2 hours ago, Eiuol said:
That question isn’t important, because you would need to establish anyway if it’s a natural object in the way that asteroids are natural. Or something that isn’t even what we think of as animate or inanimate, in the way viruses aren’t really either. I’m saying that the only way to get at a rational answer is first get a basic idea of how to categorize whatever the object is. That’s how any inquiry should begin.
Then let’s start with the first question (a repetition in some ways):
Are these objects an illusion? (starting with a yes or a no will be helpful)
2 hours ago, Eiuol said:
In the past 25 years, it’s hard to say, but again, the US government likes to classify things just for the sake of controlling information. I don’t think it’s some extra fancy justification or hidden motivation. That’s especially consistent with the US government since the establishment of the patriot act.
Are you saying that classifying things as secret has no purpose, it’s just a knee jerk reaction?
Everything that is weird is classified? So ladies and gentlemen, go back to what you were doing, there is nothing to worry about.
What is the purpose of the classification? Is it “don’t ask, it’s for your own good”?
If you want to say “there is no purpose, they just do it”, it would be an authoritarian government’s typical excuse, just another “public good” justification.
A more plausible perspective is that classification would have a purpose.
It may have been to prevent Russians or the Chinese to know that we saw these things, but the secret is already out.
Ultimately what you are saying is “let’s not ask why they classified it, they just do these things”. Is that the basic idea?