[A]ny governmental right to any action it takes MUST come from the individuals it’s meant to defend; its citizens.
Because if there were some arcane wellspring of “Federal Authority” or something similar, for the rights of a proper (protective) government then there could exist a morally acceptable government, tasked with the safety and welfare of its citizens but authorized to use any and every means advised by its mystical source of rights.
This would result in Orwell’s 1984 and be considered moral.
Yes, I think what you say is true. It is important to keep in mind that only individuals exist – “government,” like “society” only referring to a collection of individuals – and the only rights which exist, or can exist, are individual rights, and belong to everyone.
So logically, anything the government can do, it’s morally able to do BECAUSE its citizens not only hold those same right but have given it permission to excersize them, by proxy.
So individuals MUST have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, necessarily.
Correct. If individuals did not have the right to the use of objective retaliatory force, then there would be no way for any government to have such a right.
That’s part of why the argument I described earlier (retaliation is only moral when objective, objectivity is hard and time-consuming, delegating it is logical) would make so much sense.
I agree that such delegation is logical, provided that the agency to which one is delegating his right of self-defense to (in whole, or in part) is moral and objective (and provided that we understand that the individual does not thereby lose his rights). I don’t know whether I would be correct in invoking Peikoff’s essay on the “analytic/synthetic dichotomy” here, but I do not believe that it is enough to decide that “government is good, in theory; and it is logical to delegate certain rights to government” therefore one ought to delegate his rights in actuality to whatever local agency happens to currently wear the mantle of “government.”
Governments only exist as particular, actual groups of individuals. They do not each act with the force of some sort of Ideal Law, but they have actual laws on their books which may or may not be consonant with rights, with reason and reality.
And since must the government derive its rights from those it protects (meaning they, ultimately, hold those rights and it acts on their permission), they could conceivably revoke its permission IF it failed to perform the required function. So a criminal couldn’t un-consent his rights back on his way to prison but, in certain cases, one person or several or the majority of the citizens could revoke their permission.
In reality, I believe that’s referred to as “revolution!”
Yes, absolutely, although I think that there are potentially other means of “rebellion” that stop short of outright revolution, which may or may not be feasible or prudent in a given situation. At the least, the individual can withdraw his belief that his particular government has any moral authority over him, or any authority whatever that does not come from insurmountable physical force.
Whether such a person can reasonably vest his rights to another (proper, or “more proper”) agency – or must retain them fully for himself – would depend on his actual situation, in reality. A man living in Nazi Germany might not be able to resist the government effectively on his own, and perhaps he cannot escape to better circumstances either, but neither would I say that he did not have his full right to self-defense, having ceded it to his government, or having had these rights stripped from him, because they belong to government, as such. He does not owe his government any allegiance, and should not recognize it as having any kind of legitimacy.
That’s the conclusion I’ve reached at this point.
A government is useful for larger societies, but ultimately unnecessary. What IS vitally necessary is OBJECTIVITY, which is the requirement for any individual or society or government to morally use retributive force.
Insofar as the objective use of retributive force is proper governance, then such governance is absolutely necessary. But what we have currently – groups that claim control of force, but do not use it objectively, initiate force against their own citizens and others as a matter of routine, and call themselves “the government” – that is not the goal, the aim, or anything better than a perennially dangerous half-measure.
So then, I guess the only question left would be how to implement that concretely, in reality. But I’m guessing that’s a rather sizeable question, isn’t it?
It’s enormous. And at the least, to begin to approach it seriously, we would need a far better culture – the citizenry would need to be generally receptive to such a thing, because it cannot be imposed from the top down and be expected to last, or work as intended.
In the meantime, I think it’s best for an individual living here and now and in these circumstances (where the majority is unlikely to wake up Objectivst tomorrow) to understand his actual relationship to his actual government, and not pretend like it is the avatar of some sort of special authority that sets it apart from any other individual or collection of individuals. Currently it is simply the gang with the most guns.
Well sure, “government” and “anarchy,” in the sense you describe here, are both “anti-concepts” in the Randian sense of “two meanings, with the proper meaning serving to cover and to smuggle the improper one into people’s minds.” If I am rightthat sometimes by “government” Rand simply means (eg., in her official definition) “the state” (or “one monopoly agency”) and sometimes “law and order” then she is packaged-dealing governance (or law and order itself) and monopoly and is therefore guilty of question begging. Which I think she is. Most of her criticisms of anarchy are accusations of lack of law and order. Which would make sense given the above packaged-dealing. So yes, I think it’s important to unpack those.
So if government means
(1) an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area
(2) law and order in general
and anarchy means
(1) lack of an institution that holds the exclusive (monopoly) power to enforce certain rules of social conduct in a given geographical area
(2) lack of law and order in general
Then market anarchy supports government (2), but not government (1), and conversely supports anarchy (1), but not anarchy (2).
But, at the same time I agree that Rand’s official definition [government (1)] is the right (least confusing) one. And so, the least complicated thing to do is say government means “monopoly” and “anarchy” means “not having a government.” That’s all I mean by it when I use it.
What we’re discussing here *is* largely semantics, I think. 
Coming at this from a layman’s position, I must confess that the first thing I associate with “anarchy” is a general lawlessness. I think my association is not uncommon. And since I know that to not be your position (at all), I guess I’m just looking for something that would be a better fit.
I wonder. Imagine a government: something similar to the United States, but the Constitution of which prohibits the initiation of the use of force, or contains the separation of state and economy, or however we’d have such a document worded to effect the Objectivist Politics in reality. Imagine now that the power to enforce this Constitution was invested equally among the citizens, in their capacity as a part of governance, so far as they enforce it in an objective manner (the details of which would be defined by the Constitution, i.e. “trial by jury” or whatever else).
How would you describe such a system? Would it be an example of a “monopoly government”? “Market Anarchy”? Would such a thing be any nearer or further away from that which you advocate?