Unions

Unions aren’t a bad deal. Unions using government as a club to clobber businessmen is a bad deal, but unions certainly have their place.

For example, in an ideal Capitalist society, remember, government regulatory bodies would not exist (see also: OSHA). Sure, it’s in the best interest of a businessman to keep his factory in safe working conditions. But having his men organized amongst themselves (and maybe with other men who do similar work in other factories) provides a means to understand safety issues and to bargain for the alleviation of some elements of danger. There are arguments to be made from efficiency as well…

Unionism falls apart when you take away the coercive element. Your example of understanding safety issues might have held true in the past, but information technology makes it simple to get the word out widely on safety risks involved with industries and particular workplaces. OSHA would be replaced by safejob.org, or some other organization providing this info for fee (I made that up, but it happens to be a site that does something similar today, though publicly funded). The bargaining to alleviate some elements of danger would take place at wage negotiations, where the individual would weigh the risk against the benefits and require higher pay for more dangerous jobs. The employer would weigh the higher cost of labor against the cost of eliminating dangers and choose accordingly. As long as the dangers are well understood and communicated, this is the most efficient way to make those decisions. If the employer hides risks from employees, then he is committing fraud. Once discovered, the legal system can extract compensation after the fact.

As SN points out, the only time that unions can have any effect, without coercion, is when the higher value workers are willing to sacrifice some of their benefit to lower value workers. The effect would be similar if those high-value workers simply gave some of their wages to low-value workers. The difference is that with unionism, high-value workers become average-value workers when their wages are limited to the average, and overall productivity, profitability, employment and wealth are all reduced for all levels of worker.

Unionism falls apart when you take away the coercive element. Your example of understanding safety issues might have held true in the past, but information technology makes it simple to get the word out widely on safety risks involved with industries and particular workplaces. OSHA would be replaced by safejob.org, or some other organization providing this info for fee (I made that up, but it happens to be a site that does something similar today, though publicly funded). The bargaining to alleviate some elements of danger would take place at wage negotiations, where the individual would weigh the risk against the benefits and require higher pay for more dangerous jobs. The employer would weigh the higher cost of labor against the cost of eliminating dangers and choose accordingly. As long as the dangers are well understood and communicated, this is the most efficient way to make those decisions. If the employer hides risks from employees, then he is committing fraud. Once discovered, the legal system can extract compensation after the fact.

As SN points out, the only time that unions can have any effect, without coercion, is when the higher value workers are willing to sacrifice some of their benefit to lower value workers. The effect would be similar if those high-value workers simply gave some of their wages to low-value workers. The difference is that with unionism, high-value workers become average-value workers when their wages are limited to the average, and overall productivity, profitability, employment and wealth are all reduced for all levels of worker.

Let’s assume for the moment that this were true. So what? Is it your contention that the right to assemble freely should be abridged?

Speaking to efficiency… what would safejob.org (or whatever) do that a union couldn’t?

Do you see no utility in having workers organized such that they have a means of settling problems amongst themselves?

What are your thoughts on the “white collar vs. blue collar” mentality that tends to arise in workers - irrational as it may be - when they perceive the businessman as a tyrant – and do you see the union as having no impact on that?

What are your thoughts on the “white collar vs. blue collar” mentality that tends to arise in workers - irrational as it may be - when they perceive the businessman as a tyrant – and do you see the union as having no impact on that?

If anything unions do their best to actually inculcate that mentality.

In a Capitalist society, those “better workers” would be free to pursue greatness down whatever avenue they find or make for themselves. No union as such could or would have the power to stop them. If a businessman decides that his factory will be all union, and that all men will work to a quota and not beyond, then it’s not the union itself that limits the innovator, but the businessman who adopts that policy.

Unions would definitely be legal. No argument there. You’re right that a businessman who allows a union in his firm would have himself to blame. It is hard to speculate as to how things would evolve. However, if we look at history, our best guess is that most businesses would refuse to negotiate with collectives, and that not enough workers would unite to ensure that the businessman was forced to deal with their collective. Unions came into being largely because they used coercion on their employers and on other employees (often legal coercion of law). one might still have unions, but I would speculate we’d have far less than what we have today. This is particularly so in light of what people have seen as to how unions turn out.

Do you see something inherently bad about members of a large group having a unified, represented voice, or a dedicated advocate?

It is false to think that the interest of a bad worker and a good worker are common, and that they are at variance with the interest of the employer. So, while I see nothing “inherently bad” in what you describe, the problem is that they unite workers, rather than unite people with a common interest. This is the essence of why they have turned out badly. in reality, the interests of good employers and good employees are aligned, and opposed to the typically-articulated interests of bad employees.

The same with the AMA. The interests of good doctors and bad doctors are not aligned.

Now, if we were not talking about a union (which generally tries to work to some average common good of the majority of its voters) and were talking about an association around some clearly articulated and objective goal, which is actually in the interest of all its members, then forming a group like that would make sense. Even here, in a modern economy, specialized businesses often arise to meet some valid narrow purposes that were once fulfilled by unions. So, for instance, one does not need a union of people to pool resources to cover life-insurance, one can have a specialized life-insurance company.

Here are two recent union-related news articles.

Let’s assume for the moment that this were true. So what? Is it your contention that the right to assemble freely should be abridged?

Speaking to efficiency… what would safejob.org (or whatever) do that a union couldn’t?

Do you see no utility in having workers organized such that they have a means of settling problems amongst themselves?

What are your thoughts on the “white collar vs. blue collar” mentality that tends to arise in workers - irrational as it may be - when they perceive the businessman as a tyrant – and do you see the union as having no impact on that?

The premise of abridging the right to freely assemble is faulty from the beginning, Jas0n.

First of all, unions restrict freedom, they don’t give it.

My wife is in a union, by their force. She is not allowed to do the work she does without joining the union. Either join or switch careers. 5% of her wages are taken from her by the union and used basically to support political candidates she does not agree with and pay for benefits for people less skilled than her.

Secondly, lets say an employer fires anyone who wants to form a union.

This is still not abridging the right to assemble. A business is private property. The business owner gets to decide who gets to be present. The workers are free to do whatever they want outside of work.

Why on earth would a business person allow such a destructive force into their situation?

It was already mentioned that unions can only operate by force- this is why places with a choice to join the union or not no longer really exist. Once the union gets in it’s join or be fired. The exception tends to be (another job my wife held) was you could choose not to join the union but you still had to pay the union dues, you just didn’t get to vote.

I don’t know what “exploit” means. Seriously. What is to keep workers from exploiting employers, demanding exorbitant wages and benefits?

Well, there are only two ways a worker can really do that. Use threats of physical violence, or gather all of his co-workers to demand better wages. That is a union.

What power does a single employee have over an employer?

Each side gets to “exploit” to other, that is, get the best deal they possibly can, by peaceful means.

And I see no reason why, in a free economy, people can’t be free to form unions against their workers. I do not agree with compulsory unions at all.

What people generally mean when they say “exploit” is “make a profit based on the labor of others”. Well, with unions, they have not managed to completely eliminate exploitation i.e. profitability, but they have certainly reduced profitability some.

Not to sound disrespectful, but any example of such phenomenon? The most I’ve seen unions do is take $7 out of your paycheck.

What power does a single employee have over an employer?

What power does a single employer have over an employee in a free market?

And I see no reason why, in a free economy, people can’t be free to form unions against their workers. I do not agree with compulsory unions at all.

Men should be free to form unions. I don’t think anyone here would disagree.

Not to sound disrespectful, but any example of such phenomenon? The most I’ve seen unions do is take $7 out of your paycheck.

Are you asking for examples of unions destroying profit?

The auto industry is a good one. As is the railroad industry (things like forcing rail operators to have a manned caboose on every train, even though newer trains didn’t need it at all, rather than making the mechanics redundant)

Are you asking for examples of unions destroying profit?

The auto industry is a good one. As is the railroad industry (things like forcing rail operators to have a manned caboose on every train, even though newer trains didn’t need it at all, rather than making the mechanics redundant)

…and more… because of the NEA (teacher’s union) it is much harder to bring political change to our school systems; the AMA (doctor’s union) has long lobbied (successfully) to keep down the number of doctors entering the U.S. Then, there are retail unions that have seen some retailers shut down, unable to compete with Walmart. Before auto, the steel-workers union helped bring down the large steel-makers.

While unions ought to be legal, there is an overwhelming amount of historical evidence – across decades, and many countries – to indicate that unions are a bad idea.

Well, it’s unions *with the power of present-day labor law* behind them that did these things.

Without those laws, they’d be incapable of causing this much damage.

(Also: there’d be less motivation to join them because they’d be less effective at obtaining higher wages, etc., for their members. About the most they’d be able to do is forward worker complaints and suggest how to improve things to management.)

(Also: there’d be less motivation to join them because they’d be less effective at obtaining higher wages, etc., for their members. About the most they’d be able to do is forward worker complaints and suggest how to improve things to management.)

It is even worse than that. For instance, if I picture programmers in my company forming a union, I can foresee it would lead to a worse situation for me personally, in the long run. Groups like that will always cater to a pretty low-average common denominator.

While unions ought to be legal, there is an overwhelming amount of historical evidence – across decades, and many countries – to indicate that unions are a bad idea.

Its one of those eternal paradox type things :stuck_out_tongue:

Unions should be legal, but employers should also be allowed to fire whomever they please.

Since no employer in their right mind wants unions mucking up their business there would be unions of nothing but unemployed in a just world :lol:

What power does a single employer have over an employee in a free market?

The loss of a job. Whereas an employer may have several employees still working for them if one quits, an employee does not have another employer to fall back on.

The loss in the latter case, regardless of whether or not you think it is significantly greater, is greater nonetheless.

It’s also harder to tell another employer that you got fired for being too demanding. Hell, it’s difficult to tell an interviewer that you got fired period

The loss of a job. Whereas an employer may have several employees still working for them if one quits, an employee does not have another employer to fall back on.

The loss in the latter case, regardless of whether or not you think it is significantly greater, is greater nonetheless.

Many employers will tell you how difficult it is to find good employees. In the company i work for, if any of the best 25% left, they would get a job easily during any normal economic times. Depending on the job, the employer would miss them a lot or a helluva lot.

Many employers will tell you how difficult it is to find good employees. In the company i work for, if any of the best 25% left, they would get a job easily during any normal economic times. Depending on the job, the employer would miss them a lot or a helluva lot.

As someone who plans to be an entrepenuer himself, I mean not to diminish the loss of an employee, especially if we are referring to mom and pop businesses. But an employer missing one out of X amount of employees, still has employees, understaffed as they may be.

An employee has nothing once he’s fired.

An employee has nothing once he’s fired.

He still has his skills, which he can take elsewhere. An employer gains a reputation just like an employee, so if improper firings take place, justice will take care of it by means of a reputation.

I have been fired, and I have said so in interviews. I have also been hired into a good company despite being fired from a bad one. That’s what an interview is for, to let you explain scenarios like that.

EDIT: If by “nothing” you also mean no money to fall back on, that’s what a savings is for.

I could imagine Unions morphing into something like a employment agency +plus for a particular skill set. The prospective employee in exchange for a membership dues would gain training, marketing, legal help, and a heads up on perspective employers. The employers would gain from the ability could choose from various trade unions that provided the best trained labor for the price he chooses to pay. No coercion needed.

The idea that unions would have no value in a purely capitalistic society presupposes that all employers would act rationally in a purely capitalistic society.

In a totally free market, unions may very well have value as a collective negotiation tool for employees. Even Rand herself acknowledged that Unions arose for a legitimate purpose, after all:

http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/unions.html

It was business, not labor, that initiated the policy of government intervention in the economy (as long ago as the nineteenth century)—and business was the first victim. Labor adopted the same policy and will meet the same fate. He who lives by a legalized sword, will perish by a legalized sword.

The idea that unions would have no value in a purely capitalistic society presupposes that all employers would act rationally in a purely capitalistic society.

I don’t think this is presumed.

In a totally free market, unions may very well have value as a collective negotiation tool for employees.

I doubt it; but, projections like this are just guesses.

Even Rand herself acknowledged that Unions arose for a legitimate purpose, after all:

http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/unions.html

The context she’s describing is different. When pressure-group warfare is the name of the political game, it “makes sense” to form pressure groups.

He still has his skills, which he can take elsewhere. An employer gains a reputation just like an employee, so if improper firings take place, justice will take care of it by means of a reputation.

Amen. Employees are not dependent on one employer - they always have alternatives. Often the best alternative is in the same field, sometimes it’s not. But in no case is production wholly dependent on a relationship between two particular people.

Also, people have been mentioning “power” in the context of a capitalist society, which I consider a contradiction. Power implies the ability to force someone to do something, and refusing to buy someone’s product or labor has nothing to do with force.