Welcome To Reality - new show on YouTube

This time we look at some top sci-fi movies from the last couple decades and explore their themes and important contributions to the genre. Movies discussed: The Matrix, Ex Machina, Arrival, Looper and Inception.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yS\_uwOk2ydQ

 

This time we weigh in with regard to the Snowden question. Should he be pardoned? We think so. His crime was a benefit to Americans rather than a detriment, and the traditional whistleblower route was not a viable option.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=leSPhmY0gFE

 

1 Like

19 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

This time we weigh in with regard to the Snowden question. Should he be pardoned? We think so. His crime was a benefit to Americans rather than a detriment, and the traditional whistleblower route was not a viable option.

How timely. I just watched watch Snowden again last week.

Extemporaneously, law (I got the impression as a general reference) was critiqued as being “not perfect”. In this arena, laws should be good laws, or they are not good and should be amended or repealed.

Even in the sciences, as an example read in another thread, water boils at 212°F, except when it doesn’t. It’s not a bad law. The law just needed to be amended to include the consideration of atmospheric pressure.

As to a pardon, I think it would 9help circumvent bad law(s), indeed.

On 12/14/2020 at 5:49 PM, MisterSwig said:

Arrival

Took the opportunity to review both the commentary and the movie this evening. 

Both of you expressed the aspect of determinism. The movie is portrayed as a somewhat past tense narrative. Yet, it was the recollection of a future event that provided the general’s private phone number and words that would change his mind. 

She chose to make the call to avert the events unfolding before her. The phone number and the words to say were provided ‘before their occurrence’.

Determinism implies it could not have happened otherwise.

Unlike a dice roll in a Jumanji movie where the player couldn’t opt-out of the consequence, the phone call did not come across as if Louise’s person had became possessed and the actions performed by some destiny that had to unfold.

Thanks for the thoughts on the films. For this one, it made for re-examining it from a perspective I hadn’t acquired or considered from previous viewings.

 

1 Like

11 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

She chose to make the call to avert the events unfolding before her. The phone number and the words to say were provided ‘before their occurrence’.

Yes, it’s kind of a unique way to present events throughout time, as if she has access to knowledge of her entire lifespan. Tenet does something even stranger with time, where different temporal periods overlap in reality.

11 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

Unlike a dice roll in a Jumanji movie where the player couldn’t opt-out of the consequence, the phone call did not come across as if Louise’s person had became possessed and the actions performed by some destiny that had to unfold.

Right. Jumanji is like a Matrix world, where certain events are controlled by the coding. Arrival is supposed to be the real world, so Louise appears to have normal volition, yet her future is already real, which implies that her present “choices” are determined.

In Back To The Future, the writers concretize an undetermined future by showing Marty struggle to fix his interference with past events like his parents getting together. Also Marty has that family photo which tells him the future. It serves the same function as Louise’s knowledge of the future. The difference, however, is that Marty’s photo is not him, so we accept it as some kind of crystal ball-like, magical device to move the plot along. Louise’s knowledge comes from her own brain. That’s harder to accept as some magical device. It thematical suggests that she’s already experienced the future of her present world, whereas Marty hasn’t. He doesn’t know what he’s changed until he gets “back to the future.”

In this new episode we explore the nature of consciousness and the will. We attempt to define and describe them in relation to the ideas of Rand, Nietzsche and Schopenhauer. Take a break from politics and come introspect with us!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukigOFOu0Hk

 

In this episode we ask whether transwomen should be allowed to compete in women’s sports. Why have women’s sports in the first place? And do transwomen have an unfair advantage over women? Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWQsz4R\_rSU

 

We discuss the concept of “virtue signaling” in this new episode.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L8YRZypyP6o

 

Our new episode is about UFOs. We talk about the videos from the Pentagon and try to understand what can be gleaned from this evidence. We also do a bit of speculating on whether these could be natural phenomenon, or if from aliens, are they AI machines that try to avoid us for some reason?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnFCqKTpx4c

 

The typical question is as Swig put it: Are they real?
And Lev started out with not knowing what the question meant. 
Typical with most incidents.
Which has been at the core of the issue.

Some thinking they are real and some thinking they are not.
Real does not mean are they biological robots.
“Real or not” means, are they optical illusions or not.
Up until now the story has been that they are like optical illusions.

Why has the government consistently tried to keep it quiet for at least 80 years?
One of the concerning questions is: who is trying to keep it “undiscussed”.
Let us say they are pieces of dark matter that move in a certain way.
Or they are experiments done by our own government?
Has the resistance only been “cultural”, as in MOST people think these are shadows of something?
Or has there been organize governmental forces to keep it secret.

The question about volition seemed to be explained away as “it can behave as if it is sentient”.
Which is valid unless we have the tell tale of what volition would look like from the outside.

“Something could be built naturally”.
And ? … Kind of like our own volition?

The rest of the guesses became maybe maybe maybe etc.
And Swig was correct in pushing away fantasy.
That’s where people who don’t take it seriously don’t want to discuss it.
 
Ultimately, the question of “where” they originate is the the most important, but rather the question to get out of the way is: Is it a volitional phenomenon or not because if it is, we are not the animal on top of the food chain.
 

1 hour ago, Easy Truth said:

Why has the government consistently tried to keep it quiet for at least 80 years?

A great deal was during the Cold War, where virtually anything was classified if it was strange or unknown.

In the past 25 years, it’s hard to say, but again, the US government likes to classify things just for the sake of controlling information. I don’t think it’s some extra fancy justification or hidden motivation. That’s especially consistent with the US government since the establishment of the patriot act. 

1 hour ago, Easy Truth said:

Ultimately, the question of “where” they originate is the the most important, but rather the question to get out of the way is: Is it a volitional phenomenon or not because if it is, we are not the animal on top of the food chain.

That question isn’t important, because you would need to establish anyway if it’s a natural object in the way that asteroids are natural. Or something that isn’t even what we think of as animate or inanimate, in the way viruses aren’t really either. I’m saying that the only way to get at a rational answer is first get a basic idea of how to categorize whatever the object is. That’s how any inquiry should begin. 

2 hours ago, Eiuol said:

That question isn’t important, because you would need to establish anyway if it’s a natural object in the way that asteroids are natural. Or something that isn’t even what we think of as animate or inanimate, in the way viruses aren’t really either. I’m saying that the only way to get at a rational answer is first get a basic idea of how to categorize whatever the object is. That’s how any inquiry should begin. 

Then let’s start with the first question (a repetition in some ways):

Are these objects an illusion? (starting with a yes or a no will be helpful)

2 hours ago, Eiuol said:

In the past 25 years, it’s hard to say, but again, the US government likes to classify things just for the sake of controlling information. I don’t think it’s some extra fancy justification or hidden motivation. That’s especially consistent with the US government since the establishment of the patriot act. 

Are you saying that classifying things as secret has no purpose, it’s just a knee jerk reaction?

Everything that is weird is classified? So ladies and gentlemen, go back to what you were doing, there is nothing to worry about.

What is the purpose of the classification? Is it “don’t ask, it’s for your own good”?

If you want to say “there is no purpose, they just do it”, it would be an authoritarian government’s typical excuse, just another “public good” justification.

A more plausible perspective is that classification would have a purpose.
It may have been to prevent Russians or the Chinese to know that we saw these things, but the secret is already out.

Ultimately what you are saying is “let’s not ask why they classified it, they just do these things”. Is that the basic idea?
 

8 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

Are you saying that classifying things as secret has no purpose, it’s just a knee jerk reaction?

But I said controlling information. There are a huge variety of purposes for doing that as you pointed out.

8 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

Ultimately what you are saying is “let’s not ask why they classified it, they just do these things”. Is that the basic idea?

I mean to say that although it is good to know why these things are classified, for better or worse, this is pretty standard operating procedure for US military organizations. It’s so standard that they don’t even need to have special reasons. Just another day at the office.

We uploaded UFOs part 2. This time we focus on the Navy pilots from the 2004 USS Nimitz incident and various issues with eyewitness testimony in general.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NF\_PjmSueg8

 

Our latest episode is on Woke Culture. We discuss the origins, ideas and applications of wokeness or wokeism. Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqPotXW1tws

 

Our new episode is about autism. We explore various aspects of this developmental disorder, including its history, causes, and real life examples and fictional depictions in movies and TV. Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfAoeI6a1w8

 

Lev and I conclude our series on UFOs by discussing the Pentagon report and Mick West’s debunking videos. Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLBorp5L7Oo

 

In this new episode we look at urban farming. Kimbal Musk has a company called Square Roots which uses converted shipping containers to grow crops year-round in Brooklyn and Grand Rapids. How important is this industry and what sort of impact might it have on our lives? Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjTN6VbhQmw

 

We discuss rhetoric and persuasion in this latest episode of our podcast. What exactly is rhetoric and what are some important principles of persuasion? We answer these and other related questions. Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=boZ3SX4oOjs

 

Our new episode is about space tourism, and the three companies that have sent private citizens into space, SpaceX, Blue Origin and Virgin Galactic. We discuss what they’re doing now and planning for the future. Check it out!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTRktBmWshU