The blog author has agreed to pay me the $100 finders fee. I sent him a private e-mail with the information he requested.
Did he say if it was because he thought your suggestion was on he could use, or because he thought it met his criteria but he would not use it because he realizes he should have specified other criteria?
Having met Burgess briefly and having interacted with him online, I’d say honesty is his strong suit.
He said it was because the suggestion was helpful, although he isn’t yet sure Randi is the specific example he is looking for.
I retract my earlier assumption that he was trying to renege. It seemed that way based on his initial comment, but I now understand he was only trying to get more information to save time, which I sent him by email just now. I hope it is helpful to him.
“Randi explains and supports science, but he is not a full-time, specialized promoter of reason. Science is not reason. Science uses reason in particular ways, but is not the same thing as reason.* Nor does Randi, as far as I can tell from the titles in his list of publications, contrast reason with mysticism, thereby explaining both reason and mysticism.”
“Randi explains and supports science, but he is not a full-time, specialized promoter of reason. Science is not reason. Science uses reason in particular ways, but is not the same thing as reason.* Nor does Randi, as far as I can tell from the titles in his list of publications, contrast reason with mysticism, thereby explaining both reason and mysticism.”
Funny thing: Randi’s book Flim-Flam used to be carried by Second Renaissance Books.
A basic thing about Reason is that it has to be applied to something. So how can one be a “specialized promoter of reason”? What would that look like? Are we talking method without subject matter? A Platonic essence? Or is it that the candidate needs to have applied reason to multiple fields, so that one can make the case that promoting reason is the common denominator of this person’s achievement? By that standard Randi still stands tall.
In any event, I think it would be a classy thing for Burgess to pay up.
In any event, I think it would be a classy thing for Burgess to pay up.
I wouldn’t. He was offering the money for someone who can help him find what he’s looking for, not for someone who wants to take advantage of the offer by giving an obvious answer that clearly doesn’t help.
Everyone knows who Randi is, there’s no need to offer money to find out about him. Randi is clearly not what he’s looking for.
Integrity is the right word. The offer was for identifying an activist for reason, which Randi is. It was not for identifying a person he deems worthy of his scholarly attention.
Yours, for ignoring Burgess’s acknowledgement that it helped him refine and narrow his search. He also wrote an explanatory article using the links and information I sent him.
Where was this acknowledgment? He obviously admires Randi, and said a video lecture was “informative and entertaining.” But where does he say any of it helped his search? I read his article about Randi as further refinement and explanation of the kind of activist he is looking for, not as a standalone blogpost about Randi.
Given that you accepted the money knowing that Burgess did not receive the help he was looking for in return, whose integrity is in question?
I don’t understand the purpose of this.
If both parties agree that the terms have been satisfied, then what are you adding here exactly? Do you think that Burgess doesn’t agree that he’s gotten his money’s worth, but he’s allowed himself to have been badgered or tricked out of his money anyways? Or if Burgess agrees that what Robert provided was sufficient for a claim on the offer he made – and offering payment seems to suggest that very thing, imo – then why would you say it’s not?
We could speculate all day as to why Burgess decided to award the money anyway, but given that he dedicated an entire blogpost to explaining why Randi isn’t what he was looking for, I think it’s safe to conclude he didn’t get in return what he wanted with the original advertised purpose of the $100.
If someone offered you $100 to paint the porch of his house without specifying a color, would you consider your performance of the task voided if upon reviewing the work he decided he didn’t like the color you chose?
We could speculate all day as to why Burgess decided to award the money anyway, but given that he dedicated an entire blogpost to explaining why Randi isn’t what he was looking for, I think it’s safe to conclude he didn’t get in return what he wanted with the original advertised purpose of the $100.
But you don’t think that agreeing to award the money makes it safe to conclude that he thinks it should be awarded?
Is the assumption here that Burgess doesn’t know what he’s doing, so he needs us to tell him what he had in mind, and what is worth his $100?
Is painting a porch the same thing as providing a name from memory and verifying it with some simple googling? Is the owner of the porch a long term customer or friend? Etc.
Stuff doesn’t exist in a vacuum. This was an odd request by a member of an odd group, obviously with the long term goal of promoting reason. If you have the same or similar goals, why would you ever accept this money?
Dream weaver - Perhaps true, but beyond the scope of the hypothetical. If we’re going to speculate, the owner might not have realized he had a strong preference until seeing the color he disliked.
JASKN - It’s not my responsibility to tell Burgess what the information is worth to him. He is best positioned to decide that for himself.
This raises identical questions to your last post, and so my answer is also the same.
If you’d answered those questions before, I must have missed it.
Here’s my answer: I think Burgess is capable of assessing whether or not Robert deserves the money he’d offered. I think offering the money is a demonstration that Burgess believes the award is warranted. I don’t see any point in your second guessing Burgess’ decision – and I don’t see any call for Robert to refuse the money.
If both parties here are satisfied, what’s the point in calling one or both members’ integrity into question? Just an injection of nastiness, so far as I can tell.