Anthem

We’re currently reading Ayn Rand’s Anthem in school and we were discussing the question in the class the other day of whether Anthem’s world is more like that of the United states in 1776 or the United States today.

I’m quite curious to hear some of your thoughts on the matter.

Also, I’m a new member here and thought I’d pop in and say hello! :slight_smile:

In 1776, there was a major political and philosophical revolution, and I don’t think that is anything like Athem’s world.

I think Athem’s world is meant as a possible future, if our intellectuals continue to advocate irrational ideas.

Welcome to the forum, SunShine.

As Xavier said, the world in Anthem is not like 1776, nor like today. However, that’s an interesting question your teacher posed:i.e., is Anthem’s world more like 1776 or more like today.

Before all of us start bombarding you with opinions, what are your thoughts on the question?

I personally believe that the world of Anthem is more like the United States today. One of the points of collectivism is to make individuals more equal which is generally what the US is like today. Men and women of all races are treated equally. Also today the government can interfere with the rights of anyone, and the liberties of the individual are much more expendable than they previously were.

I thought it was interesting that my teacher chose to compare Anthem with 1776, which was when we were actually fighting for our independance to gain such rights.

Thank you for the welcome! :lol:

I think your answer should be more nuanced than that. The world of 1776 was mixed (like any other time period). So, it makes sense to focus in on particular aspects and explain what aspects of 1776 were opposite of the world in Anthem. Else, what would you say to the objection that, to most slaves, the world of 1776 offered a reality that was closer to Anthem?

Secondly, you say…

One of the points of collectivism is to make individuals more equal which is generally what the US is like today. Men and women of all races are treated equally.

One cannot credit collectivism per se with the idea of equality before the law. Many movements challenged the idea that some men were born with more rights than others. At least in theory, on cursory perusal, communism shares this idea with capitalism and even with Islam.

More fundamental than equality before the law is: the law itself. What is its purpose? A religious society might preach that we are all equally sinful and must pray 5 times a day, and non-compliant individuals will get exactly the same number of lashes, regardless of age, family-origin or color. A collectivist society might create rules that attempt to treat everyone as equal slaves of the state.

Anthem addresses this fundamental issue – whether man exist to serve his fellowmen – rather than the issue of whether such service should be equal across men.