Concluding this thread: characteristic is the most fundamental term for naming anything about an entity. On par in terms of being fundamental must be the term “aspect”, since that means essentially “A way in which something can be viewed by the mind”.
I take characteristic to mean any aspect, or any unit, of an identity.
And attribute, in contrast, must simply mean “distinguishing characteristic”, a characteristic that makes the thing stand out. I get that from this ITOE quote:
There.
Attribute,characteristic and aspect are all synonyms. You could substitute one in all the quotes you posted for the other and say the same exact thing.