Anarchy's objective obliteration

Yeah sure, people always say “aww that’s just semantics!” as if it’s a bad thing, but a lot of disputes come down to different interpretations of the meanings of words.

 

Yes, that’s right. And when you’re arguing for courts, rule of law, the reservation of force to retaliation, objective procedural rights, and etc., I believe that you are arguing for a form of government. Not a monopoly government – not in this case – but government nonetheless. Which is primarily why I believe that “anarchy” is a poor descriptor.

I think that when you use the term “anarchy,” you can rely on being misunderstood by nearly everybody as to your actual position.

 

My view on what you describe with the constitution is that it would be largely symbolic, but carry no real effect whatsoever. As I have pointed out before, there’s a strange objectivist obsession with written constitutions, as if having things written on a piece of paper “codifies” it.

 

Hmm. Well, strictly I think it does"codify," does it not?

But I don’t think I’d be interested in a Constitution out of an “obsession,” strange or otherwise, and I don’t find that interpretation to be very charitable. I think that if you’re going to set up a system (of government, or anything), it is helpful to know the principles that you mean to adhere to. And should you expect to work in concert with others, it is also a means of communicating your intentions to them. I think that for these (not particularly “obsessive”) reasons, countries enact constitutions or other charters, as do businesses and churches; teachers construct rubrics, syllabi; people form mission statements, and etc.

None of this “binds” us magically to do the right thing, or whatever it is we’ve intended, but neither do I think that makes it useless. If the Constitution of the United States is “largely symbolic,” that may be so, but such symbols themselves can have real effects, and I think that the Constitution has given real shape to the direction of the country. If you say that such a thing is “neither necessary nor sufficient,” to protect rights, that’s true. But neither is anything else of itself – no structure you’d devise can guarantee that rights will be upheld into the future; all depends on the actual people involved, their understanding and ultimately their actions.

But framing such a Constitution would still be a first step towards the development of those institutions and procedural safeguards that would, hopefully, allow the system its best fighting chance against whim and passion.

HD speaks of “mak[ing] this constitution fixed and immutable.” Well, how are you gonna do that? So long as people have free will, as objectivists think they do, then there is nothing on god’s green earth that you can do to “make” it fixed and immutable.

Yeah, and there’s nothing whatsoever forcing anyone to adhere to any laws, whatsoever.  People are going to ultimately do whatever they want to do.

The only point to that would be to ensure that IF people want to live properly and IF they want to govern themselves, there’s an explicit and concrete set of rules already laid out for how to do that.

And the only point to making it fixed and immutable would be so that a collectivist majority couldn’t start rewriting it at will.

Here’s a different example, one that is more realistic and that will work better under your terms:

 

Smith is in a relationship with Jones’ daughter. Smith kills the daughter a few days after he finds out she was cheating on him. Jones is pissed. He hires a judge who finds Smith guilty of murder, and Smith is sentenced to death. Now of course Smith doesn’t like this ruling. He hires a judge who doesn’t believe in the death penalty, and this judge also finds him guilty but sentences him to prison for a number of years. Both judges sit down and try to reach a consensus, but they both stick to their original verdicts and sentencing beliefs. So again, we’re at a deadlock. What happens now?:

 

…Then the legal community comes to a consensus as to whether or not this particular case is decided in Jones or Smith’s favor.

 

Ok… so we’re relying on the ‘legal community’ to come to a consensus (ie: reach a final verdict and determine sentencing) that Jones and Smith must accept? How is this any different than our current legal system, where we have a judge and jury who reach a verdict that Jones and Smith must accept? The only difference I see is that in the former, we have multiple judges sitting around a fire trying to reach a consensus (which couldn’t even be reached between just 2 judges), whereas in the latter we only have one judge and a jury of peers.

 

The former isn’t better just because there’s a bunch of judges deciding the fate of Smith- which, by the way, doesn’t make the verdict or sentencing any more objective- it’s just messier.

Here’s a different example, one that is more realistic and that will work better under your terms:

 

Smith is in a relationship with Jones’ daughter. Smith kills the daughter a few days after he finds out she was cheating on him. Jones is pissed. He hires a judge who finds Smith guilty of murder, and Smith is sentenced to death. Now of course Smith doesn’t like this ruling. He hires a judge who doesn’t believe in the death penalty, and this judge also finds him guilty but sentences him to prison for a number of years. Both judges sit down and try to reach a consensus, but they both stick to their original verdicts and sentencing beliefs. So again, we’re at a deadlock. What happens now?:

 

 

Ok… so we’re relying on the ‘legal community’ to come to a consensus (ie: reach a final verdict and determine sentencing) that Jones and Smith must accept? How is this any different than our current legal system, where we have a judge and jury who reach a verdict that Jones and Smith must accept? The only difference I see is that in the former, we have multiple judges sitting around a fire trying to reach a consensus (which couldn’t even be reached between just 2 judges), whereas in the latter we only have one judge and a jury of peers.

 

The former isn’t better just because there’s a bunch of judges deciding the fate of Smith- which, by the way, doesn’t make the verdict or sentencing any more objective- it’s just messier.

 

   The two judges thing doesn’t seem realistic. To get anything done in society you would have to subscribe to one of these agencies before hand. Someone who doesn’t subscribe to any laws would not be hired at a job, let into school, or allowed to have a bank account. 

 

   So there wouldn’t be two judges. There would be a single judge that their two agencies agreed was fair. 

 

  On punishment -

 

  A voluntarist society would most likely avoid the death penalty for all but the worst crimes. A man taking it upon himself to kill someone better have an extremely large amount of proof that he can show to the community, otherwise he may end up on trial for murder. 

 

 If someone looses a case, their company has to pay for their damages. This makes them a liability to their company. If a criminal wants to get on good terms with his company, he will need to live under conditions of their choosing. Thus the jail sentence would essentially send them to a place where they can work off their debts in peace and away from society. If they refuse to go to jail, they will become an outlaw, with no way of surviving. 

“Panarchy”?

That’s… pretty brilliant, actually.

Interesting to point out that this term has actually been used before historically. As far as we can know, the first theoritician of market anarchy is the Belgian liberal economist Gustave de Molinari. He did not call himself an anarchist, as the term was reserved for communists at the time. He had made the remark famously (in his day):

 

“Thus it is that, instead of absorbing the organism of society according to the revolutionary and communist conception, the municipality and the State are dissolved into this organism. … The future thus belongs neither to the absorption of society by the State, as the communists and collectivists suppose, nor to the suppression of the State, as the anarchists and nihilists dream, but to the diffusion of the State within society.”

 

The term “panarchy” was first used by the Molinari follower, Paul Emile de Puydt in his essay of the same title.

Here’s a different example, one that is more realistic and that will work better under your terms:

 

Smith is in a relationship with Jones’ daughter. Smith kills the daughter a few days after he finds out she was cheating on him. Jones is pissed. He hires a judge who finds Smith guilty of murder, and Smith is sentenced to death. Now of course Smith doesn’t like this ruling. He hires a judge who doesn’t believe in the death penalty, and this judge also finds him guilty but sentences him to prison for a number of years. Both judges sit down and try to reach a consensus, but they both stick to their original verdicts and sentencing beliefs. So again, we’re at a deadlock. What happens now?:

 

 

Ok… so we’re relying on the ‘legal community’ to come to a consensus (ie: reach a final verdict and determine sentencing) that Jones and Smith must accept? How is this any different than our current legal system, where we have a judge and jury who reach a verdict that Jones and Smith must accept? The only difference I see is that in the former, we have multiple judges sitting around a fire trying to reach a consensus (which couldn’t even be reached between just 2 judges), whereas in the latter we only have one judge and a jury of peers.

 

The former isn’t better just because there’s a bunch of judges deciding the fate of Smith- which, by the way, doesn’t make the verdict or sentencing any more objective- it’s just messier.

Okay there’s two points I see here. One is “how is this [consensus-finding] any different than our current legal system?” and the other is “isn’t this just messier?”

 

Well on the first question, it’s true that, in that regard, it isn’t any different. And that’s why this quest for a mythical “final arbiter” is wrong headed, because there is no such thing, not in the current system and not in market anarchy. The aspect that it is different in, is the absence of monopoly.

 

You say that it “doesn’t make the verdict or sentencing any more objective,” but I fear you have misapprehended the point. The point is not that a given legal process might be somehow more objective in anarchy than the exact same legal process under the current system. If a legal process is objective, then it’s objective. But the point is which system has a superior political structure for ensuring objective legal legal processes are arrived at, and ensuring they are kept. And it is that respect that I think market anarchy is superior to both the current political structure and limited government.

 

Now you ask if the free market version just isn’t messier? Well what is meant by “messy?”

 

First is to remember that your example makes it seem like this “deadlock” just sort of happened out of the blue. One legal opinion says executions are A-OK, the other says life is the max. Boom, what now? Well it’s not like no one could see this coming, there will be a vast network of interlocking arbitration agreements that will be in place prior to any such trial or case begins such that people getting involved will know what the stakes are. Practices will already be hammered out and known beforehand (and I see this is the gist of Hairnet’s post.) So if “messy” translates to “uncertainty,” then this is unlikely.

 

Also it’s not as if debates over the legitimacy of the death penalty don’t occur already, so I can return to you “how is that different than the current system?” The answer can be “but we have ways of dealing with it under the current system,” but again, so do we under market anarchy, and the question is then which system has better incentives for dealing with such disagreements over conflicting views of justice in a way that is (1) peaceful, and (2) consistent with individual rights? Is monopoly better for that?

 

So if you’re saying that people are peaceful enough to just agree and be like, well I’m all for executions, and you’re against them, but hey, I’ll agree not to do violence against you, and you agree to disagree peacefully with me, and we’ll just organize these occasional elections, and we’ll all agree to abide by the results as long as it’s fair… if you’re saying that people are peaceful enough to do that, then why wouldn’t the exact same people also be capable of solving it in a free market order, just without all the bad consequences that come along with democracy and monopoly?

 

But I think that, in some sense, “messy”  may simply mean “decentralized,” then I disagree that this is a gripe, rather than a positive thing. And this might go back to your post on the necessity of state laws, but Objectivists seem to have this overly rosy (to say the least) view of government and centralization. If we Objectivists can just get in control of government, then we can be a benign protector of individual rights, that an Objectivist government ought to have central control and “final say” of all legal disputes. Anything involving a decentralized “judge found” or non legislative legal system, or even the federalism of having fifty state policies, strikes Objectivists as too “messy.” It’s just not neat! The belief seems to be that a central legal body should have the authority for a final say, even if it gets it wrong. But again, I question whether such a “final arbiter” is even possible, and I question whether a centralized system of legislative law is really compatible with the values a free market system is supposed to uphold such as separation of powers, checks and balances, and respect for individual rights (one can consult the “state law” thread for my comments.)

If objective law is to be the final arbiter of rights violations and civil disputes, doesn’t that make it(law) a monopoly power? I doubt anyone would agrue that civilised society could exist without objective law and institutions that are designed to preserve it. Market anarchy or quasi-autonomous polylegal systems or arguements for them seem to come from the idea that a profit can be derived from their adminstration of ‘justice’. But isn’t the protections provided for by such agencies necessarily all cost , pure consumption ? How could any agency or institution perform any of the required actions on a profit motive? Is there profit in crime?

By ‘messy’ I just meant that more people are involved in reaching a verdict.

 

First is to remember that your example makes it seem like this “deadlock” just sort of happened out of the blue. One legal opinion says executions are A-OK, the other says life is the max. Boom, what now? Well it’s not like no one could see this coming, there will be a vast network of interlocking arbitration agreements that will be in place prior to any such trial or case begins such that people getting involved will know what the stakes ar e. Practices will already be hammered out and known beforehand (and I see this is the gist of Hairnet’s post.) So if “messy” translates to “uncertainty,” then this is unlikely.

 

This is something I haven’t seen mentioned- I’m going to come back to this once I’ve read more about market anarchy’s actual implementation (which is not described in much detail in the pdfs you linked to in the other thread. Maybe a Rothbard book will do a better job.)

I realized something earlier that I haven’t seen anyone else mention, yet.  And it could be the simplest and most singularly damning refutation of anarchism out there, unless I’m mistaken somewhere in it.  (it prompted my own realization that anarchy actually isn’t proper to man’s life)

So is this accurate?

 

To clarify briefly, I’m talking about a very specific variety of anarchism which is identical to O’ism in metaphysics, epistemology and ethics, but obviously not politics.  (like Roy Childs)  I’ll call it proto-Objectivism; abbreviated pO’ism.

Someone would reach the conclusion of pO’ism by an irrational surplus of optimism, a touch of epistemological sloppiness and utter ignorance to the meaning and purpose of objectivity, as it applies to politics and a society.  (at least those; there may be more)

For myself it was really, literal ignorance.  When I read about “objective laws” and the “objective use of retaliatory force” I thought it meant objective, as in true-to-reality and rational. It’s taken me two days just to wrap my mind around the actual meaning of it.

But I digress.  Ayn Rand’s philosophy, (to the best of my knowledge) without any concept of POLITICAL objectivity and distorted thusly (it’s really not a very large or noticeable perversion) would logically lead one to pO’ism.  Hence the name, proto-Objectivism; a stunted little philosophy which was/ is attempting to become Objectivism, but hasn’t made it there yet.

So that’s my terminology and that’s the difference between the two.  There appear to be quite a few threads on this forum, usually debating the necessity of a government, in which the anarchists are implicitly referring to pO’ism.  And that’s also the kicker because the subtle misrepresentations and that one little deletion are readily visible whenever they discuss retributive force.

You know what I’m referring to.

And the usual Objectivist objections to it are true (it would lead to endless feuding and bloodshed), but without that crucial concept it’s very easy to chalk that up to irrational people doing stupid things, or any number of other personal flaws, and dismiss it altogether.  Without that concept, even if one was shown conclusive proof that wholesale slaughter would ensue, it would still feel like a betrayal to concede the point; it seems far more like the moral-practical false dichotomy, and someone who thinks that human beings are good enough simply govern themselves isn’t likely to abandon his morals in the name of the practical.  (hence the endless, volumous threads already devoted to this argument, in which nobody convinces anyone of anything)

 

But what I realized this morning was that not only WOULD bloodshed ensue, but in a pO’ist society it SHOULD!!  In any case of ambiguous legality, wholesale slaughter would result, not from human flaws or vices, but from their VIRTUES!!!

 

Imagine a hypothetical pO’ist society in which almost every member holds that same philosophy explicitly and attempts to practice it, in reality, on Earth.  There is no government.  The people defend their own rights and when they’re violated they avenge their own rights, without trials or supervision.

One morning in pO’ville, Adam goes outside to get his newspaper when he notices someone talking to his neighbor, Bob, on his doorstep.  He can’t help but overhear the stranger’s vague remarks about bad things happening to good people’s homes.

The stranger is actually a man named Charlie, who sells home insurance door-to-door.  But Adam has no way of knowing that at this point.

When Bob hands Charlie a thick wad of cash the salesman enters his address into a database on his smartphone, thus insuring him.

Adam sees the transaction and, due to it’s shady overtones and Bob’s history, immediately realizes that he is witnessing an act of extortion.  Acting as the defender of Bob’s rights he pulls out a gun and shoots Charlie in the leg, before running over and returning Bob’s cash.  (Bob, the only immoral citizen in pO’ville, thanks his neighbor profusely)

At that moment Dan, a competing salesman who was canvassing one street over, runs over to investigate the screaming from several seconds prior.  Seeing Charlie lying in a pool of his own blood and perfectly still (passed out from pain/trauma) he whips out his blowgun and fires a poison dart at Adam.

Adam dies promptly.  Dan walks over to Bob and asks him what happened; Bob explains to him that Adam had stolen all of his priceless porcelain and hidden it in his house and, when confronted by Charlie, had shot him where he stood.  Dan, true to his ruthless dedication to justice, helps Bob retrieve his “stolen” belongings.

 

And so, in a society like that:

-Adam dies horribly, because he attempted to stop injustice from occurring

-Dan, for the same reasons as Adam, commits murder and theft and later has a bounty placed on him by Adam’s wife

-Charlie is wounded and robbed in the street for no reason whatsoever

-Bob becomes much richer for the entire episode, because of his treachery

 

I probably could’ve come up with better examples, but whatever.  The point is that not only would anarchy proliferate pillaging and slaughter; it would specifically do the most damage to the most virtuous!!

 

If person A kills C in self-defense, and B witnesses the act (but misinterprets it as murder) he SHOULD, by the pO’ist logic, punish A himself.  If he attacks him but A sees him coming in advance, then A should kill B in self-defense (again) and B should kill A to avenge C.

So A should kill B AND B should kill A.  In which, regardless of the outcome, justice and injustice will be enacted.

 

So anyway, I’m not sure what to make of this.  Is there something to that?

 

 

how is a government going to prevent such misunderstanding?

this situation can easily happen with or without government.

 

all a government could do is make a judgement in the aftermath, not prevent these events from happening.

a government does not neccicarily even need to give a different judgement than private companies providing the same services.

how is a government going to prevent such misunderstanding?

this situation can easily happen with or without government.

It could.  It’s much more likely to happen without one, but it could always happen in any group of people.

 

I’m actually still not quite sure where I stand on it, yet.  I’ve realized that before jumping into politics as if I automatically understand it (which was something I actually hadn’t stopped to question until after I started this thread) I need to sit down and formulate it explicitly, first.

Not that Rand needs reformulating at all, but there’s enough ambiguity between the big points that I need to work it out for myself to see why she reached her conclusions and what it all stands on.

(Individual rights are the starting point, individuals cannot be allowed to avenge themselves is towards the end. . . I think there are some very specific and very important things between there that I’ve missed, along the way)

 

At the time I wrote this I had my own idea of the perfect society (or as perfect as human beings could live in) and I realized that it would hurt people according to their effort towards supporting it and reward the people who didn’t.  But at this point I’m really not sure what this applies to, if anything at all.

 

I’m still working on it.

The anarchists want anarchy because they want to choose the protective agency who they agree with the most or who they think is the most just rather than being forced to live under a centralized government and its interpretation of justice.  The thing is, if there are all these different protective groups all operating under different rules, there will be some who actually get justice right and then there will be those who are not “rights respecting” groups.  If it happened in the U.S. it is just as if they U.S. has now been split into however many smaller countries.  People act as if under such a system there would be no jurisdiction and you have recourse to hire any group you want to defend you in a court case or so forth.  It would be like if Billy Hayes from “Midnight Express”, who got caught smuggling dope in Turkey could have just hired the U.S. to try his case instead of Turkey.  It doesn’t seem likely to me that the different groups would allow an agency with different rules to infringe on whatever boarders they operate on.  The enforcing agencies couldn’t be bodies of law with no physical delineated borders.  I think almost by definition a body of law has to have physical borders in which the laws apply absolutely.  Otherwise if they all had different rules how would you ever know, dealing with a given individual who subscribes to an agency you’re not familiar with, how you are allowed to interact with him?  If the different groups didn’t have physically defined borders they would be constantly clashing everywhere due to their different rules.  Governing bodies cannot just insert themselves and their rulings into areas they don’t physically control, that’s the definition of war.  I am assuming the rules would vary to a degree that this would become a problem or else why would you want this anarchy to begin with if all the agencies had practically the same rules?—it would be cheaper and more efficient to collapse them into one if that were the case just like mergers with businesses.

 

Consider what would happen when other countries begin to come in and try to take over when we have disparate disorganized agencies.  Or better yet, how would we ever deliver a preemptive blow to a country we saw as a threat with these small agencies, they would all have to come together and reach an agreement but what if enough agencies have rules that don’t allow for that? 

 

As other people have already pointed out, in a certain sense this anarchy already exists in the world at large.  You can go live under a different “protective agency” by moving to a different country.  Turning the U.S. into this anarchy just fractionates and dissolves us into smaller, weaker countries.

DonAthos said # 36

 

Governments only exist as particular, actual groups of individuals.

 

 

What do you mean by this? The US constitution is a particular actual group of individuals? Or do you mean the functions of government are carried out by particular actualr individuals , and that they may or may not adhere to the principles of a ‘governemnt’? Is it not possible to have a ‘government’, a principled moral foundation for the conduct of human interaction, adhered to be individuals?

 

Earlier in the same post you stated that ‘government’ should be seen as a collection of individuals in the same why ‘society’ refers to individuals. I think this a non sequitor, in that society as a concept has no referent other than the relation of individuals to individuals( those who live in geographic proximity and follow similar cultures and customs), but government refers to (at least in LFC) to a set of principles that conduct interactions between individuals. The fact in reality individuals will have to function within the dictates of government to facilitate its role , does not mean the individuals have the legitimate right to change or alter those dictates, the fact that individuals may at times abuse or ignore those strictures does not mean they do not exist , or that government does not have a referent other than that which ‘society’ has akin to individuals. 

The anarchists want anarchy because they want to choose the protective agency who they agree with the most or who they think is the most just rather than being forced to live under a centralized government and its interpretation of justice.  The thing is, if there are all these different protective groups all operating under different rules, there will be some who actually get justice right and then there will be those who are not “rights respecting” groups.  If it happened in the U.S. it is just as if they U.S. has now been split into however many smaller countries.  People act as if under such a system there would be no jurisdiction and you have recourse to hire any group you want to defend you in a court case or so forth.  It would be like if Billy Hayes from “Midnight Express”, who got caught smuggling dope in Turkey could have just hired the U.S. to try his case instead of Turkey.  It doesn’t seem likely to me that the different groups would allow an agency with different rules to infringe on whatever boarders they operate on.  The enforcing agencies couldn’t be bodies of law with no physical delineated borders.  I think almost by definition a body of law has to have physical borders in which the laws apply absolutely.  Otherwise if they all had different rules how would you ever know, dealing with a given individual who subscribes to an agency you’re not familiar with, how you are allowed to interact with him?  If the different groups didn’t have physically defined borders they would be constantly clashing everywhere due to their different rules.  Governing bodies cannot just insert themselves and their rulings into areas they don’t physically control, that’s the definition of war.  I am assuming the rules would vary to a degree that this would become a problem or else why would you want this anarchy to begin with if all the agencies had practically the same rules?—it would be cheaper and more efficient to collapse them into one if that were the case just like mergers with businesses.

 

Consider what would happen when other countries begin to come in and try to take over when we have disparate disorganized agencies.  Or better yet, how would we ever deliver a preemptive blow to a country we saw as a threat with these small agencies, they would all have to come together and reach an agreement but what if enough agencies have rules that don’t allow for that? 

 

As other people have already pointed out, in a certain sense this anarchy already exists in the world at large.  You can go live under a different “protective agency” by moving to a different country.  Turning the U.S. into this anarchy just fractionates and dissolves us into smaller, weaker countries.

 

 You should have bothered to read this very thread or the gallons of articles on these topics. Really do some research instead of acting like this is the first time these objections have been raised.  Here are some articles written on these issues by Roderick Long. These would be a good place to start if you are looking for responses to your questions. 

 

  http://www.freenation.org/a/f22l3.html (on defense)

 

  http://c4ss.org/content/12581 (on objective law) 

DonAthos said # 36

 

Governments only exist as particular, actual groups of individuals.

 

 

What do you mean by this? The US constitution is a particular actual group of individuals? Or do you mean the functions of government are carried out by particular actualr individuals , and that they may or may not adhere to the principles of a ‘governemnt’? Is it not possible to have a ‘government’, a principled moral foundation for the conduct of human interaction, adhered to be individuals?

 

Sure, we could sensibly talk about the US Government as consisting of the Constitution, or the three branches, the electoral college, or etc. (We can also talk about such abstract terms as “society” or “culture.”) But everything ultimately comes down to actual, real individual human beings and their decisions: the Constitution was written by individuals, ratified by individuals, is interpreted by individuals, and enforced (or not) by individuals.

I believe that this was an important point to make (as in, to this thread) because we were looking to source governmental power – and there is only one place it can ultimately come from: individual rights. If the Constitution has any authority at all, it is only due to the individuals who act within their rights in creating and enforcing such a document.

Groups, as such, whether or not they call themselves “the government” have no rights apart from the individual rights of those who comprise that government.

And that is what I meant.

 You should have bothered to read this very thread or the gallons of articles on these topics. Really do some research instead of acting like this is the first time these objections have been raised. 

 

Yeah I read the thread.  Nowhere did I say that this is the first time those objections have been raised nor was that central to the argument or the question of whether they have been sufficiently answered.  If you are upset by it you needn’t reply at all because I don’t make things personal.  I don’t know whether you remembered what was in the links you sent but they do not address the main argument I presented.  It doesn’t address at all how different “free-market” defense groups would deal without having a physical domain where their law applies absolutely.  It makes statements about how such a country would defend itself that are unconvincing and nowhere does it address how a preemptive strike could ever be accomplished. Or maybe I missed it somewhere?   Also in the article the objections to centralized government are that they would extort taxes, but in a free society they would be voluntarily funded. 

Sure, we could sensibly talk about the US Government as consisting of the Constitution, or the three branches, the electoral college, or etc. (We can also talk about such abstract terms as “society” or “culture.”) But everything ultimately comes down to actual, real individual human beings and their decisions: the Constitution was written by individuals, ratified by individuals, is interpreted by individuals, and enforced (or not) by individuals.

I believe that this was an important point to make (as in, to this thread) because we were looking to source governmental power – and there is only one place it can ultimately come from: individual rights. If the Constitution has any authority at all, it is only due to the individuals who act within their rights in creating and enforcing such a document.

Groups, as such, whether or not they call themselves “the government” have no rights apart from the individual rights of those who comprise that government.

And that is what I meant.

I agree that there is no such thing as group rights, the concept of rights is only applicable to individuals.

Given LFC , government is instituted to protect rights held by individuals. But I see government as a principled statement of appropriate interactions between individuals, a way to conduct relations governed by principles expressed in laws. Government in this sense is more the ideas , the actual people that facilitate the practical applications of carrying out the functions of various offices are not a recognized ‘group’ as having powers above and beyond any other citizen. .

I have a question.

 

Why can’t you judge your own case (provided you aren’t the accused)?  I know that most people would most likely demand far more severe punishments than would be just, but I’d like to think that I wouldn’t; again I fail to see if that’s inherent to human nature or simply an unfortunate fact of the current state of things.

Furthermore, if you cannot be your own judge because of a conflict of interest, wouldn’t that necessarily eliminate commercialized governance as well?

For instance, if you are the CEO of a company which is paid to prosecute criminals, wouldn’t it benefit you to find every single case guilty?  I think that the assertion “it would be in each company’s best interest to be objective and impartial, because that’s what people want” necessarily means that you CAN judge your own cases.

 

I do think that multiple governments could coexist simultaneously, provided they were objective and impartial.  War is bad for you; it isn’t in anyone’s best interest to start wars against peaceful neighbors (and, when left to their own devices, people usually do the rational thing hence LFC) therefore any senselessly warmongering government would present a clear and present threat to all of its neighbors and would not be likely to last very long.

 

But I think that the idea of market-governance necessarily negates the very need for a third party governor in the first place (except perhaps for the peaceful arbitration of honest disputes).

I agree that there is no such thing as group rights, the concept of rights is only applicable to individuals.

Given LFC , government is instituted to protect rights held by individuals. But I see government as a principled statement of appropriate interactions between individuals, a way to conduct relations governed by principles expressed in laws. Government in this sense is more the ideas , the actual people that facilitate the practical applications of carrying out the functions of various offices are not a recognized ‘group’ as having powers above and beyond any other citizen. .

 

I’m fine with it if you choose to look at government as an institution, or a set of institutions, or principles, or laws, or etc., so long as none of the inferences you draw from that, or the conclusions you reach, accord government some power/right that does not itself derive from individual rights.

The government – whatever it is – not only has no power beyond “individual rights,” it has less:

 

The source of the government’s authority is “the consent of the governed.” This means that the government is not the ruler, but the servant or agent of the citizens; it means that the government as such has no rights except the rights delegated to it by the citizens for a specific purpose.

And I am fine with your choosing to see that polylegalism would necessarily concede the premise that groups of individuls would in fact(perhaps de facto as opposed de jure)enjoy the rights you deny to ‘government’.

And I am fine with your choosing to see that polylegalism would necessarily concede the premise that groups of individuls would in fact(perhaps de facto as opposed de jure)enjoy the rights you deny to ‘government’.

 

I’ve been trying to make sense of this for a little while now, and I don’t think I’m there yet. So what I have to say might not be a direct response (and I invite you to clarify your point, if necessary), but just to riff off of it…

No individual has any right more than any other. No group (government included) has any rights that are more, or apart from, the individual rights of the individuals comprising that group. Whatever President Obama (properly) does, for instance, is made possible by his own individual rights, and the rights of those on whose behalf he acts.

And yes, it is true, in the capacity of government – when acting as President – Obama actually has “fewer rights” than any of the individuals of the United States, whether acting alone or in concert, for he is strictly limited to those rights granted to him by the citizens. Again, not as an individual (where he retains his full scope of individual rights), but acting in the capacity of “President,” or governance more generally. Ideally this is the function that the Constitution provides, in detailing the specific and highly limited grant of power from the citizens to the government… but in practice, as I hardly need to remind you, the Constitution has not been a perfect check against tyranny (and was flawed in its very design).

Anyways, when you say that under my system (whatever you think it is, though I’m not yet convinced you understand what I actually advocate, or why) that the individual (or groups of individuals) would “enjoy the rights I deny to government,” you are absolutely right! That is as it should be. For after all, the individual is sovereign, and everything flows from there, including governmental power, which is by nature delimited and of smaller scope (qua rights):

 

Individualism regards man—every man—as an independent, sovereign entity who possesses an inalienable right to his own life, a right derived from his nature as a rational being. Individualism holds that a civilized society, or any form of association, cooperation or peaceful coexistence among men, can be achieved only on the basis of the recognition of individual rights—and that a group, as such, has no rights other than the individual rights of its members.

 

This includes the right to form government. Change government. Dissolve government. These are among the rights of the individual, and they do not get stripped away on your say-so, or the say-so of any other man. That is what it means to be “inalienable.”

And when acting in the role of government – an individual taking on the power to act on the behalf of others – he is limited in that capacity by the rights granted to him, on the consent of those so governed.