Why is logic not included in the philosophy branches of Objectivism? Also, why are Politics & Esthetics considered fundamental branches in Objectivism?
Logic is a part of the branch of Objectivist epistemology.
Also, why are Politics & Esthetics considered fundamental branches in Objectivism?
They are not covered by the other branches and they deal with cruical and universal aspects of human life. Why should they not be?
I was arguing based on this map I found:
http://www.arts.ed.ac.uk/philosophy/study_…n1/branches.htm
Politics I can understand, but Esthetics I never really considered “crucial.” Ayn Rand herself didn’t mention Esthetics when asked to summarize her philosophy.
It’s rather difficult to summarize an esthetic theory in one sentence. She did, however, write an entire book on it: The Romantic Manifesto. In it she explains why esthetics is a fundamental requirement of man’s nature.
I was arguing based on this map I found:
That’s what I call a model of dis-integration. That “map” is more of a list of trendy dissertation topics than any kind of systematic and hierarchical approach to philosophy. It makes a false distinction between “abstract” and “applied” knowledge but does not recognize that logic and ethics cannot be studied without a basis in metaphysics and epistemology.
There is a “concept chart” of all the major areas of philosophy at http://www.importanceofphilosophy.com/Chart.html – however I’d be wary of any such map becuase it borders on playing an alphabet soup of floating abstractions. To understand each branch, you have to undertake a systematic and in-depth study.
Actually, that map is quite nice. I mean, it’s much more detailed than Ayn Rand’s 5-node-web, albeit not as elegant. Certainly, “Philosophy of Science” is a very specialized discipline, and makes an intense study of many things that are only touched upon in epistemology or metaphysics. It’s pretty rough to follow tho. Someone needs to make those arrows more organized.
I do like the way that “Philosophy of Religion” just goes nowhere. That’s funny.