Am I Objectivist?

Well, a philosophy may be complete, even without an understanding of everything in our universe. Because philosophy is an integrated view of man’s nature and the nature of reality (as a whole, not item by item), those are the two things which must be understood completely. Today, man does know enough about them to formulate a complete philosophy, even though there are plenty of areas of human inquiry yet to be explored. For example, every time we look, we see that man must use reason to survive; nothing else will do. The fact that we can’t pin down the rest mass of a top quark does not change this fact. Similarly, all we see in reality is that contradictions don’t exist. We can look forever, but we’ll never see otherwise. There’s no reason to think that future human inquiry will change this fact. We can use it as a basis for an objective philosophy.

I believe that there are such contradictions, and there is often no clear “best” answer. I also believe that this is how it will always be, when it comes to philosophical endeavors. Asking “what is the best philosophy” can often be like asking “what is the best color.”

Before you see that as criticism of objectivism, it’s entirely possible to have “favorite colors.”

The logical/emotional setup is a false dichotomy. What man is, fundamentally, is volitional. His means of survival is reason, which uses logic as its tool for handling the data provided by man’s senses. Man also has emotions, but they aren’t his means of survival, but rather an automatic response to his values. You automatically feel love for something you value most highly, anger towards a threat to your values, and so on. First comes your valuation of some thing in reality, and your emotions necessarily follow.

Our personal satisfaction with life (happiness) comes from the achievement of our values, not our particular emotions. If you’re good at something you want to be good at, you’ll be happy, and you’ll experience the emotions associated with being happy. I think if you do a little introspection, you’ll see that one’s state of happiness doesn’t start with emotions, it “ends” with it.

How could you make a rational decision that would make you sad and not be the best decision for you? I could see how bad premises could lead you to feel sad about something that was rational (such as feeling sad about getting a dear friend out of your life who was a jerk), but if it’s rational, it can’t be bad for you. The rational is the good.

Interesting. I am very epicurean in my approach to life, my values are rather simple, which make it easy to acheive that happiness.

There is a distinction worth noting. Often, “ethics” refers to a system to guide human action. It could be good, it could be bad. “Morality” refers to the proper system to guide human action – the one needed for man’s survival and determined by man’s nature – as opposed to an improper one.

Ah, which is why there is no difference to me. They are all just “a system to guide human action.” If I believed in the existence of a “proper system to guide human action,” I’d be a lot closer to objectivist.

Oy. Well, without objective truth (a redundancy), morality isn’t possible.

By your definition above, this is true. Ethics would still be possible.

Man becomes a quivering, helpless heap of body parts who manages to survive by luck alone. I think all the examples of human advancement, not the least of which is Objectivism, refutes that claim.

I see those advancements as just evidence of natural selection. From an evolutionary perspective, as a species we have survived through “luck” alone. And I see our slide toward socialism as evidence that our dominance in the role of earth’s greatest evolutionary success may be in the decline…I am hopeful, but not optimistic, that we can avoid extinction even long enough to get out of Tsiolkovsky’s cradle of humanity and expand throughout the stars. We may be an evolutionary dead end. It’s probable that when the universe reaches the cold death it is destined for, humanity will likely not even be a footnote in its existence.

Additionally, and not to be coy, but the claim that there is no objective truth is itself a claim of objective truth. And certainly there is a way to determine which evolutionary adaptations are more advantageous to a given species. I’m not even sure why you would posit such a thing, or even if you believe it.

There are plenty of objective truths. I just do not believe it is logically possible for a particular philosophy to be one of them.

I have my own personal morality that agrees for the most part with what Rand believed, but I do not believe in intrinsic “right” or “wrong.” I’m a social darwinist (really, a darwinist in every possible way) who believes that humans have evolved the concepts of “right” and “wrong,” (and indeed, that all of our behavioral mores are evolved social traits) and that there is no objective morality…there is merely what helps us advance both as individuals and as a society, and that which hinders us. (Bold added)

This is what stood out most to me when reading your post, Talya. What is your definition of “Right” and “Wrong”? I don’t mean your relativist view of what is Right and Wrong for you, in your morality, I mean what is your definition of the words?

Now, this isn’t the prettiest definition, but what is morally Right is any action which serves to further the purpose of a man’s life -without- causing harm to another man or himself. Your problem seems to lie in that it -looks- like (correct me if I’m wrong) you believe morality is relative because you have discovered that morality’s source is -not- divine. In other words, you seem to think that the only way morality can be objectively definable and universal among all men is if it was created and is enforced by some power, and since you’ve recently discovered you don’t actually believe in such a power, you believe morality no longer has any concrete basis.

This is where Objectivism disagrees with moral relativism: Morality -is- bound in reality, and just because it is not instinctual or divine does not mean that it is not objectively definable. You describe yourself as a Darwinist, which is good! But analyzing the connections between Darwin’s Natural Selection and human society actually reinforces that morality -is- objective. For instance; animals are obviously not sentient and as such cannot have rights, nor do they have any need for a code of morality, but let’s pretend they do for a moment. If an Elephant decides suddenly that his mate is hogging all his food, and that he’d be much better off with her dead, and kills her, he has just committed an -immoral- act. Why is it immoral? It does not -actually- help him in any shape, now he cannot have children with her, so his genes will obviously not be passed along and he will be easier to pick off by a predator, that Elephant just FAILED at life. The reason his choice is immoral is because it leads to his death, and the death of his mate.

Humans have it easy in one sense, we do not (currently) know of any other species that uses reason instead of instinct to survive. Because we are animals of reason over instinct, morality strictly applies to us and for us. It is wrong to initiate force, why? Because force is the opposite of reason, it breaks our ‘code’. If I killed another person in anything other than self defense, I have chosen to -relinquish- my right to live. In other words, by killing someone I am saying ‘I do not recognize this person’s right to life.’ and in turn, I should be killed; I no longer have that same right to life, because I didn’t recognize it.

The initiation of force against another person is wrong universally. There is no context in which it is correct to use force unless it is for the preservation of my own or someone else’s individual rights.

Morality -was- created by man, for man, and just because it was, does not mean it is relative.

There are plenty of objective truths. I just do not believe it is logically possible for a particular philosophy to be one of them.

This is self contradictory. The truth, as a whole, can not be conflicting with itself. It cannot be true that “the ball is all red” and “the ball is all blue”. It cannot be true that “Christianity is true” AND “buddhism is true”. There can only be one objective truth. That truth, on the whole, is huge - but reality dictates that no matter how big the truth is, it cannot be contradictory.

You really need to begin at the beginning. One of the problems you’re having here is you’re trying to start with some concepts without having a foundation behind them. This is what Rand called a “stolen concept” - if you accept a complex concept as true without understanding its supports, you cannot proceed in a valid direction.

Lets start at the beginning - what do you consider to be axiomatic? What is self evident and incontrovertible, irreducible, and impossible to deny without accepting as part of the denial?

That simply means that our theories are incomplete. It doesn’t mean that the world would have been some wild and wacky place, just that we can’t model what it would have been like. And that’s it.

I’m aware of that.

What it comes down to is that time is a measurement of motion, and if the universe had a beginning, then there could not have been anything by which to measure motion (and no measurer) in this “pre-universe”, and hence no time. If however the big bang is just some local event, and the regions of spacetime are so huge that we have not yet received light from the other “universes” that are more than 15 billion light years away, then time could have always existed (ie, there could have always been stuff by which to measure motion).

No, that’s not at all what relativistic time means.

Time, like space, can be curved, warped, changed. Einstein proved beyond doubt that time is not a constant…and in fact his theories are mathematically essential in several human technological endeavors. For instance, time literally moves faster at sea level than it does in orbit. Earth’s mass actually influences the flow of time, to the point where the differences need to be built into the clocks of GPS systems to avoid inaccuracy creeping (rather quickly) into the system. A singularity would actually cause such issues with the flow of time for objects within the event horizon that, assuming the big bang was the only one in our reality, would represent the literal beginning of time.

This is self contradictory. The truth, as a whole, can not be conflicting with itself. It cannot be true that “the ball is all red” and “the ball is all blue”. It cannot be true that “Christianity is true” AND “buddhism is true”. There can only be one objective truth. That truth, on the whole, is huge - but reality dictates that no matter how big the truth is, it cannot be contradictory.

…i think you’re misrepresenting something I’ve said there. I do not believe it’s really possible for christianity OR buddhism to be “truth” from the standpoint of reason.

I believe there is objective truth. It’s just mathematical and obvious. “The ball is all red” can be proven, it’s objective. 2+2=4 is an objective truth. The sun fuses hydrogen into helium is an objective truth.

“Murder is wrong” is not an objective truth. It is something I agree with, but there’s nothing objective about it. Morality/Ethics, philosophy, religion…they’re thought experiments, but there’s no objective truth to any of them. Some parts of them might be objectively WRONG (eg. “Noah and his 3 sons, in addition to their wives, built a big box out of wood and saved all life on earth t hrough a flood that covered the entire planet.” *Bzzzzt.* Physically impossible), but objectively true? I don’t see how that any objective truth can exist from the entirely human construct of “right and wrong.”

For instance; animals are obviously not sentient and as such cannot have rights, nor do they have any need for a code of morality, but let’s pretend they do for a moment.

Let’s first address an uncommon assumption. I actually believe some animals are far more sentient than some of my coworkers.

In all seriousness, the Atlantic Bottlenose Dolphin, as one example, is said to have the approximate cognitive and reasoning ability of a human 3-to-5 year old. My three year old daughter is most assuredly sentient. And humans most assuredly are still governed to an extent by instinct, even if we have a greater capacity for learning than most species.

There is not this wide gulf between ourselves and other creatures that most people think there is. We are certainly the pinnacle, at least for now, of evolution on earth. People read a lot more into that distinction than there is.

Anyway, as to the morality of that elephant’s decision: wouldn’t whether it helps or hinders him depend on what his purpose is? Assuming a greater level of sentience than elephants possess, propogation may not be that particular elephant’s goal.

Assuming a particular goal with which to judge objective morality that is common to all is rather … anti-individualist. You’re assuming a collective goal…and for darwinian natural selection, perhaps there may be one. But we are individuals, not collectives. If one man’s goal in life happens to be going out in a blaze of glory gun battle with Los Angeles cops, his morality will be very different than mine. Everyone is an individual, and will end up deciding on their own morality based on their own values and goals.

Regardless of whether or not animals are capable of reasoning, and regardless of whether or not human beings have instincts, animals survive via instinct, humans survive via reason. An animal instinctually stays with others of its kind, some instinctually know how to walk, and they instinctually stay to learn from their mothers on how to become self sufficient, or sufficient in the pack, depending on the species. Humans have no such instincts. A baby does not know how to walk, a baby does not know much of anything, it is instantly learning the second it is born, eventually it learns to imitate, it learns to conceptualize, and to talk, based on how it is raised. We don’t have an instinct that tells us where to go for food, how to get it, or offer any help whatsoever in the performing of any activities required to sustain our lives. We -learn- them, from people in the past who -reasoned- them out.

How do I know this? We have emotions, (which AR properly defined as the product of our values, which we gained by reason) they call back the memory of my childhood, “Food makes my stomach feel better.” “If I cry I get food.” then it evolves “I -like- food.” “My source of food is another person.” “I -like- this person, because she gives me food.” Obviously the relationship between children and parents is much more complex and meaningful, but that is how it evolves. My dog however does not ‘like’ me. She knows that she gets food every day, and she gets petting, so she repeats whatever behavior seems to get her food and petting, and that’s her life. She does not aspire, have goals, or seek to advance beyond just surviving, because that is her instinct. Her job is to survive, and pass on her genes. Humans have no such job, because we have no such instincts. We -decide- to exist, and we -decide- to use reason.

Assuming a particular goal with which to judge objective morality that is common to all is rather … anti-individualist. You’re assuming a collective goal…and for darwinian natural selection, perhaps there may be one. But we are individuals, not collectives. If one man’s goal in life happens to be going out in a blaze of glory gun battle with Los Angeles cops, his morality will be very different than mine. Everyone is an individual, and will end up deciding on their own morality based on their own values and goals.

If a dude’s life goal is to die, he’s got a philosophical contradiction. He’s not healthy, he’s going to hurt people, himself, waste time and money. When it comes down to it, his goal in life is probably -not- to die. But even if it were, to try and kill himself in that method, with the very real possibility of shooting and killing someone else, he is most definitely wrong. Usually such gun battles are not the result of a man wanting to kill -himself- but wanting to kill other people. Darwin, and philosophy, pertains to people who are alive, in other words people that like life and wish to continue to do so.

Living is not a ‘collective goal.’ It’s a choice. If you choose not to live, I recommend following that man’s idea of ‘morality.’ Since most people like living, it is in our interest to discover the best way to successfully do so within reality. Saying morality is objective because it pertains to that which furthers life does not negate individuality; it enables it. If morality is relative, why bother with anything? Why even have political opinions? Where does your libertarianism spring from? Some people have decided that their goal in life, their ‘morality’ involves dominating and controlling the lives of everyone on earth, and they work toward it every day. Who are you to tell Stalin he was wrong? In his morality, he wasn’t.

Believing that your purpose is to kill, or control, does not change the reality that those things are wrong.

Objectivism does not assume a collective goal, it assumes you have a goal which doesn’t end in death.

Which means you chose for life, which exists only under certain conditions.

Which presupposes that your means and goal don’t conflict with those conditions.

Immorality in this context is if someone is pursuing a goal which requires life but contradicts its conditions or the reverse.

I think I got that right. <_<

Talya:

You seem like an intelligent person. If you read The Virtue of Selfishness by Ayn Rand (some of her non-fiction) I think you will discover that morality can be objectively defined. In particular, the opening essay entitled “The Objectivist Ethics” provides a proof for an objective morality, demonstrating that life is the foundation of all value.

Edit: “demonstrating that life is” was “citing life as”