USA v. Donald J. Trump – Indictment 8/1/23

27 minutes ago, Doug Morris said:

The article on “banana republic” is about corruption of the political and economic system of a country into a device for extracting wealth from the general population.  Where does it mention anything relevant to the Trump case?

  

It has a different generally held connotation in ‘modern’ political rhetoric as a term to describe a corrupt government that is just a figurehead for some oligarchic regime.

The relevance is to the character of the actions of the DoJ, and it was interesting to note the O Henry connection.

So “the indictment is based on denying free speech” will be central strawman canard. The charge is not that Trump lied, but rather that he lied as part of a conspiracy to defraud, to obstruct and to deny rights. Anyone has the freedom to lie, “This watch is made of gold” as no one is thereby defrauded, but not when selling the watch as the buyer is then defrauded. Anyone is free to say many of the claims about the election mentioned in the indictment, but the indictment is not just about making those claims but the role of those claims in a conspiracy to defraud, obstruct and deny rights. One may disagree that the indictment is sufficient evidence, but it’s a sophomoric, specious strawman to characterize the indictment as tantamount to prosecution for exercise of free speech. 

On 8/2/2023 at 1:35 PM, tadmjones said:

Shouldn’t the 147 members of congress that stated, publicly, they would follow established procedures attendant to challenging slates of electors be listed as co-conspirators in advancing ‘false’ claims ?  

Why would one ask such a pointless question? They wouldn’t be indicted as co-conspirators merely for making certain statements while not being part of a conspiracy to defraud, obstruct or deny rights. 

On 8/2/2023 at 12:09 PM, tadmjones said:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic

A link to a page in which ‘banana republic’ is defined so that we see that the United States has not been and is not now a banana republic.

On 8/2/2023 at 4:32 PM, DavidOdden said:

acts against the federal government

The presidential election is a federal election. 

On 8/2/2023 at 4:32 PM, DavidOdden said:

18 USC 1001

That’s not a code being charged. 

On 8/2/2023 at 4:32 PM, DavidOdden said:

The defense will of course attack everything

I’d be curious to see whether the defense would argue that the United States does not have a basis to charge a defendant for conspiracy to defraud, obstruct and deny rights regarding the election of the president as constitutionally through a federal election is subject to federal laws and rules, meeting of the Electoral College (which is not an entity of just an individual state) and a meeting of Congress. Moreover, I don’t see that one cannot attempt to defraud the United States through fraud carried out against individual states. If someone attempts to defraud a state in such a way to make the state fraudulent in reporting election results and to send false electors, then it seems hard to argue that that is not thereby an attempt to defraud the United States.  

1 hour ago, tadmjones said:

It has a different generally held connotation in ‘modern’ political rhetoric as a term to describe a corrupt government that is just a figurehead for some oligarchic regime.

So you linked to an article that doesn’t reduce the term that way. There’s no point made in getting people to click to and read an article that doesn’t even support you, other than as a gratuitous flourish.

The reason the US is resembling a “banana republic” is that this is the first time in US history (but common in the history of banana republics) that the party of an incumbent President has resorted to criminal prosecution to block a challenger in the next election.

I also found this article, which is enlightening: https://www.zerohedge.com/political/free-speech-killing-indictment-dems-move-criminalize-political-dissent

35 minutes ago, necrovore said:

criminal prosecution to block a challenger in the next election.

That is not the reason for the prosecutions.

 

38 minutes ago, Doug Morris said:

That is not the reason for the prosecutions.

The banana republics say that, too.

2 hours ago, InfraBeat said:

So you linked to an article that doesn’t reduce the term that way. There’s no point made in getting people to click to and read an article that doesn’t even support you, other than as a gratuitous flourish.

Did you know the O Henry thing ? I think I remember Rand spoke favorably about his Gift of the Magi , do you like O Henry?

4 hours ago, necrovore said:

The reason the US is resembling a “banana republic” is that this is the first time in US history (but common in the history of banana republics) that the party of an incumbent President has resorted to criminal prosecution to block a challenger in the next election.

I enjoyed the irony that the poster linked to an article that defines ‘banana republic’ contrary to the poster’s insinuation, by linking to the article, that the United States is a banana republic. Yes, we know the connotations of the term, but it’s not supported even in a broad connotative sense that the United States is acting like a banana republic.

This is the first time such an event has happened because it’s the first time in history that any American president has done* the kind of things charged in the indictment.  

* Though, of course, Trump is presumed innocent until proven guilty. But do you claim there are any statements of facts that are not correct in the indictment?

It is a “between a rock and a hard place” situation. A democracy doesn’t want to be criminally prosecuting political candidates, but a democracy also doesn’t want to allow officials and candidates to criminally conspire to overturn an election.

As to the fact that there is a lack of bipartisanship, one could as easily fault the member of the party out of office for their lack of integrity and principle in their outlandish excuses, obfuscations and dishonest arguments made to save their hero. McCarthy even made the argument that Democrats who disputed the 2000 election and the 2016 election were not indicted. Of course they weren’t, because they didn’t conspire to defraud, obstruct and deny rights. Arguments like McCarthy’s are so transparently dishonest, illustrating that the fact that it predominately Democrats that want to pursue the case is a function indeed of Republican lack of integrity and principle.

This question doesn’t bear upon Trump’s guilt or innocence, but I am interested: Read the indictment. But switch the parties and the candidates so that the defendant is Hilary Clinton or Barack Obama or Joe Biden. Could you really, with a straight face, report here that the indictment is without merit? Really?

2 hours ago, necrovore said:

3 hours ago, Doug Morris said:

That is not the reason for the prosecutions.

The banana republics say that, too.

That’s a lousy argument. You could use that reply to anyone to assert their fault. If you said, “Jack lied to the company that  Sally is embezzling just so he could get her job”. Then someone says, “No, he honestly reported her embezzling because it’s wrong and he took it as his duty to report it”. Then you say, “That’s what job grabbers all say”. 

2 hours ago, tadmjones said:

Did you know the O Henry thing ? I think I remember Rand spoke favorably about his Gift of the Magi , do you like O Henry?

What’s your point?

7 hours ago, InfraBeat said:

That’s a lousy argument.

Isn’t it funny how that works? The indictment itself is a lousy argument, but of course it’s above challenge, and requires no proof, and anybody who dares to dispute it has to provide arguments and proofs forever which will never be enough.

It’s just like all those old arguments for Christianity. They simply assert the divinity of Christ, you can’t deny it without being required to produce piles of evidence (but of course they never have to produce any themselves at all), and they can punish you for persisting, and burn you at the stake, and you’re going to hell.

4 hours ago, necrovore said:

Isn’t it funny how that works?

Your argument is mildly humorous.

4 hours ago, necrovore said:

[the indictment] is above challenge, and requires no proof, and anybody who dares to dispute it has to provide arguments and proofs forever which will never be enough.

Of course that’s false. On the other hand, there are many people who claim, without proof, that the election was stolen; and we find that, for them, the final court rulings and refutations will never be enough. Contrast that with Gore accepting the final court ruling, and not conspiring to send false electors, even though Democrats took the majority opinion to be grievously argued.

I’m still interested: Read the indictment. But switch the parties and the candidates so that the defendant is Hilary Clinton or Barack Obama or Joe Biden. Could you really, with a straight face, report here that the indictment is without merit? Really?

5 hours ago, necrovore said:

. . . The indictment itself is a lousy argument, but of course it’s above challenge, and requires no proof, and anybody who dares to dispute it has to provide arguments and proofs forever which will never be enough.

. . .

If the facts as stated in the indictment are true, then it was Pres. Trump who was making our country into a banana republic. He failed, and he was no longer the chief executive, as was the result of the election, lawfully executed. The idea that these charges, these representations of facts in the indictment require no proof, independent proof, is bigly false. So is the idea that some sort of proof that they are false is required at all for acquittal. The burden of proof of their truth is entirely on the prosecution. And it is in an adversarial trial by jury that independent proof must be obtained; that is what it means when the jury gives a guilty verdict. To give a not-guilty verdict means the prosecution did not prove the alleged facts of the indictment, and a not-guilty verdict in our system does not require that the defense prove anything at all. It only requires the defense to have cast a reasonable doubt, in the mind of one or more jurors, of the prosecution’s representation of fact in support of each charge in the indictment.

I did not follow the O.J. Simpson trial, but I’ve gathered that most of the public thought he was guilty, even though the jury decided he was not proven guilty. The jury didn’t find that he was innocent. It’s not a responsibility they have to determine that.

If Mr. Trump is found not guilty in the federal cases or the coming Georgia case, tens of millions of Americans are going to be furious because of what they have themselves witnessed in his behavior. It’s not that they know he committed these particular criminal acts, but they’ll be sure he did all the same, just like OJ for people who watched the trial on TV. But that is not relevant to the process of law in America. We have burden of proof on the government prosecution, rights of the defendant to counsel, rights of appeal, and the adversarial setup at trial as quality-control structure for not convicting an innocent man, even if that lets a lot of guilty men remain at liberty. (It is my understanding that in recent US history prosecutors, knowing all the preceding of course, bring criminal charges only where they are very, very sure they can prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. Very few of those come to trial, because the defendant pleads guilty, and the few who come to trial end mainly in conviction.)

If Trump hadn’t announced he was seeking another term this indictment would most likely not have been brought , proof of which is the fact that all the allegations concerns conduct that occurred prior to Jan 21 2020 . The “crimes” were committed and all the evidence existed for years and immediately after the election, other than disqualifying him from office can be offered for the reason to pursue this indictment now? It is a political prosecution as are the various other indictments handed down or pending. It is laughable to defend these actions as a principled effort by the DOJ to protection the sanctity of the Republic.

They have already perpetrated three frauds (the Russian collusion hoax and subsequent special investigations) and possibly if not probably covered up enough election “irregularities” to constitute rigging/stealing the election post hoc.

Not to mention not taking any action other than covering up for a provably corrupt Biden. 

The ‘world’ was shut down for years to remove their populist demagogue thorn from their side. 
 

It’s Chiquita s all the way down.

Tad,

Conjecture, even hypothesis consistent with some facts, is not “proof”. There is no proof that the US government staged the attack on 9/11. There is no proof that Sen. Cruz’s father assisted in the assassination of JFK. There is no proof that Hitler lived out a full life in South America. There is no proof that Cary Grant was a homosexual. There is no proof that AIDS was caused by bad nutrition. There is no proof that Jesus rose from the dead, notwithstanding millions who believe he did.

If you have evidence that Pres. Biden is corrupt, specify it and send it to the FBI or perhaps your Congressperson. Proof will be responsibility of the prosecution. Since the Pres. is a public figure, you can specify the particulars in public print also, immune from liability, even if you state falsehoods, even ones that are lies. Thanks to the Court that gave us finally, literally freedom of the press (1960).

It was foreseeable that bringing indictments against Mr. Trump in this interval would help him secure the Republican nomination, which is required to give him a chance to win reelection. Foreseeable, given his manifest numerous Believing followers. Too bad for his opponents that the cases gelled now. 

Some of the crimes Bernie Madoff was indicted for were committed 17 years earlier. It can take quite a while sometimes to build a good case for successful prosecution. The law has to patiently press forward and not charge prematurely.

1 hour ago, tadmjones said:

If Trump hadn’t announced he was seeking another term this indictment would most likely not have been brought , proof of which is the fact that all the allegations concerns conduct that occurred prior to Jan 21 2020 . The “crimes” were committed and all the evidence existed for years and immediately after the election, other than disqualifying him from office can be offered for the reason to pursue this indictment now?

It is case of great magnitude. It is not a given that it would not take a long time to arrive at an indictment. Your supposition is not supported. And even if the motivation were merely political, that would not make the evidence not exist.

/

The Mueller report was not fraud.

You assert an election “coverup”. Your basis is discredited crackpot websites.

/

1 hour ago, tadmjones said:

The ‘world’ was shut down for years to remove their populist demagogue thorn from their side. 

A ludicrous claim you cannot support. 

1 hour ago, tadmjones said:

It’s Chiquita s all the way down.

Is that recognition of U.S. military/corporate imperialism in Central America?

Whitewater was over four years from start of the investigation until the release of the report.

The Blagojevich investigation took fours before his arrest.

The John Edwards investigation took more than two years before his indictment. 

Should we look up other cases of magnitude to see how long they took? Or should we just take tadmjones at his word that the timing can only be accounted for by political motivations? This would be to take the word of someone who claims, without a mote of evidence that U.S. news companies colluded with the Biden campaign to make Covid seem worse than it is, for the purpose of changing election laws; moreover, tadmjones most recent claim that the Covid shutdowns WORLDWIDE were for the purpose of getting Trump out of office. 

I have this question for tadmjones also: Read the indictment. But switch the parties and the candidates so that the defendant is Hilary Clinton or Barack Obama or Joe Biden. Could you really, with a straight face, report here that the indictment is without merit? Really?