Hi, there. You can call me Talya.
I’m a 35 year old mother of two, who has gone through an evolution in religious, political, and social views over the years. I find myself admiring Ayn Rand’s objectivism more and more, without necessarily agreeing with or espousing all of her views. Of course, in the points where I differ, it’s often more of a theoretical disagreement, than a practical one. I often find myself using objectivist philosophy in debates and disagreements, to the point that I sometimes consider identifying myself as Objectivist, but there are enough differences I do not want associated with me that I end up shunning such collectivist groupings in favor of my own unique individual interpretations.
Let’s start with who I have been.
I was born in Ontario, Canada. My parents are first generation immigrants from Northern Ireland, my father is a very “orange” Irish loyalist and an Anglican priest as well. (Uh oh, the preacher’s kid…betcha she’s fun, eh?) I abandoned the beliefs of my father fairly early in life, and as a teenager began investigating “new age” religions that fit with my sense of self identity…Druidism and Celtic paganism in various forms. In the end, though, it would seem I never really had faith in a God. You can read my very sporadically updated blog if you’d like to know how that came about, but suffice it to say, I’m quite Agnostic now. Atheist? I object to the term. I cannot prove that there is no God, any more than my father can prove that there is one. Atheism requires the faith that God does not exist. I merely know that the existence of God is no more likely than the existence of the invisible pink unicorn, or the flying spaghetti monster. God may exist or may not, but I see no evidence of Her existence, nor do I see a reason to put faith in one. The universe exists how it exists, whether due to divine intervention or not, and any God who may or may not have existed has long since abandoned us.
Politically? As a teenager, I was quite “left wing,” bleeding heart socialist in my views–because to a teenager, who doesn’t see the whole picture or understand economics, that seems like the moral, good thing to be. But life is so much more complex than the way its seen in youth, and over time, I’ve drifted toward the “right,” in a somewhat “libertarian” direction, going more and more for individualism and freedom over the collective.
So here I am, the almost-atheist who believes in individualism, rewarding excellence, and generally stamping out the mediocrity-inducing snare of socialsim. How can I not be objectivist?
Well, for one, I’m a moral relativist (isn’t relativist the opposite of objectivist?). I have my own personal morality that agrees for the most part with what Rand believed, but I do not believe in intrinsic “right” or “wrong.” I’m a social darwinist (really, a darwinist in every possible way) who believes that humans have evolved the concepts of “right” and “wrong,” (and indeed, that all of our behavioral mores are evolved social traits) and that there is no objective morality…there is merely what helps us advance both as individuals and as a society, and that which hinders us. It just so happens that I believe that many of Rand’s philosophies are the most helpful to human advancement. How can I be a relativist objectivist? It doesn’t work. So I’ve never identified that way. Then there are some minor issues. I believe in providing equality of opportunity in society, not equality of outcome. The disadvantaged may have excellence that surpasses those born with advantages, if given the opportunity. As such, I end up believing in certain small social structures and safety nets (far less than what most governments offer today, so I end up on the same side of most political beliefs anyway.) I am not a true “laissez-faire” capitalist, although I strongly believe that we should head a lot more towards governmental non-interference than what we see around us in developed nations today. In a group consisting otherwise of a combination of Libertarians and Objectivists, I’d definitely be the “bleeding heart left-wing” voice. On the other hand, in a group consisting otherwise of neo-cons and liberals, I’d be the “evil godless/right-wing nazi.” I’m really without a political place that I fit into.
But then again, isn’t that rather a point that Ayn Rand would have agreed with? Was not individualism and finding your own path, rather than parotting and following the beliefs of others something she would have agreed with? Even if she didn’t agree with all of my positions, would not we have had more common ground than differences, and out of respect for the individual, been happy to agree to disagree (even as we could debate such things forever?)
So in the end, am I an Objectivist? Or do such distinctions matter, and is the need to belong to a collective think-tank and all be in agreement in itself something that Rand would have despised?
I don’t know. I just know that I have more in common with you guys than I do with society at large.