$100 Finders fee: Can you name a full-time activist for Reason?

The answer was: “It’s just speculation except for the part where Burgess says he didn’t get what he was after.”

Here is some speculating as to why Burgess paid even though he didn’t get what he wanted:

-Legal protection. Even if Burgess thought he shouldn’t pay the money based on his original stipulations, maybe a court wouldn’t agree, and he doesn’t want legal troubles.

-Ambiguity. Burgess thinks he should have been clearer in his original stipulations. Instead of create a public dispute, he pays $100.

-Credibility. Burgess really does want what he was originally after, and if he pays $100 once publicly, it might motivate others which might ultimately get him a name which fits his needs.

-Etc.

In the existing scenario I would not have personally accepted the money unless Burgess insisted and gave a good reason. Maybe that’s what happened.

The answer was: “It’s just speculation except for the part where Burgess says he didn’t get what he was after.”

But that’s not all we know. We also know he offered to pay – that’s not speculative – and I think that says that he believes he’s received something that entitles Robert to the $100 he’d offered.

 

Here is some speculating as to why Burgess paid even though he didn’t get what he wanted:

-Legal protection. Even if Burgess thought he shouldn’t pay the money based on his original stipulations, maybe a court wouldn’t agree, and he doesn’t want legal troubles.

-Ambiguity. Burgess thinks he should have been clearer in his original stipulations. Instead of create a public dispute, he pays $100.

-Credibility. Burgess really does want what he was originally after, and if he pays $100 once publicly, it might motivate others which might ultimately get him a name which fits his needs.

-Etc.

Yes, I agree – these are all speculations. To them, we could add what Robert originally reported:

 

He said it was because the suggestion was helpful, although he isn’t yet sure Randi is the specific example he is looking for.

I don’t know Burgess personally, but sN reported, based on his own interactions, that honesty is Burgess’ “strong suit.” So I guess I’m willing to take it like this: Burgess found Robert’s suggestion helpful, and on that basis decided to award the $100.

I don’t know Burgess personally, but sN reported, based on his own interactions, that honesty is Burgess’ “strong suit.” So I guess I’m willing to take it like this: Burgess found Robert’s suggestion helpful, and on that basis decided to award the $100.

There is also this, from the conversation between Burgess and Robert on Burgess’ blog:

 

You have not established Randi as a specialized activist focused primarily for reason, but you have given me a useful example of someone who might be mistaken for being a specialist for reason, a simulacrum, so to speak. That will help me distinguish the meaning of “specialized activist.”

When he says “you have given me a useful example” and “that will help me,” he’s providing his rationale for awarding the $100. I see no further call for “speculation” as to his motive – I trust Burgess to be able to speak his own mind on the matter.

1 Like

I think we’ve covered all we can at this point. The reason I initially posted was because I don’t think integrity was only Burgess’ responsibility – and I disagreed with taking the money, based on what I both knew and guessed.

If someone offered you $100 to paint the porch of his house without specifying a color, would you consider your performance of the task voided if upon reviewing the work he decided he didn’t like the color you chose?

Let’s say this painter has a boss. When he discovers that his porch is a color he hates, the owner calls the boss and tells him what happened (he forgot to mention the color, so the painter went ahead and did the job without asking him). What do you think the boss would say to this painter: “job well done” or “if you do that again you’re fired”?

I’m a freelancer (I’m not a painter, I’m a web developer, but it makes no difference what the exact profession is), and, as a freelancer, I have to act as my own boss. I have to evaluate myself honestly, and do everything in my power to make sure my clients get their money’s worth from me.

My issue (and JASKN’s, too, afaict) with your actions is that you, in this instance, have acted as a freelance service provider, but did not hold yourself to that standard. You held yourself to a standard that would get you fired from any job where someone evaluates your performance.

If I was Burgess, I would tell you that Randi is not what I need, and maybe give you a chance to ask for further clarifications and do the job properly (if you showed any signs that you can). And if you had a boss, your boss would agree with me, and tell you the same thing, because he would have the reputation of the company to protect.

P.S. My best guess as to why Burgess didn’t go that route is that he doesn’t have the business experience to recognize this situation for what it is. But I don’t actually know this. It’s also possible that $100 is just less important to him than keeping his blog free of arguments over getting paid. It’s also possible that he is taking responsibility for doing a bad job explaining what he’s looking for.

But I seriously doubt he’s happy about how this turned out. And that’s your fault. If you wanted that $100, you could’ve and should’ve done more, by asking for clarifications first.

There is a world of difference between a formal customer-service-oriented business relationship between two parties and a unilateral offer specifying terms of performance to any takers in the market. I have no prior relationship with this man, nor did I want to invest my own valuable time and risk the opportunity by attempting to flesh out his own terms for him. I think people here are doing him a disservice by doubting his intellectual capacity for conducting his own affairs. My organization just paid a large sum of money to a contractor for work that didn’t ultimately help us - that’s the nature of business uncertainty and it doesn’t negate the contractor’s fulfillment of the terms of the contract. If you want to do extra work to satisfy your clients, that may make sense for you as someone who relies on such recommendations, but there is no moral or legal obligation to go above and beyond in that manner.

… nor did I want to invest my own valuable time and risk the opportunity by attempting to flesh out his own terms for him.

What about his offer made you think any fleshing out was possible? Are you saying the offer was ambiguous and that depending on interpretation a name like Randi may or may not have fit?

What about his offer made you think any fleshing out was possible? Are you saying the offer was ambiguous and that depending on interpretation a name like Randi may or may not have fit?

 

I’m saying the opposite. The terms were clear enough to me where I felt I could meet them without requiring further clarification.

I’m saying the opposite. The terms were clear enough to me where I felt I could meet them without requiring further clarification.

That makes no sense to me. I found the offer ambiguous and therefore not something that ought to be legally binding, neither something that one could reply to with a firm conviction that it would be what he was looking for. When he rejected your suggestion, the rational response would have been to clarify why you think Randi was the name he was looking for. Instead, you turned aggressive implying that he was trying to cheat you out of your earned dues.

After that type of response, a typical customer would have told you to go to hell. However, in my opinion, he realized that his offer had been ambiguous, and even though your suggestion was not what he was looking for, it did give him the opportunity to conceptualize what he was really looking for, and what he did not want. Obviously not worth the $100, but what the heck, it is just money, even though he’s a long-time retired guy a $100 isn’t much these days. Anyone who’s been in the Objectivist movement as long as he has understands the filth and accusations that some people (not you, but folks who seek mileage from this type of episode) will throw around. In my personal evaluation: the easiest thing would be to give in to the blackmail and send you your $100.

So, enjoy your $100, but I doubt it was for value given. Therefore it is simply value taken. Not illegal… you basically played him for a sucker.

1 Like

That makes no sense to me. I found the offer ambiguous and therefore not something that ought to be legally binding, neither something that one could reply to with a firm conviction that it would be what he was looking for. When he rejected your suggestion, the rational response would have been to clarify why you think Randi was the name he was looking for. Instead, you turned aggressive implying that he was trying to cheat you out of your earned dues.

 

An offer can be clear in its terms yet incomplete according to what the offeror had in mind. The offeree is not responsible for anything except the plain meaning of the offer. Having had no prior contact with this individual, and this being a first-to-arrive unilateral offer, I had no reason to invest my time making sure that there were no additional terms or preferences he wanted addressed. If I was going to help him craft and strengthen his offer, I would have charged a heck of a lot more than $100 for the legal services. But he didn’t ask me to do so, nor did I have the obligation to inquire. I did, however, briefly explain why I felt Randi fit the criteria on his blog and then provided additional information in a follow up e-mail.

 

 

In my personal evaluation: the easiest thing would be to give in to the blackmail and send you your $100.

 

If you’re going to throw around serious accusations like “blackmail,” you should understand what they mean first. Blackmail involves use of force or a threat to reveal damaging information. I in no way used force or threatened to do anything to this individual, much less reveal any hidden information as everything occurred out in the open for all to see.

 

So, enjoy your $100, but I doubt it was for value given. Therefore it is simply value taken. Not illegal… you basically played him for a sucker.

 

As I stated earlier, I think you are doing this individual a disservice by insulting his capacity to conduct his own affairs.

In my personal evaluation: the easiest thing would be to give in to the blackmail and send you your $100.

I’m calling foul on your use of the term “blackmail”. RB already addressed it so all I’m doing is wagging my finger in your general direction, I don’t have anything to add to what he wrote. I’d give you a warning point, if I were a moderator (no thanks!).

If we’re going to sling legal terms around, how about Implied Warranty?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied_warranty

Did Burgess specify that the name he was seeking was one he hadn’t heard of before? Someone he could form a partnership with? I get the feeling he wanted those two features, a kind of fitness for a particular purpose. Did he work it into the offer? Oops, time for more reading, now on Offer and Acceptance:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Offer_and_acceptance

Nope, he didn’t. Is it an offeree’s function to…forget it, this is getting boring even for me.

RB said:

The offeree is not responsible for anything except the plain meaning of the offer.

Unless, of course, meaning involves the intentional states of the speaker. In which case, on an occasion when the offerer realizes the wording (symbols-syntax) was not making clear their intended referents, they might simply take responsibility for the ambiguity… However, a person who learns that the offerer did not in fact mean what conditions the offeree took as satisfying the intentional object-state of affairs they intended to convey, might feel this is not the sort of trade they are interested in…(might)

If you’re going to throw around serious accusations like “blackmail,” … …

Someone pointed out to me that Burgess was almost certainly unaware of this discussion on this forum. I agree. In other words, he probably was not aware of any rudeness and hostility from you. Therefore, I was wrong to call it “blackmail”.

(Added after a search: For a discussion on blackmail, and whether it ought to be a crime at all, see this topic.)

Thanks. That is an interesting examination of blackmail.

Is James Randi a full-time, specialized activist for reason?

In summary, working only from these three samples and from his newsletters which I read decades ago, I can say James Randi has had a long, productive, successful career as a defender of science and an exposer of “flim-flam.” He is not a specialized, full-time activist for reason. Randi’s relationship to reason is analogous to the imprint a seal makes in wax. The imprint in the wax is a result of the seal. Likewise, Randi’s work in supporting science is a result of his respect for reason, but respect for a subject is not the same as specializing in promoting it.

 

The imprint a seal makes in was essentially a description of Aristotle’s view of how the mind forms concepts.

 

From what I’ve been able to glean from a small vien of sources, is that Burgess is actually seeking someone worthy of being financed  to actively promote reason on a full time basis. Such a specialist would indeed be worth his weight in gold.

Burgess’s second book, “The Power and the Glory” documents a few advocates for reason from centuries past. So, this is consistent with that theme.

A follow-up post from Burgess, in which he proposes a “Donor’s Network for Reason Activists”.

"PLAN. No money will pass through DNRA. Money will flow directly from individual donors to individual activists."

 

According to the IRS: To be deductible, charitable contributions must be made to qualified organizations. Payments to individuals are never deductible.