Anarchy's objective obliteration

  :slight_smile: I appreciate and acknowledge that I did intend some rhetorical meaning in asking you where the government gets that right, if not from the individuals which comprise it… but honestly, I was “saying” less than asking. I really want to know your thoughts on that matter, because I think it’s one of the central matters of this discussion.

Agreed.  And any governmental right to any action it takes MUST come from the individuals it’s meant to defend; its citizens.

Because if there were some arcane wellspring of “Federal Authority” or something similar, for the rights of a proper (protective) government then there could exist a morally acceptable government, tasked with the safety and welfare of its citizens but authorized to use any and every means advised by its mystical source of rights.

This would result in Orwell’s 1984 and be considered moral.  So logically, anything the government can do, it’s morally able to do BECAUSE its citizens not only hold those same right but have given it permission to excersize them, by proxy.

 

So individuals MUST have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, necessarily.

 

I’d have to imagine that the argument for government, or for monopoly government, or for whatever position you’re putting contra “anarchy,” relies upon the idea that it is a better defense of the individual’s rights than otherwise. Meaning: the individual will choose to delegate his right of self-defense to an objective proceeding, because that is ultimately a better protection for him, as an individual (in that it will help to establish to others that his use of retaliatory force is, in fact, retaliatory and not the initiation of force). Not that he is metaphysically stripped of his rights, but that he is making a choice (which, I would further argue, suggests that he could potentially choose otherwise, and sometimes should).

Agreed, again!

That’s part of why the argument I described earlier (retaliation is only moral when objective, objectivity is hard and time-consuming, delegating it is logical) would make so much sense.

And since must the government derive its rights from those it protects (meaning they, ultimately, hold those rights and it acts on their permission), they could conceivably revoke its permission IF it failed to perform the required function.  So a criminal couldn’t un-consent his rights back on his way to prison but, in certain cases, one person or several or the majority of the citizens could revoke their permission.

In reality, I believe that’s referred to as “revolution!”

 

Well, if we believe that the objective administration of justice has requirements (like a “jury of one’s peers,” or specific rules of evidence, or what have you), then “Objectivist vigilantes” would be equally beholden to those requirements.

But if someone followed all of the requirements we would demand of a proper government (which potentially could include recusing one’s self in a matter in which one is personally involved), then I do not see why someone should not be allowed to “take matters into his own hands.”

That may not be the sexy Death Wish style vigilantism that we initially imagine, but my interest is in taking seriously the idea that no individual (and by extension no group, government included) ought to initiate force against any other.

Agreed a third time.  That’s the conclusion I’ve reached at this point.

A government is useful for larger societies, but ultimately unnecessary.  What IS vitally necessary is OBJECTIVITY, which is the requirement for any individual or society or government to morally use retributive force.

 

So then, I guess the only question left would be how to implement that concretely, in reality.  But I’m guessing that’s a rather sizeable question, isn’t it?

Exactly!  That’s exactly what I would’ve said a few days ago!

 

 

 

Okay, then.  Assuming we all agree on Objectivist ethics, we come to individual rights and their application into a civilized society.

The basic question is: does an individual have the right to defend his own rights, personally, with retaliatory force- yes or no?

If not then people need a government for that purpose (as well as arbitrating petty squabbles), and if your rights are violated and then the criminal gets away then it’s immoral (?) and unlawful for you to exact your own vengeance.  This position is implicitly clear throughout most of Ayn Rand’s writings; the problem is that (to the best of my knowledge) she never made it explicitly clear.  And it doesn’t seem to logically follow from the rest.

If so then people don’t need a government (anarchy) and if someone violates your rights it’s perfectly fine to take matters into your own hands, after-the-fact (vigilantism).  A society of lawless, O’ist vigilantes (which seems to logically follow) is what I was referring to.

I package-deal them together because they both stem from the same premise and would be closely interrelated applications of it.  Different concretes but they have the same source.

 

A few days ago I was entirely convinced of the second response (yes), until I read through this:

http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?showtopic=5399

 

 

Yeah. . . I was trying to express what I had forgotten through a short story, which speaks for my state of mind at that point.

Okay, well as some aspects of this have already been discussed, I’ll just add on to what I think is the biggest issue here. You seem to be convinced of the necessity of having one single monopoly agency in order to avoid vigilantism. But all I’m saying is that this doesn’t follow. Take another look at the thread I linked you to, which you share here. It doesn’t make such a leap. Even Don (the original author) states the following: “[The point is that] objectivity demands they prove [guilt] to every other member of society. Only a government can provide such a mechanism. (The anarchist would of course dispute this last claim as well, but the point here isn’t to make the case for limited government…”

 

As the author hiimself realizes, it does not follow from the fact that vigilantism ought to be illegal to the fact that we only need one monopoly agency. For a market based legal system does not lack objective legal procedures, it just does not have one single monopoly agency who is allowed to employ them, rather than a multiplicity of such agencies. Market anarchists that agree on objective legal principles do not favor vigilantism, we do in fact favor a unique set of principles and legal procedures. But we do not favor their enforcement by a unique agency, rather we favor free entry into the field of specifying and enforcing such rules.

 

Your confusion lies in your conflating “objective legal procedures” with “monopoly,” which is precisely the issue free market anarchism seeks to challenge: that a monopoly is necessary for objective law. Note in the following quotation from you:

 

 

5: Every individual has the right to defend himself and his property, and to the objective use of retaliatory force

Which would mean that anyone could morally exact their own justice. . . If they took the responsibility of acting as bailiff, detective, prosecution, defense, judge, jury and executioner- and publicist of the act, for everyone else’s benefit.

 

This wouldn’t make sense precisely because “acting as bailiff, detective, prosecution, defense, judge, jury and executioner- and publicist of the act” is not “the objective use of retaliatory force.” So no, we don’t say that people should be allowed to do this. And anyway, just think about it from a practical point of view. Would it make sense to have people running around enforcing their own subjective interpretations of justice, Rambo-style, on their own? No, of course not. What would your community say? Your neighbors, your employer, your insurer, your family? Nobody would put up with that kind of aggressive behavior, even if it turned out you were right in whatever you were doing.

2046 covers some of this in post #3 (again, in the thread you linked to). According to Rothbard, in an anarchist society, if Ben kills Jerry, Ben will be charged with murder if Jerry is not found guilty (of murdering someone else) in a court of law. However, if Jerry is found guilty, Ben will be praised for ‘executing justice’ and that will be the end of it. The moral of the story is: According to Rothbard, yes, people should be able to take justice into their own hands- but they must still face the consequences of their actions. Ben better be damn sure that Jerry is guilty before enacting his own justice.. or he himself will be guilty of killing an innocent man.

 

It’s my understanding that in the society 2046 is talking about, private court systems would exist instead of a government monopoly. (Please correct me if I’m wrong here.) In this type of system the criterion for judging guilt would vary, but it would probably be more complex than “he sez she sez.”

Well, just to clear any confusion, no I can’t quite agree with the above point. That statement of Rothbard’s, that vigilantism would be permitted, as long as the vigilantee was in fact correct and held to answer after the fact, was a controversial view even among anarchist libertarians. Most market anarchists do not support such an idea. Rothbard’s most prominent student Hans Hoppe, for example, disagreed at length that vigilantism should (or would) be permitted at all, and that only those who employed objective and rational procedures should be permitted to exercise any kind of force, and secondly, on an economic level, only those agencies which employed procedures that most people agreed on as being just would flourish in society, as non-monopoly agencies depend on market incentives rather than being able to tap a captive customer base. It it thus more likely that a monopolist agency would pervert law and exercise non-objective uses of force.

This wouldn’t make sense precisely because “acting as bailiff, detective, prosecution, defense, judge, jury and executioner- and publicist of the act” is not “the objective use of retaliatory force.”

What then constitutes the objective use of retaliatory force?

 

Your confusion lies in your conflating “objective legal procedures” with “monopoly,” which is precisely the issue free market anarchism seeks to challenge: that a monopoly is necessary for objective law.

Actually, I’ve come to the conclusion that it ISN’T necessary- but imminently practical.  (although that was part of my original confusion in this thread)

But if a collective monopoly isn’t necessary for objective law but an individual acting as “bailiff, detective, prosecution, defense, judge, jury, executioner and publicist” isn’t sufficient for objective law, then what IS the criterion for objectivity?

 

You make some very intriguing points about competing governments.  Would these agencies be exclusively judicial, or would they have enforcement arms as well?

 

And just out of curiosity, have you ever read The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein?

That statement of Rothbard’s, that vigilantism would be permitted, as long as the vigilantee was in fact correct and held to answer after the fact, was a controversial view even among anarchist libertarians. Most market anarchists do not support such an idea.

 

Thanks for the clarification.

 

Wait. . . Privatized courts whose verdicts are enforced by any and all individuals, at large?

…then what IS the criterion for objectivity?

 

I don’t mean to over-quote 2046, but he provides an explanation about the implementation of a market based legal system in this thread. (Took me awhile to find!) Here is a compilation of his main points (let me know if I’ve left anything major out- also, DonAthos provides a lot of useful dialogue- I suggest reading through the entire thread, but if you don’t have time, here’s a short summary):

 

Thesis

The entire point market anarchism seeks to challenge is whether a monopoly is necessary in order to have a proper legal process. -2046, post #83

 

Basics

  1. Everyone has conflicting interpretations of justice- that’s just a part of human nature. (Locke, Letters Concerning Toleration) -2046, post #18

2. These conflicting interpretations of justice exist in both a single monopoly government, and a market-based legal system (which has competing providers of legal services). -2046, post #18

  1. There is nothing to “compel” human beings with free will to act in certain ways, outside of the institutions and structures that they arrange themselves in, according to whatever articulated philosophical principles they go by. -2046, post #107

 

Crux

  1. There does exist an independent verifiable standard by which to judge legal procedures. (ie: There is a way to verify objectively that one interpretation of justice is valid whereas another one is not.)  -2046, post #10

  2. Because of this, it doesn’t matter who employs the legal procedures in question. -2046, post #10

  3. If one single monopoly agency employs the correct procedures, then it is morally right, but so is every other agency which employs correct procedures. -2046, post #10

  4. If, on the other hand, the one monopoly agency employs incorrect procedures, then it is morally wrong, as is every agency which employs such procedures. -2046, post #10

  5. Accountability to an authority does not logically necessitate accountability to one single agency, but can actually include accountability to a multiplicity of them. _-_2046, post #86

  6. In a market-based legal order, competing agencies would have free entry into the field. -2046, post #10

  7. These providers (on the free market) would respond to consumer demand. -2046, post #18

  8. That is, the public wouldn’t stand for Rambo-style justice. People would want an agency that utilizes only the proper procedures and is accountable to the public for how it enforces the law. -2046, post #89

  9. There would still be constitutional restraints and various checks and balances. That is, there would still be various institutions and incentives for people to do things. -2046, post #18

  10. The free market as a constitutional political structure is simply a generalization of the principle of checks and balances, not the elimination of accountability to authority. -2046, post #86

  11. There would not be just one organization that takes upon itself the job of forcing all the other agencies to conform to the single, uniform standard of objective justice. -2046, post #23

  12. Multiple agencies can compete in this field, for if the coercive imposition of these objective principles of justice is permissible, then it is permissible for anybody (and not just one agency). -2046, post #23

 

Conclusion

A market-based legal order follows a good incentive structure for objectivity. -2046, post #56

Non-state laws and non-monopoly courts and judicial systems are ideal, and would better serve the goals of individuals, instead of one just monopoly agency.  -2046, post #98

1 Like

What then constitutes the objective use of retaliatory force?

  then what IS the criterion for objectivity?

I put these two quotes together because they’re really the same question. Well I can’t just like answer this in a brief post. This is the job of the field of law. There’s tons of libertarian scholars out there that study libertarian law and its applications, you can search their articles on google. Just type in libertarian law and polycentric law and stuff like that. The main thing is that voluntary institutions that would emerge in a libertarian society are capable of peacefully and justly solving disputes that people have. A good starting point might be Smith’s Justice Entrepreneurship in a Free Market.

 

You make some very intriguing points about competing governments.  Would these agencies be exclusively judicial, or would they have enforcement arms as well?

 

And just out of curiosity, have you ever read The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein?

And another thing is that we can’t be expected to exactly blueprint a free market legal order. The same way socialists might say, “oh you want a free market in (say) shoe production. Well then, tell us how this would work?? Will there be multiple shoe designs? How many companies would there be? Would they be exclusively sales departments, or would they have production facilities attached? How many shoes must be produced per year? How many types would there be, how many colors? If you can’t answer this, then that’s a problem!”

 

Well no, we cannot say a priori how it would work. The only thing we can say is that profitibility is the standard. Maybe there will be various judges and arbitration firms who would have contracts with enforcement agencies, being separate, maybe insurance agencies will provider arbiters and have their own built-in police and security departments, who knows.

 

And sorry I’ve heard of, but I haven’t read the Heinlein book.

I don’t mean to over-quote 2046, but he provides an explanation about the implementation of a market based legal system in this thread. (Took me awhile to find!) Here is a compilation of his main points (let me know if I’ve left anything major out- also, DonAthos provides a lot of useful dialogue- I suggest reading through the entire thread, but if you don’t have time, here’s a short summary):

Wow, awesome!

 

Indeed.  But I think that you are also in favor of government, so far as I can tell. 

 

 

We can only hope!  :slight_smile:

Well… I shouldn’t presume to speak for you, but so far as I can tell you consistently argue in favor of law and order – subordinating “might” to “right,” and specifically by reserving force to reprisal.

I believe that this constitutes a belief in “governance” generally (and Objectivist Politics, again more specifically).

Your positions put you into conflict with belief in a “monopoly” government, but over the course of our discussions I’ve come to believe that this aspect is not necessarily an essential aspect of government, as such. After all, there is no “one world government” (as yet), yet we would hardly say that the world is therefore in a state of anarchy. There is quite a lot of “archy” to go around. The United States has its own governmental power split numerous ways across what we call “checks and balances” (and further still, with state, county and local structures, and etc.), yet we would not say that the United States is therefore anarchic. I believe that your position may possibly be cast (and fairly) as a further “balance.”

I think that if you’re agreed that the initiation of force is to be eliminated from society, that you are in philosophical agreement with Rand’s Objectivist Politics (obviously excepting her believing that a monopoly government is proper, and follows, insofar as she did). The particular organization of that government is perhaps more properly “political science,” though we can say that the organization must be consistent with the essence of the position. Just as a proper government must be funded without coercion, neither may it maintain its “monopoly” on retaliatory force through coercive means (which is to say that it has no particular monopoly).

By adopting “anarchy” for your views (and though there may be historical precedent for this; you would certainly know better than I), I think that you’re conceding that governance and a monopoly of those activities are fundamentally inseparable. I think it’s a “package” that needs to be unpacked at the least, to see if that’s really so.

 

Well sure, “government” and “anarchy,” in the sense you describe here, are both “anti-concepts” in the Randian sense of “two meanings, with the proper meaning serving to cover and to smuggle the improper one into people’s minds.” If I am rightthat sometimes by “government” Rand simply means (eg., in her official definition) “the state” (or “one monopoly agency”) and sometimes “law and order” then she is packaged-dealing governance (or law and order itself) and monopoly and is therefore guilty of question begging. Which I think she is. Most of her criticisms of anarchy are accusations of lack of law and order. Which would make sense given the above packaged-dealing. So yes, I think it’s important to unpack those.

 

So if government means

 

(1)  an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area

(2) law and order in general

 

and anarchy means

 

(1) lack of an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area

(2) lack of law and order in general

 

Then market anarchy supports government (2), but not government (1), and conversely supports anarchy (1), but not anarchy (2).

 

But, at the same time I agree that Rand’s official definition [government (1)] is the right (least confusing) one. And so, the least complicated thing to do is say government means “monopoly” and “anarchy” means “not having a government.” That’s all I mean by it when I use it.

 

Interestingly enough, I think the conflation of anarchy (1) with anarchy (2) is an example of a bad (as opposed to good in the Hayekian sense) “spontaneous order” which instead of helping to sustain the free market, helps to sustain statism.

 

(On the other hand, “anarcho-capitalism,” “market anarchism,” or even just “anarchism” or “libertarianism” is a lot simpler, and really, how are you going to get the kids to storm the barricades, so to speak, with “free-market-constitutionalist-polycentric legal order!!! Gooooo!”)

 

Also see this thread, Free markets against capitalism. And if you really wanna get interesting, see Cuzan Do We Ever Really Get Out of Anarchy? (Maybe all “government” is really “anarchy” and not the other way around??)

1 Like

hmm, I’m not sure I see the logic behind the so-called market anarchy position. sounds quite similar like anarcho-capitalism

hmm, I’m not sure I see the logic behind the so-called market anarchy position. sounds quite similar like anarcho-capitalism

The difference between the two is mostly rhetorical in nature. The term is mostly an attempt to distance the movement away from those who support free markets and capitalism in name only while supporting government controls that benefit the wealthy. 

 

Market Anarchism could refer to the more obscure types of Anarchism proposed in the 19th century by guys like Spooner and Benjamin Tucker. While supporting Markets, they had problems with certain legal ideas that were associated with property in the 19th century.  Even Proudhon can be considered a Market Anarchist because his ideas of property bordered on socialist, but he still supported voluntarism and a free market economy.  

 

In the end, the term “Anarcho-Capitalism” was coined by Rothbard, and I am pretty sure even he thought it was a mistake. He took the two words that scare everyone and put them together to name his political philosophy. 

Thank you!  =]

And another thing is that we can’t be expected to exactly blueprint a free market legal order. The same way socialists might say, “oh you want a free market in (say) shoe production. Well then, tell us how this would work?? Will there be multiple shoe designs? How many companies would there be? Would they be exclusively sales departments, or would they have production facilities attached? How many shoes must be produced per year? How many types would there be, how many colors? If you can’t answer this, then that’s a problem!”

 

Well no, we cannot say a priori how it would work. The only thing we can say is that profitibility is the standard. Maybe there will be various judges and arbitration firms who would have contracts with enforcement agencies, being separate, maybe insurance agencies will provider arbiters and have their own built-in police and security departments, who knows.

 

And sorry I’ve heard of, but I haven’t read the Heinlein book.

And the reason I asked those two questions is because I think I’ve read about what you’re describing in that book.

The gist of it was that there was this society inside the moon, where there was always an airlock within walking distance and people who went around bullying people and violating rights tended to see the opposite side of them.  This caused everyone to be the nicest and most polite people you’d ever meet.  And whenever someone needed a judge to sort something out they’d hire someone at random to arbitrate for a few hours’ salary.

Just an interesting thought.

Does anyone know of a good explanation for exactly what objectivity requires?

Does anyone know of a good explanation for exactly what objectivity requires?

Well it requires a lot of things. I think a common thread that runs through a lot of your questions is the age old principle that you cannot be a judge in your own case. From your quote I replied to before, this seems like a concern of yours. And certainly that is a principle that most people can understand and relate to. But notice that if that principle were implemented, it rules out having one single monopoly agency or government. So that scenario you described where someone is his own judge jury and executioner is the status quo.

Well actually, if you’re the victim of some crime then I think you’re THE best judge for that case.  (you already have all the evidence and know all the facts; you actually experienced it!)  But obviously, the accused can’t be the judge (who would ever find themselves guilty?) and objectivity requires that, if someone’s violated your rights, you prove it to everyone else before you punish them.  The problem I really run into is when a third party, neither criminal nor victim, steps in and tries to help.

But that would actually be applicable to the status quo because if, for instance, someone kills a cop then the government can (and does!) take matters into its own hands.  But if someone accuses the government of something then the only recourse is some other branch of the government which obviously, under the current circumstances, is somewhat less than ideal.  That’s part of why I’m partial towards “pO’ism”; if the wrong people get into power and stay in power, who defends the citizens from them?

 

I’m still not sure where I stand on the whole thing, yet.  But I do know that in order to figure that out I need a better idea of what objectivity requires and why.

Well actually, if you’re the victim of some crime then I think you’re THE best judge for that case.  (you already have all the evidence and know all the facts; you actually experienced it!)  But obviously, the accused can’t be the judge (who would ever find themselves guilty?) and objectivity requires that, if someone’s violated your rights, you prove it to everyone else before you punish them.  The problem I really run into is when a third party, neither criminal nor victim, steps in and tries to help.

 

“With injured parties judging their own cases, however, there would be a tendency for these judges to exact more than enough compensation for their damages…The former aggressors, perceiving that an injustice has been done to them, judge their own case and punish the punishers. If the injury is more than compensated for, then the aggression-overcompensation cycle could continue indefinitely. To rid themselves of this cycle, men establish independent and impartial arbitration institutions to decide cases.” -Fielding

 

Well no, we cannot say a priori how it would work.

 

Well, ok. Here’s an example from Fielding: Smith wrongs Jones. Jones hires a fair judge on the free market, and that judge finds Smith guilty. Smith doesn’t like the verdict, so he hires his brother as a judge. The brother finds Smith not guilty. What happens now? According to Fielding, Jones can “grab his shotgun and seize part of Smith’s property in compensation for Jones’s injuries.” Further, “Other members of the society may […] inflict injuries on [smith] without having to pay compensation.”

Doesn’t this sound like a step back from civilized society? 1. Jones has to personally act (err- threaten Smith with a shotgun) to get what he’s owed. (This assumes that Smith isn’t armed and ready to shoot Jones for trespassing on his property.) 2. Jones is somewhat relying on ‘society’ to be on his side and ostracize Smith. That might be realistic in a very, very small town, but I don’t see it happening anywhere else. (For instance, imagine all the robberies that happen in New York everyday. Who has time to listen to all the he-said-she-saids of a case, try to objectively determine who’s in the wrong, and ‘inflict injuries’ upon that party?)

 

Contrast this with our current court system: both parties would still get legal representation, and would have their case tried in a single court, with a single judge and jury of peers (who are not related to either party). The evidence is presented and a verdict is reached. If Smith is found guilty, he is forced to pay Jones whether he likes it or not, or he’ll go to jail. As Fielding says, “[the courts] decisions are backed by force.” This option sounds better to me, because Jones doesn’t have to worry about society being on his side, or threatening Smith with a gun. Further, even though Smith is a dirty thief, he doesn’t have to worry about everyone and their mother ‘inflicting injuries’ upon him. He is forced to pay what he owes Jones, and (theoretically) everyone can go home happy. No need for guns, or threats, or anything like that.

 

So.. what am I missing? Why do you prefer the former option?

[A]ny governmental right to any action it takes MUST come from the individuals it’s meant to defend; its citizens.

Because if there were some arcane wellspring of “Federal Authority” or something similar, for the rights of a proper (protective) government then there could exist a morally acceptable government, tasked with the safety and welfare of its citizens but authorized to use any and every means advised by its mystical source of rights.

This would result in Orwell’s 1984 and be considered moral.

 

Yes, I think what you say is true. It is important to keep in mind that only individuals exist – “government,” like “society” only referring to a collection of individuals – and the only rights which exist, or can exist, are individual rights, and belong to everyone.

 

So logically, anything the government can do, it’s morally able to do BECAUSE its citizens not only hold those same right but have given it permission to excersize them, by proxy.

 

So individuals MUST have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, necessarily.

 

Correct. If individuals did not have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, then there would be no way for any government to have such a right.

 

That’s part of why the argument I described earlier (retaliation is only moral when objective, objectivity is hard and time-consuming, delegating it is logical) would make so much sense.

 

I agree that such delegation is logical, provided that the agency to which one is delegating his right of self-defense to (in whole, or in part) is moral and objective (and provided that we understand that the individual does not thereby lose his rights). I don’t know whether I would be correct in invoking Peikoff’s essay on the “analytic/synthetic dichotomy” here, but I do not believe that it is enough to decide that “government is good, in theory; and it is logical to delegate certain rights to government” therefore one ought to delegate his rights in actuality to whatever local agency happens to currently wear the mantle of “government.”

Governments only exist as particular, actual groups of individuals. They do not each act with the force of some sort of Ideal Law, but they have actual laws on their books which may or may not be consonant with rights, with reason and reality.

 

And since must the government derive its rights from those it protects (meaning they, ultimately, hold those rights and it acts on their permission), they could conceivably revoke its permission IF it failed to perform the required function.  So a criminal couldn’t un-consent his rights back on his way to prison but, in certain cases, one person or several or the majority of the citizens could revoke their permission.

In reality, I believe that’s referred to as “revolution!”

 

Yes, absolutely, although I think that there are potentially other means of “rebellion” that stop short of outright revolution, which may or may not be feasible or prudent in a given situation. At the least, the individual can withdraw his belief that his particular government has any moral authority over him, or any authority whatever that does not come from insurmountable physical force.

Whether such a person can reasonably vest his rights to another (proper, or “more proper”) agency – or must retain them fully for himself – would depend on his actual situation, in reality. A man living in Nazi Germany might not be able to resist the government effectively on his own, and perhaps he cannot escape to better circumstances either, but neither would I say that he did not have his full right to self-defense, having ceded it to his government, or having had these rights stripped from him, because they belong to government, as such. He does not owe his government any allegiance, and should not recognize it as having any kind of legitimacy.

 

That’s the conclusion I’ve reached at this point.

A government is useful for larger societies, but ultimately unnecessary.  What IS vitally necessary is OBJECTIVITY, which is the requirement for any individual or society or government to morally use retributive force.

 

Insofar as the objective use of retributive force is proper governance, then such governance is absolutely necessary. But what we have currently – groups that claim control of force, but do not use it objectively, initiate force against their own citizens and others as a matter of routine, and call themselves “the government” – that is not the goal, the aim, or anything better than a perennially dangerous half-measure.

 

So then, I guess the only question left would be how to implement that concretely, in reality.  But I’m guessing that’s a rather sizeable question, isn’t it?

 

It’s enormous. And at the least, to begin to approach it seriously, we would need a far better culture – the citizenry would need to be generally receptive to such a thing, because it cannot be imposed from the top down and be expected to last, or work as intended.

In the meantime, I think it’s best for an individual living here and now and in these circumstances (where the majority is unlikely to wake up Objectivst tomorrow) to understand his actual relationship to his actual government, and not pretend like it is the avatar of some sort of special authority that sets it apart from any other individual or collection of individuals. Currently it is simply the gang with the most guns.

 

Well sure, “government” and “anarchy,” in the sense you describe here, are both “anti-concepts” in the Randian sense of “two meanings, with the proper meaning serving to cover and to smuggle the improper one into people’s minds.” If I am rightthat sometimes by “government” Rand simply means (eg., in her official definition) “the state” (or “one monopoly agency”) and sometimes “law and order” then she is packaged-dealing governance (or law and order itself) and monopoly and is therefore guilty of question begging. Which I think she is. Most of her criticisms of anarchy are accusations of lack of law and order. Which would make sense given the above packaged-dealing. So yes, I think it’s important to unpack those.

 

So if government means

 

(1)  an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area

(2) law and order in general

 

and anarchy means

 

(1) lack of an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area

(2) lack of law and order in general

 

Then market anarchy supports government (2), but not government (1), and conversely supports anarchy (1), but not anarchy (2).

 

But, at the same time I agree that Rand’s official definition [government (1)] is the right (least confusing) one. And so, the least complicated thing to do is say government means “monopoly” and “anarchy” means “not having a government.” That’s all I mean by it when I use it.

 

What we’re discussing here *is* largely semantics, I think. :slight_smile:

Coming at this from a layman’s position, I must confess that the first thing I associate with “anarchy” is a general lawlessness. I think my association is not uncommon. And since I know that to not be your position (at all), I guess I’m just looking for something that would be a better fit.

I wonder. Imagine a government: something similar to the United States, but the Constitution of which prohibits the initiation of the use of force, or contains the separation of state and economy, or however we’d have such a document worded to effect the Objectivist Politics in reality. Imagine now that the power to enforce this Constitution was invested equally among the citizens, in their capacity as a part of governance, so far as they enforce it in an objective manner (the details of which would be defined by the Constitution, i.e. “trial by jury” or whatever else).

How would you describe such a system? Would it be an example of a “monopoly government”? “Market Anarchy”? Would such a thing be any nearer or further away from that which you advocate?

I wonder. Imagine a government: something similar to the United States, but the Constitution of which prohibits the initiation of the use of force, or contains the separation of state and economy, or however we’d have such a document worded to effect the Objectivist Politics in reality. Imagine now that the power to enforce this Constitution was invested equally among the citizens, in their capacity as a part of governance, so far as they enforce it in an objective manner (the details of which would be defined by the Constitution, i.e. “trial by jury” or whatever else).

How would you describe such a system? Would it be an example of a “monopoly government”? “Market Anarchy”? Would such a thing be any nearer or further away from that which you advocate?

Panarchy, from pan- universal governance.

 

I’d also make this constitution fixed and immutable, though.  There are only two things it needs to prohibit, force and fraud.  All other applications are simply a matter of identifying the two when you see them and acting accordingly.

So I wouldn’t even give the unwashed masses any mechanism for creating new laws.  If you don’t like something that someone’s doing- prove exactly how it harms you or get over it.

Panarchy, from pan- universal governance.

 

“Panarchy”?

That’s… pretty brilliant, actually.

“With injured parties judging their own cases, however, there would be a tendency for these judges to exact more than enough compensation for their damages…The former aggressors, perceiving that an injustice has been done to them, judge their own case and punish the punishers. If the injury is more than compensated for, then the aggression-overcompensation cycle could continue indefinitely. To rid themselves of this cycle, men establish independent and impartial arbitration institutions to decide cases.” -Fielding

 

 

Well, ok. Here’s an example from Fielding: Smith wrongs Jones. Jones hires a fair judge on the free market, and that judge finds Smith guilty. Smith doesn’t like the verdict, so he hires his brother as a judge. The brother finds Smith not guilty. What happens now? According to Fielding, Jones can “grab his shotgun and seize part of Smith’s property in compensation for Jones’s injuries.” Further, “Other members of the society may […] inflict injuries on [smith] without having to pay compensation.”

Doesn’t this sound like a step back from civilized society? 1. Jones has to personally act (err- threaten Smith with a shotgun) to get what he’s owed. (This assumes that Smith isn’t armed and ready to shoot Jones for trespassing on his property.) 2. Jones is somewhat relying on ‘society’ to be on his side and ostracize Smith. That might be realistic in a very, very small town, but I don’t see it happening anywhere else. (For instance, imagine all the robberies that happen in New York everyday. Who has time to listen to all the he-said-she-saids of a case, try to objectively determine who’s in the wrong, and ‘inflict injuries’ upon that party?)

 

Contrast this with our current court system: both parties would still get legal representation, and would have their case tried in a single court, with a single judge and jury of peers (who are not related to either party). The evidence is presented and a verdict is reached. If Smith is found guilty, he is forced to pay Jones whether he likes it or not, or he’ll go to jail. As Fielding says, “[the courts] decisions are backed by force.” This option sounds better to me, because Jones doesn’t have to worry about society being on his side, or threatening Smith with a gun. Further, even though Smith is a dirty thief, he doesn’t have to worry about everyone and their mother ‘inflicting injuries’ upon him. He is forced to pay what he owes Jones, and (theoretically) everyone can go home happy. No need for guns, or threats, or anything like that.

 

So.. what am I missing? Why do you prefer the former option?

Well I mean, I don’t prefer that. Again, I don’t think that all anarchies are necessarily libertarian. This just sounds like the same worries about vigilantism that HD had. Like I said to HD earlier, I think what you’re worring about can be boiled down to the age-old principle of objective law that “you cannot be a judge in your own case.”

 

So no, you shouldn’t be allowed to “grab your shotgun” and settle things yourself, or allowed to get your brother to rule in your favor. My point is that vigilantism is an initiation of force because it violates procedural rights. We sometimes tend to think of rights violations in terms of who, in a dispute, is metaphysically the victim and who is metaphysically the aggressor. Which one, in fact, committed a rights-violation? Or not? But the point is, as per the thread I linked on vigilantism, the answer to that isn’t perceptually self-evident. So, on top of a person’s indivudal rights, in the sense of their right to person and property, we assert that people also have certain “procedural rights,” such as a right to have one’s guilt or innocence determined by a reliable epistemological procedure. It is not enough that a person be, in fact, metaphysically guilty, but that those inflicting the sentence must know he is guilty and prove it with just legal procedures. So, I would assert, no one has a right to inflict any retaliatory force otherwise, but note that none of this allows us to infer one single monopoly agency. (Such was the attempt of Robert Nozick, but unlike Objectivists who just tend to treat it as a self-evident assertion, he actually provided an argument for it, albiet an unsuccessful one.)

 

But anyway just think about it from a practical point of view, as I have been saying before with my points of “Rambo-style” self-enforcement, the community is not going to like anyone doing such things anyway, regardless of the fact that it violates procedural rights. No one is going to stand for someone just unilaterally saying hey that Smith guy is a criminal, I’m certain, so I’m gonna just “grab my shotgun” and get a bunch of my buddies and just break down his door and start doing whatever dispensing of justice I see fit. That’s not a neighborly thing to do, your employer’s not gonna like that, your insurance company is going to hear of your aggressive behavior and say, hey we heard your breaking down doors with shotgun in hand, I mean what the heck are you doing, it’s just not smart to do that. So rather than do something like that, it’s just better from a practical standpoint to have a professional agency come in, who are trained and equipped, who have non-lethal means to restrain and arrest someone, who aren’t going to come in with guns blazing and escalate the situation.

 

And the same for the Smith side in your story. If Smith just goes to get his brother or uncle or friend or whatever to rule on a case, I mean, who in the community is going to accept such a verdict? I mean this is pretty obviously non-objective. The same enforcement agency is not just gonna go, oh hey, you got your brother to rule on the case, that’s good enough for us, regulators mount up! Again, that wouldn’t be smart obviously, so they would say hey, you have to appeal through generally accepted legal channels, you have to follow the law, you have to bring us an opinion from a reputable and neutral judge or set of judges overturning the Jones decision, or whatever, before we will act on your behalf. And the same for Jones. Then the legal community comes to a consensus as to whether or not this particular case is decided in Jones or Smith’s favor.

Yes, I think what you say is true. It is important to keep in mind that only individuals exist – “government,” like “society” only referring to a collection of individuals – and the only rights which exist, or can exist, are individual rights, and belong to everyone.

 

 

Correct. If individuals did not have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, then there would be no way for any government to have such a right.

 

 

I agree that such delegation is logical, provided that the agency to which one is delegating his right of self-defense to (in whole, or in part) is moral and objective (and provided that we understand that the individual does not thereby lose his rights). I don’t know whether I would be correct in invoking Peikoff’s essay on the “analytic/synthetic dichotomy” here, but I do not believe that it is enough to decide that “government is good, in theory; and it is logical to delegate certain rights to government” therefore one ought to delegate his rights in actuality to whatever local agency happens to currently wear the mantle of “government.”

Governments only exist as particular, actual groups of individuals. They do not each act with the force of some sort of Ideal Law, but they have actual laws on their books which may or may not be consonant with rights, with reason and reality.

 

 

Yes, absolutely, although I think that there are potentially other means of “rebellion” that stop short of outright revolution, which may or may not be feasible or prudent in a given situation. At the least, the individual can withdraw his belief that his particular government has any moral authority over him, or any authority whatever that does not come from insurmountable physical force.

Whether such a person can reasonably vest his rights to another (proper, or “more proper”) agency – or must retain them fully for himself – would depend on his actual situation, in reality. A man living in Nazi Germany might not be able to resist the government effectively on his own, and perhaps he cannot escape to better circumstances either, but neither would I say that he did not have his full right to self-defense, having ceded it to his government, or having had these rights stripped from him, because they belong to government, as such. He does not owe his government any allegiance, and should not recognize it as having any kind of legitimacy.

 

 

Insofar as the objective use of retributive force is proper governance, then such governance is absolutely necessary. But what we have currently – groups that claim control of force, but do not use it objectively, initiate force against their own citizens and others as a matter of routine, and call themselves “the government” – that is not the goal, the aim, or anything better than a perennially dangerous half-measure.

 

 

It’s enormous. And at the least, to begin to approach it seriously, we would need a far better culture – the citizenry would need to be generally receptive to such a thing, because it cannot be imposed from the top down and be expected to last, or work as intended.

In the meantime, I think it’s best for an individual living here and now and in these circumstances (where the majority is unlikely to wake up Objectivst tomorrow) to understand his actual relationship to his actual government, and not pretend like it is the avatar of some sort of special authority that sets it apart from any other individual or collection of individuals. Currently it is simply the gang with the most guns.

 

 

What we’re discussing here *is* largely semantics, I think. :slight_smile:

Coming at this from a layman’s position, I must confess that the first thing I associate with “anarchy” is a general lawlessness. I think my association is not uncommon. And since I know that to not be your position (at all), I guess I’m just looking for something that would be a better fit.

I wonder. Imagine a government: something similar to the United States, but the Constitution of which prohibits the initiation of the use of force, or contains the separation of state and economy, or however we’d have such a document worded to effect the Objectivist Politics in reality. Imagine now that the power to enforce this Constitution was invested equally among the citizens, in their capacity as a part of governance, so far as they enforce it in an objective manner (the details of which would be defined by the Constitution, i.e. “trial by jury” or whatever else).

How would you describe such a system? Would it be an example of a “monopoly government”? “Market Anarchy”? Would such a thing be any nearer or further away from that which you advocate?

Yeah sure, people always say “aww that’s just semantics!” as if it’s a bad thing, but a lot of disputes come down to different interpretations of the meanings of words.

 

My view on what you describe with the constitution is that it would be largely symbolic, but carry no real effect whatsoever. As I have pointed out before, there’s a strange objectivist obsession with written constitutions, as if having things written on a piece of paper “codifies” it. HD speaks of “mak[ing] this constitution fixed and immutable.” Well, how are you gonna do that? So long as people have free will, as objectivists think they do, then there is nothing on god’s green earth that you can do to “make” it fixed and immutable. So, while paper guarantees of rights may have symbolic value, they are neither necessary (look at Britain) nor sufficient (look at Soviet Russia) to count as actual constitutional structure. What does count in terms of constitutional structure, is the actual institutions and patterns that people arrange themselves into.