If someone offered you $100 to paint the porch of his house without specifying a color, would you consider your performance of the task voided if upon reviewing the work he decided he didn’t like the color you chose?
Let’s say this painter has a boss. When he discovers that his porch is a color he hates, the owner calls the boss and tells him what happened (he forgot to mention the color, so the painter went ahead and did the job without asking him). What do you think the boss would say to this painter: “job well done” or “if you do that again you’re fired”?
I’m a freelancer (I’m not a painter, I’m a web developer, but it makes no difference what the exact profession is), and, as a freelancer, I have to act as my own boss. I have to evaluate myself honestly, and do everything in my power to make sure my clients get their money’s worth from me.
My issue (and JASKN’s, too, afaict) with your actions is that you, in this instance, have acted as a freelance service provider, but did not hold yourself to that standard. You held yourself to a standard that would get you fired from any job where someone evaluates your performance.
If I was Burgess, I would tell you that Randi is not what I need, and maybe give you a chance to ask for further clarifications and do the job properly (if you showed any signs that you can). And if you had a boss, your boss would agree with me, and tell you the same thing, because he would have the reputation of the company to protect.
P.S. My best guess as to why Burgess didn’t go that route is that he doesn’t have the business experience to recognize this situation for what it is. But I don’t actually know this. It’s also possible that $100 is just less important to him than keeping his blog free of arguments over getting paid. It’s also possible that he is taking responsibility for doing a bad job explaining what he’s looking for.
But I seriously doubt he’s happy about how this turned out. And that’s your fault. If you wanted that $100, you could’ve and should’ve done more, by asking for clarifications first.