I tend to keep track of the Times opinion-editorials simply because they, more than any other media group, tend to set the terms of the intellectual discourse in the country.
In a recent opinion piece, Paul Krugman attacks laissez-faire capitalism. Here are the relevant lines:
…the attempt to turn Iraq into a laissez-faire showpiece was, in its own way, as much an in-your-face rejection of world opinion as the decision to go to war. Dogmatic views about the universal superiority of free markets have been losing ground around the world.
Latin Americans are the most disillusioned. Through much of the 1990’s, they bought into the “Washington consensus” - which we should note came from Clinton administration officials as well as from Wall Street economists and conservative think tanks - which said that privatization, deregulation and free trade would lead to economic takeoff. Instead, growth remained sluggish, inequality increased, and the region was struck by a series of economic crises.
As an exercise in philosophic detection, I ask the following: what are all the wrong elements in the above passage, i.e. what’s wrong with his argument, what is wrong with his premises, what bad concepts is he using, etc.? Furthermore, what would be an appropriate and concise response to his piece?