipient in sensory perception. Rand’s proposition is a generalization of that view to all consciousness (further, AS 1047 and ITOE 30–31). (Rand’s proposition holds true it seems to me not only in our waking conceptual consciousness, but even the consciousness we have in dreams. Consciousness there is of something other than itself, I would say, because I have found Freud’s find of always a day residue in dreams to be correct.) I have some remarks on the similarity and difference between Rand and Sartre on this conception of consciousness here. I expect her difference with Brentano and Husserl is as considerable as her difference with Sartre concerning this character of consciousness. Perhaps only Rand stated this conception with the exact full meaning that was hers. I think the idea true and important, however original with her.

 

There is a conception of Rand’s concerning relation of world and mind, and the conformance of the latter to the former, that so far as I have been able to discover is unprecedented in the history of philosophy. That is her duo: “Existence is Identity, Consciousness is Identification” (AS 1016, also). Something like the first wing of that was realized by Avicenna, as recently noted.* With this insight, Avicenna and Rand (independently of him) were extending Aristotle, but it was a significant extension, and I think, a point true and important. Joined with the second wing, they seems to me a very important innovation in the history of philosophy, and a true one.

Stephen